The Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

The Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust (Taxation) [2022] AATA 2482 (5 August 2022)

Division:SMALL BUSINESS TAXATION DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/5233

Re:The Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust

APPLICANT

AndCommissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr Linda Kirk

Date:5 August 2022

Place:Sydney

The Reviewable Decision dated 8 April 2021 is affirmed.

...........[Sgnd]..................................................

Senior Member Dr Linda Kirk

Catchwords

TAXATION – Coronavirus Economic Response Package – Entitlement to Cash Flow Boost –Where entity is a trust – Whether the entity satisfied the ‘payment and withholding in the period’ requirement – Whether the entity entered into or carried out a scheme or part of a scheme for the sole or dominant purpose of making the entity entitled to the cash flow boost – Decision affirmed

Legislation

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Boosting Cash Flow for Employers (Coronavirus Economic Response Package) Act 2020 (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)

Cases

Blank v Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 242 FCR 96

Brent v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1971) 125 CLR 418

Brookton Co-operative Society Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 147 CLR 441

Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 235

Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404

Hamed and Commissioner of Taxation [2010] AATA 684

MJ and IT Holdings Pty Ltd and Commissioner of Taxation [2021] AATA 3250

Permanent Trustee Company of New South Wales v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1940) 6 ATD 5

RFZD and Commissioner of Taxation (Taxation) [2022] AATA 988 (14 April 2022) para [75]

VNBM and Commissioner of Taxation [2021] AATA 1626

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Memorandum to Coronavirus Economic Response Package Omnibus Bill 2020 and associated Bills

Treasury Factsheet: Cash flow assistance for businesses

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr Linda Kirk

5 August 2022

  1. On 20 November 2020 the Commissioner of Taxation (‘the Respondent’) made a decision (‘the Decision’) that the Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust (‘the Applicant’) is not entitled to receive the Cash Flow Boost (‘CFB’) pursuant to subsection 5(1) of the Boosting Cash Flow for Employers (Coronavirus Economic Response Package) Act 2020 (Cth) (‘the BCF Act’).

  2. The Respondent made this decision on the basis that he was not satisfied that the Applicant could substantiate the payments of salary and wages purported to have been made to Mr Justin Cook (‘Mr Cook’) for the quarters ended 31 March 2020 and 30 June 2020 (‘the Relevant Periods’), therefore failing the payment and withholding requirement in subsection 5(1)(a) of the BCF Act.[1]

    [1] Exhibit R1, T-Documents, T2.

  3. On 19 January 2021, the Applicant objected to the Decision (‘the Objection’).[2] On 8 April 2021, the Respondent disallowed the Objection, concluding that the Applicant did not satisfy the payment and withholding requirement of the CFB eligibility…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust (Ta... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2482
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the entitlement of The Trustee for JC Mobile Sharpening Discretionary Trust (the Applicant) to the Cash Flow Boost (CFB) under the Coronavirus Economic Response Package (BA Economic Response Package) Act 2020 (BCF Act). The dispute arose because the Commissioner of Taxation (the Respondent) contended that the Applicant had entered into or carried out a scheme for the dominant purpose of obtaining the CFB, thereby disqualifying it from entitlement.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant satisfied the requirement of having made payments and withholdings in the relevant period, and crucially, whether the Applicant, or its associates and agents, had entered into or carried out a scheme, or part of a scheme, with the sole or dominant purpose of making the Applicant entitled to the CFB. This involved examining the Applicant's decisions regarding the remuneration of its sole worker, Mr Cook, including the timing and nature of payments, the withholding of PAYG amounts, and the issuance of payslips, particularly in light of the Applicant's financial position and prior tax planning practices.

The Tribunal reasoned that the Applicant bore the burden of proof to demonstrate that the objection decision should not have been made or should have been made differently, applying the standard of proof on the balance of probabilities. The Tribunal considered evidence relating to the Applicant's decision to treat Mr Cook as an employee, to remunerate him as such rather than making a trust distribution, to withhold PAYG from this remuneration, and to pay a significant bonus despite the Applicant being in a tax and accounting loss position. The Tribunal found that the Applicant failed to discharge its burden of proof in establishing that it did not enter into or carry out a scheme for the sole or dominant purpose of obtaining the CFB.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Reviewable Decision dated 8 April 2021, meaning the Applicant was not entitled to the Cash Flow Boost.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, paragraph 5(1)(g) of the BCF Act looks not only at whether the entity entered into or carried out a scheme, but also at the actions of the associates and agents of the relevant entity and whether they have entered into a relevant scheme on the relevant entity’s behalf.[13] RELEVANT FACTS AND EVIDENCE[13] VNBM at [23]. The Applicant operates a knife sharpening business (‘the Business’), offering its services to the meat industry in South Australia. The Applicant is a discretionary trust, of which the trustee is JC Mobile Sharpening Pty Ltd (ACN 626 933 515),[14] a company incorporated on 20 June 2018,[15] of which Mr Cook is the sole director and shareholder.[16] The primary beneficiaries of the Applicant[17] are Mr Cook and his spouse, Ms Brigitta Kiss (‘Ms Kiss’).[18] The Applicant commenced trading on 1 July 2018.[19][14] Exhibit R1, ST7-274; Applicant’s Supplementary Tender Bundle Annexure A-43.[15] Exhibit R1, ST8-292.[16] Exhibit R1, ST8-292 and 293; Transcript, P-9, P-10.[17] Exhibit R1, T11-41. [18] Exhibit R1, Applicant’s SOFIC, Annexure A, Applicant Deed Annexure A-43; T10-36 to 37, where Mr Cook and Ms Kiss are described as beneficiaries of the Applicant at Item 55 of the Applicant’s income tax return for the income year ended 30 June 2019.[19] Exhibit R1, T24-166. Mr Cook first operated the Business as a sole trader when it commenced operating in 2015.[20] The Applicant discretionary trust was established by deed dated 20 June 2018.[21] Mr Cook gave evidence to the Tribunal that the day-to-day operations of the Business did not change after the establishment of the Applicant.[22] Mr Walsh’s evidence was that there were some additional costs in transitioning to the new structure,[23] but he did not detail those additional costs, or provide details of quantum, or point to other business records to support it. [20] Transcript, P-6 line [6].[21] Exhibit R1, Applicant’s SOFIC, Annexure A, Applicant Deed Annexure A-43.[22] Transcript, P-10 lines [9] to [30].[23] Transcript, P-78 lines [15] to [16]. Mr Cook is the sole worker for the Applicant. No contract of employment between the Applicant and Mr Cook, nor any contemporaneous evidence of the formation of an employment relationship or the terms of Mr Cook’s employment, was provided by the Applicant or Mr Cook. On 8 November 2020, the Applicant referred to himself as ‘self-employed’ on his AMP Bank Home Loan Application Summary.[24] [24] Exhibit R1, Item No. 7. Mr Cook, in his evidence, confirmed that there had been an increase in profits every year since the inception of the Business whilst he operated it as a sole trader.[25] Mr Walsh accepted, in his evidence, that it was ‘arguable’ that the Applicant did not need to wait until the preparation of the financial statements for the 2019 Income Year to see the profitability of the Business in order to determine if wages could be paid to Mr Cook.[26][25] Transcript, P-8 lines [20] to [22].[26] Transcript, P-78 lines [18] to [21].PAYGW amounts reported by the Applicant

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the basis of the evidence before it and the above reasons, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant has failed to discharge its burden of proof to establish, for the purposes of paragraph 5(1)(g) of the BCF Act, that it did not enter into or carry out a scheme for the sole or dominant purpose of obtaining a CFB.DECISION The Reviewable Decision dated 8 April 2021 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent also contends that the Applicant (and/or its associates and agents) entered into or carried out a scheme for the purposes of paragraph 5(1)(g) of the BFC Act, consisting of one or more of the following actions:(a)the decision by the Applicant to commence treating Mr Cook, the Applicant’s sole worker, as an employee during the Relevant Periods;(b)the decision by the Applicant to remunerate Mr Cook as an employee rather than making a trust distribution of business profits to him at the end of the income year ended 30 June 2020 as per the tax planning practice of the Applicant in the income year ended 30 June 2019, the relevant preceding income year, and the Applicant’s first income year of trading;(c)the decision of the Applicant, to withhold PAYG from that remuneration;(d)the decision by the Applicant, on the advice of its tax agent, Voltage Accounting, to pay a $33,000 bonus to Mr Cook, purportedly based on the Applicant’s financial position prior to the end of the 2020 income year, despite being in a tax and accounting loss position, and a purported practice of ‘paying profits as a wage’;[134](e)the decision by the Applicant to issue two payslips to Mr Cook purporting to show that a net wage of $61,525 (including the $33,000 bonus) had been paid to Mr Cook in the Relevant Periods, when no payment of salary and wages was made.CONSIDERATION AND REASONS[134] T16-81.Burden of proof On a review before the Tribunal, the Applicant has the burden of proving that the objection decision should not have been made or that it should have been made differently.[135] Discharging the burden of proof requires the Applicant to establish the facts upon which it relies and, if it is necessary for the Applicant to establish a particular fact in order to displace the Respondent’s decision, the Applicant must satisfy the Tribunal with respect to that fact.[136] The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities.[137] It has been described as involving a weighing up of the arguments of each party so that if a taxpayer succeeds in ‘weighing down [the] scales ever so slightly in [its] favour’ then it will have discharged the burden.[138] [135] RFZD and Commissioner of Taxation (Taxation) [2022] AATA 988 (14 April 2022); Hamed and Commissioner of Taxation [2010] AATA 684.[136] As above.[137] As above.[138] Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Cassaniti [2018] FCAFC 212, [88]. The Applicant can discharge the burden in any one of several ways. For example, it can do so by direct evidence and/or by drawing inferences from the evidence,[139] but not from conjecture.[140] While evidence from a taxpayer is not prima facie unacceptable, uncorroborated, self-serving statements are to be tested closely and received with the greatest caution.[141] There is no onus on the Respondent to show that an assessment or, in this case, an objection decision, is correct.[142] Therefore, the Applicant cannot succeed merely by identifying errors or flaws in the Respondent’s decision.[140] As above.[141] As above.[142] As above.