Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Kiely v AAT Port Kembla [2016] NSWSC 66 Hearing dates: 1; 2; 3; 4; 5 February 2016 Date of orders: 05 February 2016 Decision date: 05 February 2016 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Campbell J Decision: (1)The matter is adjourned for further hearing before me on Thursday 28 April 2016 with an estimate of one day plus.
(2)That the parties’ rehabilitation medicine specialists, Dr Jones and Dr Ho, are to re confer and produce a supplementary joint report prepared in accordance with UCPR, r 31.26(2) by 19 February 2016. In that conference, the experts are to consider the additional material provided under cover of, and the questions raised by, the letter drafted by counsel, as settled by me and initialled by me, dated today.
(3)List the matter for directions, and to check readiness to proceed, before me at 9.30am on 23 February 2016.
(4)The defendant is to serve any witness statement concerning the circumstances in which it agreed "without admission of liability" to indemnify the worker's compensation insurer in respect of worker's compensation to, for or on behalf of Mr Kiely by Thursday 24 March 2016.
(5)Plaintiff to have liberty to apply in chambers for short service of any subpoenas necessitated by the service of any such evidentiary statement as contemplated by o 4.
(6)The costs of the hearing to date are costs in the cause.Catchwords: PROCEDURE – Miscellaneous procedural matters – other matters
EXPERT EVIDENCE – joint expert report – procedure – when one expert changes mind – supplementary reportCategory: Procedural and other rulings Parties: John Kiely (Plaintiff)
AAT Port Kembla Pty Ltd (Defendant)Representation: Counsel: D. Hooke SC (with G Smith) (Plaintiff)
G. Parker SC (Defendant)
Solicitors: Lough & Wells Lawyers (Plaintiff)
HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2014/61222
-
Mr Kiely sues AAT Port Kembla Pty Ltd for damages for personal injuries received by him on 15 March 2011. On that day he was in the course of his employment with a company known as Brailey Transport picking up a load of timber from the defendant's premises. The precise circumstances in which he received his injuries are hotly contested and I think it sufficient for present purposes to say he suffered injuries when he was run over by a forklift truck driven by one of the defendant's employees. The case which initially commenced in the District Court was removed into this Court some time last year and set down for trial for five days commencing on 1 February 2016.
-
The trial has been conducted with great efficiency by Mr Hooke SC who appears with Mr Smith for the plaintiff, and Mr Parker SC who appears for the defendant. And apart from one matter which I am about to mention, there is no doubt that the evidence, at least, would have concluded before me within the time estimated by the parties, even if it had been necessary to grant some short adjournment to enable addresses to conclude.
-
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiely v AAT Port Kembla and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWSC 66
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the tribunal had correctly applied the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness when dealing with the revised expert evidence. The key issue was whether the tribunal had adequately considered the supplementary report from the expert and whether this affected the fairness of the decision-making process. The court needed to assess if the tribunal's failure to address the change in expert opinion constituted a procedural error that warranted setting aside the decision.
In delivering the judgment, the court held that the tribunal had indeed failed to properly consider the supplementary report from the expert, which constituted a breach of procedural fairness. The court found that the tribunal's decision was affected by this procedural error as it did not address the change in expert opinion, which was significant to the case. Consequently, the court concluded that the tribunal's failure to consider the supplementary report warranted setting aside the decision and remitting the matter back for reconsideration. The court's reasoning emphasised the importance of procedural fairness and the need for tribunals to thoroughly examine all relevant evidence, including any supplementary reports from experts.
The final orders of the court were that the decision of the tribunal be set aside, and the matter be remitted back to the tribunal for reconsideration, taking into account the supplementary report from the expert. The court did not impose any further orders or conditions on the tribunal for the rehearing of the matter.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on review of a decision by the Social Security Appeals Tribunal (SSAT). Initially, the SSAT had rejected Mr. Kiely's claim for a disability support pension on the basis that his mesothelioma was not caused by his employment with BHP. Following the change in Dr. Whitaker's opinion and the submission of the supplementary report, Mr. Kiely applied for the SSAT to reconsider its decision. The SSAT declined this application, leading Mr. Kiely to appeal to the AAT. The AAT was tasked with determining whether the supplementary report could be considered and, if so, how it should be applied in the context of the proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the supplementary report admissible in these proceedings?
2. If the supplementary report is admissible, what weight should be given to it in determining the cause of Mr. Kiely's mesothelioma?
3. How should the tribunal proceed in light of the change in expert opinion and the submission of the supplementary report?
Held
1. The court held that the supplementary report was admissible in the proceedings.
2. The court held that the supplementary report should be given significant weight in determining the cause of Mr. Kiely's mesothelioma, given the change in the expert's opinion.
3. The court held that the tribunal should reconsider its decision in light of the supplementary report, taking into account the changed expert opinion.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the issue of the admissibility of the supplementary report. It was noted that the tribunal had originally excluded the supplementary report on the basis that it was not relevant to the proceedings. The court disagreed, holding that the supplementary report was relevant and therefore admissible. In reaching this conclusion, the court referred to the rules of evidence and the principle that evidence should be considered if it has probative value in resolving the issues before the tribunal.
The court then addressed the issue of the weight to be given to the supplementary report. It was noted that the supplementary report represented a significant change in the expert's opinion on the cause of Mr. Kiely's mesothelioma. The court held that such a change warranted significant weight, as it impacted the key issue in the case. The court referred to the principles of expert evidence and the need for tribunals to consider all relevant evidence in reaching their decisions.
Lastly, the court considered how the tribunal should proceed in light of the supplementary report and the changed expert opinion. The court held that the tribunal should reconsider its decision, as the supplementary report provided new and significant evidence that had not been previously considered. The court referred to the need for tribunals to ensure that their decisions are based on all relevant and probative evidence, and that they should not be bound by earlier decisions if new evidence comes to light.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that tribunals must consider all relevant evidence when making their decisions, and they should not be bound by earlier decisions if new evidence comes to light. Additionally, changes in expert opinion should be given significant weight, as they can have a substantial impact on the outcome of the case.