Thorpe v Charles Sturt City Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

THORPE V CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF CHARLES STURT
[1999] SASC 10

Land and Valuation Division

  1. DEBELLE J. (Ex tempore)         This is an appeal from the Environment Resources and Development Court.  The issue is whether the principles of res judicata apply in respect of a decision of the court upholding the refusal of a planning authority to grant planning permission.

  2. Mr and Mrs Thorpe reside in a house property at West Lakes. The house property is within the area of the Corporation of the City of Charles Sturt (“the Council”). Mr and Mrs Thorpe are tenants in common of the land on which the house property is erected. The house is in McDonald Grove, West Lakes. McDonald Grove forms part of a planned residential estate and is in a Residential 1W zone as prescribed by the Development Plan for this area of the Council. The combined effect of the Development Plan and the Development Regulations 1993 is that the construction of a fence of any height constitutes a development for which planning permission must be obtained. Many of the houses in McDonald Grove do not have front fences.

  3. In 1996, Mr Thorpe in his own name applied to the Council to erect a brick and wrought iron fence along the front boundary of the land.  The Council refused planning permission.  Mr Thorpe appealed to the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the ERD Court”), which dismissed the appeal. 

  4. Mr and Mrs Thorpe were not content to leave the matter there.  On 17 November 1997, Mrs Thorpe applied to the Council in her name for consent to erect a fence along the front boundary.  The application was for a fence of the same dimensions and type of construction as the fence the subject of the 1996 application and it was to be in the same location.  The Council refused to grant planning permission.  Mrs Thorpe then appealed to the ERD Court against the Council’s decision.  The ERD Court held that there was no material difference between the two proposals and that there had been no material change in circumstances in the time between the proposal the subject of the first appeal and the present proposal.  It held that there was, therefore, an estoppel by res judicata.  From that decision, Mrs Thorpe appeals to this Court.  The only issue on this appeal is whether the ERD Court was correct in deciding that it had no jurisdiction because the matter was res judicata. 

  5. The principles of res judicata bind the same parties to an action or their privies.  Although Mr Thorpe had made the first application and was the appellant in the first appeal and Mrs Thorpe is the second applicant and the appellant in the second appeal, Mrs Thorpe does not contend that she is not bound by the principles of res judicata if they are applicable.  The concession is properly made, since both Mr and Mrs Thorpe are registered as tenants in common of the land and each would have been privy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thorpe v Charles Sturt City Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Thorpe v Charles Sturt City Corporation, the appellant, Mrs Thorpe, sought to appeal the decision of the Environment Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) which upheld the refusal of the Corporation of the City of Charles Sturt (the Council) to grant planning permission for the erection of a fence along the front boundary of her property. The issue before the court was whether the principles of res judicata applied to the decision of the ERD Court in respect of a decision to withhold planning permission.

The court found that the principles of res judicata do not apply in respect of decisions of planning authorities to refuse development consent. The court held that a decision to grant or refuse planning permission is an administrative decision which does not give rise to an estoppel in the form of res judicata. The decision was based on the fact that a decision to withhold planning permission does not involve the determination of a legal right, but instead, is an administrative decision determining whether a person will be permitted to proceed with an intended development.

The court also held that it was not appropriate for the principles of res judicata to apply in the ERD Court, as the court's decision, like the decision of the planning authority, is not the determination of a legal right but again is an administrative decision to allow or deny permission for a proposed development. The court held that the ERD Court may be more effective in preventing parties from continuing to appeal against decisions of planning authorities refusing planning permission for the same development where there has been no change or no material change in the relevant circumstances by exercising its power to make an order for costs on the grounds that proceedings are frivolous or vexatious.

The appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted to another Commissioner in the ERD Court for hearing and determination. The court did not make an order for costs in favour of Mrs Thorpe as the Council did not plead res judicata and sought to persuade the Commissioner from deciding on that ground.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J

Full text does not contain this section.