Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 763

Citation: Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 763
Parties: ALBERT CESARIO VINCIGUERRA v MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD (ACN 084 715 177)
File number: WAD 90 of 2008
Judge: GILMOUR J
Date of judgment: 21 July 2010
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - derivative action - leave to commence proceedings under s 237 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - consideration of requirements under s 237(2)
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 79, 181, 182, 183, 232, 233, 236(1)(a)(i), 237, 247A 461(1)(k)
Cases cited: Apollo Shower Screens Pty Ltd v Building and Construction Industry Long Service Payments Corporation (1985) 1 NSWLR 561 cited
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd (2001) 208 CLR 199 cited
Blatch v Archer [1794] 1 COWP 63 cited
Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd(2004) 211 ALR 457 cited
Cemcon, In the matter of Hall Concrete Constructions (Vic) Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 696 cited
Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd (2008) 65 ACSR 661 cited
Charlton v Baber(2003) 47 ACSR 31 cited
Ehsman v Nutectim International Pty Ltd (2006) 58 ACSR 705 referred to
Fiduciary Ltd v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd(2005) 53 ACSR 732 applied
FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd v O'Meara; von Stanke v O'Meara [2007] SASC 413 discussed
Goozee v Graphic World Group Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 170 FLR 451 cited
Joinery Products Pty Ltd v Imlach (2008) 67 ACSR 520 cited
Maher v Honeysett & Maher Electrical Contractors Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 859 cited
Metyor Inc v Queensland Electronic Switching Pty Ltd [2003] 1 Qd R 186 cited
Oates v Consolidated Capital Services Ltd (2008) 218 FLR 73 cited
Power v Ekstein (2010) 77 ACSR 302 cited
Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) (2008) 65 ACSR 700 cited
South Johnstone Mill Ltd v Dennis (2007) 163 FCR 343 cited
Stephen Hooker v Infinity Systems Pty Ltd; Ian James Purchas v Infinity Systems Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 188 cited
Swansson v R A Pratt Properties Pty Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 313 applied
Talisman Technologies Inc v Queensland Electronic Switching Pty Ltd[2001] QSC 324 referred to
Vetter v Lake Macquarie City Council (2001) 202 CLR 439 cited
Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (2007) 61 ACSR 583 cited
Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509 cited
Date of hearing: 8 December 2009
Date of last submissions: 12 April 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 162
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr D Solomon
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Solomon Brothers
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr M McCusker QC
Solicitor for the Defendant: Q Legal

INDEX

BACKGROUND........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .....

[7]

SECTION 237 OF THE ACT........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........

[14]

PROBABLE THAT THE DEFENDANT WILL NOT ITSELF BRING THE PROCEEDINGS – S 37(2)(a) OF THE ACT........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .......

[17]

Ruthven Report........…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 763
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd involved the plaintiff, who owned 30 of the 100 ordinary shares in the defendant company, seeking leave to bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against its directors. The plaintiff alleged breaches of statutory and fiduciary duties by the directors and sought an injunction to prevent the company from issuing additional shares without the court's leave. The central legal issues were whether the plaintiff met the criteria under s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 for being granted leave to commence proceedings, and whether the plaintiff was the appropriate person to bring such a derivative action.

The court considered whether the company was likely to bring the proceedings itself, whether the plaintiff was acting in good faith and if it was in the company's best interests for the plaintiff to be granted leave. Additionally, the court had to determine if there was a serious question to be tried and whether the plaintiff had provided notice to the company of his intention to apply for leave. The court found that the plaintiff had not provided evidence on the ability of the potential respondents to meet any judgment, but this did not necessarily preclude the grant of leave. Furthermore, the court concluded that the plaintiff was not the appropriate applicant as his fiduciary duties to the company and his potential personal liabilities could conflict, and that the company, not the plaintiff, should be the plaintiff in such derivative claims.

The court granted the plaintiff leave to bring the derivative action, emphasising the importance of considering all the criteria in s 237(2) of the Act and the need for the applicant to bear the onus of establishing these criteria. The court also noted that while the plaintiff was not the ideal applicant, the circumstances of this case warranted granting leave due to the serious nature of the allegations and the potential harm to the company if not addressed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff’s application also seeks orders for an injunction restraining the defendant from issuing any additional shares without the leave of the Court. At a hearing on 16 May 2008, the defendant, by counsel, undertook to the Court not to issue any shares until further order. The defendant has not sought to be discharged from that undertaking. In the circumstances, unless and until a discharge of the undertaking is sought, the plaintiff does not press his application for an injunction. BACKGROUND The plaintiff owns 30 of the 100 ordinary shares issued in the defendant. The remaining 70 ordinary shares are owned by Sola-Kleen. The directors of the defendant at all material times were:(a)prior to 18 July 2000, Mr Gilmour; (b)between 18 July 2000 and 22 April 2004, the plaintiff and Mr Gilmour;(c)between 22 April 2004 and 15 January 2008, Mr Gilmour; (d)between 15 January 2008 and 5 May 2008, Mr Gilmour and Trevor John Harradine; and(e)since 5 May 2008, Mr Gilmour, Mr Harradine and Kenneth James Byfield. During the period from 1998 to 29 July 2006, the plaintiff was also an employee of the defendant. Mr Gilmour is the sole director and shareholder of Sola-Kleen. Mr Armenti is the external accountant for the defendant. In November 2006, the plaintiff applied for orders pursuant to s 247A of the Act requiring the defendant to permit him to inspect its books. On 22 May and 5 June 2007 respectively I made orders in favour of the plaintiff permitting that inspection with costs: Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (2007) 61 ACSR 583. In accordance with those orders Mr Gorey inspected the books of the defendant and provided the plaintiff with a report regarding the results of his investigation (the Gorey Report). The plaintiff commenced this application in May 2008. At the interlocutory injunction hearing on 16 May 2008, referred to above, orders were made referring the matter to mediation. The mediation process continued until 15 December 2008. SECTION 237 OF THE ACT Pursuant to s 237 of the Act, a member of a company, being a person referred to in s 236(1)(a)(i), may apply to the Court for leave to bring proceedings in the name of the company. The plaintiff is such a person. Pursuant to s 237(2) the Court must grant the application if it is satisfied that:(a)it is probable that the company will not itself bring the proceedings, or properly take responsibility for them, or for the steps in them;(b)the applicant is acting in good faith; and (c)it is in the best interests of the company that the applicant be granted leave; and (d)if the applicant is applying for leave to bring proceedings there is a serious question to be tried; and(e)either: (i)at least 14 days before making the application, the applicant gave written notice to the company of their intention to apply for leave and of the reasons for applying; or(ii)it is appropriate to grant leave even though subparagraph (i) is not satisfied. Leave under s 237 should not be given lightly. Applications for leave are not interlocutory, but final; and the applicant bears the onus of establishing all five requirements in s 237(2): Swansson v R A Pratt Properties Pty Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 313 at [24]. If any of the prescribed conditions is unsatisfied, the court must refuse the application: Goozee v Graphic World Group Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 170 FLR 451 at [27].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The defendant refers to a possible alternative of the plaintiff commencing proceedings for oppression, pursuant to ss 232 and 233 of the Act. Those provisions are not, in my opinion, apt to facts alleged in the draft statement of claim. In particular s 233 does not contemplate an order for payment of damages or compensation by a director to the company for breach of statutory and/or fiduciary duties. Ability of the potential respondents to meet at least a substantial part of any judgment The plaintiff has not provided any evidence, or sought to adduce any evidence at the hearing, as to whether the potential respondents would be able to meet any judgment awarded in the derivative action, if leave were granted. I do not regard this as fatal to the plaintiff’s application. The plaintiff submits that the evidence adduced by him must be considered in light of the particular circumstances of these proceedings and in light of the maxim that “all evidence is to be weighed according to the proof which it was in the power of one side to have produced, and the power of the other to have contradicted”: Blatch v Archer [1794] 1 COWP 63 at 65; 98 ER 964 at 970 per Lord Mansfield; Apollo Shower Screens Pty Ltd v Building and Construction Industry Long Service Payments Corporation (1985) 1 NSWLR 561 at 560; Vetter v Lake Macquarie City Council (2001) 202 CLR 439 at 454 [36] per Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Callinan JJ. If the putative defendants are or will not be in a position to meet any judgment debt then such evidence could and should, in this case, have come from the defendant. Mr Gilmour controls Sola-Kleen and it is to be expected that Sola-Kleen, Mr Gilmour and Mr Armenti would be in the defendant’s camp. No evidence from them was filed on this question. Moreover Sola-Kleen made an offer to buy the plaintiff’s shares in the defendant. I infer it had and has the means to pay for them. Whether the plaintiff is the appropriate applicant In s 237(2)(c) the emphasis is on the identity of the applicant who seeks leave: Metyor Inc v Queensland Electronic Switching Pty Ltd [2003] 1 Qd R 186 at [17]. The defendant submits that the grant of leave to the plaintiff may place him in a position where his duty and interest conflict. The defendant submits that the conflict would be between:(a)the plaintiff’s fiduciary duty to the company, as a derivative applicant acting on its behalf; and (b)his potential liability to the company and/or any personal claims, as a former director and key employee. The claims in the draft statement of claim allege as against Mr Gilmour breach of the duties imposed by ss 181 to 183 of the Act and fiduciary duties. These are duties owed by Mr Gilmour to the defendant, not to any of its directors or shareholders: Joinery Products Pty Ltd v Imlach (2008) 67 ACSR 520 at 532 [37]. Consequently, the defendant is the appropriate, and only, plaintiff in respect of these claims. The defendant further submits that the draft statement of claim does not provide for any investigation of any claims which the defendant may have against the plaintiff, in particular for the period in which the expenses are said to have been incurred and the plaintiff was both a director and employee of the defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established