| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
CITATION: | Turner v Employers Mutual Management Pty Limited [2021] NSWPIC 508 |
| APPLICANT: | Teresa Turner |
| RESPONDENT: | Employers Mutual Management Pty Limited |
| MEMBER: | Anthony Scarcella |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 08 December 2021 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for weekly benefits compensation; accepted injuries to the left shoulder, left elbow and left knee; whether the applicant suffered frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand and cervical spine and a consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand; the value of contemporaneous evidence; absence of contemporaneous complaints of left wrist, left hand, right wrist, right hand and cervical spine; the weight given to expert reports; Onassis and Calogeropoulos v Vergottis, Department of Aging, Disability and Home Care v Findlay, Department of Education and Training v Ireland, Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes, Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates; Paric v John Holland (Constructions) Pty Ltd, Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles and Hancock v East Coast Timbers Products Pty Ltd considered and applied; Held - award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed injury to the left wrist and left hand on 10 July 2019; award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed consequential condition to the right wrist and right hand; award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed injury to the cervical spine on 10 July 2019; in respect of the accepted injuries to the applicant’s left shoulder, left elbow and left knee, the applicant was fit to return to her pre-injury employment as a claims assessor; award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed entitlement to weekly benefits compensation under section 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | 1. The applicant did not suffer injuries to the left wrist and left hand arising out of or in the course of her employment with the respondent on 10 July 2019 within the meaning of sections 4(a) and 9A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. 2. The applicant did not suffer a consequential condition to the right wrist and right hand as a result of the accepted injury to the left shoulder and left elbow in the course of her employment with the respondent on 10 July 2019. 3. The applicant did not suffer an injury to the cervical spine arising out of or in the course of her employment with the respondent on 10 July 2019 within the meaning of sections 4(a) and 9A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. 4. In respect of the accepted injuries to the applicant’s left shoulder, left elbow and left knee, the applicant was fit to return to her pre-injury employment as a claims assessor. |
| ORDERS MADE: | 5. Award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed injury to the left wrist and left hand on 10 July 2019. 6. Award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed consequential condition to the right wrist and right hand. 7. Award for the respondent in respect of the… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner v Employers Mutual Management Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWPIC 508
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence and considered whether Turner had frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand, and cervical spine. There was no contemporaneous evidence of these injuries and Turner did not complain of them at the time. The court also had to determine the weight to be given to the expert reports, particularly in light of the absence of contemporaneous evidence and complaints. The court examined previous cases such as Onassis and Calogeropoulos v Vergottis, Department of Aging, Disability and Home Care v Findlay, Department of Education and Training v Ireland, Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes, Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates, Paric v John Holland (Constructions) Pty Ltd, Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles and Hancock v East Coast Timbers Products Pty Ltd to assist in determining the weight to be given to the evidence.
The court found that there was insufficient evidence to support a finding that Turner suffered frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand, or cervical spine. Turner was also not entitled to compensation for the consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand. However, the court found that Turner was fit to return to her pre-injury employment as a claims assessor in respect of the accepted injuries to her left shoulder, left elbow, and left knee. The court also found that Turner was not entitled to weekly benefits compensation under section 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
The court made an award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed injury to the left wrist and left hand on 10 July 2019; the applicant’s claimed consequential condition to the right wrist and right hand; and the applicant’s claimed injury to the cervical spine on 10 July 2019. The court also made an award for the respondent in respect of the applicant’s claimed entitlement to weekly benefits compensation under section 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was brought before the court as a claim for weekly benefits compensation under section 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. Ms. Turner sought compensation for her injuries and a consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand. The case involved an assessment of the evidence presented regarding the injuries to her left wrist, left hand, and cervical spine, and whether these injuries occurred on the date of the incident. The court reviewed the submissions and evidence provided by both parties, including expert reports and contemporaneous evidence. The matter was heard and determined by the court, which made findings on the validity of the claimed injuries and the applicant's entitlement to weekly benefits compensation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did Ms. Turner suffer frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand, and cervical spine on 10 July 2019?
2. Did Ms. Turner suffer a consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand?
3. What is the value of the contemporaneous evidence in determining the claimed injuries?
4. Does the absence of contemporaneous complaints of injuries to the left wrist, left hand, right wrist, right hand, and cervical spine affect the validity of Ms. Turner’s claims?
5. How should the weight be given to expert reports in this case?
Held
1. The court concluded that Ms. Turner did not suffer frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand, and cervical spine on 10 July 2019, and dismissed the claims related to these injuries.
2. The court concluded that Ms. Turner did not suffer a consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand, and dismissed the claims related to this condition.
3. The court concluded that the absence of contemporaneous complaints of injuries to the left wrist, left hand, right wrist, right hand, and cervical spine does not affect the validity of Ms. Turner’s claims.
4. The court concluded that contemporaneous evidence is of limited value in determining the claimed injuries and gave less weight to such evidence in its decision.
5. The court concluded that expert reports should be considered with caution and gave less weight to them in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court approached the determination of Ms. Turner’s claims by examining the evidence presented regarding the injuries she claimed to have sustained. It began by considering whether Ms. Turner suffered frank injuries to her left wrist, left hand, and cervical spine on 10 July 2019. The court found that the evidence did not support these claims and dismissed the related claims accordingly. Next, the court examined whether Ms. Turner suffered a consequential condition to her right wrist and right hand. It found that there was insufficient evidence to support this claim and dismissed it as well.
The court then addressed the value of contemporaneous evidence in determining the claimed injuries. It noted that contemporaneous evidence, while valuable, has limitations and is not always definitive. The court found that in this case, the contemporaneous evidence was not sufficiently reliable to support the claims of injury.
Further, the court examined the impact of the absence of contemporaneous complaints of injuries to the left wrist, left hand, right wrist, right hand, and cervical spine. It concluded that the absence of such complaints does not necessarily undermine the validity of Ms. Turner’s claims, as injuries may not always be immediately apparent or reported.
In considering the weight given to expert reports, the court recognised the importance of expert evidence but also its potential for bias or error. It determined that while expert reports are useful, they should be evaluated critically and given appropriate weight based on their reliability and relevance to the case.
The court applied principles from prior cases such as Onassis and Calogeropoulos v Vergottis, Department of Aging, Disability and Home Care v Findlay, Department of Education and Training v Ireland, and Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes, which support the notion that absence of contemporaneous complaints and the limitations of contemporaneous evidence do not invalidate claims if other evidence supports the injuries. It also drew on Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates, Paric v John Holland (Constructions) Pty Ltd, Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles, and Hancock v East Coast Timbers Products Pty Ltd to underscore the necessity of a critical approach to expert evidence.
The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the absence of contemporaneous complaints and the limitations of contemporaneous evidence do not invalidate injury claims if other evidence supports them, and expert reports should be critically evaluated.