The Uniting Church v Takacs

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
The Uniting Church v Takacs   [2008] NSWCA 141

FILE NUMBER(S):
40176/07

HEARING DATE(S):
6 February 2008

JUDGMENT DATE:
20 June 2008

PARTIES:
THE UNITING CHURCH IN AUSTRALIA PROPERTY TRUST (NSW) t/as Northaven Retirement Village  (Appellant) 
John Ernest TAKACS  (Respondent) 

JUDGMENT OF:
Hodgson JA McColl JA Basten JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court - Common Law Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
SC 20224/05

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Rothman J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
6 March 2007

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Takacs v The Uniting Church [2007] NSWSC 175

COUNSEL:
P R GARLING SC/ R G GAMBI  (Appellant) 
P G MAHONY SC/ R E QUICKENDEN  (Respondent) 

SOLICITORS:
Ebsworth & Ebsworth  (Appellant) 
CBD Law  (Respondent) 

CATCHWORDS:
TORTS – Personal injury – Breach of statutory duty – Negligence – Construction Safety Act 1912 – Construction Safety Regulations 1950, Regs 73 and 74 – Painting contractor engaged to measure and quote – Whether “construction work” – Whether construction work carried out by owner – Whether owner in charge of construction work – Contractor falls from roof – Whether owner negligent. 

LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Liability Act, Sch 1, Pt 3, cl 6
Civil Liability Amendment (Personal Responsibility) Act 2002 (NSW), s 4(1) and Sch 3
Construction Safety Act 1912 (NSW) s 3, s 22
Construction Safety Regulations 1950 (NSW) regs 73 and 74 
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1965 (NSW) s 7
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), s 33
Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 (NSW), s 139 and Sch 1, Sch 3, cll 3(c) and 4
Scaffolding and Lifts Act 1912 (NSW)
Scaffolding and Lifts (Amendment) Act 1978 (NSW), Sch 1, cl 2
Statutory Duties (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 (NSW)

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Almeida v Universal Dye Works Pty Limited [2000] NSWCA 264; [2001] Aust Torts Reports 81-603
Balesfire Pty Ltd t/as Gutter Shop v Adams [2006] NSWCA 112
Bhambra v Roet [2003] NSWCA 393
Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd v Producers and Citizens Co-operative Assurance Company of Australia Ltd (1931) 46 CLR 41
Dalton v Angus (1881) 6 App Cas 740
Darling Island Stevedoring and Lighterage Co Ltd v Long (1957) 97 CLR 36
Davey v Skinner [1961] 61 SR (NSW) 648
Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc [2002] HCA 8; (2002) 209 CLR 95
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
H C Buckman & Son Pty Limited v Flanagan [1974] HCA 30; (1974) 133 CLR 422
Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 44; (2001) 207 CLR 21
House v the King (1936) 55 CLR 449
Jones v Bartlett (2000) 205 CLR 166
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Kolodziejczyk v Grandview Pty Ltd [2002] NSWCA 267
Lenz v Trustees of the Catholic Church [2005] NSWCA 446
Marshall v Whittaker’s Building Supply Co [1963] HCA 26; (1963) 109 CLR 210
Maggiotto Building Concepts Pty Ltd v Gordon [2001] NSWCA 65
Northern Sandblasting Pty Ltd v Harris (1997) 188 CLR 313
Papatonakis v Australian…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Uniting Church v Takacs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *The Uniting Church v Takacs* involved an appeal to the New South Wales Court of Appeal concerning personal injury sustained by the plaintiff, Mr Takacs, who fell from the roof of premises owned by The Uniting Church (the Trust). Mr Takacs, a painting contractor, had been invited to the premises by the Trust's building maintenance manager to quote for painting work. While attempting to measure the roof, he fell approximately nine metres, suffering significant injuries. The plaintiff's claim was based on alleged breaches of statutory duty under the *Construction Safety Act 1912* (NSW) and the *Construction Safety Regulations 1950* (NSW), as well as negligence.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the work being undertaken by the plaintiff constituted "construction work" as defined by the Act, whether the Trust was the "constructor" in relation to that work, and consequently, whether the Trust owed a statutory duty of care under Regulation 73 or 74. Additionally, the court considered whether the Trust was negligent in its duty of care to the plaintiff. The plaintiff argued that the Trust, through its employee Mr Bagnara, had failed to provide safe working conditions, including adequate scaffolding or safety measures to prevent falls from height.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the judgment of the primary judge. The court reasoned that the plaintiff's activity of measuring the roof for a painting quote did not amount to "construction work" as defined by the *Construction Safety Act 1912*. Therefore, the specific duties imposed by Regulations 73 and 74 of the *Construction Safety Regulations 1950* were not engaged. Furthermore, the court found that the Trust was not the "constructor" of any construction work. While Mr Bagnara was involved in organising maintenance, his actions in relation to the plaintiff's task did not render the Trust the constructor of construction work. The court also found that the Trust was not negligent, as the circumstances did not establish a breach of any duty of care owed to the plaintiff.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal entered judgment for the Trust and ordered that the plaintiff pay the Trust's costs of the proceedings and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal allowed. (2) Judgment below set aside. (3) In lieu thereof judgment for the Trust and order that the plaintiff pay the Trust's costs of the proceedings. (4) Order that the plaintiff pay the Trust costs of the appeal and have a certificate under the Suitor's Fund Act if otherwise eligible.

Background

Background to the litigation

The relevant statutory provisions were set out as follows by the primary judge: [33]The Construction Safety Act 1912 (NSW) (Act No 38) as it was in force at the time of the accident on 4 May 1999 had relevant definitions which were:[3](1) ‘Building work’ means:(a) work in constructing, erecting, installing, adding to, altering, repairing, equipping, finishing, painting, cleaning, signwriting, sheathing, spraying, dismantling or demolishing or any other prescribed operation that: (i) is done in relation to a building or structure, at or adjacent to the site thereof, or ……‘Construction work’ means:(a) building work, excavation work, compressed air work and diving work …‘Constructor’, in relation to any construction work, means the person who by himself or herself (otherwise than as a servant or agent of the person carrying out that work) or by the person's servants or agents carries out that work. [34]The relevant provisions of the Construction Safety Regulations 1950 (NSW) made pursuant to the Construction Safety Act 1912 (NSW) are:[73]Any person who directly or by his servants or agents carries out any construction work shall take all measures that appear necessary or advisable to minimise accident risk and to prevent injury to the health of persons engaged in such construction work and for this purpose, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, he shall, subject to Regulation 74:(1)provide suitable and safe scaffolding, which shall conform to the requirements of these Regulations, for all work which cannot be done safely by a person standing on permanent or solid construction, except when such work can be done safely from ladders constructed in conformity with the provisions of these Regulations,…(3)provide means by fencing or otherwise for securing the safety of any person working at a place from which he would be liable to fall a distance of more than 1.8 m,…(8)effectively fence in the manner prescribed by these Regulations, all platforms, the open sides of all floors, openings in floors, roofs and platforms into which persons could accidentally walk, the open sides of stairways and stairway landings and all excavations and holes more than 1.5 m deep.Provided that it shall be permissible to remove when necessary any guard rail, fence or part thereof for the purpose of handling materials or for the installation of other work, subject to such guard rail, fence or part thereof being at once replaced upon completion of such work,…[74](1) Where there is a risk that a person engaged in construction work may fall because there is no adequate hand hold or foot hold, the person in charge of the construction work shall provide:(a)a safety belt and safety line or safety harness and safety line complying with the requirements of AS 1891 for the use of that person, or(b)a safety net complying with the requirements of BS 3913, while the work is being carried out …FACTS There was no dispute concerning the primary judge’s following findings as to the facts of the accident: [3]The plaintiff, having been born on 28 January 1967, was 32 years of age at the time of the incident. The plaintiff completed a four year apprenticeship as a painter. He worked for a business called Douglas Painting Services for one year and thereafter purchased the business, changing its name to Brush-Rite. The work performed by the plaintiff in that business was the painting of shipping containers and commercial buildings (although, in the latter case, not generally new construction). [4]The plaintiff operated the business that he had acquired as a partnership and had done so from approximately June 1997. ……[6]The plaintiff performed work for a variety of companies including Telstra, Arnott’s Biscuits, McDonalds and the like. His work included painting machinery, walls and buildings, ovens and other machinery and other maintenance. He was, as is obvious, an experienced painter who was aware of the means of safe use of ladders. Notwithstanding his apprenticeship and experience he had never worked on roofing and had never had occasion to build scaffolding.[7]As already stated, on 4 May 1999 the plaintiff fell from the roof of the premises owned and occupied by the defendant. The plaintiff had gone to the premises at the invitation of Mr Bruno Bagnara, the defendant’s building maintenance manager. [8]The plaintiff had worked for the defendant on a number of occasions at different locations on the North Shore of Sydney. On each occasion the plaintiff was invited to measure, quote and ultimately perform work. On each occasion the arrangement was made with Mr Bruno Bagnara. [9]The evidence is that Mr Bagnara took care of the maintenance of the buildings of the defendant and I infer that he organised, coordinated and supervised general building maintenance and minor construction work for the various premises of the defendant. He was employed by the defendant and had an office in the basement of the defendant’s premises at the Northaven Retirement Village. [10]On 4 May 1999 the plaintiff received a telephone call from Mr Bagnara who asked him to “come and do a quote”. Mr Bagnara told the plaintiff that he wanted him “to have a look at a roof”. [11]The plaintiff responded that it was getting a little late and that he just wanted to go home and asked if it were possible if he could do it tomorrow. After a short conversation about the then location of the plaintiff, Mr Bagnara said to him: ‘You have to drive past here to go home; so just drop in.’ As a consequence of that conversation, the plaintiff arrived at the premises at Northaven. [12]On the way to Northaven, the plaintiff collected a friend of his, another painter, Mr John Ayre, to whom he was providing a lift home to the Central Coast where they both lived and where they were intending to go for a drink. [13]On arrival at Northaven the plaintiff and Mr Ayre went to Mr Bagnara’s office in the basement. Mr Bagnara said to him: ‘Come with me; come up and I’ll show you what I want you to look at.’ [14]At that point the plaintiff, Mr Bagnara and Mr Ayre climbed an internal staircase that went to the top of the building to a locked door. Mr Bagnara unlocked the door and said: ‘Come out here.’ The plaintiff did precisely that; at which time he, Mr Bagnara and Mr Ayre were standing on a roof platform on an air-conditioning unit. About 6 foot below the platform was the main roof. [15]The main roof consisted of old profile kliplok roofing. Kliplok roofing is a form of roof sheeting in which the sheets lock together by clips — hence the name. Each sheet consists of a number of ridges with a flat panel between each of them. In the case of this kliplok sheeting, the ridges are not sufficiently distant from each other to be able to place the length of a foot between the ridges, at right angles to them, on the flat panel. As a consequence, it was difficult to walk across the roofing and it would require either walking sideways (placing each foot sideways in the flat panel between the ridge) or placing the foot on two ridges (the heel on one ridge and the toe area on the other). [16]While standing on the platform surrounding the air-conditioning tower Mr Bagnara showed the plaintiff the area of the roof that was, in Mr Bagnara’s view, problematic. There was rust on a section of the roof. The rust that he was shown was between the ridges in the flat panel section of some sheets and was, in the opinion of the plaintiff, very minor. That opinion is not controverted. [17]When the plaintiff saw the section of rust from the platform, he expressed the view to Mr Bagnara that: ‘I would have thought there would still be many many years before it needed work.’ Mr Bagnara asked how it would be treated and the plaintiff responded:‘There are paint chemicals you can put on to sort of create a coating to put the rust back into the roof to seal it off.’ Mr Bagnara responded that he wanted to get a quote to paint the roof. To that comment, the plaintiff responded:‘This sort of roof, if you want to do it properly, you should use industrial paints, so you are going to get that long-term issue out of it. The cost of industrial painting on this size roof; surely it would be cheaper to get a roofer in and replace it.’ Mr Bagnara said:‘Still just measure it, and give me a quote and we’ll talk about it later.’ [18]The three of them then moved around the platform to an area where another section of the roof (or another part of the roof) could be seen and Mr Bagnara said: ‘You know we want you to measure this roof too.’ The plaintiff responded: ‘How are we going to get down there?’ [19]After a further currently irrelevant conversation and at Mr Bagnara’s suggestion, the plaintiff and Mr Ayre waited while Mr Bagnara obtained a ladder which fitted into a section of the platform where the balustrade was not glassed in. He lowered the ladder through the balustrade onto the roof below. Mr Bagnara then said words to the following effect: ‘Go down and measure the roof. I’m going back to my office; as soon as you measure it bring the ladder back to me and go home.’ [20]It seems the plaintiff commented on the design and the absence of glass panels in two places on the air-conditioning platform to which Mr Bagnara said: ‘This is always how we get access to that roof.’ [21]The ladder, as earlier stated, was placed in the gap in the balustrade to the roof below by Mr Bagnara leaning it back on the chilling tower. The ladder was unsecured. In accordance with the abovementioned statement of Mr Bagnara, the plaintiff climbed down the ladder as did Mr Ayre. Mr Ayre stayed at the base of the ladder holding the coil end of a measurement tape while the plaintiff walked out over the roof in order to do one measurement of the roof’s length and one measurement of its breadth. The plaintiff held the end of the tape measure and the tape moved out of the coil as the plaintiff moved away from Mr Ayre. [22]As earlier stated it was not possible to walk normally on the roofing. The plaintiff walked on the roofing by having the heal of his shoe on one ridge and the front of his shoe on the next; thereby walking on two ridges at a time and the major part of his foot (or boot) was unsupported. The plaintiff was wearing steel-capped work boots. The top of the ridges were approximately 50 to 60 millimetres in height above the flat panel of the sheeting. [23]The intention was for the plaintiff to go to the end of the roof, crouch down and hold the tape so that Mr Ayre could read the measurement required by Mr Bagnara. [24]Surrounding the roof sheeting was a parapet the height of which varied because of the slope of the roof. At one end of the roof the parapet was approximately 600 millimetres and at the far end (the end to which the plaintiff was walking) it was at or about shin height. [25]As the plaintiff approached the end of the roof he crouched in order to place the tape along the roof and measure it relatively accurately. As he crouched his foot slipped between the ridges of the kliplok, got caught there and the plaintiff stumbled. [26]It was his right foot that was caught between the ridges of the kliplok and the stumble was enough to put the plaintiff off balance. The plaintiff was unable to regain balance, went to grab for the parapet but, because of its height, or lack of it, was unable to grab it and rolled over the edge of the roof. The plaintiff fell 3 stories, approximately 9 metres, landing on his right upper arm and the right side of his body. He suffered multiple injuries to the details of which I will return later in this judgment. Decision of Primary Judge

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was no dispute concerning the primary judge’s following findings as to the facts of the accident: [3]The plaintiff, having been born on 28 January 1967, was 32 years of age at the time of the incident. The plaintiff completed a four year apprenticeship as a painter. He worked for a business called Douglas Painting Services for one year and thereafter purchased the business, changing its name to Brush-Rite. The work performed by the plaintiff in that business was the painting of shipping containers and commercial buildings (although, in the latter case, not generally new construction). [4]The plaintiff operated the business that he had acquired as a partnership and had done so from approximately June 1997. ……[6]The plaintiff performed work for a variety of companies including Telstra, Arnott’s Biscuits, McDonalds and the like. His work included painting machinery, walls and buildings, ovens and other machinery and other maintenance. He was, as is obvious, an experienced painter who was aware of the means of safe use of ladders. Notwithstanding his apprenticeship and experience he had never worked on roofing and had never had occasion to build scaffolding.[7]As already stated, on 4 May 1999 the plaintiff fell from the roof of the premises owned and occupied by the defendant. The plaintiff had gone to the premises at the invitation of Mr Bruno Bagnara, the defendant’s building maintenance manager. [8]The plaintiff had worked for the defendant on a number of occasions at different locations on the North Shore of Sydney. On each occasion the plaintiff was invited to measure, quote and ultimately perform work. On each occasion the arrangement was made with Mr Bruno Bagnara. [9]The evidence is that Mr Bagnara took care of the maintenance of the buildings of the defendant and I infer that he organised, coordinated and supervised general building maintenance and minor construction work for the various premises of the defendant. He was employed by the defendant and had an office in the basement of the defendant’s premises at the Northaven Retirement Village. [10]On 4 May 1999 the plaintiff received a telephone call from Mr Bagnara who asked him to “come and do a quote”. Mr Bagnara told the plaintiff that he wanted him “to have a look at a roof”. [11]The plaintiff responded that it was getting a little late and that he just wanted to go home and asked if it were possible if he could do it tomorrow. After a short conversation about the then location of the plaintiff, Mr Bagnara said to him: ‘You have to drive past here to go home; so just drop in.’ As a consequence of that conversation, the plaintiff arrived at the premises at Northaven. [12]On the way to Northaven, the plaintiff collected a friend of his, another painter, Mr John Ayre, to whom he was providing a lift home to the Central Coast where they both lived and where they were intending to go for a drink. [13]On arrival at Northaven the plaintiff and Mr Ayre went to Mr Bagnara’s office in the basement. Mr Bagnara said to him: ‘Come with me; come up and I’ll show you what I want you to look at.’ [14]At that point the plaintiff, Mr Bagnara and Mr Ayre climbed an internal staircase that went to the top of the building to a locked door. Mr Bagnara unlocked the door and said: ‘Come out here.’ The plaintiff did precisely that; at which time he, Mr Bagnara and Mr Ayre were standing on a roof platform on an air-conditioning unit. About 6 foot below the platform was the main roof. [15]The main roof consisted of old profile kliplok roofing. Kliplok roofing is a form of roof sheeting in which the sheets lock together by clips — hence the name. Each sheet consists of a number of ridges with a flat panel between each of them. In the case of this kliplok sheeting, the ridges are not sufficiently distant from each other to be able to place the length of a foot between the ridges, at right angles to them, on the flat panel. As a consequence, it was difficult to walk across the roofing and it would require either walking sideways (placing each foot sideways in the flat panel between the ridge) or placing the foot on two ridges (the heel on one ridge and the toe area on the other). [16]While standing on the platform surrounding the air-conditioning tower Mr Bagnara showed the plaintiff the area of the roof that was, in Mr Bagnara’s view, problematic. There was rust on a section of the roof. The rust that he was shown was between the ridges in the flat panel section of some sheets and was, in the opinion of the plaintiff, very minor. That opinion is not controverted. [17]When the plaintiff saw the section of rust from the platform, he expressed the view to Mr Bagnara that: ‘I would have thought there would still be many many years before it needed work.’ Mr Bagnara asked how it would be treated and the plaintiff responded:‘There are paint chemicals you can put on to sort of create a coating to put the rust back into the roof to seal it off.’ Mr Bagnara responded that he wanted to get a quote to paint the roof. To that comment, the plaintiff responded:‘This sort of roof, if you want to do it properly, you should use industrial paints, so you are going to get that long-term issue out of it. The cost of industrial painting on this size roof; surely it would be cheaper to get a roofer in and replace it.’ Mr Bagnara said:‘Still just measure it, and give me a quote and we’ll talk about it later.’ [18]The three of them then moved around the platform to an area where another section of the roof (or another part of the roof) could be seen and Mr Bagnara said: ‘You know we want you to measure this roof too.’ The plaintiff responded: ‘How are we going to get down there?’ [19]After a further currently irrelevant conversation and at Mr Bagnara’s suggestion, the plaintiff and Mr Ayre waited while Mr Bagnara obtained a ladder which fitted into a section of the platform where the balustrade was not glassed in. He lowered the ladder through the balustrade onto the roof below. Mr Bagnara then said words to the following effect: ‘Go down and measure the roof. I’m going back to my office; as soon as you measure it bring the ladder back to me and go home.’ [20]It seems the plaintiff commented on the design and the absence of glass panels in two places on the air-conditioning platform to which Mr Bagnara said: ‘This is always how we get access to that roof.’ [21]The ladder, as earlier stated, was placed in the gap in the balustrade to the roof below by Mr Bagnara leaning it back on the chilling tower. The ladder was unsecured. In accordance with the abovementioned statement of Mr Bagnara, the plaintiff climbed down the ladder as did Mr Ayre. Mr Ayre stayed at the base of the ladder holding the coil end of a measurement tape while the plaintiff walked out over the roof in order to do one measurement of the roof’s length and one measurement of its breadth. The plaintiff held the end of the tape measure and the tape moved out of the coil as the plaintiff moved away from Mr Ayre. [22]As earlier stated it was not possible to walk normally on the roofing. The plaintiff walked on the roofing by having the heal of his shoe on one ridge and the front of his shoe on the next; thereby walking on two ridges at a time and the major part of his foot (or boot) was unsupported. The plaintiff was wearing steel-capped work boots. The top of the ridges were approximately 50 to 60 millimetres in height above the flat panel of the sheeting. [23]The intention was for the plaintiff to go to the end of the roof, crouch down and hold the tape so that Mr Ayre could read the measurement required by Mr Bagnara. [24]Surrounding the roof sheeting was a parapet the height of which varied because of the slope of the roof. At one end of the roof the parapet was approximately 600 millimetres and at the far end (the end to which the plaintiff was walking) it was at or about shin height. [25]As the plaintiff approached the end of the roof he crouched in order to place the tape along the roof and measure it relatively accurately. As he crouched his foot slipped between the ridges of the kliplok, got caught there and the plaintiff stumbled. [26]It was his right foot that was caught between the ridges of the kliplok and the stumble was enough to put the plaintiff off balance. The plaintiff was unable to regain balance, went to grab for the parapet but, because of its height, or lack of it, was unable to grab it and rolled over the edge of the roof. The plaintiff fell 3 stories, approximately 9 metres, landing on his right upper arm and the right side of his body. He suffered multiple injuries to the details of which I will return later in this judgment. Decision of Primary Judge

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.