Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd t/as Quirks Refrigeration v Sweeney

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:     Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd t/as Quirks Refrigeration v Sweeney [2005]  NSWCA 8

FILE NUMBER(S):
40212/04

HEARING DATE(S): 03/02/05

JUDGMENT DATE:    18/02/2005

PARTIES:
Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd t/as Quirks Refrigeration (Appellant)
Maria Sweeney (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:        Giles JA Ipp JA Brownie AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:    District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):             DC 1350/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:        Robison DCJ

COUNSEL:
J E Maconachie QC/N Chen (Appellant)
M L Williams SC/M Ward (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Holman Webb (Appellant)
McLachlan Chilton (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE - Vicarious liability - Employer/employee relationship - Test for determining whether a person is an employee - Factors regarded as relevant to the issue - Independent contractor - Whether a principal is vicariously liable for the actions of an independent contractor - NEGLIGENCE - Vicarious liability - representative - principal is not vicariously liable for the actions of a person who is neither an independent contractor nor an agent but is a representative of that principal.  D

LEGISLATION CITED:
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW), cl 2(1), Schedule 1

DECISION:
(1) Application for leave to appeal granted (2) Appeal upheld (3) The judgment and verdict in favour of Mrs Sweeney are set aside, and in lieu thereof there shall be judgment and a verdict in favour of Boylan (4) Mrs Sweeney to pay Boylan's costs of the trial, the costs of the application for leave to appeal and appeal (5) Mrs Sweeney to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise entitled.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40212/04
DC 1350/02

GILES JA
IPP JA
BROWNIE AJA

Friday, 18 February 2005

BOYLAN NOMINEES PTY LTD t/as QUIRKS REFRIGERATION v MARIA SWEENEY

FACTS

On 2 August 2000 Mrs Sweeney was injured in the convenience store of a BP service station when a refrigerator door fell on her.  Boylan had supplied the refrigerator and was responsible for its maintenance and service. 

The owner of the convenience store, on 2 August 2000, complained to Boylan that the refrigerator’s door was not closing properly and requested Boylan to attend to it.  Boylan thereupon arranged for Mr Comninos to go to the service station and service the refrigerator.  Mr Comninos did just that.  The door fell on Mrs Sweeney shortly after Mr Comninos completed working on it.

Mrs Sweeney brought an action in negligence against Boylan.  Robison DCJ granted judgement and a verdict in her favour after having found that Mr Comninos carried out the servicing of the refrigerator negligently and that Boylan was vicariously liable for his negligence.  Boylan now appeals against Robison DCJ’s finding that it was vicariously liable for Mr Comninos’s negligence. 

HELD per Ipp JA (Giles JA and Brownie AJA agreeing):

  1. The mere fact that a person represents a principal does not necessarily make him/her an employee.  Due regard must be had to the factors that have been long regarded as relevant to the question.  

  2. When determining whether a person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd t/as Quirks Refrigeration v Sweeney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Boylan Nominees Pty Ltd (trading as Quirks Refrigeration) against a judgment in favour of Mrs Sweeney. The dispute arose from an incident where Mrs Sweeney suffered injury, and the primary judge had found Boylan liable due to vicarious responsibility for the conduct of Mr Comninos. Boylan challenged the finding that Mr Comninos was an employee for whom they could be vicariously liable.

The central legal issue before the court was whether Mr Comninos was an employee of Boylan, thereby rendering Boylan vicariously liable for his actions, or an independent contractor for whom Boylan would not be liable. This required the court to determine the nature of the relationship between Boylan and Mr Comninos, applying the relevant legal tests for distinguishing between an employee and an independent contractor.

The court reasoned that the primary judge's finding that Mr Comninos was an employee was not supported by the evidence. Despite a "close working relationship," the facts indicated that Mr Comninos operated his own business, Cool Runnings Refrigeration and Airconditioning Pty Ltd, held a contractor's licence, supplied his own tools and van (which displayed his company's identity), arranged his own insurance, and was paid on a piecework basis via invoices. Boylan did not provide him with a salary, superannuation, or a work van, nor was there an obligation for Boylan to provide work or for Mr Comninos to accept it. These factors strongly pointed towards an independent contractor relationship, not one of employment.

Consequently, the appeal was upheld. The judgment and verdict in favour of Mrs Sweeney were set aside, and judgment was entered in favour of Boylan. Mrs Sweeney was ordered to pay Boylan's costs of the trial and appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Application for leave to appeal granted (2) Appeal upheld (3) The judgment and verdict in favour of Mrs Sweeney are set aside, and in lieu thereof there shall be judgment and a verdict in favour of Boylan (4) Mrs Sweeney to pay Boylan's costs of the trial, the costs of the application for leave to appeal and appeal (5) Mrs Sweeney to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise entitled.

Background

Background to the litigation

Accordingly, the judge must be taken to have found Boylan to be liable solely by reason of its vicarious responsibility for the conduct of Mr Comninos. In the circumstances, I would not uphold the argument that Boylan was liable other than vicariously. The facts relating to Boylan’s engagement of Mr Comninos Robison DCJ said that there was “a close working relationship to say the least” between Boylan and Mr Comninos and that their relationship was “significant”, but did not explain what he understood the consequence of such a relationship to be. Eventually, the judge found that “at the end of the day Mr Comninos was acting as a servant or agent of [Boylan] with the authority and the approval of [Boylan] to undertake the work that he did”. Senior counsel for both Boylan and Mrs Sweeney accepted that this was intended to be a finding that Mr Comninos was an employee of Boylan. Boylan challenged the validity of this finding. Boylan’s premises, at the relevant time, comprised at least a warehouse (where refrigeration equipment was stored) and a service department, including a workshop. The service department was staffed by six employees (who worked within Boylan’s plant) and three “field service” employees (who carried out work principally at the premises of Boylan’s customers). In addition, Boylan engaged two men who it termed “contractors”. The contractors did not work within the Boylan plant. They did the same kind of work as the field service employees but were only requested to work when the three field service employees were fully occupied. Mr Comninos was one of those two contractors. In practice, he carried out work for Boylan on a daily basis. Mr Comninos held a trade certificate as a refrigeration mechanic and a contractor’s licence issued by the Department of Fair Trading. Boylan regarded him as an independent contractor. Robison DCJ found that “Mr Comninos had his own business”. There was no formal or general contract between Boylan and Mr Comninos. Whenever Boylan needed him to do work for a customer, he would be requested to do so. In other words, Boylan was not obliged to provide work for Mr Comninos on a continuing basis or for any specific period, and Mr Comninos was not obliged to work for Boylan on a continuing basis or for any specific period. Boylan did not supply Mr Comninos with equipment or tools, did not pay him superannuation and did not provide him with a work van. He took out his own workers compensation and public liability insurance. Mr Comninos supplied his own van for the purposes of his work. The van, the judge found, “had his own corporate identity displayed on it”. His “corporate identity” was a company called Cool Runnings Refrigeration and Airconditioning Pty Ltd, of which he was a director. His van had the words “Cool Runnings” displayed on it. The evidence does not reveal whether Boylan, in law, engaged Mr Comninos or his company. Mr Comninos was not paid a salary, but invoiced Boylan for the hours of work he performed, that is, on a piecework basis. At times, he purchased spare parts from a manufacturer of refrigeration equipment (not Boylan). On his own initiative he used these spare parts when servicing equipment at Boylan’s request. He would then invoice Boylan for those spare parts. Sometimes he would obtain the spare parts from Boylan itself.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established