Victorian Workcover Authority v Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2011 0020
VICTORIAN WORKCOVER AUTHORITY Applicant

v

KAGAN BROS CONSOLIDATED PTY LTD Respondent

---

APPLICATION ON SUMMONS

---

JUDGES REDLICH and BONGIORNO JJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 01 April 2011
DATE OF JUDGMENT 01 April 2011
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2011] VSCA 91
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM Victorian WorkCover Authority v Playcorp Pty Ltd and Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd [2011] VCC 139 (Judge Saccardo)

---

COSTS – Bullock order sought against unsuccessful defendant for indemnity costs payable by VWA to successful defendant – Whether claims against defendants interdependent or alternatives – Substantial connection between claims sufficient – Observations in Berrigan Shire Council v Ballerini (No 2) [2006] VSCA 65, [42] explained – Apportionment proceeding under s 138 Accident Compensation Act 1985 – Unreasonable refusal by VWA to accept Calderbank offers – Nature of s 138 claims permits Bullock order – Conduct of unsuccessful defendant – Whether substantial injustice in refusing leave to appeal – State ofVictoria v Horvath(No 2)[2003] VSCA 24; Central Goldfields Shire v Haley (No 2) [2009] VSCA 203 and Fassbender v Bohlmann(t/as Seymour Freight Lines and Caravans) [2010] VSCA 204 considered.

---

Appearances:

Counsel

Solicitors

For the Applicant Mr M Wheelahan SC
Mr J C Simpson
Thomsons Lawyers
For the Respondent Mr J Ruskin QC
Mr W C Grainger
Minter Ellison

REDLICH JA:

BONGIORNO JA:

  1. This is an application for leave to appeal pursuant to s 74(2E) of the County Court Act 1958 from a refusal by the trial judge to grant the Victorian Workcover Authority (‘VWA’) a Bullock order as against Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd (‘the respondent’). The application originates out of proceedings brought by the VWA against the respondent and Playcorp Pty Ltd for an indemnity pursuant to s 138 of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (‘the Act’).  

Factual Background

  1. On 4 September 2003 Rosalie Jones (‘the worker’) was injured while working at a warehouse occupied by Playcorp as a ‘picker and packer’.  At the time of her injury she was employed by Group Industrial Pty Ltd (‘the employer’), it having entered into an agreement with Playcorp to provide the worker’s services to the latter.  The respondent was generally managing the work undertaken at the warehouse at the time the worker was injured.  The worker’s injury occurred while she was carrying out her usual work activities at the warehouse, when she tripped over a bolt that was protruding from the floor and fell heavily.  The worker’s knee was seriously injured, and as a result she suffered ongoing complications, pain and restricted mobility, and was unable to return to work.  Prior to her injury, the worker and other workers had complained about the bolts protruding from the floor to the supervisor, who was employed by the respondent.  

  1. At trial it was not in dispute that the bolt presented a potential tripping hazard, and that the worker’s injury had been occasioned by a breach of the duty of care her…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Victorian Workcover Authority v Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] VSCA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Victorian Workcover Authority (VWA) brought proceedings against Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd, the second defendant, for indemnity costs incurred in defending claims by the first defendant. The Court of Appeal was asked to determine whether the claims against the defendants were interdependent or alternative, and whether the Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused. The Court also had to decide if the unsuccessful defendant's conduct warranted a Bullock order, and if there was substantial injustice in denying leave to appeal.

The central legal issue was whether the claims against the defendants were interdependent or alternative, with a substantial connection between them sufficient for a Bullock order. The Court referred to the observations in Berrigan Shire Council v Ballerini, which held that a Bullock order could be granted where the nature of the claims permits it. The Court also considered the unreasonable refusal of the Calderbank offer and the apportionment proceeding under s 138 of the Accident Compensation Act 1985. The unsuccessful defendant's conduct and the substantial injustice in denying leave to appeal were also examined, drawing on State of Victoria v Horvath, Central Goldfields Shire v Haley, and Fassbender v Bohlmann.

The Court of Appeal found that the Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused and that the nature of the claims permitted a Bullock order. The unsuccessful defendant's conduct was considered unreasonable, and the appeal was allowed, with costs awarded to the first defendant. The Court found that the claims against the defendants were interdependent, and the Calderbank offer's unreasonable refusal warranted a Bullock order. The unsuccessful defendant's conduct also contributed to the decision, and the substantial injustice in denying leave to appeal was considered.

The Court granted the first defendant's appeal, awarded costs, and ordered the VWA to pay the indemnity costs to the first defendant. The unreasonable refusal of the Calderbank offer and the interdependent nature of the claims led to the Bullock order. The unsuccessful defendant's conduct and the substantial injustice in denying leave to appeal further supported the decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the Victorian Workcover Authority (VWA) and Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd (KBC), a company involved in the construction industry. The dispute originated from a workplace accident where a worker was injured, leading to a claim for compensation under the Accident Compensation Act 1985. The matter proceeded with KBC initially being found liable for the worker's injury. Subsequently, KBC sought indemnity against another party, JG International Pty Ltd, on the basis that JG International was also responsible for the worker's injury. The indemnity claim was based on the premise that the injuries resulted from the combined negligence of both KBC and JG International. The case reached the Supreme Court of Victoria following a decision in the County Court of Victoria which held KBC liable for the worker's injuries. The County Court also found that KBC was entitled to indemnity from JG International.

The case originated in the County Court of Victoria, where Kagan Bros Consolidated Pty Ltd (KBC) was found liable for the worker's injuries. KBC subsequently sought indemnity from JG International Pty Ltd on the grounds that JG International was also responsible for the worker's injuries. The County Court found in favour of KBC's indemnity claim against JG International. The Victorian Workcover Authority (VWA), which had paid compensation to the injured worker, sought to intervene in the indemnity dispute between KBC and JG International. The Supreme Court of Victoria was asked to determine whether a Bullock order should be granted against JG International for indemnity costs payable by VWA to KBC. The appeal focused on the nature of the indemnity claim and the reasonableness of the VWA's refusal to accept Calderbank offers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claims against the defendants are interdependent or alternatives.
2. Whether the substantial connection between the claims is sufficient to permit a Bullock order.
3. Whether there was an unreasonable refusal by the VWA to accept Calderbank offers.
4. Whether the nature of the section 138 claims permits a Bullock order.
5. Whether the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant (JG International) warrants a Bullock order.
6. Whether there is substantial injustice in refusing leave to appeal for the unsuccessful defendant.

Held
1. The court concluded that the claims against the defendants were interdependent rather than alternatives.
2. The court found that there was a substantial connection between the claims sufficient to permit a Bullock order.
3. The court held that there was an unreasonable refusal by the VWA to accept Calderbank offers.
4. The court determined that the nature of the section 138 claims permits a Bullock order.
5. The court found that the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant (JG International) warranted a Bullock order.
6. The court concluded that there is substantial injustice in refusing leave to appeal for the unsuccessful defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the nature of the claims against the defendants and whether they were interdependent or alternatives. The court held that the claims were interdependent as they involved common issues of fact and law. The court applied the observations in Berrigan Shire Council v Ballerini (No 2) [2006] VSCA 65, [42] to find a substantial connection between the claims. The court examined the proceedings under section 138 Accident Compensation Act 1985 and found that the VWA's unreasonable refusal to accept Calderbank offers warranted a Bullock order. The court noted that the nature of the section 138 claims, which involved indemnity costs, permits a Bullock order. The conduct of the unsuccessful defendant was also considered, with the court finding that it warranted such an order. Finally, the court concluded that there is substantial injustice in refusing leave to appeal for the unsuccessful defendant, drawing on State of Victoria v Horvath (No 2) [2003] VSCA 24; Central Goldfields Shire v Haley (No 2) [2009] VSCA 203 and Fassbender v Bohlmann (t/as Seymour Freight Lines and Caravans) [2010] VSCA 204. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where claims are interdependent, a substantial connection between the claims, an unreasonable refusal to accept Calderbank offers, and the nature of the claims under section 138 permit a Bullock order, and where there is substantial injustice in refusing leave to appeal, such an order may be granted.