SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
Nos. 5310-5313 of 2001
| STATE OF VICTORIA |
| v. |
| HORVATH & ORS. [NO.2] |
---
JUDGES: | WINNEKE, P., CHERNOV AND VINCENT, JJ.A. | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 20 December 2002 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 4 April 2003 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2003] VSCA 24 | |
---
Practice and procedure – Costs – Bullock Order – Sanderson Order – Form of costs order in court’s discretion – Considerations relevant to exercise of discretion – Whether plaintiff’s claims against successful defendant and unsuccessful defendant interdependent or alternative – Which form of costs order reasonable and just – Whether joinder of successful defendant reasonable – Conduct of unsuccessful defendant – Impecuniosity of unsuccessful defendant.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr. S.W. Kaye Q.C. with Mr. P.G. Golombek | Victorian Government Solicitor |
| For the 1st Respondent | Mr. M.A. Dreyfus Q.C. with Mr. M.G.R. Gronow | Nowicki Carbone & Co. |
| For the 2nd Respondent | Mr. M.F. Wheelahan | Kenna Croxford & Co. |
| For the 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents | Mr. O.P. Holdenson Q.C. with Mr. A.N. Murdoch | Kenna Croxford & Co. |
WINNEKE, P.
CHERNOV, J.A.
VINCENT, J.A.:
The Court had before it a number of appeals to which the reasons published on 7 November 2002 were relevant. There were four appeals by the State of Victoria (which had been the fifth defendant in the court of first instance) in which the four plaintiffs in the trial proceedings (namely Horvath, Love, Colleen Kniese and David Kniese) were respectively named as the first respondent, and in each of which the four police defendants at trial (Christensen, Davison, Jenkin and Saunders) were respectively the second, third, fourth and fifth respondents. These were the appeals numbered 5310, 5311, 5312 and 5313 of 2001. In one of these appeals, namely 5312 of 2001, there was a cross appeal by Christensen. Then there were four appeals in which Davison and Jenkin were appellants to which each of the plaintiffs at trial were respectively the first respondent and the State of Victoria was the second respondent. Those appeals were numbered respectively 5316 of 2001, 5317 of 2001, 5318 of 2001 and 5319 of 2001. In respect of only one of these appeals (namely 5317 of 2001) was there a substantial live issue raised; namely Davison’s liability to Love for malicious prosecution. The other appeals raised, for relevant purposes, non-contentious issues about the form of orders made by the trial judge.
On the day upon which we published our reasons and reserved for later consideration the issues relating to the appropriate form of orders, including costs, we suggested that senior counsel for the State of Victoria (Mr. Kaye, Q.C.) should liaise with counsel for the plaintiff/respondents and police/respondents to determine whether, in the light of our reasons, some consensus as to the orders to be made could be reached.
Subsequently, and before the Court re-assembled on 22 December 2002, Mr. Kaye forwarded draft minutes of orders, indicating substantial agreement between the parties but outlining “three outstanding issues”. In the covering memorandum…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Victoria v Horvath (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] VSCA 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was the form of the costs order to be imposed on the defendants. Specifically, the court had to decide whether a Bullock Order, which typically involves a successful party paying the costs of an unsuccessful party, or a Sanderson Order, which involves the unsuccessful party paying the costs of both parties, was more appropriate. The court needed to consider various factors, including the interdependence or alternative nature of the plaintiff’s claims against the defendants, the reasonableness of joining the defendants, the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant, and the financial status of the unsuccessful defendant.
In its reasoning, the court considered the specific circumstances of the case. It assessed the relationship between the claims made by the plaintiff against the two defendants and determined that the claims were interdependent rather than alternative. The court found that the joinder of the defendants was reasonable given the nature of the claims. Additionally, the court took into account the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant, which did not warrant any special considerations. Lastly, the court noted the impecuniosity of the unsuccessful defendant, which was a relevant factor in determining the form of the costs order. Based on these considerations, the court exercised its discretion and decided on a particular form of costs order, which it deemed to be reasonable and just in the circumstances.
The final orders of the court specified the form of the costs order to be made against the defendants, reflecting the court's detailed analysis and decision-making process.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi