Vero Lenders v Taylor Byrne Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vero Lenders v Taylor Byrne Pty Limited [2006] FCA 1430

TRADE PRACTICES – INSURANCE – action for damages pursuant to s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and compensation pursuant to s 87 arising out of a contended failure on the part of the Respondents to disclose in a valuation relied upon by a mortgage insurer, features of the improvements to a property said to constitute unusual features, an unusual design or an unusual configuration of the improvements – consideration of the Australian Property Institute (API) Residential Valuation and Security Assessment Pro-forma Valuation Instrument and Supporting Memorandum – consideration of a claim for negligence by the Applicant mortgage insurer against the valuer. 

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
CLERP Economic Reform Program (Audit Reform and Corporate Disclosure) Act 2004
Law Reform Act 1995 (Qld)

Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge Willemstad (1976) 136 CLR 529
White v Jones [1995] 2 AC 207
Perre v Apand (1999) 198 CLR 180
Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd (1999) 199 CLR 413
Nocton v Lord Ashburton [1914] AC 932
Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465
Interchase Corporation Limited (in liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) Pty Ltd (No. 3) (2003) 1 Qd.R 26
Hill v Van Erp (1997) 188 CLR 159
Morris v C W Martin & Sons Ltd [1966] 1 QB 716
State of New South Wales v Lepore & Anor (2003) 212 CLR 511
The Koursk (1924) 18 Ll L Rep 153
Credit Lyonnais v ECGD (1998) 1 Ll L Rep 19
Thompson v Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 574
Evans Deacon Pty Ltd v Sebel Furniture Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 171
H G v The Queen (1999) 197 CLR 414
Qantas Airways Limited [2004] ACompT 9
I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (2002) 210 CLR 109

VERO LENDERS MORTGAGE INSURANCE LIMITED v TAYLOR BYRNE PTY LIMITED & DAVID JAMES DUFFIELD
QUD90 OF 2004

GREENWOOD J
3 NOVEMBER 2006
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD90 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

VERO LENDERS MORTGAGE INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 001 825 725
Applicant

AND:

TAYLOR BYRNE PTY LIMITED ACN 010 317 432
First Respondent

DAVID JAMES DUFFIELD
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 NOVEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant is granted leave to further amend the Application and further amend the Further Amended Statement of Claim filed 8 December 2005 so as to introduce a claim for damages pursuant to s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) against the First Respondent.

2.The proceeding is dismissed. 

3.The Applicant pay the costs of the Respondents of the proceeding. 

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD90 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

VERO LENDERS MORTGAGE INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 001 825 725

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vero Lenders v Taylor Byrne Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1430
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vero Lenders Mortgage Insurance Limited brought an action against Taylor Byrne Pty Limited, seeking damages for a fraudulent misrepresentation that led to the issuance of a mortgage insurance policy. The borrower had applied for a loan through Resi Home Loans, and the application included an incorrect property valuation. Despite the incorrect valuation, Vero Lenders issued the insurance policy, leading to the dispute over whether the insurer had relied on the valuation in issuing the policy. The court had to determine whether the insurer relied on the valuation and if the misrepresentation was material.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the insurer relied on the valuation report in issuing the insurance policy and whether the misrepresentation was material. The court examined the insurer's underwriting practices, the role of the underwriter and manager in assessing the valuation, and the process of approving the loan application. The court also considered the significance of the valuation report in the decision-making process and whether the misrepresentation had a material impact on the decision to issue the policy.

The court found that the insurer's underwriting officer, Tome Zrilic, read and assessed the valuation report, and his recommendation to approve the proposal was based on this assessment. Although the loan manager, Mr Ramage, did not read the valuation report, he relied on the underwriter's recommendation. The court accepted that the insurer's underwriting process was robust and that the misrepresentation did not materially impact the decision to issue the policy. Therefore, the court ruled in favor of the respondents and dismissed the insurer's claim.

The court granted the insurer leave to amend the application to include a claim for damages against the first respondent, dismissed the proceeding, and ordered the insurer to pay the respondents' costs. This decision highlights the importance of the insurer's underwriting process and the role of the underwriter and manager in assessing the valuation report and making the decision to issue the policy.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant is granted leave to further amend the Application and further amend the Further Amended Statement of Claim filed 8 December 2005 so as to introduce a claim for damages pursuant to s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) against the First Respondent.

2. The proceeding is dismissed.

3. The Applicant pay the costs of the Respondents of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Written objections to particular paragraphs of affidavits were exchanged between the parties. During the course of the trial, objections to evidence were dealt with as each witness was called and each affidavit tendered. THE BACKGROUND FACTS I find the facts to be these. On 19 April 1999, Cornitus Cats and Bethwyn Cats (the “borrower”) completed an application form addressed to Residential Housing Corporation Pty Ltd trading as Resi Home Loans (‘Resi’) for a loan to re‑finance an existing house loan and for additional funds for investment, in a total amount of $400,000.00. The application document was lodged with Resi on 21 April 1999 and recites in the Assets and Liabilities Statement the residential property at 30 Latreille Terrace as one of the assets of the borrower at a value of $520,000.00. In another section of the same document, the ‘estimated value’ of the property is described as ‘$470,000.00+’. The Resi application document recites that the borrower has made an application for finance to Perpetual Trustees Victoria Limited and Permanent Custodians Limited (‘Permanent’) to be arranged by Resi. On 22 April 1999, Resi submitted a proposal for lenders residential mortgage insurance (‘L M insurance’) to Royal & Sun Alliance Lenders Mortgage Insurance Limited (‘Royal & Sun Alliance’) now known as Vero Lenders Mortgage Insurance Limited, the Applicant. In these reasons, I will generally describe Royal & Sun Alliance as Vero. In the insurance proposal, the lender is described as Perpetual and the mortgage manager of the proposed loan on behalf of Perpetual is described as Interstar Securities Pty Ltd (‘Interstar’). The proposal identifies a loan amount of $356,250.00 and recites that the ‘loan application form, valuation/security assessment, all associated and supporting documents and details of further securities must be submitted with, and form part of, this proposal’. Plainly enough, the proposal document contemplates that a range of material and information will be assessed by the insurer in making a decision as to whether to accept the proposal and assume the risk. From February 1998 to June 2000, Tome Zrilic was employed by Vero as an underwriter. Prior to 1998, Tome Zrilic had worked as a residential lending officer for a period of between two and four years at variously, Advance Bank, Commonwealth Bank and Aussie Home Loans and was responsible for approving residential housing loans. That role also involved the assessment of property valuations to ensure that the proposed security was acceptable from a lender’s perspective and thus Tome Zrilic was familiar with the assessment of valuation reports. In 1999, Tome Zrilic was responsible for reviewing lenders mortgage insurance proposals put to Vero by or on behalf of Interstar. Often, such applications were submitted to Vero by a loan originator or loan arranger such as Resi. In the case of proposals made on behalf of Interstar, applications would often be submitted to Vero by Resi as the loan originator in circumstances where Interstar was acting as the manager of the loan application for Perpetual as the proposed lender and mortgagee.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GREENWOOD J
In reviewing the R D Input Sheet Mr Zrilic says that he would have inserted as the total loan amount an amount of $400,000.00 as the potential amount of the loan based on the application document. He then altered that amount by inserting the amount to be actually lent consistent with the LVR. Mr Zrilic says that he recommended a full approval of the proposal and endorsed and signed the proposal as approved on 19 May 1999 leading to the issue of Cover Note F28083 with an expiry date of 19 August 1999. The issue of the Cover Note bound Vero to issue a policy subject to the payment of a premium ($522.00). The policy in fact issued on 8 September 1999.Conclusions I accept the evidence of Mr Zrilic and Mr Ramage in relation to this sequence of events. Even though neither witness has a present independent recollection of the specific events, I accept that Vero’s underwriting practices and policies and the extant documents establish that the course of events involved the submission of a proposal, a pre-approval of the proposal, the submission to Vero of a copy of a valuation undertaken by David Duffield and Taylor Byrne, an assessment of the valuation by Mr Zrilic, a recommendation of approval of the proposal by Mr Zrilic and an approval of the proposal by Mr Ramage leading to the issue of the Cover Note on 19 May and ultimately a policy of L M insurance on 8 September 1999. In addition, the respondents contend that the applicant has not demonstrated reliance upon the valuation in any material way other than confirmation of the valuation amount. It was put to Mr Zrilic in cross-examination that he did not ‘read’ the valuation and he denied that proposition. I accept and find that Mr Zrilic read the valuation. I accept and find that Mr Ramage probably did not read the valuation but relied upon Mr Zrilic’s assessment of it leading to Mr Zrilic’s recommendation of approval. In reliance upon that recommendation, Mr Ramage approved the proposal as the amount of the loan exceeded the SER limit applicable to Mr Zrilic. Importantly, the process of pre-approving and more particularly, finally approving applications for L M insurance is a core business process for Vero. The process is the subject of protocols and a prescriptive policy manual especially in relation to the insurer’s approach to valuation. The policy manual sets out a wide range of policy positions in relation to each category of risk associated with issuing L M insurance policies. Mr Zrilic and Mr Ramage, (but in particular the underwriting officer dealing with the transaction, Mr Zrilic) are the defenders at the gate for the insurer in containing risk and exposure and in dealing with those things that the insurer considers attract a particular level of criticality in the approval process. They are experienced writers of L M insurance policies. They are astute to the requirements of the Policy Manual and the importance of the valuation process. They are experienced and informed readers of valuations and they are required to bring an enquiring mind to the assessment of a valuation and the role a valuation plays in the assumption of risk in relation to the particular transaction in question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GREENWOOD J