Tweed Shire Council v Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      TWEED SHIRE COUNCIL v HANCOMATIC MUSIC PTY LTD & ANOR HANCOMATIC MUSIC PTY LTD v LETITIA HANCOCK HANCOMATIC MUSIC PTY LTD v ANTHONY RICHARD HANCOCKHANCOMATIC MUSIC PTY LTD v LUKE HANCOCK bnf ANTHONY HANCOCK [2007]  NSWCA 350

FILE NUMBER(S):
40021/2006
40022/2006
40230/2006
40030/2006
40031/2006
40032/2006

HEARING DATE(S):               22, 23 and 24 May 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 6 December 2007

PARTIES:
TWEED SHIRE COUNCIL
HANCOMATIC MUSIC PTY LTD & ANOR
LETITIA ARAGON HANCOCK
ANTHONY RICHARD HANCOCK
LUKE HANCOCK bnf ANTHONY HANCOCK

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P McColl JA Bell J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 71/2002
DC 72/2002

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Phegan J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    9 December 2005

COUNSEL:
P Taylor QC/ J Castaldi - Tweed Shire Council
P Deakin QC/B Shields - Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd
D Wheelahan QC/P McGuinness - Hancock

SOLICITORS:
Morag & Agnew  - Tweed Shire Council
Curwood Partners - Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd
Bruce Peters - Hancock

CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – Appeal - general principles – interference with judge’s findings of fact – functions of appellate court – findings on issue of negligence – generally – whether safety glass was required to be installed by Ordinance and/or Australian Standard – where trial judge found construction of sliding glass door to be after Ordinance and/or Australian Standard came into existence – finding of fact overturned on appeal
TORTS – Negligence – essentials of action for negligence – duty of care – miscellaneous cases – owner of premises – partly commercial premises – motel and reception – sliding glass door to reception made of annealed glass – child ran into sliding door – child was son and brother of plaintiffs – whether there was a failure to construct building in accordance with Ordinance and/or Australian Standard – building found to be constructed before Ordinance and/or Australian Standard came into effect – relevance of Ordinance and/or Australian Standard to negligence
TORTS – Negligence – essentials of action for negligence – duty of care – miscellaneous cases – where council gave approval for building – whether council had a duty to advise or require plaintiffs’ and owners’ compliance with Ordinance – Local Government Act 1919, s 310, s 314
TORTS – Negligence – essentials of action for negligence – duty of care – miscellaneous cases – whether owner under a duty conduct a safety audit when renovations carried out – duty is not so specific – duty is to take reasonable care in the circumstances – where no knowledge of dangers of annealed glass – where annealed glass not a dangerous defect

LEGISLATION CITED:
Halsbury’s Laws of Australia
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946
Local Government Act 1919

CASES CITED:
Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167
Ahluwalia v Robinson [2003] NSWCA 173
Andar Transport Pty Ltd v Brambles Ltd (2004) 217 CLR 424
Balesfire Pty Ltd t/as Gutter Shop v Adams [2006] NSWCA 112
Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd t/as Quirks Refrigeration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tweed Shire Council v Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Tweed Shire Council v Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd* involved an appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerning the liability of Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd, the owner of motel premises, and the Tweed Shire Council. The dispute arose from the death of a six-year-old child who suffered fatal injuries after running into a sliding glass door made of annealed glass at the motel reception area. The plaintiffs, the child's parents, sued Hancomatic, which in turn sought an indemnity from the Council, alleging breaches of duty of care.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether Hancomatic and/or the Council owed a duty of care to the deceased child and his parents, and if so, whether that duty was breached. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the use of annealed glass in the sliding door constituted a breach of duty, particularly in light of relevant building ordinances and Australian Standards that came into effect after the premises were constructed. The court also had to assess whether the Council, having approved the building, had a duty to advise or require compliance with these regulations, and whether the owner had a duty to conduct a safety audit during renovations.

The Court of Appeal overturned the trial judge's findings of fact regarding the timing of the construction and the applicability of the relevant Ordinance and Australian Standard. The court reasoned that the building was constructed before the Ordinance and the Australian Standard came into effect, rendering them not directly applicable to the original construction. The court clarified that the duty of care owed by the owner of premises is to take reasonable care in the circumstances, not to conduct specific safety audits, and that annealed glass was not considered a dangerous defect in the absence of knowledge of its specific dangers. The court found that neither Hancomatic nor the Council had breached their respective duties of care.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal upheld all appeals, meaning the original judgment in favour of the plaintiffs and the indemnity awarded to Hancomatic against the Council were overturned.

Orders

Orders of the court

Uphold all appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

At issue are questions of duty of care and breach touching the liability of Hancomatic Music Pty Ltd (“Hancomatic”) and the Tweed Shire Council (“the Council”) with respect to the type of glass installed in certain premises at the time of the accident. Hancomatic was the owner of the premises and it alone was sued by the plaintiffs. It was awarded a full indemnity from the Council on the grounds of either a breach of duty to Hancomatic or as a joint tortfeasor that would, if sued by the plaintiffs, have been liable to them.Background and issues At about 4pm on 3 March 1999 Ryan Hancock, aged six years, ran into a glass sliding door leading into the motel reception area at premises known as the Town Motel and Eatery in Wharf Street, Murwillumbah. The glass shattered severely lacerating his neck and severing his carotid and jugular blood vessels. He died approximately 35 minutes later. The glass in the door was annealed glass. Ryan’s father and mother, Anthony and Letitia Hancock, were close by when the accident happened. They ran to Ryan’s aid. His brother, Luke, who was then aged 7, was running behind him. Each plaintiff brought proceedings against the owner of the premises, Hancomatic, seeking to recover damages in relation to the injuries they claim to have suffered as a consequence of the circumstances in which Ryan died. They asserted that various duties of care had been breached by Hancomatic because annealed glass, rather than safety glass, had been used in the reception area door. It was common ground at trial that the glass door had been constructed when Hancomatic redeveloped the Wharf Street premises in the period 1971 – 1973. The redevelopment involved refurbishing an existing building to create a shopping complex fronting onto Wharf Street to the south. The shopping area included the motel reception area. The other aspect involved constructing motel units at the north end of the property. During the period of the redevelopment, the statutory regime relating to the characteristics of glass to be used in glass doors in commercial premises significantly altered. In the early 1970s building regulation was controlled by Pt XI of the Local Government Act 1919 (ss304-319) and Ordinance No 71. (See generally Wilcox, The Law of Land Development in New South Wales (1967) Law Book Company at Chapters11-14. Ordinance 71, cl 44C relevantly stipulated that safety class shall be used in … every glass door” (cl 44C(b)(i)). The clause was inserted into Ordinance 71 (Building) by Government Gazette No 1 7/1/72, taking effect from 1 July 1972. Further, Australian Standard AS1288 (Installation of Glass in Buildings), which provided for limits to areas which could be glazed with annealed glass, was published in 1973. The 1973 Australian Standard, AS1288 was given statutory force by regulations made under the Local Government Act 1919. According to the expert evidence at trial none of the sliding doors at the Wharf Street premises, including in the reception area sliding door, was within the maximum permitted area in which annealed glass could be used (Red 52K. References to “Red” relate to Red Book in 40021/2006.).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established