- I have had the advantage of reading in draft the speeches of my noble and learned friends, Lord Hobhouse of Woodborough, Lord Millett and Lord Scott of Foscote. For the reasons they give, and with which I agree, I would allow this appeal.
- I have read the speeches of my noble and learned friends, Lord Millett and Lord Scott of Foscote. For the reasons which they give I would allow the appeal and make the order which he proposes.
- This dispute has arisen from the special facts of this case, the making of an order for the sale of goods pendente lite which were the subject of financing agreements which had been contractually terminated by the goods owner.
- There is no problem about the financing agreements themselves. The appellants needed to obtain computer systems in order to operate their business. They did not wish (and maybe were not able) to finance the transaction themselves. They accordingly entered into finance agreements with the respondents. They were elaborate agreements structured so as to keep the cost to the appellants as low as possible. They took the form of hire agreements. The title to the goods remained throughout with the respondents and was not at any time nor in any circumstances to pass to the appellants or any company associated with them. The appellants had the possession of the goods but no power to sell or otherwise deal with them either during the currency of the agreements nor afterwards. This structure reflected the fact that one of the important features of the agreements was the inclusion of provisions to enable the respondents to obtain the maximum tax advantages. The appellants had a contractual right to require the respondents to sell the goods at the end of the 'primary' contract period but the appellants could only act as the negotiating agent of the respondents in relation to the sale and the sale must be at a price approved by the respondents prior to the sale. Further this right could only be exercised if the appellants had fully performed all their contractual obligations to the respondents. The benefit to the appellants was that the appellants were then entitled to receive a sum equivalent to 95% of the proceeds of sale by way of a rebate on hire previously paid. There were also default provisions of a familiar kind which gave the respondents the right to bring the agreements to an end at any stage if the appellants failed to perform their obligations. These were the forfeiture rights which the respondents exercised and from which the appellants claimed relief in the action. The purpose of claiming relief was so that the appellants could take advantage of the provisions for the sale of the goods and enjoy the benefit of the rebate.
- There is now no dispute that the agreements were of a character susceptible to relief against forfeiture; they were financing agreements and possession of the…
LORD BROWNE-WILKINSON
My Lords,
LORD HOBHOUSE OF WOODBOROUGH
My Lords,
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read On Demand Information Plc & Ors v Michael Gerson (Finance) &... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2002] UKHL 13
- Decision Date