Trutmann and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

Trutmann and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2022] AATA 687 (6 April 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/3869

Re:Philippe Trutmann

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:6 April 2022

Place:Melbourne

Pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........................................................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP – applicant was conferred Australian citizenship – minister revoked citizenship – two grounds of revocation – applicant convicted of serious offence – minister satisfied contrary to the public interest for the applicant to remain an Australian citizen – review by tribunal of minister’s decision – threshold question – would person be rendered stateless – tribunal satisfied applicant holds another citizenship – consideration of factors – facts of offending – very large number of child sex offences where applicant was in position of trust over victims – is it contrary to public interest for applicant to remain citizen – relevant factors to take into account – should the discretion be exercised to revoke – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 33A, 35, 37, 38AA
Australian Citizenship Act 1948 (Cth), s 13, Div 2, Part III
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth), Preamble, ss 3, 34, 52
Federal Act on the Acquisition and Loss of Swiss Citizenship 1952 (Switzerland)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 35

Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic), s 62

Cases

BOY19 v Minister for Immigration and BorderProtection [2019] FCA 574

Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith [1991] VicRep 6

Irving and Minister of State for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs [1996] FCA 663

McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2005] FCAFC 142; (2005) 88 ALD 12

Minister for Home Affairs v Waraich [2020] FCA 1513

NPRT and Minister for Home Affairs; Re: [2020] AATA 3641
O’Sullivan v Farrer [1989] HCA 61; (1989) 168 CLR 210
Prasad and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Re: [1994] AATA 326
Re Davis [1947] HCA 53; (1947) 75 CLR 409
TRHL and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection; Re: [2015] AATA 803
TRHL v Minister forImmigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 3765
Water Conservation & Irrigation Commission (NSW) v Browning [1947] HCA 21; (1947) 74 CLR 492

Secondary Materials

Kim Rubenstein, Australian Citizenship Law (Thomson Reuters, 2nd ed, 2017) Table 4.1230
Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Final Report (2017) Vol 13, p 168; Commonwealth of Australia

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

6 April 2022

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant, Mr Philippe Trutmann, was born in 1961 in Guatemala. He migrated to Australia around 1966. In December 1993, he was granted Australian citizenship by conferral.

  2. In December 2005, Mr Trutmann was convicted in the County Court of Victoria of the following offences: Gross indecency – person under 16 (19 counts); Indecent act with a child under the age of 16 (22 counts); Knowingly possess child pornography (one…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trutmann and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 687
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Trutmann for review of the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to revoke his Australian citizenship. The Minister had revoked Mr Trutmann's citizenship on two grounds: that he had been convicted of a serious offence, and that it was contrary to the public interest for him to remain an Australian citizen. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the Minister's decision was correct.

The Tribunal was tasked with determining three key questions. First, it had to ascertain whether revoking Mr Trutmann's Australian citizenship would render him stateless, as the power to revoke citizenship for a serious offence is not exercisable if the person would become stateless. Second, if he would not be rendered stateless, the Tribunal had to consider whether the statutory requirements were met, specifically whether Mr Trutmann had been convicted of a serious crime and whether it was contrary to the public interest for him to remain an Australian citizen. Finally, even if these conditions were met, the Tribunal had to decide whether exercising the discretion to revoke his citizenship was the correct and preferable decision.

The Tribunal found that Mr Trutmann was a Swiss citizen by descent, having been born to Swiss parents. This finding meant that the power to revoke his citizenship was not debarred by the potential consequence of statelessness. In considering whether it was contrary to the public interest to retain citizenship, the Tribunal emphasised that this assessment is directed outwards to the interests of the Australian community, rather than inwards to the personal circumstances of the individual. The Tribunal noted that Mr Trutmann had been convicted of a very large number of child sex offences, committed over a decade while he was in a position of trust. His offending behaviour commenced before he applied for citizenship and continued for some time after. The Tribunal concluded that his conduct demonstrated a disregard for the obligations inherent in Australian citizenship, including the obligation to obey the laws of Australia.

The Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision to revoke Mr Trutmann's Australian citizenship. As a consequence, Mr Trutmann would continue to hold the non-citizen visa he possessed by operation of law. The Tribunal noted that while this visa was cancellable, any future decision regarding its cancellation would be a separate matter, subject to its own administrative and judicial review processes, where Mr Trutmann could then raise factors such as his length of residence in Australia and family links.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1993, the Applicant, Mr Trutmann, was granted Australian citizenship. However, his citizenship was subsequently revoked in 2016 by the Minister for Home Affairs. The revocation was based on two grounds: Mr Trutmann's conviction for a serious offence and the Minister's satisfaction that it was contrary to the public interest for him to remain an Australian citizen. The case came before the tribunal for a review of the Minister’s decision, focusing on whether Mr Trutmann would be rendered stateless by the revocation, whether the statutory requirements for revocation were met, and whether it was appropriate to exercise the discretion to revoke his citizenship.

Mr Trutmann admitted to the Tribunal that he had been sexually abusing boys in his care for nearly eight years leading up to 1993, when he applied for citizenship, and continued to do so for over two more years. His offending was clandestine and predatory, lasting more than a decade. He acknowledged that he knew at the time that his actions were both legally and morally wrong and that he had no regard for the obligations to obey the law and respect others inherent in the grant of citizenship. The Tribunal noted the stark and lasting effects of his offending on many of his victims, some of whom have been adversely affected for life.

Mr Trutmann was born in Guatemala to Swiss parents, and the Tribunal was satisfied that he acquired Swiss citizenship by descent. Since 1 January 1992, Swiss citizens who voluntarily acquire another citizenship do not automatically lose their Swiss citizenship, and the Tribunal accepted that Mr Trutmann had not lost his Swiss citizenship when he acquired Australian citizenship. This meant that revoking his Australian citizenship would not render him stateless. The Tribunal also concluded that the statutory requirements for revocation were met, as Mr Trutmann had been convicted of a serious crime and sentenced to a serious prison term, and it was contrary to the public interest for him to remain an Australian citizen.

The matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as a review of the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to revoke the Australian citizenship of Mr Trutmann. The Tribunal's review was conducted under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), specifically section 58, which allows for the review of decisions related to the conferral, loss, or cancellation of Australian citizenship. The Tribunal considered the Minister's decision to revoke Mr Trutmann's citizenship on two grounds: that Mr Trutmann had been convicted of a serious offence, and that it would be contrary to the public interest for him to remain an Australian citizen. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Minister's decision was correct and preferable, considering the statutory criteria and relevant case law. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application for review by Mr Trutmann, the submission of evidence from both parties, and the Tribunal's consideration of the evidence and relevant legal principles in its decision-making process.

Mr Trutmann, who was born in Guatemala to Swiss parents, was granted Australian citizenship in 1993. He was subsequently convicted of numerous serious child sex offences and sentenced to prison. Following his conviction, the Minister revoked his citizenship on the grounds that it was contrary to the public interest for him to remain a citizen, considering the nature and seriousness of his crimes. The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing this decision, including whether the revocation would render Mr Trutmann stateless, and if the revocation was the correct and preferable decision under the Act. The Tribunal considered Mr Trutmann's submissions and evidence, as well as the Respondent's arguments and evidence, to reach its conclusion.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the Respondent’s opening submissions, Mr Barrington agreed with the Applicant’s submissions about which counts should be regarded as occurring before the grant of citizenship.ORAL EVIDENCEEvidence of the Applicant The Applicant told the Tribunal about his current employment and previous positions he has held. He also advised about certain academic studies he has undertaken and the qualifications he has attained. He is currently working in full-time employment. The Applicant told the Tribunal that he has been in a relationship with Mr XL for around ten years. They live together, and Mr XL works one day a week. Mr Trutmann told the Tribunal that his father is deceased. His mother has recently taken up residence in an aged care home which is around 20 minutes’ drive from where his sister lives in Victoria. He drives to see his mother every weekend and talks to her on the telephone on other occasions. He said his mother is physically healthy but is suffering from short-term memory loss. The Tribunal noted that there is corroborating medical evidence before it from a gerontologist (Exhibit A4). When asked why he had applied for the revocation to be set aside, Mr Trutmann said he had worked hard on his rehabilitation. He said that he is “conscious of the harm caused by that type of behaviour” and sees the revocation as a preliminary step to make it possible for him to be deported. He said deportation would destroy his life with Mr XL and remove him from seeing his mother again. He said his whole life centres around Australia. The Applicant told the Tribunal that his father’s work meant frequent international postings, and when he was an infant the family moved to Germany and then to Australia in 1966. He said his parents were here until 1970 when his father was transferred to Algeria. His parents and his sister, Mrs XS, went to Algeria, but he and his two brothers became boarders at the school they had already been attending in Victoria as day students. He stayed in Australia until 1973 and then went to Switzerland for schooling for two years, before attending a boarding school in England. He finished there in 1980 and came back to Australia, where his father had been re-posted. He has lived in Australia since 1980, leaving for holidays on, he estimated, about ten occasions for no longer than four weeks on any one occasion. The Applicant said he was 24 when he started on the boarding house staff. One of the students had a problem with bed wetting and he was tasked to wake the boy up to go to the lavatory to minimise the chance of it occurring. The child was a heavy sleeper, and the Applicant told the Tribunal that his offending commenced in this context. When asked about his offending behaviour, the Applicant said: It is horrible to know the effect of my offending on my victims. It bothers me. I shake my head. I can’t understand how I justified what I was doing. The Applicant agreed that his offending continued for the years he was a boarding house assistant. He said when he was asked to leave the boarding house in 1996 by the head of campus, it was because another staff member had questioned his role there. He said his offending did not come to light at that time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the event that the Tribunal affirms the decision, the Applicant would continue to hold the non-citizen visa he has by operation of law. That visa is cancellable, but it is speculation as to whether a separate decision would in the future be made by the Minister or a delegate to initiate a cancellation, and such speculation is not only fruitless but not a question relevant to this administrative review. If consideration was given to cancellation, or the visa was cancelled, the Applicant would be entitled to avail himself of the same apparatus of administrative and judicial review as any other non-citizen whose visa is cancelled onshore, and would be able to call in aid the length of time he has resided in Australia, his frail mother and his family links, and other factors. CONCLUSION As mentioned above, because the Tribunal has found that Mr Trutmann is a Swiss citizen, the power to revoke his Australian citizenship is not debarred by the potential consequence of statelessness. Some of the oral evidence and written statements refer to potential implications for the Applicant’s partner, Mr XL, the Applicant’s sister, and his mother if his citizenship is not restored. The concept of whether it is “contrary to the public interest” for a person to remain an Australian citizen is not directed inward to the personal circumstances of a person whose citizenship has been revoked or where revocation is being contemplated. It is, in contrast, directed outward, to an assessment of the interests of the Australian community at large. The High Court said in O’Sullivan that the notion of the “public interest” should be considered in the context of the relevant statute. Mr Trutmann applied to be a citizen under the now repealed 1948 Australian Citizenship Act. Section 13(1) provided a discretionary power for the Minister to grant a certificate of Australian citizenship to a person who satisfied the Minister, among under things, that he or she is of good character (section 13(1)(f)). The current Act provides in its preamble that citizenship represents full and formal membership of the community of the Commonwealth of Australia; and that persons who are conferred citizenship undertake to accept the obligation, inter alia, to uphold and obey the laws of Australia. In September 1993, when Mr Trutmann applied for Australian citizenship, on his own admission, he had been sexually abusing boys in his care for just short of eight years. He continued to do so for more than two more years. His offending campaign of child sexual abuse was, without hyperbole, clandestine and predatory. It lasted more than a decade. Mr Trutmann told the Tribunal he knew – at the time – it was both legally and morally wrong. He had no regard for the obligations to obey the law and respect others in society that is inherent in the grant of citizenship. The effect of the offending, years later, on many of the victims is starkly set out in the victim impact statements, extracts of some of which are in these reasons. Many of these men have been adversely affected for life.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In terms of the Minister’s discretion, Mr Barrington submitted that it is a powerful factor that Mr Trutmann would not have obtained citizenship had his criminal actions been known. He has an ex-citizen visa and is entitled to remain in the community. The Respondent accepts that he has lost certain entitlements: he cannot vote and cannot re-enter Australia if he leaves this country, but that it is not appropriate to take into account the prospect of deportation, because that is speculatory.CONSIDERATION Senior Member Walsh described revocation of Australian citizenship in Re:TRHL and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 803 when she said, at [23], that it is an “extraordinary power which has historically been used sparingly”. The Tribunal agrees with her description and adds that the fact that this is a power that the Minister has not delegated underlines that its use is not a routine or common occurrence. Revocation of Australian citizenship can potentially have serious consequences for a person and, in some cases, for his or her family. It is nonetheless a power that the Parliament has explicitly given to the Minister in the Act. There are three questions for the Tribunal to decide. The first is: would Mr Trutmann be rendered stateless by the revocation of his Australian citizenship? If the answer to this question is ‘yes’, then the power to revoke is not exercisable under the Act. The second question is: are the requirements of the Act met in that, relevantly, the Applicant has been convicted of a serious crime by being sentenced to a serious prison sentence (as defined in the Act) and it would be contrary to the public interest for the person to remain an Australian citizen? If the answer to that second two-part question is ‘yes’, nonetheless the Tribunal must determine whether it is the correct and preferable decision to exercise the discretion to revoke Mr Trutmann’s Australian citizenship.Would the Applicant be rendered stateless? This is a threshold question, because as mentioned above, section 34(3) of the Act prevents the Minister cancelling the citizenship of a person based on conviction for a serious offence if the effect of revocation would be that the person was not a citizen or national of any country, i.e., is rendered stateless. Mr Trutmann was born in the Republic of Guatemala where his father was at the time working. His evidence was that his father was a Swiss citizen, as was his mother who acquired Swiss citizenship on her marriage. The Respondent submitted that the Applicant therefore acquired Swiss citizenship by descent under Article 1 of the Federal Act on the Acquisition and Loss of Swiss Citizenship 1952 (Switzerland) by virtue of being born of Swiss parents. The Respondent submitted that, since 1 January 1992, Swiss citizens who voluntarily acquire another citizenship do not automatically lose their Swiss citizenship (noting that Mr Trutmann acquired Australian citizenship by conferral in 1993).