Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Blacktown City Council [2020] NSWCA 106 Hearing dates: 15 May 2020 Date of orders: 09 June 2020 Decision date: 09 June 2020 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Gleeson JA at [39];
Emmett AJA at [40]Decision: (1) To the extent necessary grant Universal Property Group Pty Ltd leave to appeal from the judgment and orders given in the Land and Environment Court on 21 November 2019.
(2) Treat the notice of appeal filed on 17 December 2019 as validly filed, to the extent that leave was required.
(3) Dismiss the appeal.
(4) Order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs in this Court.Catchwords: ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – planning schemes and instruments – State Environmental Planning Policies – secondary dwellings – site area and minimum lot size – whether minimum lot size requirement overridden – State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW), cl 22; State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW), cl 4.1AC
STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – amendment and repeal – implied repeal – harmonious construction – conflict between State Environmental Planning Policies – whether capable of harmonious construction – requirement for actual contrariety
STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – amendment and repeal – implied repeal – clauses in separate instruments each purporting to control inconsistency by prevailing over the other – effect of each clauseLegislation Cited: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), ss 3.24, 3.28, 4.2, 4.15, 4.25; s 74
Environmental Planning and Assessment Amendment Act 2017 (NSW)
Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), s 57State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW), cl 8; Pt 2, Div 2, cll 19, 20, 21, 22, 23; Sch 1, Pt 2, cll 2, 3, 4, 7, 9, 10
State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW), cl 6, Pt 2 cl 7; Pt 4 cl 16; Appendix 4 cll 1.2, 1.9; Pt 2 cll 2.1, 2.3; Pt 4 cll 4.1AB, 4.1AC, 4.5, 4.6
State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) Amendment (Alex Avenue and Riverstone Precincts) 2010 (NSW)Cases Cited: Butler v Attorney General for the State of Victoria (1961) 106 CLR 268; [1961] HCA 32
Commissioner of Police for New South Wales v Eaton (2013) 252 CLR 1; [2013] HCA 2
Garnett v Bradley (1878) 3 App Cas 944
Goodwin v Phillips (1908) 7 CLR 1; [1908] HCA 55
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Nystrom (2006) 228 CLR 566; [2006] HCA 50
Potier v Attorney General for New South Wales (2015) 89 NSWLR 284; [2015] NSWCA 129
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355; [1998] HCA 28
Rose v Hvric (1963) 108 CLR 353; [1963] HCA 13
Saraswati v The Queen (1991) 172 CLR 1; [1991] HCA 21Texts Cited: D Pearce, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (9th ed, LexisNexis, 2019)
M Leeming, Resolving Conflicts of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Blacktown City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NSWCA 106
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was the proper interpretation and application of two State Environmental Planning Policies (SEPPs) that appeared to contain conflicting provisions regarding the development of secondary dwellings. Specifically, the court had to determine whether clause 22 of the SEPP (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009, which permitted secondary dwellings on lots of any size, impliedly repealed or overrode clause 4.1AC of the SEPP (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006, which stipulated a minimum lot size for such developments. The court also considered the effect of clauses within each SEPP that purported to resolve inconsistencies by prevailing over other planning instruments.
The Court of Appeal applied the principles of statutory interpretation, particularly concerning the harmonious construction of legislative provisions and the doctrine of implied repeal. The court found that the two SEPPs were capable of harmonious construction and that there was no actual contrariety between clause 22 of the SEPP (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 and clause 4.1AC of the SEPP (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006. The court reasoned that the SEPP (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 was intended to facilitate affordable rental housing and did not, by its terms, override specific provisions in other SEPPs that might impose additional requirements, such as minimum lot sizes, for development. The court concluded that the provisions could co-exist, with the SEPP (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 continuing to impose its lot size requirement.
The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal and treated the notice of appeal as validly filed. However, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent’s costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) To the extent necessary grant Universal Property Group Pty Ltd leave to appeal from the judgment and orders given in the Land and Environment Court on 21 November 2019.
(2) Treat the notice of appeal filed on 17 December 2019 as validly filed, to the extent that leave was required.
(3) Dismiss the appeal.
(4) Order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs in this Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
In response to the refusal, Universal appealed to the Land and Environment Court (the Court), arguing that the minimum lot size requirement should not apply to the site due to the provisions of the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW), specifically clause 22, which they contended should override the requirement in the Sydney Region Growth Centres Policy. The Court dismissed the appeal, finding that the two Policies could be harmoniously construed and that there was no actual contrariety between them that would necessitate the overriding of one by the other. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Universal sought leave to appeal to the New South Wales Court of Appeal.
The facts leading to this appeal revolve around the interpretation and application of these two Policies and the Council's refusal to grant development consent based on the minimum lot size requirement. The Council argued that the minimum lot size requirement was a necessary condition to ensure sustainable urban development and to maintain the character of the Sydney Region. Universal, on the other hand, argued that the Affordable Rental Housing Policy should take precedence as it aims to increase the availability of affordable rental housing, a matter of broader public benefit. The central issue in this case lies in determining whether the two Policies can coexist without one overriding the other and if the minimum lot size requirement should apply to the proposed development.
The matter of Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Blacktown City Council originated in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, where Universal Property Group Pty Ltd (the appellant) sought a review of a decision made by Blacktown City Council (the respondent). The appellant challenged the respondent's decision to deny a development application for a secondary dwelling on a specific property, contending that the minimum lot size requirement under the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW) was overridden by the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW). The Land and Environment Court, in a judgment delivered on 21 November 2019, dismissed the appellant's application. Dissatisfied with this outcome, the appellant lodged a notice of appeal on 17 December 2019, seeking leave to appeal against the decision of the Land and Environment Court. This appeal came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the primary focus was on the procedural validity of the appeal and the interpretation of the relevant State Environmental Planning Policies. The Court was tasked with determining whether the notice of appeal was properly filed and, if so, whether the appeal itself should be allowed. The Court's decision on these preliminary procedural matters set the stage for a comprehensive review of the substantive issues concerning the interplay between the two State Environmental Planning Policies.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the minimum lot size requirement for secondary dwellings is overridden by the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW)?
2. Is there a conflict between the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW), cl 22 and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW), cl 4.1AC that cannot be resolved through harmonious construction?
3. If a conflict exists, what is the effect of the clauses in each policy that purport to control the inconsistency by prevailing over the other?
4. Is there an actual contrariety between the two policies that necessitates an implied repeal of one over the other?
Held
1. The court concluded that the minimum lot size requirement for secondary dwellings is not overridden by the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW). Appeal dismissed.
2. The court determined that there is no conflict between the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW), cl 22 and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW), cl 4.1AC that cannot be resolved through harmonious construction. Application dismissed.
3. As no conflict was found, the court did not need to address the effect of the clauses in each policy that purport to control the inconsistency by prevailing over the other.
4. The court found that there is no actual contrariety between the two policies that necessitates an implied repeal of one over the other. Application dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Blacktown City Council, the NSW Court of Appeal addressed the interplay between the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW) with respect to secondary dwellings. The court examined whether the minimum lot size requirement for secondary dwellings was overridden by the two policies and whether there was a conflict between the policies that could not be resolved through harmonious construction. The Court of Appeal found that the minimum lot size requirement was not overridden and that no actual contrariety existed between the policies.
The Court began by assessing whether the minimum lot size requirement for secondary dwellings was overridden by the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) and the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW). The court concluded that neither policy explicitly provided for the overriding of the minimum lot size requirement. The policy for affordable rental housing, by its terms, did not address the minimum lot size, and the policy for growth centres did not explicitly state that it would override the minimum lot size. The court relied on the plain language of the policies and found that there was no express repeal or modification of the minimum lot size requirement.
Next, the Court considered whether a conflict existed between cl 22 of the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) and cl 4.1AC of the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW). The court examined whether the two provisions could be interpreted in a way that allowed them to operate harmoniously. The court applied the principle that statutes and policies should be construed in a manner that avoids conflict if possible. The court found that cl 22 of the affordable rental housing policy could be interpreted to allow for secondary dwellings on lots smaller than the minimum size if they were for the purpose of providing affordable rental housing, while cl 4.1AC of the growth centres policy could be interpreted to permit secondary dwellings on smaller lots for the purpose of achieving growth centre objectives. The court held that these provisions could be harmoniously construed to allow secondary dwellings on smaller lots under specific circumstances.
The court also addressed the effect of the clauses in each policy that purported to control the inconsistency by prevailing over the other. The court found that neither clause contained language that explicitly stated it would override the other. The court emphasized that the absence of such language meant that no implied repeal could be inferred. The court applied the principle that an implied repeal requires clear and unmistakable evidence of an intention to repeal. Since neither clause contained such language, the court found that no implied repeal occurred.
Finally, the court examined whether there was an actual contrariety between the two policies that necessitated an implied repeal of one over the other. The court found that the policies could be interpreted in a way that allowed them to operate without conflict. The court relied on the principle that an actual contrariety must exist for an implied repeal to occur. Since the court found that the policies could be harmoniously construed, it concluded that no actual contrariety existed, and thus no implied repeal was necessary.
In summary, the Court of Appeal held that the minimum lot size requirement for secondary dwellings was not overridden by the State Environmental Planning Policy (Affordable Rental Housing) 2009 (NSW) or the State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006 (NSW). The court found that the provisions in each policy could be harmoniously construed to allow for secondary dwellings on smaller lots under specific circumstances. The court also held that there was no actual contrariety between the policies that necessitated an implied repeal. The ratio decidendi of this case is that when interpreting planning policies, courts will seek to harmonize provisions to avoid conflict, and an implied repeal will only be inferred if there is clear and unmistakable evidence of an intention to repeal.