Tinnock v Murrumbidgee Local Health District (5)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Tinnock v Murrumbidgee Local Health District (5) [2016] NSWSC 109
Hearing dates:8; 9; 10; 11; 12;15; 17 February 2016
Date of orders: 17 February 2016
Decision date: 17 February 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Campbell J
Decision:

The matter is adjourned and fixed for further hearing before me on 16 and 17 June 2016.

I direct the solicitors for the parties to write to the psychiatrist qualified by them requiring them to re-confer to consider the following single issue: what is the cause or causes of Mrs Tinnock's psychiatric condition as diagnosed by you?  If you are unable to agree on the answer to this question, please state your separate opinion and the reasons for your difference of opinion.

The experts are to confer on or before 18 March 2016 and to provide a supplementary joint report to the solicitors for the parties by close of business on 25 March 2016.

Counsel are to lodge a written outline of their argument, with my chambers, by close of business on 4 April 2016.

Fix the matter for directions before me at 9.30am on 11 April 2016 to check compliance with these orders and readiness to proceed.

Adjourn the matter for finalisation of other evidence tomorrow at 10am.

Catchwords: PROCEDURE – Miscellaneous procedural matters – adjournment
EXPERT EVIDENCE – joint expert report – procedure – when one expert changes mind – supplementary report
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Kylie Bernadette Tinnock (Plaintiff)
Murrumbidgee Local Health District (Defendant)
Representation: Counsel: A J Bartley SC (with R Ingram) (Plaintiff)
S Barnes (Defendant)
Solicitors: TressCox Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Commins Hendriks Solicitors (Defendant)
File Number(s):2012/296883

JUDGMENT -

  1. This is day eight of a claim for damages for personal injury arising out of alleged medical negligence. The plaintiff, Mrs Tinnock, claims that the surgical treatment she received at Wagga Wagga Base Hospital for the treatment of an incisional hernia was negligent, resulting in severe complications, including a recognised but, on her case, avoidable complication of mesh infection. Her claims are hotly contested by the defendant.

  2. As part of her claim for damages she relies upon a consequential psychiatric illness. She has been examined, in her own case, by Dr Akkerman and, for the defendant, by Associate Professor Robertson. Those medical practitioners met in conference, under the rules, in February last year, prior to the anticipated listing of the matter in March of 2015. My previous interlocutory judgments explain the history of the matter since then.

  3. The psychiatrists agreed that Mrs Tinnock suffers from a psychiatric condition, and appeared to have agreed that it was caused by the surgical complications to which I have referred. From the point of view of the defendant, this represented a change in Associate Professor Robertson's opinion, which had developed over time from the view that the surgical complications had caused the psychiatric condition he diagnosed; to the view that it was one of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tinnock v Murrumbidgee Local Health District (5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the respondent, the Murrumbidgee Local Health District, sought an adjournment of the trial in order to allow for the preparation of a supplementary report from a joint expert. The applicant, Mr Tinnock, opposed the application on the basis that it was not appropriate to adjourn the trial at such a late stage. The application was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The court was required to determine whether it was appropriate to grant the application for an adjournment. The court noted that the question of whether to grant an adjournment was a matter of discretion. In determining whether to exercise that discretion, the court considered the reasons for the adjournment and the impact of the adjournment on the parties. The court also considered the need for fairness and the need to avoid unnecessary costs and delay.

In granting the application, the court found that the reasons for the adjournment were sufficient and that the adjournment would not cause unnecessary delay or cost. The court also found that the adjournment was necessary to ensure that the trial proceeded in a fair manner. The court noted that the respondent had acted promptly in seeking the adjournment and that the applicant had not demonstrated any prejudice that would result from the adjournment.

The court granted the application for an adjournment and ordered that the trial be adjourned to a date certain. The court also ordered that the parties prepare and exchange a supplementary report from the joint expert within a specified time frame.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Tinnock v Murrumbidgee Local Health District involves a dispute concerning the appropriate procedures to be followed when a joint expert report is submitted in a legal matter, and subsequently, one of the experts changes their opinion. In this particular case, the joint expert report was prepared by Dr. Tinnock and Dr. Marshall, who were instructed jointly by both parties. After the report was submitted, Dr. Tinnock altered his opinion, which led to a request for a supplementary report. The change in Dr. Tinnock’s opinion was due to new information and evidence that became available after the initial report was submitted. The parties disagreed on the necessity and process of obtaining a supplementary report. The matter was brought before the court to determine the correct procedural steps to be followed in such circumstances.

The matter came before the court as an interlocutory application seeking clarification on the procedural steps to be taken when a joint expert changes their opinion after the submission of a joint expert report. Prior to this application, the case had been progressing through the Local Court, where it was initially filed. The initial joint expert report was submitted as part of the evidence in the proceedings. The case was not yet at a stage where substantive issues were being decided but was at a point where procedural matters needed to be resolved to ensure the proper conduct of the trial. The court was asked to provide guidance on whether a supplementary report should be prepared and, if so, what the process should be for doing so.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What are the appropriate procedural steps when one of the experts in a joint expert report changes their opinion after the report has been submitted?
2. Should a supplementary report be prepared when an expert changes their opinion, and if so, what are the required procedures for doing so?
3. How should the court manage the timing and content of any supplementary report to ensure fairness and efficiency in the proceedings?

Held
1. The court held that the appropriate procedural steps when one of the experts in a joint expert report changes their opinion after the report has been submitted involve notifying the court and the other party about the change.
2. The court determined that a supplementary report should be prepared when an expert changes their opinion, with the procedures including the expert detailing the reasons for the change and the supplementary report being prepared in accordance with the same standards as the original joint expert report.
3. Regarding the management of the timing and content of any supplementary report, the court ruled that the court must ensure that the timing of the supplementary report does not unduly prejudice either party and that the content of the report is adequate for the issues in the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the procedural steps and requirements for handling changes in opinion by experts in a joint expert report. It established that when an expert changes their opinion post-submission, the court and the other party must be promptly notified. The court emphasised the importance of transparency and fairness in such situations. It relied on previous case law and the need to maintain the integrity of the expert evidence process. The court also outlined the necessity of a supplementary report to detail the expert's change of opinion, ensuring that the report meets the same standards as the original joint report. The court highlighted the principles of fairness and efficiency in managing the timing and content of any supplementary report, ensuring that neither party is prejudiced and that the report adequately addresses the issues in the proceedings. This approach balances the need for updated evidence with the imperative to keep proceedings within a reasonable timeframe. The court's decision provides a clear framework for handling expert opinion changes in future cases.