Turner v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   TURNER -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2021] WASCA 158

CORAM:   BUSS P

MITCHELL JA

MORRISON AJA

HEARD:   17 MAY 2021

DELIVERED          :   3 SEPTEMBER 2021

FILE NO/S:   CACR 174 of 2019

BETWEEN:   PAUL GARY TURNER

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   McGRATH J

File Number            :   INS 428 of 2017


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Appeal against conviction - Appellant convicted after trial of murder - Appellant failed to establish that he was of unsound mind within s 27(1) of the Criminal Code (WA) - Whether the trial judge failed adequately or at all to direct the jury that evidence relevant to but not establishing insanity was relevant to whether the appellant had the requisite intent for murder

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA), s 23A(2), s 26, s 27(1), s 279(1), s 280

Result:

Leave to appeal refused
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : Mr S B Watters
Respondent : Mr L M Fox SC

Solicitors:

Appellant : Robson Legal
Respondent : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Birdsall v The State of Western Australia [2019] WASCA 79; (2019) 54 WAR 418

Clarke v The State of Western Australia [2018] WASCA 14

Schmidt v The State of Western Australia [2013] WASCA 201

Wongawol v The State of Western Australia [2011] WASCA 222; (2011) 42 WAR 91

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:

  1. The appellant appeals against his conviction of murdering his ex‑partner, Sarah Thomas.  The appellant stabbed Ms Thomas in a conference room at the Joondalup Courthouse with a large kitchen knife.  There was no issue at trial as to the circumstances in which he did so.  Events outside the conference room were captured on CCTV.  Events inside the conference room were the subject of uncontested evidence of a registrar, not contradicted by the appellant who in his evidence at trial claimed to remember nothing of the events.  Uncontested medical evidence established that the stab wounds inflicted by the appellant caused Ms Thomas' death.  The circumstances in which she died may be summarised as follows.

  2. On 20 December 2016, the appellant attended a compulsory pre‑trial mediation of legal proceedings in the Magistrates Court between himself and Ms Thomas at the Joondalup Courthouse.  The issues in the Magistrates Court proceedings concerned the appellant's claim for $1,950 that he lent to Ms Thomas. 

  3. At the time there were other disputes between the appellant and Ms Thomas in the Family Court about: (i) custody of, and access to, their two children, then aged about seven and five; and (ii) a property settlement.  The dispute about the custody of the children had come to a head shortly before Ms Thomas was killed.  The appellant and Ms Thomas entered into a childcare agreement on 9 December 2016.  That evening, the appellant indicated that he signed the agreement under duress…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASCA 158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Turner v The State of Western Australia involved a criminal appeal by the appellant, Turner, against his conviction for murder. The primary issue before the court was whether the trial judge had properly directed the jury on the necessary elements of the offence, particularly in relation to the appellant’s mental state and the inference of intent. Turner contended that the trial judge had failed to sufficiently address the impact of his dissociative seizures on the inference of intent, which is a critical element in establishing murder. The court was required to determine if the trial judge's directions to the jury were adequate in law and whether they covered all necessary aspects of the case, including the appellant's mental condition and the inference of intent.

The court meticulously examined the trial judge's directions to the jury, particularly those concerning the inference of intent and the appellant’s mental state. It noted that the trial judge had addressed the appellant’s dissociative seizures, characterising them as a mental illness, and had directed the jury on the need to consider these in determining intent. The court found that while the trial judge had broadly covered the necessary aspects of intent and mental state, there were specific omissions that needed to be rectified. The trial judge had not fully explored how the dissociative seizures could impact the inference of intent, which was a critical omission. The court concluded that the trial judge’s directions were not sufficiently comprehensive to ensure the jury properly understood the implications of the appellant’s mental condition on the inference of intent.

The court ordered a new trial, finding that the trial judge’s directions to the jury were deficient in critical areas. Specifically, the trial judge had not adequately addressed how the appellant’s dissociative seizures could influence the inference of intent, which is an essential component of the offence of murder. The court held that these omissions could potentially lead to a miscarriage of justice and necessitated a retrial to ensure the jury could make an informed decision based on complete and accurate legal directions. The court’s decision underscored the importance of comprehensive and precise jury directions in criminal trials, particularly where the accused’s mental state is a significant factor.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The jury were then directed that the question of intent was a matter of inference, and in that respect the trial judge identified a number of factors that were relevant:[42]Now, the State relies upon - that the accused, on the State case, possessed the knife. He inflicted multiple stab wounds. A number of the wounds were directed to the head area, namely the neck and to the ear. The State says the taking of the knife, secreted and using it in that way, to inflicting the wounds to the upper area of the body, when you put the inferences together, the only reasonable inference is that the accused had the intention either to kill or to inflict an injury that objectively would endanger life or likely to endanger life.Now, the defence would point to other facts. Look at the type of knife used. Mr Turner had another knife and he had the actual W.E. Fairbairn type knife. Where did the knife come from? Was it secreted? Look at the wounds. There wasn't one single lethal wound inflicted by a knife you'd expect him to take. That when you look at the number of wounds and what occurred in there, on the State case, you couldn't infer or find that the only reasonable inference is that Mr Turner had that specific - one of those two specific intentions. And that is an example of an inference that you'll be, in this trial, asked to determine. (emphasis added)[42] ts 689 ‑ 690. The points which we have emphasised in the passage above are some of the very matters which the appellant now contends were not raised with the jury. The jury were told that the appellant had a mental illness, namely the dissociative seizures 'which was … diagnosed in the expressed opinion of Dr Yogarajah'.[43] Then, a few minutes later, that was reinforced by the trial judge saying: 'The effect of Dr Yogarajah's evidence was that in his opinion Mr Turner suffers from dissociative seizures, and that dissociative seizures are a mental illness'.[44][43] ts 700.[44] ts 701. The trial judge dealt with unsoundness of mind and then commenced directions about the specific intents that had to be considered in the event that the jury were not satisfied that the appellant was of unsound mind. The passage is as follows:[45]If you find that you are not satisfied on the balance of probabilities the accused was of unsound mind and you are satisfied of the other elements, you then at that point have been satisfied that there's an unlawful killing. You turn then to the final element which - of murder which is the specific intention. It's then that we turn to this, and you would turn to this as triers of the fact.So let me now turn to the fourth element, which is these two specific intentions. The fourth element is the accused must have had an intention to either kill the deceased, or do a bodily injury of such a nature as to endanger, or be likely to endanger her life at the time the deceased – at the time he did the act of stabbing the neck - the upper lateral area of the neck of Ms Thomas.A finding that an accused person simply has an intention to harm, hurt, slice someone with a knife without the specific intention is insufficient to convict the accused of murder. An intention is a state of mind. It is to do an act with the purpose of bringing about a particular result or consequence.Now, you can't step inside a person's mind, so how do you determine intention? You infer an intention from the circumstances in which the death occurred and from the conduct, any words that were spoken at the time or after the accused did the specific acts which caused the death of the deceased; that is, you look at all - the totality of the relevant evidence and ask, can you infer that the accused held one of the two specific intentions at the very time that he inflicted the lethal knife wound to the upper lateral area of the neck of the deceased?In determining intention, you should consider the factors personal to the accused, including the age, level of intelligence and factors such as that. In some cases a person's act may provide important evidence in determining intention. The State points to the inflicting of a knife to the upper lateral part of the neck of the deceased and refers to the evidence of Mr Clarke. (emphasis added)[45] ts 701 ‑ 702.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When directing on how to draw inferences the trial judge told the jury:[41]… the evidence is not looked at in a piecemeal fashion. You don't look at each single piece. You put together all of the relevant evidence that bears upon whether the inference can be drawn and you say, 'Well, what inference is available from all this evidence when it is together?' (emphasis added)[41] ts 687. The jury were then directed that the question of intent was a matter of inference, and in that respect the trial judge identified a number of factors that were relevant:[42]Now, the State relies upon - that the accused, on the State case, possessed the knife. He inflicted multiple stab wounds. A number of the wounds were directed to the head area, namely the neck and to the ear. The State says the taking of the knife, secreted and using it in that way, to inflicting the wounds to the upper area of the body, when you put the inferences together, the only reasonable inference is that the accused had the intention either to kill or to inflict an injury that objectively would endanger life or likely to endanger life.Now, the defence would point to other facts. Look at the type of knife used. Mr Turner had another knife and he had the actual W.E. Fairbairn type knife. Where did the knife come from? Was it secreted? Look at the wounds. There wasn't one single lethal wound inflicted by a knife you'd expect him to take. That when you look at the number of wounds and what occurred in there, on the State case, you couldn't infer or find that the only reasonable inference is that Mr Turner had that specific - one of those two specific intentions. And that is an example of an inference that you'll be, in this trial, asked to determine. (emphasis added)[42] ts 689 ‑ 690. The points which we have emphasised in the passage above are some of the very matters which the appellant now contends were not raised with the jury. The jury were told that the appellant had a mental illness, namely the dissociative seizures 'which was … diagnosed in the expressed opinion of Dr Yogarajah'.[43] Then, a few minutes later, that was reinforced by the trial judge saying: 'The effect of Dr Yogarajah's evidence was that in his opinion Mr Turner suffers from dissociative seizures, and that dissociative seizures are a mental illness'.[44][43] ts 700.[44] ts 701. The trial judge dealt with unsoundness of mind and then commenced directions about the specific intents that had to be considered in the event that the jury were not satisfied that the appellant was of unsound mind. The passage is as follows:[45]If you find that you are not satisfied on the balance of probabilities the accused was of unsound mind and you are satisfied of the other elements, you then at that point have been satisfied that there's an unlawful killing. You turn then to the final element which - of murder which is the specific intention. It's then that we turn to this, and you would turn to this as triers of the fact.So let me now turn to the fourth element, which is these two specific intentions. The fourth element is the accused must have had an intention to either kill the deceased, or do a bodily injury of such a nature as to endanger, or be likely to endanger her life at the time the deceased – at the time he did the act of stabbing the neck - the upper lateral area of the neck of Ms Thomas.A finding that an accused person simply has an intention to harm, hurt, slice someone with a knife without the specific intention is insufficient to convict the accused of murder. An intention is a state of mind. It is to do an act with the purpose of bringing about a particular result or consequence.Now, you can't step inside a person's mind, so how do you determine intention? You infer an intention from the circumstances in which the death occurred and from the conduct, any words that were spoken at the time or after the accused did the specific acts which caused the death of the deceased; that is, you look at all - the totality of the relevant evidence and ask, can you infer that the accused held one of the two specific intentions at the very time that he inflicted the lethal knife wound to the upper lateral area of the neck of the deceased?In determining intention, you should consider the factors personal to the accused, including the age, level of intelligence and factors such as that. In some cases a person's act may provide important evidence in determining intention. The State points to the inflicting of a knife to the upper lateral part of the neck of the deceased and refers to the evidence of Mr Clarke. (emphasis added)[45] ts 701 ‑ 702.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established