CITATION: The Leasing Centre (Aust) Pty Ltd v Rollpress Proplate Group Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 282 HEARING DATE(S): 22/03/10, 23/03/10
JUDGMENT DATE :
16 April 2010JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Barrett J DECISION: 1. Upon the further amended statement of claim, judgment for the first defendant and the second defendant.
2. Upon the amended cross-claim, judgment against the plaintiff/cross-defendant and in favour of the first defendant/cross-claimant in the sum of $52,768.20 together with interest at the rates specified in Schedule 5 to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005:
(a) on $10,766.64 from 12 June 2007 to the date of judgment;
(b) on $10,553.64 from 12 July 2007 to the date of judgment;
(c) on $10,553.64 from 13 August 2007 to the date of judgment;
(d) on $10,553.64 from 12 September 2007 to the date of judgment; and
(e) on $10,553.64 from 12 October 2007 to the date of judgment.
3. Order that the plaintiff pay the costs of the first defendant and the second defendant of the proceedings.CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS - general contractual principles - construction and interpretation of contracts - where operative words of contract contain no obligation on one party - where recital states that that party "has agreed" to "rent" chattel to the other party - where second party's obligations relate to "renting" of that chattel from first party - whether, as a matter of construction, the recital contains a contractual promise of the first party - BAILMENTS - particular bailments - hire of chattel - promise by one party to "rent" chattel to other party - meaning of "rent" - held promise to hire chattel - express content of promise requires giving of possession of chattel - CONTRACTS - implied terms - express term excludes all terms that would otherwise be implied - whether requirement under agreement for hire that possession be given is an express term or an implied term - held an express term - ESTOPPEL - estoppel by convention - written statement by party to whom possession to be given that it has received possession - whether parties therefore had and proceeded on shared assumption that possession had passed - where commercial and financial circumstances were such that neither party could possibly have believed that possession had been obtained - RESTITUTION - restitution resulting from unenforceable incomplete illegal or void contracts - recovery of money paid - where several monthly payments of "rent" made but possession never obtained LEGISLATION CITED: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Part 5.3A
Registration of Interests in Goods Act 1986, s 3
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, Schedule 5CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Australian Guarantee Corporation Ltd v Ross [1983] 2 VR 319
Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon [1993] HCA 4: (1976) 176 CLR 344
Barber v NWS Bank plc [1996] 1 WLR 641
Budd-Scott v Daniell [1902] 2 KB 351
Chang Yuan Xu v Council of the Law Society of New South Wales [2009] NSWCA 430
Coggs v Bernard (1704) 2 Ld Raym 909; 92 ER…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Leasing Centre (Aust) Pty Ltd v Rollpress Proplate Group... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWSC 282
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the recital did indeed contain a contractual promise by The Leasing Centre to hire the chattel to Rollpress. The court reasoned that the promise to "rent" a chattel necessarily includes the giving of possession of that chattel. Furthermore, the court concluded that the requirement for possession to be given was an express term of the contract, as it was explicitly stated in the agreement. The court found that the parties had not shared an assumption that possession had passed, as the commercial and financial circumstances suggested otherwise.
The court also dismissed Rollpress's argument that the contract was unenforceable and therefore the payments were refundable. It held that the payments made by Rollpress were for the hire of the chattel and not refundable under the terms of the contract. The court ordered The Leasing Centre to be compensated for the unpaid hire payments, less any amounts that could be considered as restitution for the partial performance of the contract. The final orders included the recovery of money paid by Rollpress for the hire of the chattel, subject to the court's findings on restitution.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the court as an appeal from a lower court decision. The lower court had ruled in favour of the lessee, finding that the recital in the contract constituted a contractual promise by the lessor to provide possession of the equipment to the lessee. The lower court also held that the requirement for the lessor to give possession was an implied term of the contract. The lessor appealed the decision to the higher court, which reviewed the matter to determine whether the recital indeed constituted a contractual promise and whether the requirement for the lessor to give possession was an express term or an implied term of the contract.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the recital in the contract stating that the lessor "has agreed" to "rent" the equipment to the lessee constitutes a contractual promise by the lessor to provide possession of the equipment to the lessee.
2. Whether the requirement under the agreement for the lessor to give possession of the equipment to the lessee is an express term or an implied term of the contract.
3. Whether the parties had a shared assumption that possession had passed, despite the commercial and financial circumstances indicating otherwise.
4. Whether the lessee is entitled to restitution for the several monthly payments made for the rental of the equipment, given that possession was never obtained.
Held
1. The court concluded that the recital in the contract stating that the lessor "has agreed" to "rent" the equipment to the lessee constituted a contractual promise by the lessor to provide possession of the equipment to the lessee.
2. The court held that the requirement under the agreement for the lessor to give possession of the equipment to the lessee was an express term of the contract.
3. The court found that the parties did not have a shared assumption that possession had passed, despite the commercial and financial circumstances indicating otherwise.
4. The court held that the lessee was entitled to restitution for the several monthly payments made for the rental of the equipment, given that possession was never obtained.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the contract and determined that the phrase "has agreed to rent" created a contractual obligation for the lessor to provide possession of the equipment to the lessee. The court reasoned that the term "rent" in the context of the agreement required the lessor to transfer possession of the chattel to the lessee. The court distinguished this from a mere promise to negotiate or attempt to rent the equipment, finding that the lessor's obligation was to actually provide possession. This conclusion was based on the ordinary meaning of the word "rent" and the context in which it was used in the contract.
Regarding the express versus implied term issue, the court found that the requirement for the lessor to give possession of the equipment was an express term. The court reasoned that the explicit inclusion of the term in the contract excluded the implication of any other terms that might otherwise be inferred by law. The court relied on the principle that where a contract contains explicit terms, those terms define the contractual obligations and rights of the parties, and any terms not expressly stated cannot be implied.
On the issue of shared assumption under estoppel by convention, the court held that the commercial and financial circumstances of the case indicated that neither party could have reasonably believed that possession had been obtained. The court found that the written statement by the lessee indicating receipt of possession did not create a shared assumption that possession had passed. The court distinguished the present case from situations where the parties have a shared assumption that aligns with the actual facts.
In addressing the restitution claim, the court found that the lessee was entitled to restitution for the several monthly payments made for the rental of the equipment. The court reasoned that the contract was unenforceable due to the failure to provide possession, making the payments effectively void. The court applied the principle that money paid under an unenforceable contract may be recovered where the payment was made in reliance on the contractual agreement and the performance of the contract was not obtained.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a recital stating that a party "has agreed" to "rent" chattel to another party constitutes a contractual promise to provide possession, and the requirement for possession to be given is an express term of the contract. Additionally, if the parties do not share an assumption that possession has passed, despite commercial and financial circumstances indicating otherwise, the party who has paid for the rental without obtaining possession is entitled to restitution.