TRHL and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 803 (15 October 2015)
Division
GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s)
2015/0382
Re
TRHL
APPLICANT
And
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Senior Member CR Walsh
Date 15 October 2015 Place Perth The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
....(Sgd) CR Walsh....................................................................
Senior Member CR Walsh
CATCHWORDS
CITIZENSHIP – REVOCATION – Applicant, an Australian citizen, extradited to the United Kingdom and convicted of 13 “serious (child sex) offences” and sentenced to 11 years imprisonment – Applicant’s convictions and sentence upheld on appeal - Applicant’s Australian citizenship revoked by the Minister – whether it would be “contrary to the public interest” for the Applicant to remain an Australian citizen –decision under review affirmed
LEGISLATION
Australian Citizenship Act 1948
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 – s 21(1) – s 21(2) – s 21(3) – s 21(4) – s 21(5) – s 21(6) – s 21(7) – s 21(8) – s 26 – s 27 - s 34(2)(b)(ii) – s 34(2)(c) – s 34(5)
International Transfer of Prisoners Act 1997
Migration Act 1958Sexual Offenders Monitoring Act 2005 (Vic)
CASES
Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith [1991] 1 VR 63
Fenn v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 931
Hogan v Hinch [2011] 243 CLR 506
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 139 ALR 84
McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2005] FCAFC 142
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Baker [1997] FCA 105
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Daniele (1981) 5 ALD 135
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Gungor (1982) 4 ALD 575
Osorio v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] AATA 59
Re Prasad v Minister Assisting the Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1993) 30 ALD 292
Saffron v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (No 2) (1991) 30 FCR 578; 102 ALR 19
Shakure v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] AATA 63
Taradel v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2005] AATA 1255WBU v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 45 AAR 225
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Australian Citizenship Instructions – 10.5.2
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member CR Walsh
15 October 2015
INTRODUCTION
The Applicant seeks a review of the Minister’s decision, dated 22 December 2014, to revoke the Applicant’s Australian citizenship under s 34(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Citizenship Act). The reason for the Minister’s decision was that many years after applying for Australian citizenship, the Applicant was convicted of “serious offences” (being 13 child sex offences), within the meaning of s 34(5) of the Citizenship Act, and the Minister was satisfied that it would be contrary to the “public interest” for the Applicant to remain an Australian citizen.
The primary motivation behind the Applicant making this application is that if the Applicant is permitted to retain his Australian citizenship he will be entitled to apply to be transferred from the United Kingdom prison in which he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TRHL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] AATA 803
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the Minister's decision to revoke the Applicant's citizenship was lawful and whether it would be contrary to the public interest for the Applicant to remain an Australian citizen. The court considered the nature and seriousness of the Applicant's criminal conduct, his lack of remorse, and the risk of reoffending. The Applicant argued that he was a low-risk offender and that his age and ties to Australia should be taken into account. The Minister, on the other hand, argued that the Applicant's criminal history and the potential harm to the Australian community if he reoffended outweighed any hardship caused to the Applicant and his wife.
The court found that the Minister's decision to revoke the Applicant's citizenship was lawful and in accordance with the provisions of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007. The court also found that it would be contrary to the public interest for the Applicant to remain an Australian citizen, given the seriousness of his criminal conduct and the risk of reoffending. The court rejected the Applicant's argument that his age and ties to Australia should be taken into account, and it found that the Minister had properly considered all relevant factors in reaching his decision.
The court affirmed the Minister's decision to revoke the Applicant's Australian citizenship, and it dismissed the Applicant's appeal. The Applicant's Australian citizenship was revoked, and he was no longer entitled to the rights and privileges of Australian citizenship. The Applicant was required to surrender his Australian passport and other documents of identity within 28 days of the court's decision. The Applicant also had the right to apply for an Australian travel document to enable him to return to Australia if he wished to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant is a citizen of the United Kingdom who migrated to Australia in 1974 as a permanent resident (under the Migration Act 1958 (Migration Act)), with his wife (also a citizen of the United Kingdom), to work on the coal fields around Lithgow in New South Wales. The Applicant and his wife lived in Lithgow until 1989. There, the Applicant worked as a manager for a company called “Coalex” and his wife worked initially for a local solicitor and later for mines rescue. In 1989, the Applicant and his wife moved to Hervey Bay in Queensland to retire because the Applicant could no longer work as a result of a severe, workplace related, back injuries sustained whilst working on the coal fields in Lithgow. In the mid-1990s, the Applicant and his wife moved to Perth, Western Australia, to be near the Applicant’s sister and husband. On 12 March 1996, the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship. The Applicant was granted Australian citizenship on 30 April 1996. The Applicant’s wife also became an Australian citizen in 1996. Both the Applicant and his wife retained their British citizenship after becoming Australian citizens. The Applicant subsequently had an operation to put plates in his back. According to the Applicant, following his back operation he was in chronic pain and could not stand for long periods of time and he remained house bound except to walk the dogs daily. The Applicant’s wife worked for the Department of Transport until 2010, when she retired. In 2011, the Applicant was extradited from Western Australia to the United Kingdom to face trial in the Crown Court at Kingston-Upon-Thames for charges relating to child sex offences alleged to have been committed by the Applicant in the United Kingdom between 1959 and 1973, before the Applicant and his wife migrated to Australia (in 1974) and became Australian citizens (in 1996). At the beginning of 2012, the Applicant’s wife flew to the United Kingdom to support her husband throughout his criminal trial. On 26 October 2012, the Applicant received a sentence of imprisonment for 11 years for the following 13 convictions: · Two counts of rape;· Two counts of attempted rape;· Six counts of indecent assault;· One count of indecency with a child; and· Two counts of indecent assault. In her “Sentencing Remarks”, Judge Susan Tapping, of the Crown Court at Kingston-Upon-Thames, stated: You have been convicted by the jury of 13 serious offences. For more than 20 years you have sexually abused children in your own family. You began offending when you were in your mid teenage years, perhaps 16 or 15 at the earliest. There were two nieces who lived a safe distance from you, but, as can so often happen, they spent part of their school summer holidays at their grandparents home in Wales. You still lived at home with your parents and continued after your mother was widowed. Your older sisters loved and trusted you, so the thought that their daughters were at any risk in the house never entered their minds and how wrong they were. When your eldest niece was eight or nine years old you began to indecently assault her, ending when she was around 12. During that period you attempted to rape her on one occasion, failing only because she was so young.One niece was not enough for you, because you also sexually abused her cousin, who is only two years younger. She came alone to Wales for summer holidays, but at other times was with her cousin, even sleeping in the same bedroom. That did not deter you, because you crept into the bedroom and assaulted one and then the other. This second victim was around the age of 10 when it started and again you tried to rape her. Again you failed, perhaps again because she was so young. Over a period of years you continued to indecently assault her in ways that are seared into her memory over 50 years later.You were so sure that these two young girls would not complain, even though there were always adults in the house downstairs in the evening. You made sure that they would keep your secret by making them feel that no one would believe their complaints and even by threatening one that she would be taken away from her mother and sent to a naught girl’s school, never to come home again. This was an especially powerful threat to a little girl who was an only child and very close to her mother.Maybe your first marriage brought your offending to a temporary halt, because you lived away from your mother’s house for a while and the girls themselves grew older.As it was, very sadly, your next victim was to be the daughter from this first failed marriage. She was adopted by yet another older sister of yours and her husband and they lived in a house with your mother. This child visited your home regularly when you moved out again after your second marriage. This marriage has been childless and your wife treated the little girl very well indeed, being like a mother to her.You, however, chose to take advantage of the situation again. From the time that she was still at junior school, so below 11 years of age, you forced her to masturbate you. Modern understanding would see this as grooming the child so that from the age of 13 for about two years you raped her whenever you got the opportunity.This is utterly depraved behaviour against your own child. As she got older she was able gradually to stop coming to your house so that she was no longer your victim. She too was told to keep things secret and although you did not threaten her, in effect you bribed her with gifts to keep her silent.Your last offence was in December 1973 when you were now 39 years old and on the day your mother’s funeral took place. Living a few doors down in the same street was your youngest niece. The family gathered at the house for the wake. You may well have been very upset, but unbelievably you took this opportunity to indecently assault this 12 year old. It is the least serious in its facts, but that is only because you took the chance to grope her breast area when outside the house, seeing off guests with perhaps other people around.Two months later you immigrated to Australia where you have lived the second half of your life. You left behind confused and damaged adults and children who grew up with the shadow of what you had done to them, haunting them all their lives.Gradually over time first two then three of them came to realize they had not been your lone victims. Your daughter kept silent except to her immediate family until her cousins had gone to the police in 2008. It took three years for the legal technicalities of the extradition process to be completed and then you were arrested on an extradition warrant in the summer of 2011. You did not contest that process and you arrived back in the United Kingdom by the end of September 2011 with this trial beginning a year later.I have read four victim impact statements taken from your victims. I am not surprised that all of them have difficulty in expressing the life-long impact that your sexual abuse of them has had on them. I watched four women of total integrity giving evidence before this jury. Under pressure to try and recall dates and details that had blurred in their minds not once did any of them try and make things sound better for them by over embellishing their accounts. They found the experience of giving evidence embarrassing and intrusive. However, they were compelling witnesses telling the distressing truth and I am sure that that is why the jury rejected your evidence that they were liars who had colluded together to make up a fabricated account against you. This was nothing more than the wriggling of a cowardly man, unable to accept that the past had caught up with him.I know from the evidence that the four victims, all here in court today, do not know the full details of what occurred to each other. Therefore, I have not detailed what each of them suffered in these remarks to save them from further public embarrassment. That does not detract from the very serious view any court should take of these offences.……..You are the one who must now face your day of reckoning. Maybe you thought that you were safe from justice halfway around the world, but you were not.Mr Kimsey has this morning urged a number of matters on me on your behalf. You are now 78 years of age and have some health problems that require daily medication. Since you have not offended in Australia you have rehabilitated yourself and the public no longer need protection from you. There has been a long delay and that passage of time means that any sentence will be hard. Your wife of nearly 50 years gave evidence in the trial and has written me a letter on your behalf. In a very different way she is your final victim. Contact with you will be more difficult in these circumstances, because she must return to Australia and lead a lonely existence, a very different life from what she was expecting a little over a year ago. The victims do not blame her at all. Indeed, their affection for her was among the factors that led them to be silent for so long.………..……….The most serious counts are those of rape and they are seriously aggravated by the offences committed against three other children over such a long period of time. Offences that began as a teenager and ended at the age of nearly 40.……… ………Your conduct towards your daughter was utterly shameful with life-long consequences for her. Her life was damaged and changed forever. Your repeated rapes of her mean that the appropriate sentencing bracket is the highest in the Guidelines.Taking all your offending into account, but tempered by totality, the starting point for sentence in this case is one of 16 years imprisonment. Giving effect to all your mitigation there must be a reduction in this sentence……..the sentence is reduced to one of 11 years on each count concurrent…….You will be eligible [for] (sic) release at the halfway point of this sentence and there is now no time to take into account on remand. As a matter of administration you will now register for life on the Sex Offenders’ Register.