Tolocorp Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Tolocorp Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council & Anor [2007]
QCA 33
PARTIES:  TOLOCORP PTY LTD ACN 081 843 834
(first respondent/applicant)
v
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL
(second respondent/first respondent)
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(applicant/second respondent)
FILE NO/S:  Appeal No 4753 of 2006
DC No 4653 of 2005
DIVISION:  Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:  Application for Leave Integrated Planning Act
ORIGINATING 
COURT: 
Planning and Environment Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  9 February 2007
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  19 October 2006
JUDGES:  McMurdo P, Mackenzie J and Fryberg J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court,
McMurdo P and Mackenzie J concurring as to the order
made, Fryberg J dissenting
ORDER:  Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs
CATCHWORDS:  ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL
PLANNING – DEVELOPMENT CONTROL –
APPLICATIONS – GENERALLY – when application duly
made – application properly made if subdivision not contrary
to regulatory or draft regulatory provisions – Integrated
Planning Act 1997 (Qld) s 3.2.1(7)(f)

SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND –
OTHER MATTERS – South East Queensland Regional Plan

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – PLANNING purposes” – Regulatory Provisions s 5(3)(d)(i)
Integrated Planning Act 1997 (Qld) s 2.1.23, s 2.3.2, s 2.3.16,
s 2.4.3, s 2.5.2, s 2.5A.10, s 2.5A.11, s 2.5A.12, s 2.5A.15,
s 2.5A.17, s 2.5A.18, s 2.5A.22, s 2.5A.23, s 2.6.1, s 3.1.4,
s 3.2.1, s 3.3.15, s 3.5.4, s 3.5.5, s 3.5.11, s 4.1.2, s 4.1.56,
s 4.1.57
Chang & Anor v Laidley Shire Council [2006] QCA 172;
Appeal No 8164 of 2005, 26 May 2006, distinguished
D’Orta-Ekenaike v Victoria Legal Aid (2005) 223 CLR 1,
cited
Dempsey v Hack [2005] QCA 34; Appeal No 8721 of 2004;
18 February 2005, distinguished
Gerlack v Clifton Bricks Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 478, cited
Lloyd v Robinson (1962) 107 CLR 142, cited
Paulger v Hall [2002] QCA 353; Appeal No 3950 of 2002,
13 September 2005, cited
Pioneer Industries v Baker [1997] 1 Qd R 514, cited
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority
(1998) 194 CLR 355, cited
Stubberfield v Paradise Grove Pty Ltd [2000] QCA 299;
Appeal Nos 4796 of 2000 and 38 of 1993, 28 July 2000, cited
Westpac Banking Corporation v Klef Pty Ltd [1998] QCA
311; Appeal No 8204 of 1998, 16 October 1998,
distinguished
COUNSEL:  C L Hughes SC, with M A Williamson, for the applicant
D R Gore QC, with S P Fynes-Clinton, for the first
respondent
T N Trotter for the second respondent
SOLICITORS:  Crown Solicitor for the applicant
IPA Law Planning Lawyers for the first respondent
Wakefield Sykes for the second respondent
  1. McMURDO P: The applicant second respondent, the State of Queensland, under s 4.1.57 Integrated Planning Act 1997 (Qld) ("IPA") seeks leave to appeal under s 4.1.56 IPA from an order of the Planning and Environment Court declaring that the first respondent applicant, Tolocorp Pty Ltd, made a properly made development application to the Noosa Shire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tolocorp Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QCA 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tolocorp Pty Ltd took Noosa Shire Council to court over a dispute concerning the zoning of a parcel of land and the validity of a planning application. The case was heard by the Queensland Court of Appeal, where the central issue was whether the land in question was zoned for rural residential purposes, specifically a single dwelling on a lot greater than 2000m2, and whether the application for subdivision was properly made. The court needed to determine if the land was part of an area in the planning scheme that favoured residential use and whether the application complied with regulatory provisions.

The court examined the Rural Pursuits zone's intent, which included provisions for dwellings on lots larger than 0.2 hectares, suggesting suitability for rural residential purposes. Despite the restriction on self-assessment for subdivisions, the court found that the intent of the Rural Pursuits zone was to cater for rural landowners' needs, aligning with rural residential use. The court also considered the compatibility of other developments within the zone and the specified intent of the Rural Residential zone, which was more explicitly defined. The court concluded that the land was indeed zoned for rural residential purposes, even if not predominantly so, and that the application for subdivision was properly made as it did not contravene regulatory or draft regulatory provisions.

In light of these findings, the court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and ordered Tolocorp Pty Ltd to pay the costs associated with the appeal. This decision underscored the importance of interpreting planning schemes holistically and considering the broader context and intent of zoning provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

Tolocorp Pty Ltd applied for approval of a subdivision of a 31.5-hectare parcel of land in Pomona, Queensland. The land was situated within the Rural Pursuits zone of the Noosa Planning Scheme. The application sought to create a new residential subdivision with each lot being greater than 2000 square metres. Part of the Tolocorp land abutted an area designated for Open Space - Conservation and Waterway Protection, which was intended to protect environmental values and adjacent waterways. The Noosa Shire Council initially refused the application on the basis that it did not comply with the planning scheme and regulatory provisions. Tolocorp appealed this decision to the Queensland Planning and Environment Court, which was subsequently dismissed. Tolocorp further appealed to the Queensland Court of Appeal, which was also dismissed. Tolocorp then applied to the High Court of Australia for special leave to appeal.

Tolocorp Pty Ltd applied for a subdivision of their land in Pomona, Queensland, which was zoned under the Rural Pursuits zone of the Noosa Planning Scheme. The Noosa Shire Council initially refused the application. Tolocorp appealed this decision to the Queensland Planning and Environment Court, which was dismissed. The appeal was then taken to the Queensland Court of Appeal, which also dismissed the appeal. Tolocorp subsequently applied to the High Court of Australia for special leave to appeal. The High Court dismissed the application for special leave to appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As noted above, part of the Tolocorp land abutted an area where the preferred dominant land use was Open Space - Conservation and Waterway Protection. That use was described as “open space, where the protection of environmental values or adjacent waterways is of key importance.” Where proposed development on adjacent land might result in adverse impacts, consideration would be given to requiring the submission of environmental impact statements, requiring modifications to or refusing development which would result in adverse impacts, setting conditions which would protect environmental values and requiring land to be dedicated to the Crown for open space purposes.[52] [52] Section 13.6.1.3. Submissions and conclusions To what conclusions does the foregoing analysis lead? Is the Tolocorp land allocated as part of an area in a planning scheme which, read as a whole, favours the use of the land for purposes that are residential purposes involving a single dwelling on a lot greater than 2000m2? A number of factors favour an affirmative answer. First, in the Rural Pursuits zone the purposes set out in column 3A of the table of zones included a dwelling house and it is clear from table 7.2 that this was intended to be on an area greater than 0.2 ha. It is true that the purpose ceases to be self- assessable if the development involves subdivision,[53] but that is the consequence of the Act in every case. It cannot be allowed to produce a result that s 5.3 of the Regulatory Provisions had no scope for operation. Second, the intent of the zone was to cater for the needs and interests of land owners in the rural areas of the Shire. That is quite apt to describe the use of the land for rural residential purposes. Third, other column 3A developments are on their face compatible with rural residential use. Fourth, rural settlement was a preferred dominant land use in respect of nearly half of the land while rural conservation, the preferred dominant land use of most of the balance, specifically envisaged that rural settlement in conjunction with the land included in the rural residential settlement or rural settlement designations might be a suitable use. [53] Section 3.1.4, sch 10, sch 8. On the other hand the intent of the zone is specified in very vague terms. That is in marked contrast to the intent of the Rural Residential zone: “This zone is intended to provide for development of land for the principal purpose of either:- Before resolving the question whether the land was zoned “for” rural residential purposes, it is desirable to consider the related question of whether, if so, it was zoned for purposes that were “predominantly” rural residential purposes. There is considerable commonality among the factors which affect those two questions. The parties differed widely in their approach to the latter question, although each side accused the other of construing the Regulatory Provisions in a way which gave “predominantly” no effect. For the State it was submitted (in effect) that to give effect to the word it was necessary to identify rural residential purposes as predominant among the purposes for which the land was zoned. For Tolocorp it was submitted that the inquiry should focus solely on the purposes of the particular development.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered several factors in determining whether the Tolocorp land was allocated as part of an area in a planning scheme which favoured residential purposes involving a single dwelling on a lot greater than 2000m2. Firstly, the Rural Pursuits zone included a dwelling house as one of the purposes set out in column 3A of the table of zones. The table further indicated that this was intended to be on an area greater than 0.2 ha. Although the purpose ceased to be self-assessable if the development involved subdivision, this consequence was a result of the Act in every case and did not negate the scope for operation of section 5.3 of the Regulatory Provisions. Secondly, the intent of the Rural Pursuits zone was to cater for the needs and interests of land owners in the rural areas of the Shire, which aligned with the use of the land for rural residential purposes. Additionally, other column 3A developments were compatible with rural residential use. Finally, rural settlement was a preferred dominant land use in respect of nearly half of the land, while rural conservation, the preferred dominant land use of most of the balance, specifically envisaged that rural settlement in conjunction with the land included in the rural residential settlement or rural settlement designations might be a suitable use. However, the court noted that the intent of the zone was specified in vague terms, which was in marked contrast to the intent of the Rural Residential zone. On the question of whether the land was zoned for predominantly rural residential purposes, the court considered the related question of whether, if so, it was zoned for purposes that were "predominantly" rural residential purposes. The parties differed widely in their approach to this question, with each side accusing the other of construing the Regulatory Provisions in a way which gave "predominantly" no effect. The court ultimately concluded that the land was not zoned for predominantly rural residential purposes.