Tweedale v Carnival Plc trading as P&O Cruises

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tweedale v Carnival PLC trading as P&O Cruises [2021] FCA 1633

File number(s): NSD 967 of 2019
NSD 969 of 2019
NSD 1016 of 2019
NSD 1017 of 2019
NSD 1019 of 2019
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 22 December 2021
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for service outside the jurisdiction – application for substituted service – where applicants propose to effect service on second respondent’s solicitor under Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu) – where applicants propose to effect service personally on third respondent under Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu) – whether requirements of Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 10.43 and 10.49 satisfied – no discretionary grounds to decline to grant leave – applications granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to correct name of second respondent – where liquidator named as party as opposed to company in liquidation – where the applicants were mistaken as to the correct description of the second respondent company rather than as to the party’s identity – no apparent prejudice to company in liquidation – application granted

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (contained in Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth))

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 8.21, 8.22, 8.23, 8.24, 10.43, 10.48, 10.49

Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu) rr 5.2, 5.8, 5.9

Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents in Civil or Commercial Matters, opened for signature 15 November 1965, 658 UNTS 163 (entered into force 10 February 1969)

Vanuatu Companies (Insolvency and Receivership) Act No. 3 of 2013 (Vanuatu) Sch 4 Pt 2, cl 4

Cases cited:

Au Ka Ying v Guangdong (HK) Tours Co Ltd [2003] HCPI 440/2002 (Court of First Instance)

Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v Grand Shipping SA (1991) 173 CLR 231

BY Winddown Inc v Vautin [2016] FCAFC 168; (2016) 249 FCR 262

Costa Vraca Pty Ltd v Bell Regal Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 305

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Ma [1999] FCA 1093; (1999) 92 FCR 569

Heilbrunn v Lightwood PLC [2007] FCA 433

Ho v Akai Pty Ltd (in liq) [2006] FCAFC 159; (2006) 247 FCR 205

Jasmin Solar Pty Ltd v Trina Solar Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1453; (2015) 331 ALR 108

Laing v Victoria (2005) 144 FCR 462

Laurie v Carroll (1958) 98 CLR 310

McGraw-Hill Financial Inc v Clurname Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 211; (2017) 123 ACSR 467

Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491

Suzlon Energy Ltd v Bangad (No 3) [2012] FCA 123

Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd (1990) 171 CLR 538

Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 177; (2015) 323 ALR 138

Wong Mee Wan v Kwan Kin Travel Services Ltd  [1995] 4 All ER 745; [1996] 1 WLR 38

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 83
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tweedale v Carnival Plc trading as P&O Cruises and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1633
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tweedale v Carnival Plc trading as P&O Cruises involved a dispute over service of documents and amendments to the party names in a legal proceeding. The matter was before the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues focused on whether the applicants could amend the name of the second respondent, and if the court should grant leave for service of the originating application and statement of claim outside Australia.

The court addressed these issues by first considering the applicants' request to correct the name of the second respondent. It found that the applicants had mistakenly identified the liquidator instead of the company in liquidation. However, the court determined that this error did not prejudice the company in liquidation. Consequently, the court granted the applicants' request to amend the name of the second respondent.

Regarding the service of documents abroad, the court noted that the applicants had proposed to serve the documents on the second respondent's solicitor and the third respondent personally, in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu). The court found that the requirements of the Federal Court Rules 2011 were satisfied and that there were no discretionary grounds to decline the applications. Therefore, the court granted the applications for service outside the jurisdiction.

In summary, the court granted leave to amend the name of the second respondent and allowed service of the originating application and statement of claim outside Australia. The costs were reserved for a later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant be granted leave pursuant to r 8.21(1)(c) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to correct the name of the second respondent to “Adventures in Paradise Limited (5559) (in liquidation)” in the originating application.

2. By 4:00pm on Wednesday, 19 January 2022, the applicant is to:

(a) amend the name of the second respondent on the originating application, with the date on which the amendment is made and the date of these orders to be recorded on the originating application at the same time in accordance with r 8.23(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth);

(b) amend the name of the second respondent on the statement of claim with the date on which the amendment is made and the date of these orders; and

(c) file by electronic means the originating application and statement of claim as amended in accordance with these orders.

3. The applicant be granted leave to serve the originating application and statement of claim as corrected in accordance with orders 1 and 2 above, together with a copy of these orders and the accompanying reasons dated 22 December 2021, upon the second respondent in Vanuatu.

4. The applicant be granted leave to effect service of the originating application and statement of claim on the solicitor for the second respondent, Mr Mark Fleming of Pacific Partners, in accordance with rule 5.9(2)(d) of the Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu).

5. The applicant be granted leave to serve the originating application and statement of claim as corrected in accordance with orders 1 and 2 above, together with a copy of these orders and the accompanying reasons, on the third respondent in Vanuatu by personal service in accordance with rr 5.2 and 5.8 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2002 (Vanuatu).

6. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, I note that this matter has suffered from significant delays due, among other things, to deficiencies in the way the interlocutory applications were prepared, including the failure to lead evidence on certain essential elements required to be satisfied before leave to serve abroad could be granted, the applicants’ mistake in naming the liquidator as the second respondent in each of the matters instead of Adventures in Paradise, and the applicants’ failure to address the relevance of limitation periods to the applications to amend or substitute the second respondent. With respect, a higher standard in the conduct of proceedings in the Federal Court is to be expected, particularly where counsel has been briefed and the proceedings at this stage are ex parte with respect to the second and third respondents. In this regard, I would emphasise that I am not making a finding that the legal representatives have acted so as to breach any professional or other obligations or suggesting that such a finding might be made. Rather, against that context, I wish to highlight how imperative it is for the parties going forward to do all that is reasonably in their power to progress this matter efficiently to trial and to facilitate the Court’s task in resolving the dispute, in line with the obligations under ss 37M and 37N of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). 3. EVIDENCE In support of the interlocutory applications, the applicant(s) in each matter respectively relied upon:(1)the affidavits of Sara Kaurin, solicitor, Shine Lawyers, sworn 7 June 2021 and 28 October 2021 (NSD 967 of 2019);(2)the affidavits of Ms Kaurin sworn 7 June 2021 and 28 October 2021 (NSD 969 of 2019);(3)the affidavits of Rita Yousef, solicitor, Stacks Goudkamp, affirmed 7 June 2021 and 28 October 2021 (NSD 1016 of 2019);(4)the affidavits of Ms Yousef affirmed 7 June 2021 and 28 October 2021 (NSD 1017 of 2019); and(5)the affidavits of Ms Yousef affirmed 7 June 2021 and 28 October 2021 (NSD 1019 of 2019). The contents of the affidavits of Ms Kaurin and Ms Yousef listed at [14] above are relevantly identical. For convenience, therefore, I refer collectively to the Kaurin/Yousef June and Kaurin/Yousef October affidavits. The Kaurin/Yousef June affidavits set out, among other things, the history of the proceedings, unsuccessful attempts at effecting service, matters pertaining to an insurance policy in place between the first respondent and Adventures in Paradise which was issued on 14 December 2015, and correspondence with AIG’s solicitor and Adventure in Paradise’s liquidator and solicitor respectively. Rule 10.43(3)(c) of the FCR provides that an application for leave to serve an originating application outside Australia must be accompanied by an affidavit stating, among other things, that the proposed method of service is permitted by:(i)if a convention applies – the convention; or(ii)if the Hague Convention applies – the Hague Convention; or(iii)in any other case – the law of the foreign country.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 27 May 2020, the Supreme Court of Vanuatu rejected the application to proceed against Adventures in Paradise (the Vanuatu judgment) (Annexures SK-18/RY-18 to the Kaurin/Yousef June affidavits). In that regard, the judge noted that the liquidator had advised that he was hoping that a sale of Adventures in Paradise’s land would be completed that week, its debts fully discharged and a final order to have Adventures in Paradise removed from the register applied for within a month (Vanuatu judgment at [9]). Her Honour concluded that it was necessary to decline the application because there was no evidence of the terms and conditions of any policy of insurance covering Adventures in Paradise at the time of the motor vehicle accident (Vanuatu judgment at [17]). Her Honour also referred to other matters that counted against the grant of leave including prejudice to the creditors (as the liquidation would be delayed), the apparent insufficiency of the applicants’ undertaking to defray the cost of keeping Adventures in Paradise on foot during the period of litigation, and the applicants’ delay in commencing proceedings (Vanuatu judgment at [18]). Subsequently, on 10 September 2020 the solicitors for P&O Cruises produced to the applicants a copy of the insurance policy taken out by Adventures in Paradise with AIG in response to an application for preliminary discovery (Kaurin/Yousef June affidavits at [37]–[38] and Annexures SK-22/RY-22). The applicants submit that that policy would provide cover for the applicants’ damage and loss and may also cover the third respondent’s negligence (applicants’ June submissions at [20]). On 6 November 2020, Stacks Goudkamp sent a letter to Mr Fleming and Mr Jenkins seeking an update as to the status of Adventures in Paradise, noting that during oral submissions at the hearing of the application in Vanuatu, Mr Fleming had informed the Court that the liquidator hoped that the liquidation process would be completed within a month. The letter also advised that if the liquidation had come to an end and all creditors and expenses had been paid, the applicants considered that Mr Jenkins had no interest in continuing to act as liquidator in opposition to the applicants’ claim and, subject to Mr Jenkins’ response, advised of their intention to proceed to appoint a new liquidator to continue the claim made on the insurance policy in relation to the damages sought by the applicants (Kaurin/Yousef June affidavits at [39] and Annexures SK-23/RY-23). On 16 December 2020, the applicants were directed to file and serve any application for substituted service in the current proceedings by 18 December 2020. On 21 December 2021, the time for filing and service of the application for substituted service and any application for service outside the jurisdiction in relation to the second respondent was extended to 22 December 2020. On 23 December 2020, the interlocutory applications were filed seeking leave to serve the originating applications and the statements of claim outside Australia, orders for substituted service and in the alternative, orders for deemed service, pursuant to rr 10.43, 10.49 and 10.48 respectively of the FCR. In view of the conclusions which I have reached (as explained below), it is unnecessary to consider the alternative order sought for deemed service under r 10.48 of the FCR.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the hearing on 16 February 2021 with respect to the first interlocutory applications, P&O Cruises indicated that they did not oppose nor consent to the orders then sought by the applicants. They did not file any submissions or otherwise seek to be heard on the current interlocutory applications. 5. CONSIDERATION5.1 The application for leave to amend/correct the name of the second respondent The applicants seek orders amending the name of the second respondent, the liquidator, to Adventures in Paradise (5559) (in liquidation) on the basis that “the incorrect naming is a “mistake in the name of the party to the proceeding” and may be corrected under Rule 8.21(1)(c)” of the FCR (the first alternative). Alternatively, the applicants submit that the error is in the identity of the party and therefore leave to amend the name is sought under rule 8.21(1)(d) (the second alternative). In the further alternative, an order is sought under rule 8.21(1)(f) to substitute the proper party, Adventures in Paradise (5553) (in liquidation), for the liquidator (the third alternative). Rule 8.21 relevantly provides that:(1) An applicant may apply to the Court for leave to amend an originating application for any reason, including:…(c) to correct a mistake in the name of a party to the proceeding; or(d) to correct the identity of a party to the proceeding; or…(f) to substitute a person for a party to the proceeding; … Rule 8.21(1) is not an exhaustive statement of the grounds on which an originating application may be amended: McGraw-Hill Financial Inc v Clurname Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 211; (2017) 123 ACSR 467 at [23] (the Court). Rule 8.22 provides that if an originating application is amended with the effect that another person is substituted as a party to the proceeding, the proceeding is taken to have started for that person on the day the originating application is amended. The alterations must be made on the originating application under rule 8.23, which also requires the date on which the amendment is made and the date on which the order permitting the amendment is made, to be marked on the originating application. Rule 8.24 is also relevant, which provides that:An order that an applicant be permitted to amend an originating application ceases to have effect unless the applicant amends the originating application in accordance with the order within:(a) the period specified in the order; or(b) if no period is specified in the order – 14 days after the date on which the order permitting the amendment was made.Note: If the Court permits an applicant to amend an originating application, the Court may also make orders about the procedure for amending the originating application and serving the originating application. As to the first alternative on which the applicants rely, the applicants submit that the power under rule 8.21(1)(c) includes the situation where a party, intending to sue a person identified by a particular description, was mistaken as to the name of the person who answered that description.