MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour [2014] FCA 990

Citation: MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour [2014] FCA 990
Parties: MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD ACN 084 715 177 v MALCOLM STEWART GILMOUR and MAGIL NOMINEES PTY LTD ACN 009 059 607 (IN LIQ); MALCOLM STEWART GILMOUR and MAGIL NOMINEES PTY LTD ACN 009 059 607 (IN LIQ); MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD ACN 084 715 177 and ALBERTO CESARIO VINCIGUERRA
File number: WAD 256 of 2010
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 12 September 2014
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – fiduciary and statutory directors’ duties – alleged breaches of ss 181, 182, 183 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and fiduciary duties – whether certain expenses incurred by company were unnecessary to be incurred or excessive – whether first defendant breached directors’ duties in relation to expenses – whether second defendant involved in contraventions – whether second defendant entitled to a set-off for amounts in cross-claim

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether any claims or cross-claims statute-barred under Limitation Act 1935 (WA) or Limitation Act 2005 (WA)

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 79, s 180, s 180(1), s 180(2), s 180(3), s 181, s 181(1), s 181(2), s 182, s 182(1), s 182(2), s 183, s 183(1), s 183(2), s1305, s 1317E, s 1317H, s 1317H(2), s 1317K
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 79

Limitation Act 2005 (WA) s 13
Limitation Act 1935 (WA) s 38, s 38(1)(c)(v)

Cases cited: Ardeshirian v Robe River Iron Associates (1993) 43 FCR 475
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2002] NSWSC 171; (2002) 168 FLR 253
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich [2009] NSWSC 1229; (2009) 236 FLR 1
Chew v R (1991) 4 WAR 21
Equiticorp Finance Ltd (in liq) v Bank of New Zealand (1993) 32 NSWLR 50
Marchesi v Barnes [1970] VR 434
Maronis Holdings Limited v Nippon Credit Australia Pty Ltd [2001] NSWSC 448; (2001) 38 ACSR 404
MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Vinciguerra (No 2) [2011] FCAFC 48; (2011) 276 ALR 319
MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Vinciguerra [2011] FCAFC 31; (2011) 82 ACSR 367
R v Byrnes [1995] HCA 1; (1995) 183 CLR 501
Re Ledir Enterprises Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1332; (2013) 96 ACSR 1
Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 763; (2010) 79 ACSR 293
Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 503; (2007) 61 ACSR 583
Westpac Banking Corporation v Bell Group Limited (in liq) (No 3) [2012] WASCA 157; (2012) 44 WAR 1
Date of hearing: 14-17 October 2013
Date of last submissions: 31 October 2013
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 592
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr DH Solomon, Mr CS Williams
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Solomon Brothers
Counsel for the Defendants: Mr KA Dundo
Solicitor for the Defendants: HopgoodGanim

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 256 of 2010

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 990
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour, the plaintiff, MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (MGCC), sought to recover expenses that they claimed were wrongfully incurred by the defendants, Mr Gilmour and Sola-Kleen. The case arose from a derivative action initiated by Mr Vinciguerra, a former employee of MGCC, who alleged that Mr Gilmour, a director of MGCC, and Sola-Kleen, a company associated with him, had authorised payments and incurred expenses that were excessive or not properly related to MGCC's business. The defendants denied any wrongdoing and argued that any claims were statute-barred under the Limitation Act 1935 (WA). Additionally, Sola-Kleen asserted a cross-claim against MGCC for unpaid management fees.

The central legal issue in this case was whether Mr Gilmour breached his fiduciary and statutory duties as a director by authorising payments and incurring expenses that were excessive or not properly related to MGCC's business. The court had to determine the validity of the expenses claimed by MGCC, assess whether the business judgment rule applied to protect Mr Gilmour's decisions, and consider the applicability of the statute of limitations to the claims. Furthermore, the court needed to examine the merits of Sola-Kleen's cross-claim for unpaid management fees.

The court thoroughly examined the expert evidence provided by Mr Gorey, an expert in accounting, and Mr Lopez, who was appointed as the liquidator of MGCC. Mr Gorey's report identified certain expenses that he believed were excessive or not properly related to MGCC's business, while Mr Lopez's report provided a different assessment of the expenses. The court considered the factual assumptions made by Mr Gorey, including his reliance on documents and information available at the time, and noted his concerns about the absence of certain accounting records. The court also evaluated the submissions from both sides regarding the business judgment rule and the surrounding circumstances under which the expenses were incurred.

The court concluded that certain expenses were indeed excessive or not properly related to MGCC's business, and these amounted to $97,166 for the period from 1 July 2002 to 30 June 2007. However, the court found that claims for amounts prior to 13 September 2004 were statute-barred. Regarding the cross-claim by Sola-Kleen, the court found that MGCC owed Sola-Kleen $330,613 for management fees due for the periods ending 30 June 2001 and 30 June 2002.

The court ordered that Mr Gilmour and Sola-Kleen pay MGCC $97,166, representing the excessive or improperly related expenses for the specified period. The court also ruled that Sola-Kleen was entitled to set off the amount of its cross-claim against any sum it might be liable to pay to MGCC, resulting in a net liability of $233,513 owed by Sola-Kleen to MGCC.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In order to deal with the expenses that remain in issue, the evidence of the expert witnesses will first be considered, followed by a consideration of the evidence of the other witnesses. The expert evidence Mr Gorey and Mr Lopez were called, as expert witnesses, to give their opinion evidence concurrently. Mr Gorey provided his expert report of 3 April 2013 (exhibit 11) in which he was asked to address the following issues:(1)Whether any of the expenses set out in the particulars to paras 7 and 8 of the statement of claim were:·additional to the expenses that MGCC incurred in carrying on its business;·unnecessary to be incurred by MGCC;·not properly related to MGCC’s business; ·otherwise ought not to have been incurred by MGCC; and/or·for the purposes of MGCC’s business, but were incurred in excessive amounts and exceeded the amount by which the expense related to, or was incurred for the purpose of MGCC’s business.(2)Whether there were any other expenses of MGCC that can be so characterised.(3)In relation to any expenses which related to and were for the purposes of MGCC’s business but were incurred in an excessive amount or exceeded the amount by which the expense related to, or was incurred for the purpose of MGCC’s business, the amount by which the expense exceeded what related to or was incurred for the purpose of MGCC’s business, or the amount by which the expense exceeded the reasonable amount of such expense. In his report, Mr Gorey set out the factual assumptions he had made at the time of signing his report, which included those drawn from documents and information identified in his report as well as from previous reports he had prepared in relation to earlier proceedings and which were dated 7 September 2007 and 11 March 2008. He also noted some accounting difficulties of an audit nature, and that he had earlier received information from Mr Vinciguerra by way of written answers to a list of questions provided. Mr Gorey also made the point that material he saw did not include accounting and other records of Sola‑Kleen that he considered were necessary to enable a full examination by him of the operations of that company in order to establish the validity of the management fees and other costs charged by that company to MGCC; and he noted the documents he would have expected to have seen in that regard including general ledgers, bank statements, payroll records, invoices of various types and financial statements for the years ended 30 June 2006 and 2007. He said that in the absence of such materials, he had had to rely on other information and in some instances had made assumptions without the ability to verify them. In his report, Mr Gorey then set out background in relation to both MGCC and Sola‑Kleen, in which he confirmed his understanding that MGCC at material times had two business components. The main business was the sale of chemicals used in the mining industry, with its major market being in Kalgoorlie, but also South Australia. Sales from this source in 2006 totalled $1,558,000. It also operated a division that serviced and cleaned air conditioning units, concentrated in Perth, with sales in 2006 of $445,000.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The business judgment rule, if met, has the result that the requirements of s 180(1) will be met. In this regard, subss 180(2) and (3) provide:(2)A director or other officer of a corporation who makes a business judgment is taken to meet the requirements of subsection (1), and their equivalent duties at common law and in equity, in respect of the judgment if they:(a)make the judgment in good faith for a proper purpose; and(b)do not have a material personal interest in the subject matter of the judgment; and(c)inform themselves about the subject matter of the judgment to the extent they reasonably believe to be appropriate; and(d)rationally believe that the judgment is in the best interests of the corporation.The director’s or officer’s belief that the judgment is in the best interests of the corporation is a rational one unless the belief is one that no reasonable person in their position would hold.NoteThis subsection only operates in relation to duties under this section and their equivalent duties at common law or in equity (including the duty of care that arises under the common law principles governing liability for negligence)—it does not operate in relation to duties under any other provision of this Act or under any other laws.(3)In this section:business judgment means any decision to take or not take action in respect of a matter relevant to the business operations of the corporation. In many respects the defendants contend that all of the expenses the subject of the claim by MGCC have a valid business explanation such that s 180(1) is not contravened, nor any of the duties imposed by ss 181‑183. In that regard, the defendants submit that in assessing whether there has been a breach of ss 180-183 one must consider:(1)The surrounding circumstances. See Equiticorp Finance Ltd (in liq) v Bank of New Zealand (1993) 32 NSWLR 50; Maronis Holdings Limited v Nippon Credit Australia Pty Ltd [2001] NSWSC 448; (2001) 38 ACSR 404.(2)Whether the director deliberately engaged in conduct knowing that it was not in the company’s best interests or for a proper purpose. See Marchesi v Barnes [1970] VR 434 at 438.(3)Whether the conduct of the director was a deliberate act or combination of acts with the knowledge of what was being done was not for the purpose of furthering the interest of the company but to achieve a collateral purpose. See R v Byrnes [1995] HCA 1; (1995) 183 CLR 501. So far as s 180(1) is concerned, I accept that consideration should also be given to the type of company involved, the size and nature of its business, the provisions of its constitution, the composition of the board and the distribution of the work between the board and other officers. See Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich [2009] NSWSC 1229; (2009) 236 FLR 1 at [7201] (Austin J); Re Ledir Enterprises Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1332; (2013) 96 ACSR 1 at [75] (Black J). In Ledir, Black J at [77] observed in respect of the statutory duty under s 181 that it reflects directors’ duties under the general law to act in good faith in the interests of and for the benefit of the company as a whole, noting that in Chew v R (1991) 4 WAR 21, Malcolm CJ summarised the requirements of that duty as including that directors must exercise their powers in the interests of the company, and must not misuse or abuse their power and must not misappropriate the company’s assets for themselves.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As a result of financial concerns harboured by Mr Vinciguerra following the cessation of his employment with MGCC, he successfully took proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), for orders first to inspect MGCC’s books and later to obtain the leave of the court to pursue a derivative action in the name of MGCC against Mr Gilmour and Sola-Kleen. As to the inspection orders, see Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 503; (2007) 61 ACSR 583. As to the grant of leave to pursue the derivative action, see Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 763; (2010) 79 ACSR 293; and MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Vinciguerra [2011] FCAFC 31; (2011) 82 ACSR 367. Mr Vinciguerra was also successful in obtaining a costs order in his favour in the Full Court. See MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Vinciguerra(No 2) [2011] FCAFC 48; (2011) 276 ALR 319. This proceeding is conducted pursuant to the leave granted to Mr Vinciguerra to pursue the derivative action in the name of MGCC against Mr Gilmour and Sola-Kleen. MGCC – effectively Mr Vinciguerra – claims that, in breach of his duty as a director under the CorporationsAct and under the general law as a fiduciary, Mr Gilmour, with Sola‑Kleen’s involvement, authorised the payment of monies to Sola-Kleen that should not have been paid or were excessive, and incurred legal expenses in defending the various Federal Court proceedings commenced by Mr Vinciguerra to gain access to the records of MGCC and for leave to commence the derivative action. The sum of expenses in issue, as initially estimated in the expert report of Mr Trevor Gorey, chartered accountant, dated 3 April 2013, and filed on behalf of MGCC, was $1,653,889. By the time the trial commenced, the defendants, having regard to advice they had received from Mr George Lopez, chartered accountant and by then liquidator of MGCC, conceded, without any admission as to any breach of duty by Mr Gilmour, that for the period 1 July 2002 to 30 June 2007, there were expenses of $97,166 charged by Sola-Kleen to MGCC or incurred by MGCC which may not be capable of substantiation. Otherwise they denied the claims made against them. The defendants say that any claims in respect of amounts prior to 13 September 2004, that is to say six years prior to the commencement of the derivative action, are, in any event, statute-barred pursuant to s 38 of the Limitation Act 1935 (WA). Sola-Kleen also claims that it is entitled to set off against any sum that it might be found liable to pay, the amount of its cross-claim against MGCC. Sola-Kleen cross-claims, with the leave of the liquidator (who had been appointed prior to trial), alleging that MGCC owes it a total of $330,613, being management fees due for the period ending 30 June 2001 of $167,316.66 and for the period ending 30 June 2002 of $163,296.37, based on the calculations referred to in Annexure E of Mr Lopez’ expert report dated 13 September 2013.