Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merri Todd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Applications 765075(25) The Wizard of Oz Hemp Co & Device; 800208(31) The Wizard of Oz Pet Food Company & Device; 818213(16) The Wizard of Oz Card Co & Device; and, 918093(43) The Wizard of Oz Holiday Farms & Device; to register trade marks by Yo-Merry Todd and opposition thereto by Turner Entertainment Company

And

Applications 927055(29, 30) The Wizard of Oz Fantastic Food Co & Device; 934712(32) The Wizard of Oz Drinks Co & Device; 946065(5 & 31) The Wizard of Oz; to register trade marks by Yo-Merry Todd and opposition thereto by Turner Entertainment Company

And

Applications 951800(39) The Wizard Tour Co & Device; 973832(33) The Wizard of Oz Drinks Co & Device; 973833(18) Wizard of Oz Timber & Leather Co & Device; and, 1006339(3, 4, 21, 22, 34) Wizard of Oz & Device to register trade marks by Yo-Merry Todd and opposition thereto by Turner Entertainment Company.

Delegate:

Iain Thompson

Representation:

Applicant.  Was not represented, did not appear or file written submissions

Opponent:  Julia Baird of Counsel instructed by James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates

Decision:

     33  ATMO 2007

  1. s52 proceedings – grounds under sections 42, 43 and 60 in relation to all oppositions; section 44 in relation to 918093(43), 934712(32) and 973832(33); section 58 in relation to 765075(25), 818213(16), 927055(29), 973833(18) and 1006339 (in Class 21 only). Outcomes as discussed in decisions.
  2. No costs order.

Background

  1. Yo-Merry Todd (‘the applicant’) of Sandgate, Queensland, has filed applications, as grouped above, to register eleven trade marks, current details of which are:

Yo-Merry Todd Application details

Notice of Opposition served and filed:

App No:              765075
Priority Date:                   17 Jun 1998
Goods/Services:   Class 25: Clothing, headgear
Trade Mark:  

30 Sep 1999

App No:              800208
Priority Date:                   14 Jul 1999
Goods/Services:   Class 31: Range of pet foods
Trade Mark:  

1 Aug 2000

App No:              818213
Priority Date:                  23 Dec 1999

Goods/Services:   Class 16: Paper, cardboard and goods made from these materials; printed matter; bookbinding material; photographs; stationery; playing cards; plastic materials for packaging; artist's materials; paint brushes; adhesives for stationery or household purposes

Trade Mark:  

11 Sep 2000

App No:              918093
Priority Date:                  1 Jul 2002

Goods/Services:   Class 43: Holiday farms - providing food, drink and accommodation

Trade Mark:                     

22 Jan 2003

App No:              927055
Priority Date:                   16 Sep 2002

Goods/Services:   Class 29: Jellies, jams, milk products, products made from dried and cooked fruit, vegetables and vegetable products, meat extracts other products including meat, fish, poultry and edible oils
Class 30: Confectionery, ices, yeast products, products using baking powder, condiments, sauces, preparations using flour and cereals, breads, pastries, honey, treacle, coffee, tea, cocoa, sugar, rice, sago, tapioca and preparations made from these

Trade Mark:  

11 Apr 2003

App No:              934712
Priority Date:                   19 Nov 2002

Goods/Services:   Class 32: Range of non-alcoholic drinks - including mineral waters - aerated waters and drinks, cordials, fruit juices, fruit drinks, soft drinks and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merri Todd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turner Entertainment Company (the opponent) sought to register the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ in Australia for a range of goods and services, including computer games, clothing, toys, and entertainment services. Yo-Merri Todd (the applicant) opposed this registration. The dispute concerned whether the opponent's proposed use of the trade mark would be misleading or deceptive under Australian consumer law, or otherwise contrary to law.

The court was required to determine whether the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ, when applied to the goods and services specified in the application, would be likely to mislead or deceive the Australian public. This involved considering the extent to which the mark had acquired a reputation in Australia and whether its use in relation to the proposed goods and services would create a false impression about their origin or endorsement. The court also had to consider the provisions of section 42 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), which mandates rejection of a trade mark application if its use would be contrary to law.

The court reasoned that the expression THE WIZARD OF OZ had permeated the Australian language to the extent that it connotes the well-known 1939 motion picture. It found that, by the priority date of the application, the opponent's trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia in relation to various merchandise, including mouse pads, figurines, soft toys, drinking glasses, mugs, key rings, Christmas ornaments, dolls, and clothing, often sold in connection with a theme park. The court considered the child-oriented nature of the film's theme and how this was reflected in the marketing of associated goods. Applying principles from cases such as *Advantage-Rent-A-Car Inc v Advantage Car Rental Pty Ltd*, the court acknowledged that while registrars may face challenges in assessing legal questions, the threshold for refusal under section 42 is whether use "would" be contrary to law, not merely "could" be. The court also referred to section 52 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) concerning misleading or deceptive conduct.

The court concluded that the opponent's trade mark had a significant reputation in Australia and that its use in relation to the specified goods and services was likely to mislead or deceive the public into believing that these goods and services were endorsed by or associated with the well-known motion picture and its associated rights holders. Consequently, the court found that the use of the trade mark would be contrary to law under section 42 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth) and section 52 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth). The application for registration was therefore rejected.

Background

Background to the litigation

Turner Entertainment Company, a subsidiary of Time Warner Entertainment Company, applied to register the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ for various goods and services, including computer games, printed matter, clothing, and entertainment services. The application faced opposition from Yo-Merri Todd, who owned the rights to the 1939 motion picture "The Wizard of Oz" and held multiple registrations and pending applications for the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ in the USA. The opponent had licensed various entertainment rights in Australia, including an animated television series and a live ice show. Additionally, merchandise featuring the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ, such as mouse pads, figurines, soft toys, and clothing, had been sold in Australia, particularly in the context of a theme park.

The dispute arose from Turner Entertainment Company’s application to register the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ for a broad range of goods and services in Australia. Yo-Merri Todd opposed the application, arguing that the use of the trade mark would be misleading or deceptive and contrary to law. The opponent contended that the trade mark had permeated the Australian language to the extent that it was synonymous with the motion picture, and that Turner Entertainment Company’s proposed use of the trade mark for goods outside traditional entertainment merchandise could confuse the public regarding the source or sponsorship of these products. The evidence provided by the opponent included statutory declarations detailing the history of the motion picture and its associated merchandise, as well as the extensive licensing and marketing activities undertaken by the opponent in Australia.

Turner Entertainment Company defended its application by arguing that the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ was well-known for the motion picture but that the proposed use of the mark for the specified goods and services would not mislead or deceive the public. The company asserted that its use of the trade mark would be consistent with the well-established reputation of the motion picture and would not cause confusion regarding the source or sponsorship of the goods and services. Turner Entertainment Company also highlighted the broad scope of the opponent’s existing registrations and applications for the trade mark, suggesting that the opponent’s opposition was an attempt to monopolize the trade mark rather than a genuine concern for consumer protection.

The factual events leading to the legal dispute involved the opponent's established rights and activities concerning the motion picture "The Wizard of Oz" and the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ in Australia. The opponent had a long history of marketing and licensing the motion picture and its associated merchandise, while Turner Entertainment Company sought to register the trade mark for a wide array of goods and services, potentially expanding the scope of the trade mark beyond traditional entertainment merchandise. This expansion raised concerns from the opponent about potential consumer confusion and the dilution of the trade mark's reputation.

Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merri Todd is a case that originated as an application to the Registrar of Trade Marks for the registration of the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ. This application was opposed by the opponent, who claimed that the trade mark was scandalous and that its use would be contrary to law under sections 42(a) and 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The matter proceeded to a hearing before a judge of the Federal Court of Australia, where the Registrar's decision to reject the application was reviewed. The applicant, Turner Entertainment Company, sought judicial review of the Registrar's decision, arguing that the trade mark was not scandalous and that its use would not be contrary to law. Key procedural steps included the filing of evidence in support of and in opposition to the application, the issuance of interlocutory orders, and the conduct of a substantive hearing. The Court considered the evidence presented and relevant legal principles, ultimately deciding whether the trade mark met the criteria for refusal of registration under the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The oppositions to the applications are grouped because the evidence in support served and filed by the opponent over the effulgence of time relates to the trade marks that occur within these groups. The evidence in answer has also naturally followed this pattern.Evidence A list of the statutory declarations served and filed in relation to these proceedings is appended at Annex 1to these reasons. The Wizard of Oz is the name of a motion picture musical made in 1939 by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Inc. It is closely based on the book The Wonderful Wizard of Oz written by L Frank Baum in 1900 which is regarded by many as an American classic and features such characters as Dorothy, her dog Toto, the Tin Man, the Scarecrow, and the Cowardly Lion. In 1986, the opponent acquired all rights in the motion picture and its related trade marks and copyrights. The opponent has some dozen registrations of the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ in the USA and has a pending application (885337) in Australia, filed on 2 August 2001, to register the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ in Classes 9, 16, 25, 28 and 41 of the International (Nice) Classification of Goods and Services for the goods and services:Class: 9 Computer games, electronic games and educational games; computer software; apparatus for recording, transmission or reproduction of sound and images; sound and/or video recordings including records, tapes, video tapes, discs, compact discs, video discs, DVD's and CD-ROMs; magnets Class: 16 Printed matter; instructional, teaching and educational materials; stationery; playing cards; pens; photographs; decalcomanias; stickers; coasters; trading cards; books including children's books and activity books Class: 25 Clothing, footwear and headgear Class: 28 Games including electronic and educational games; toys and soft toys including stuffed toys, gymnastic and sporting articles in this class; Christmas decorations; games and playthings Class: 41 Entertainment services, being production and distribution of motion pictures and television productions; video, radio, television and film entertainment; production of video, radio, television and film programmes; provision, production, development, presentation, networking and rental of interactive television, interactive games, interactive entertainment and interactive competition services, television, radio and telephone programmes, films, sound and video recordings; organisation, production and presentation of competitions, contests, games and quizzes, studio entertainment and audience entertainment; publication of books; presentation of live performances; amusement parks; cinema facilities; exhibitions; movie studios The opponent, or its predecessor in business, MGM, has licensed broadcast rights for the motion picture within Australia, as well as related entertainments such as an animated television series called The Wizard of Oz. In 1996, a show called The Wizard of Oz on Ice toured Australia under the opponent’s aegis. Additionally, the soundtrack of the songs from the musical motion picture have been sold in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will finally, in this part of the decision, observe that the Courts have found that this marketing or cross promotion might be seen by the public to be in relation to goods which are quite outside those that are traditionally looked to for endorsement by television or movie companies such as fast foods, stationery or soft drinks. In the Crocodile Dundee case it was shoes and in the Duff case, it was beer. Conclusions Accordingly, it appears to me that the expression THE WIZARD OF OZ has permeated the Australian language to the extent that it connotes the motion picture of the same name. Additionally, I consider it more likely than not that at the priority date of the first opposed application the opponent’s trade mark had a reputation in Australia in relation to mouse pads, figurines, soft toys, drinking glasses, drinking mugs, key rings, Christmas ornaments, dolls and clothing and that the context of this is in part in relation to a theme park where all but the latter two items of these goods have been for sale. I also observe that the theme of the motion picture The Wizard of Oz is very well known. It is strongly child-oriented and this theme to an extent runs in the marketing associated with the motion picture under the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ by the opponent in its goods which are mouse pads, figurines, soft toys, drinking glasses, drinking mugs, keyrings, and Christmas ornaments, and the licensed sale of dolls and clothing bearing the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ.Legal PrinciplesSection 42 Section 42 of the Act provides:42 Trade mark scandalous or its use contrary to lawAn application for the registration of a trade mark must be rejected if:(a)the trade mark contains or consists of scandalous matter; or(b)its use would be contrary to law. Ms Baird referred me to the principles in the decision by Madgwick J in Advantage-Rent-A-Car Inc v Advantage Car Rental Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 683 at paragraph 28 to my attention:I acknowledge the claim made by counsel for the Registrar that such an approach requires the Registrar to look at questions of law outside his or her expertise and that this can be difficult and may place a large and onerous responsibility upon the Registrar. However, the Registrar has the comfort that the criterion is that the use "would" not "could" be contrary to law. Further, there is no reason why the Registrar could not seek legal advice before forming his/her opinion. It should also be noted that what is required is that the Registrar form a view as to whether the use of a trade mark would be contrary to law. Such opinion does not have a similar effect to say, a judicial conclusion of law as to breach of copyright in copyright proceedings; the effect is limited to the refusal of registration. In any case, an appeal de novo lies from the Registrar's decision to this Court where any error of the Registrar may be corrected. Under section 42 of the Act, Ms Baird also referred me to section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974, which provides:52 Misleading or deceptive conduct(1)A corporation shall not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.(2)Nothing in the succeeding provisions of this Division shall be taken as limiting by implication the generality of subsection (1).Note:For rules relating to representations as to the country of origin of goods, see Division 1AA (sections 65AA to 65AN).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court first addressed whether the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" had become generic and therefore scandalous or contrary to law under section 42 of the Act. The Court considered that the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" had permeated the Australian language to the extent that it connotes the motion picture of the same name. However, this did not necessarily mean that the term had become generic or scandalous. The Court acknowledged that a term could be generic even if it was not the common name for the goods or services, but rather if it had come to be understood as the common name for the goods or services in the minds of the public. The Court found that the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" had not become generic in this sense.

The Court then considered whether the use of the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" in the context of the opponent's marketing and promotion of goods and services was misleading or deceptive under section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974. The Court found that the marketing and promotion of goods and services under the trade mark "THE WIZARD OF OZ" by the opponent was not misleading or deceptive because the public would understand that the goods and services were associated with the motion picture The Wizard of Oz. The Court noted that the theme of the motion picture The Wizard of Oz was very well known and was strongly child-oriented. The Court found that the marketing and promotion of goods and services under the trade mark "THE WIZARD OF OZ" by the opponent was consistent with this theme.

The Court also considered to what extent the opponent's trade mark had a reputation in Australia in relation to certain goods as of the priority date of the first opposed application. The Court found that the opponent's trade mark had a reputation in Australia in relation to mouse pads, figurines, soft toys, drinking glasses, drinking mugs, key rings, Christmas ornaments, dolls, and clothing as of the priority date of the first opposed application. The Court noted that these goods were sold in a theme park associated with the motion picture The Wizard of Oz.

The Court then considered whether the opponent's trade mark use in the context of a theme park contributes to the reputation of the trade mark in relation to the goods listed. The Court found that the opponent's trade mark use in the context of a theme park did contribute to the reputation of the trade mark in relation to the goods listed. The Court noted that the theme park was associated with the motion picture The Wizard of Oz and that the goods sold in the theme park were associated with the motion picture.

The Court also considered whether the theme of the motion picture The Wizard of Oz influences the marketing associated with the motion picture under the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ. The Court found that the theme of the motion picture The Wizard of Oz did influence the marketing associated with the motion picture under the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ. The Court noted that the marketing and promotion of goods and services under the trade mark "THE WIZARD OF OZ" by the opponent was consistent with the child-oriented theme of the motion picture.

Finally, the Court considered whether the use of the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ on the listed goods and services is likely to mislead or deceive the public under section 42(b) of the Act. The Court found that the use of the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ on the listed goods and services was not likely to mislead or deceive the public. The Court noted that the public would understand that the goods and services were associated with the motion picture The Wizard of Oz and that the marketing and promotion of goods and services under the trade mark "THE WIZARD OF OZ" by the opponent was consistent with the theme of the motion picture.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" has not become generic or scandalous under section 42 of the Act and that the use of the term "THE WIZARD OF OZ" in the context of the opponent's marketing and promotion of goods and services is not misleading or deceptive under section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974. The Court found that the opponent's trade mark had a reputation in Australia in relation to certain goods as of the priority date of the first opposed application and that the opponent's trade mark use in the context of a theme park contributed to the reputation of the trade mark in relation to the goods listed. The Court also found that the theme of the motion picture The Wizard of Oz influenced the marketing associated with the motion picture under the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ and that the use of the trade mark THE WIZARD OF OZ on the listed goods and services was not likely to mislead or deceive the public.