The State of Western Australia v Thomas [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CRIMINAL

CITATION:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- THOMAS [No 2] [2024] WASC 403

CORAM:   SEAWARD J

HEARD:   24 OCTOBER 2024

DELIVERED          :   31 OCTOBER 2024

FILE NO/S:   INS 2 of 2022

BETWEEN:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Prosecution

AND

DECLAN SEAN THOMAS

Accused


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Trial by judge alone - Murder - Where the accused admitted to killing the deceased - Whether accused was mentally impaired - Whether the accused was deprived of any of the capacities specified in s 27 of the Criminal Code - Where the accused was deprived of the capacity to know that he ought not to do the act - Section 27(1) of the Criminal Code

Criminal Law (Mental Impairment) Act 2023 (WA) - Accused acquitted of charge on the grounds of mental impairment - Custody order with a limiting term of life imprisonment

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA) s 27, s 279
Criminal Law (Mental Impairment) Act 2023 (WA) s 46, s 50
Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA) s 93, s 118, s 119
Evidence Act 1906 (WA) s 32

Result:

Not guilty on account of mental impairment pursuant to s 27(1) of the Criminal Code

Custody order made with a limiting term of life imprisonment

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Prosecution : Mr J Mactaggart
Accused : Ms K Farley SC & Mr D Fernandez

Solicitors:

Prosecution : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)
Accused : Legal Aid (WA)

Cases referred to in decision:

Evans v The State of Western Australia [2010] WASCA 34

Gore v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 163

Hawkins v The Queen (1994) 179 CLR 500

Hone v The State of Western Australia [2007] WASCA 283; (2007) 179 A Crim R 138

R v Falconer [1990] HCA 49; (1990) 171 CLR 30

R v Porter [1933] HCA 1; (1933) 55 CLR 182

R v Radford (1985) 20 A Crim R 388

Stapleton v The Queen [1952] HCA 56; (1952) 86 CLR 358

The State of Western Australia v Chokolich [2024] WASC 346

The State of Western Australia v Jones [2018] WASC 395

The State of Western Australia v Taylor [2021] WASC 470

The State of Western Australia v Thomas [2023] WASC 405

Ward v The Queen [2000] WASCA 413; (2000) 23 WAR 254

SEAWARD J:

Introduction

  1. The accused, Declan Sean Thomas, has been indicted on one count that alleges that on 12 July 2020 at Mandurah, he murdered his father, Edward Charles Thomas, contrary to s 279 of the Criminal Code (WA).

  2. The State's case is that Mr Thomas struck Edward Thomas in the back of the head with a frying pan with force and then placed him in a choke‑hold.  Mr Thomas then struggled with Edward Thomas on the floor before using a serrated kitchen knife to cut Edward Thomas's throat whilst he was lying on the floor.

  3. On 26 October 2023, McGrath J ordered that Mr Thomas be tried by judge…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Thomas [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASC 403
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Declan Sean Thomas was charged with the murder of his father, Edward Charles Thomas, on 12 July 2020. The accused admitted to the killing, and the primary legal issue for the court was whether the accused was mentally impaired at the time of the offence. The court considered whether the accused was deprived of any of the capacities specified in s 27 of the Criminal Code, particularly the capacity to know that he ought not to do the act. The accused had a history of mental health issues, including ADHD, Asperger syndrome, and substance abuse, which were relevant to determining his mental state at the time of the murder. The court also examined the provisions of the Criminal Law (Mental Impairment) Act 2023 (WA).

The court concluded that the accused was deprived of the capacity to know that he ought not to do the act, as he was suffering from a significant mental impairment at the time of the offence. This finding was based on expert evidence and the accused's own history of mental health issues and substance abuse. The court found that the accused's actions were a result of his mental impairment, and therefore acquitted him of the charge of murder on the grounds of mental impairment. However, the court made a custody order for the accused, with a limiting term of life imprisonment, due to the seriousness of the offence and the need to protect the public.

The final orders of the court were that the accused be acquitted of the charge of murder and be detained under the provisions of the Mental Health Act. The court also ordered that the accused be subject to a limiting term of life imprisonment, reflecting the gravity of the offence and the need for public protection. The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the evidence and the applicable legal principles, ensuring that justice was served in this complex case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The State's Statement of Case provides as follows: [8][8] Exhibit 1.1.The accused Mr Declan Sean Thomas is charged on indictment with 1 count alleging that on the 12th July 2020 at Mandurah, he murdered Edward Charles Thomas. At that time Mr Thomas, then aged 31, was the son of the deceased man, Mr Edward Charles Thomas, then aged 71. The deceased man was a fragile man with a pre-existing medical condition.Background and Context to the Circumstances Attending the Commission of the Alleged Offence2.Mr Declan Sean Thomas was born of a relationship between the deceased man, Mr Edward Charles Thomas and Ms Marianne Thomas. The accused was born in Derby on the 6th December 1988.3.The accused with his sister Natasha attended Capel Primary School. While attending primary school, the accused began to consume cannabis.4.During his teen years, the accused began to manifest mental issues between the ages of 13 to 15 years old. These issues manifested themselves in feelings of paranoia about anything or anybody acting in an official capacity. When travelling in a car with his mother, the accused would cover up the speakers citing that 'they' were trying to listen to our conversations. At that time, the accused began to become verbally aggressive towards his father, his sister and his mother.5.When the accused reached his 20s, he began to become violent and aggressive with family members and police were called to intervene on occasions.6.After an incident in 2009, the accused's mother Ms Marianne Thomas, took the accused to get professional help and he was diagnosed with ADHD and Asperger syndrome and was prescribed Ritalin. Medical practitioners tried to treat the accused with other types and varieties of prescribed drugs. The accused refused to take prescribed medications and continued to use cannabis and began experimenting with methylamphetamine. The accused also was a heavy drinker or consumer of alcohol and for a time consumed or ingested chronic or synthetic cannabis.7.The accused engaged in a family context in paranoid behaviour including a refusal to trust doctors and other health workers and a belief that he would be taken away by betting corporations after he had had any large wins believing betting companies may have been concerned he had a winning formula that would adversely effect their profits. The accused also engaged in behaviour like shaving his head after using or ingesting methylamphetamine.8.During an incident in May 2011, the accused's mother Ms Marianne Thomas, called police after the accused threatened to smash up the home they were then living in the Mandurah Peel area. When police attended the house, the accused attacked them with a hockey stick, was arrested and admitted to an Emergency Department at the Peel Mandurah Hospital and became under the care of Ruagaruah Community Services.9.In 2017 or 2018 with the assistance of his mother Ms Marianne Thomas, the accused moved into a unit, at unit 5/34 Rockford Street, Mandurah. At that time, the deceased man lived at unit 15, 162 Mandurah Terrace, Mandurah, which was a relatively short distance from the unit occupied by the accused. The accused would visit the deceased and ask him for money or consume some of his alcohol.10.At that time, the accused spent monies he received by way of Social Security on alcohol, gambling, cannabis and to buy methylamphetamine.11.Prior to the 12th July 2020, the accused's mother Ms Marianne Thomas, observed what she thought a deterioration in the accused's mental state. The accused would utter words to the effect of 'How are your voices?' and 'Who are they?'. The accused would further utter words to the effect of 'Same mum' and 'Don't worry. They are not nasty'. The accused was sending threatening text messages and his behaviour was threatening in that the accused was verbally aggressive. 12.Prior to the 18th July 2020, the accused began to utter words in the presence of his mother Ms Marianne Thomas about elderly people to the effect of 'Old people have too much money and take up too much space. They don't do anything' and 'Old people are a waste of space' and 'Old people should be put down when they are 60'.13.About two weeks before the 12th July 2020, the accused's mother Ms Marianne Thomas, became aware that the accused stole $50.00 from the deceased man which was spent on either the purchase of illegal drugs or gambling. Ms Thomas reimbursed the deceased man.14.On the week commencing the 6th July 2020, the accused's mother Ms Marianne Thomas, picked up the accused to take him shopping and observing him that his eyes were blank and his face was expressionless. Ms Thomas asked the accused if he was OK and he replied 'I'm OK mum'. The accused spoke to her about 'going hunting for mushrooms'.The Deceased Man Mr Edward Charles Thomas15.As at the 12th July 2020, Mr Edward Charles Thomas, lived at unit 15, 162 Mandurah Terrace, Mandurah. Mr [Edward] Thomas had been married to Ms Marianne Thomas and the two of them had separated after the family moved to Halls Head in 2005. Mr Edward Charles Thomas had been employed by the Water Corporation and then started to work at Murdoch University lecturing in indigenous studies. 16.As at the 12th July 2020, Mr Edward Charles Thomas's health had been deteriorating in recent years and while he could walk reasonably he was using a gopher to walk around. Mr Edward Charles Thomas had had a stroke a couple of years previously which was diagnosed after a visit to his optometrist. Mr Edward Charles Thomas had also been diagnosed with asbestosis, had had a knee replacement and a shoulder replacement.17.Mr Edward Charles Thomas was in regular contact with members of his family including his former wife Marianne, his daughter Ms Nathasha [sic] Dawn Thomas and the accused.Circumstances Attending the Commission of the Offence18.At 9.40pm on the 12th July 2020, Mr Colin Daly, a police auxiliary officer, based at Mandurah Police Station, was on duty. Mr Daly's role was to answer phone calls and attending anyone arriving at the police station front desk if need be. While in the traffic office, Mr Daly looked up at the CCTV screen and observed a male person sitting in the entrance lobby of the traffic office. Mr Daly walked into the police reception desk area and pressed a button to allow the person to enter the lobby. That person was the accused and Mr Daly observed a mark on his left cheek. The accused was wearing a shirt [sic] sleeve t-shirt and shorts. Mr Daly asked the accused how he could help him and the accused replied, 'I have just killed my dad'. Mr Daly immediately smelt alcohol on the accused's breath. Mr Daly repeated to the accused, 'You've just killed your dad?' and the accused replied, 'Yes'. Mr Daly asked the accused how he had done it, to which the accused replied, 'I've hit my dad with a frying pan and gouged his eyes out and slit his throat'. Mr Daly asked the accused for his details and the accused replied that his name was Declan Thomas with the date of birth of 6th December 1988. Mr Daly informed a colleague, Sergeant Cramer, of the conversation. The accused was then escorted by Mr Daly to an office and given a drink by way of refreshment.19.After the initial conversation or interchange with Mr Daly, Acting Sergeant Plater and Senior Constable Weedon spoke to the accused. They were later joined by Sergeant Cramer. Acting Sergeant Plater observed the accused seemed agitated and his behaviour was up and down from calm to verbally aggressive. The accused remained in the custody of those officers for several hours while other police officers went to and searched the premises at unit 15, 162 Mandurah Terrace, Mandurah.20.While in the presence of Acting Sergeant Plater and Senior Constable Weedon, the accused made a comment along the lines of 'I've killed my father, I beat him with a frying pan and gouged his eyes out'. While in the company of Acting Sergeant Plater and Senior Constable Weedon, the accused was observed to behave erratically and his mood was fluctuating and he on occasions showed aggression. It was the perception of Senior Constable Weedon that the accused appeared to be acting in a delusional way and appeared to be having some kind of mental episode. At some stage, the accused was restrained by handcuffs being applied in the front stack position.21.Several police officers including Acting Sergeant Herbert, Senior Constable Tamblyn and Constable Plater responded to a call to attend premises at unit 5, 34 Rockford Street, Mandurah. These were premises occupied by the accused. The officers were then requested to conduct a welfare check on the deceased man, Mr Edward Charles Thomas at unit 15, 162 Mandurah Terrace, Mandurah.22.Arriving at unit 15, 162 Mandurah Terrace, Mandurah, at about 10.00pm, Acting Sergeant Herbert entered the unit and observed the deceased man wearing what appeared to be dark pyjamas bottoms and a top, laying on his righthand side on the loungeroom floor. The deceased man had a significant amount of blood on his body and also on the floor next to him. Acting Sergeant Herbert observed a small knife with a black handle which appeared to be a household steak knife next to the deceased man's body. The television was turned on and the kitchen light was on. Acting Sergeant Herbert observed a large laceration on the deceased man's throat which travelled from the centre to the right side under his ear and a bloodied and swollen face. Acting Sergeant Herbert asked Senior Constable Plater to shine his torch on the deceased man's face and when Acting Sergeant Herbert observed him he appeared to be unresponsive. Acting Sergeant Herbert then attempted to see if the deceased man had a pulse by using two fingers to feel his neck and in doing so observed that his body was warm to the touch. Senior Constable Plater retrieved some bandages from a medic bag and endeavoured to apply some bandages to the deceased man. 23.Acting Sergeant Herbert declared the scene a protected forensic area at 10.00pm. Upon being advised by his colleague, Detective Senior Constable Tamblyn that she had located a human eyeball in the master bedroom of the unit, Acting Sergeant Herbert entered the master bedroom where he observed what appeared to be an eyeball on the floor to the right side of the bed. The eyeball still had a small amount of flesh attached and also a small amount of blood. Acting Sergeant Herbert then conducted a further search of the unit to eliminate the possibility of any other persons being present and in doing so located another human eyeball on the floor near the sliding door. That human eyeball also had a small amount of flesh attached and also a small amount of blood.24.Senior Constable Plater heard Acting Sergeant Herbert try to arouse the deceased man by saying 'Sir, sir' and when Acting Sergeant Herbert moved or rolled the deceased man's body over, he saw a large wound about 4 to 5 inches long going from the middle of his throat across to the righthand side up towards his ear.25.Senior Constable Plater also observed an imprint of what he thought was the heel of a large size sneaker on the floor of the loungeroom made from blood. Senior Constable Plater observed on the right side of the deceased man what he could see was a steak knife about 1 to 2 feet from the body. The blade of the knife was about 6 inches long and it had a black handle. Senior Constable Plater observed the deceased man to be lying on what looked like a wooden ornamental spear and another ornamental object. Senior Constable Plater could observe a broken pair of reading glasses at the head of the deceased man's body.26.The knife was seized as an exhibit during a search of the premises and subsequent Homicide Squad and Forensic Police enquired an operation. The knife was examined in the fingerprint laboratory of the West Australian Police Forensic Branch and the dimensions of the knife were later measured by officers attached to the PathWest during examination of the knife. The overall length of the knife was 215 millimetres. The knife had a serrated, single edge blade length of approximately 112 millimetres at its widest point. The width of the blade of the knife was 17 millimetres. Photographs of the knife are attached to this Statement of Case.27.Senior Constable Tamblyn observed from the doorway to the unit what she thought was the body of an elderly male of frail frame and grey coloured hair. Senior Constable Tamblyn could see lots of blood on the male's face and could hardly see any facial features due to what she perceived as significant facial trauma. Senior Constable Tamblyn observed that the deceased man's forehead and eyebrow area looked chunky and swollen and 'kind of messed up'. Senior Constable Tamblyn could not observe any facial features due to the large amount of trauma on the face and the angle of the head tilted away from her. Senior Constable Tamblyn observed a lot of red blood, thick in the carpet, and clear liquid like plasma or water in appearance in amongst the red thick liquid which she thought was blood. Senior Constable Tamblyn observed blood on the deceased man's chest and stomach.28.Senior Constable Tamblyn observed in what she referred to as 'the little loungeroom' a frying pan that was upside down. The frying pan was over to the left of the deceased man's body near a heater. Senior Constable Tamblyn did not touch the frying pan. Entering the master bedroom, Senior Constable Tamblyn saw the circular sphere of an eyeball with a tube of sorts attached to the back and alerted Acting Sergeant Herbert's attention to it.Post Mortem Report (pp 179-194 PB)29.A post mortem examination conducted on the deceased on the 15th July 2020, by forensic pathologist Dr Kueppers and Dr Ong determined that the cause of death was neck and head injury in a man with atherosclerotic heart disease. The post mortem examination showed a sharp force injury to the neck, with an injury to the upper airway (larynx) and muscles at the front of the neck (strap muscles) as well as probable injury to the thyroid vessels. There was evident bilateral traumatic enucleation of the eyes. There were blunt force head injuries including facial lacerations, bruising, abrasions and nasal fracturing; and minor injuries were present to the limbs and the back of the head. There was hardening, thickening and narrowing of the vessels supplying the heart muscle (coronary atherosclerosis) with associated scarring of the heart muscle. The liver had a fatty appearance.30 .The post mortem report disclosed numerous lacerations on the front left and right side of the deceased's face and upper eyelid.31.Internal examination of the deceased man's head showed subcutaneous and soft tissue haemorrhaging at the right frontal region, subcutaneous and soft tissue haemorrhaging to the left occipital region of the scalp and a patchy soft tissue haemorrhage at the left and right temporalis muscle. 32.An examination of the deceased man's neck showed an apparently incised wound to the neck transversely oriented, the centre being present approximately 146 millimetres above the right heel as measured to the anterior midline and the wound measured approximately 180 millimetres in length with a maximum gaping width of approximately 45 millimetres with the head in a neutral position. One end of the wound located on the left side of the anterior lateral neck displayed a split dual appearance demarcated by skin tag. The other end was located to the right side of the neck. There was visible injury to the subcutaneous soft tissue and underlying anterior neck structures including thyroid cartilage. There was also visible transection of the neck musculature.33.There was an obliquely oriented gaping defect through the full thickness of the anterior aspect of the thyroid cartilage orientated in an approximate 10.00-4.00 o'clock position as viewed from the front of the neck with the body in the anatomical position measuring approximately 30 millimetres x 6 millimetres. There was a complete transection of the proximal right superior thyroid artery approximately 5 millimetres from its origin.34.Macroscopic ('naked eye') specialist neuropathologist's examination of the brain showed evidence of cerebrovascular disease including multifocal complicated atheroma of the arteries at the base of the brain and an old stroke and a border stroke distribution with a right occipital lobe. There were no macroscopic features of recent traumatic brain injury.35.There was bilateral traumatic enucleation of both eyes.Toxicological Analysis Sample of Blood of the Accused36.A toxicological analysis of the blood of the accused disclosed that the accused had .00520 milligrams/litre of tetrahydrocannabinol in his blood and a blood alcohol reading of .011%.The Accused's Electronic Record of Interview with Detective Senior Constable Lee McKnight & Detective Senior Constable Andy Smith of Tuesday the 13th July 2020 at 1.26pm37.The accused was interviewed by Detective Senior Constable Lee McKnight and Detective Senior Constable Any Smith of the Homicide Squad on Tuesday the 13th July 2020 at 1.26pm. After cautioning the accused and advising him of his rights pursuant to the Criminal Investigation Act and ensuring that he had some refreshment and clarifying that he actually wanted to answer questions, Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked the accused, 'Right, oh, Declan, mate. I'm going to ask you, talk this straight out, mate, OK. What do you know about the death of, um, Edward Thomas last night?'. The accused replied at page 12 and page 13 of the transcript, 'um, well I entered the house and he was sitting in his chair. I picked up a frying pan off the kitchen sink, walked up behind him and hit him once over the head with it and then twice and then I've grabbed him around the neck and I've put a chokehold. We were on the ground for about 30 or 40 seconds, struggling because I was trying to end his life and it got to be quite a struggle so I've used my fingers to gauge his eyes to try and take out his sight because it was, he was quite strong and after that I picked up a knife and slit his throat and held his hand, he squeezed it and he left the world. That was that'.38.The accused then elaborated, 'it was a thing where he had been getting to me for a long time. He wasn't exactly a terrible man. We never really got along or but we weren't complete enemies'. The accused continued, 'And he was just getting older and older and older, and he just kept playing, playing half of the pain is - yeah. I just went and did that'. The accused repeated, 'Yeah, he was getting older and older'.39.Detective Senior Constable McKnight clarified with the accused, 'Yep and what's the pain you speak of that you just mentioned?'. The accused replied, 'Well, it doesn't really move around anymore. He doesn't, it's not like he was years ago'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight then clarified the address that the deceased man lived at and the accused replied, 'Yeah, yeah, near, that's why I told you guys to get there, if you could get there last night and - just make sure that the body is secured and out of sight and stuff of people'.40.The accused clarified that earlier in the day he had just been watching TV having a few drinks and smoking and stated that he wasn't overly intoxicated or anything. At page 14 of the transcript and page 215 of the prosecution brief, Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked the accused, 'when you say a few drinks, can you remember what you were drinking?' and the accused replied, 'Bullet Bourbon' which he clarified was lemonade and cola. The accused replied that he had drunk about a quarter of it, a quarter of a bottle of that liquor. The accused further stated, 'wasn't much, I definitely wasn't drunk or anything'. 41.At page 15 of the transcript, being page 216 of the prosecution brief, the accused was asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Yep, um. Um, you mentioned smoking as well' and the accused replied, 'cannabis and tobacco'. The accused confirmed that he was a daily consumer of cannabis and at page 16 of the interview and page 217 of the prosecution brief, stated 'it's just one of those things that makes me feel better'. The accused also told Detective Senior Constable McKnight that he used crystal meth as well on and off. 42.At pages 16 and 17 of the transcript of the interview, being pages 217 and 218 of the prosecution brief, the accused clarified that his father did not live far from home from him and said it was getting dark and between about 7.00 or 8.00pm when he went to his father's house. The accused said he just knocked on the door and his father let him in.43.At page 18 of the transcript of the electronic record of interview and page 219 of the prosecution brief, the accused was asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'So, when did you make the decision, um, I guess to do what you've done last night to your father?' and the accused replied, 'He didn't know'. The accused then elaborated that 'It's a complicated thing. It's been going on for quite, it's been going on for years'. 44.At page 19 of the transcript, being page 220 of the prosecution brief, the accused was asked, 'Was that straight away or sort of since inside and spoke for a period of time, we watched TV together?' and the accused replied, 'Um, I think I said hello to him and that and I said hello to him and stuff and that's, um, you know, I just said hello to him, then walked from there and picked up a frying pan from the sink'. The accused told Detective Senior Constable McKnight that his father was in the reclining chair and at page 20 of the transcript of the electronic record of interview, being page 221 of the prosecution brief, the accused said that he walked up from behind his father because he didn't want him to know about it and wanted it to be as quick as possible. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Sure, um, I guess in terms of action I get it, you know, what kind of, did you swung at him and hit him in the back of the head?' and the accused replied, 'Yes' and when asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight from the side or from above, the accused replied, 'It was just a hard hit'. The accused further clarified that the first blow struck and he was still awake and it was a pretty strong blow. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight whether the deceased man said anything to him, the accused replied that he said 'Oh, Dec'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'How many times he was hit with the frying pan?', the accused replied, 'Twice, three times'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Did that cause him to go to the floor or was it a wrestle off the chair onto the floor?', the accused replied, 'Um, no, he was just, I put him in a sleeper hold'.45.The accused was then asked about what else he did to the deceased and at page 22 of the transcript, being page 223 of the prosecution brief, the accused replied, 'Cause he, we were struggling on the floor and he almost had me. Yeah, he's 70, 75. I know how old he was and he still had me. I was lucky to even win that fight' and the accused continued, 'And I took his eyes out. It wasn't something there, I was mucking around, it was just fast because I wanted to take out his eyesight and I ended with a knife'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Was that in close proximity or did you have to get back up to, to grab a knife from somewhere?'. The accused replied, 'I think I had to get up to grab it and it was running, yeah, it was pretty fast. It was fast as possible'. The accused continued, 'No fucking around' and when asked to describe the steak knife, the accused replied, 'It was a black, it was a black steak knife, the kitchen knife' and the accused clarified that it had a serrated edge. The accused said that his father was on the floor at the time and on his back. At page 24 of the transcript of the electronic record of interview, being page 225 of the prosecution brief, the accused was asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Yep, um, he's laying on his back, um, OK, so you've come over with the knife. Were you standing or kneeling?' and the accused replied, 'Um, yes. I went down, yeah, um, he was on the ground so I just, yeah, just next to him and just cut his throat, yeah, several times, several cuts'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'OK, do you remember what you did, ah, he's grabbed your hand, you've said, ah, do you remember what you did immediately afterwards?'. The accused replied, 'Um, that's where he was, that's when he was nearly dead' and continued, 'And at that time he was just lying lying back' and the accused further clarified, 'And that was his last breath, yeah'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'OK. Did so. Did you see him die?', the accused replied, 'Yes'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Yep, um, I just want to confirm with you what makes you say I guess definitely dead in your mind?', the accused replied, 'Well, he was just dead. If he was not dead then I don't know what's going on. He's not dead then he's not human. Oh, no, he would be dead?, Yes'.46.The accused was then asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Alright, and what about yourself, Declan?. Did you immediately after that, did you, what did you do?' and the accused replied, 'Um, I just, um, left there. I've picked up, I picked up my bottle, left there, just closed the door and started walking down to the police station. I had a few sips along the way, left the bottle on the ground and just kept walking and I just went to a major police station again and that was it'.47.During the balance of the interview, the accused was asked about mental health issues, his alcohol and drug consumption and issues relating to his father being in pain. Near the conclusion of the interview, at page 48 of the transcript, being page 249 of the brief, Detective Senior Constable Smith asked the accused, 'When you turned up at your dad's place, was he surprised to see you?'. The questioning continued. Detective Senior Constable Smith put to the accused, 'OK, so when he opened the door, he thinks you've just come around for a visit like you normally would?'. The accused replied, 'Yeah'. The accused was asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'What emotion were you feeling?', and the accused replied, 'Maybe I should have faced him instead of hitting from behind. I just thought it was a good thing to do. I didn't want him to see it coming'. The accused continued, 'I love him too much'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Um, what, um, what emotion, you said it wasn't range or anything like that. Did you feel any emotion last night when you go there?', and the accused replied, 'Before and after, mostly after', and continued. 'Now I have to live with that for the rest of my days'.48.The accused was then asked about comments that he made to police officers at the Mandurah Police Complex before he was taken into custody by officers of the Homicide Squad. At page 50 of the transcript of the electronic record of interview, being page 251 of the brief, the accused was asked, 'Cause we are, we were made aware of some comments that you made, to, um, the police officers but they've told us their comments. We don't, I don't know if they are exactly true or not. So I just wanted to hear from you what you can remember saying'. The accused replied, 'Oh, just cornering the mike right, like, right wing fuck wits and right, what is it, righthanded bastards or fucking I don't know what else. It's all, it's just some of it, a little bit of it is non-sensical because it's just somethings, that I just, another one, was, I just wanted fucking jellybeans and stuff. But it's just some people that would just pissing me off and I didn't like. I didn't really hate them to begin with. And it's just like, it's got nothing, it's got nothing to do with any, it's only cause I couldn't quite come up with something to just, name calling, you know, like, you're right, like, you're right, fuckwit, yeah, fucking jellybean, fucking dickhead'. When asked by Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'Do you remember what that was all?', the accused replied, 'Just them, just telling them what I did and then just being there, waiting and waiting to get here to now'.49.The accused was then asked a series of questions about the forensic examination that occurred at the house or unit that he occupied at unit 5/34 Rockford Street. At p253 of the prosecution brief, being page 52 of the transcript of the electronic record of interview, it was put to the accused that blood droplets had been located by a forensic examination of the unit going up the stairs towards the living room. The accused clarified that he lived in a two storey unit which was a little townhouse. When asked whether he was aware of any blood droplets on the stairs going up the stairs, the accused replied, 'It might have come off me'. The accused clarified that, 'When I got back, I washed my hands in the sink and washed the blood off my hands in the bottom sink'.50.Detective Senior Constable McKnight then clarified, 'OK, when will that have been?' and the accused stated, 'Um, when I got back and washed, I washed my hands in the sink and washed the blood off my hands in the bottom sink'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked, 'At your house?'. The accused replied, 'That's another thing, I didn't, that's something I forgot to mention to you'.51.Detective Senior Constable McKnight clarified with the accused, 'So, let's work back from there. So you're saying that you've washed your hands in your sink?, and the accused replied, 'Yeah'. The accused clarified that the sink is the bottom one, the silver sink where the front door is, the laundry sink'.52.Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked the accused, 'OK. Um, alright, so I'm just trying to get this clear. So you said that when you left your dad you didn't go back or you weren't going back to your house. Are you saying now that you did go back to your house after you left?' and the accused replied, 'Yes. I know, that's I thought I told you guys that, did I fail to mention it'. The accused then stated, 'Nah, I've gone back from his house to my house and to the police station'. The accused then stated in answer to a question from Detective Senior McKnight, 'Did you go anywhere else on the way?' and the accused stated, 'Yeah, I did fail to mention it cause I washed my hands in the sink there. The good thing you brought that up actually'. The accused further stated, 'I might have, I might have had a smoke or something and then going from there, I wasn't there very long, it was, I probably would have been there not very long at all, probably about 5 minutes, probably less, walking from there to the police station. I can remember sitting there on the couch now feeling it as well, it's up to 2 or 3 minutes, wasn't very long and then I just got up from there. And that's when I left. Possibly that's when I left the door open and just left it like that. I left it. I think I've left it open to the start and then I got back as well and then I left, yeah. I didn't intend on coming back at all, no'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked the accused, 'Do you say you went back for a smoke, a cigarette smoke or a?'. The accused replied, 'Well, I, that part I'm not sure. I might have had a smoke or a drink. I definitely brought my bottle with me. My, I then put it down the footpath and on the way I couldn't be bothered with it anymore. I wasn't taking it to the police station. Oh'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight then asked the accused, 'OK, so you've gone back there immediately after your dad's house, washed your hands in the .... ah, laundry sink, you've possibly gone upstairs, possibly had a smoke or a drink but, you were there roughly 5 minutes we think perhaps and then you've left from there', and the accused replied, 'Yes'.53.The accused told Detective Senior Constable McKnight, 'I've gone from my dad's to my house ... about 2-3 minutes and then from there straight to the station'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight clarified, 'Straight to the police station, OK?' and the accused replied, 'I ran, yeah, I left, yeah'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight asked the accused, 'Did you see anyone else you knew in your travels?, and the accused replied, 'From, no'.54.At page 256 of the prosecution brief, being page 55 of the transcript, Detective Senior Constable McKnight clarified with the accused, 'What happens there. What's happened there is that you've told us about in quite some detail, you've walked to your house' and the accused replied, 'Yes'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight then clarified with the accused, 'Washed your hands in the laundry sink?', and the accused replied, 'Yes', and Detective Senior Constable McKnight clarified, 'Possibly gone upstairs' and the accused replied, 'Had a smoke or drink, yes'. Detective Senior Constable McKnight then clarified, 'Left the door open or with your key in the door' and the accused replied, 'Yep', and Detective Senior Constable McKnight then clarified, 'And then you've taken your jumper off', and the accused replied, 'And then I've just taken off and left it there and kept walking'.55.After the accused left the unit at unit 5/34 Rockford Street, Mandurah, he then walked to the Mandurah Police Station.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established