Technology Leasing Ltd v Tony Phillips Industries P/L and Anthony Phillips

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Local Court of New South Wales


CITATION: Technology Leasing Ltd V Tony Phillips Industries P/L and Anthony Phillips [2010] NSWLC 27
JURISDICTION: Civil
PARTIES: Technology Leasing Limited
Tony Phillips Industries Pty Limited
Anthony Phillips
FILE NUMBER:
PLACE OF HEARING: Tweed Heads/Byron Bay
DATE OF DECISION: 10/15/2010
MAGISTRATE: Magistrate Dakin
CATCHWORDS: Contracts – general contractual principles – construction and interpretation of contract – rental and hire agreements – promise to rent.Bailment, contracts – implied and express terms – whether requirement under rental agreement for hire/rent that possession be given is implied or express term.Estoppel – estoppel by convention – whether written statement by party to whom possession to be given that it was arranging to take possession caused parties to proceed on shared assumption that possession had passed.Agency – whether equipment provider and finance broker agent of equipment ownerRestitution – restitution resulting from unenforceable incomplete contract – whether money paid as rent recoverable when possession never obtained
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
CASES CITED:
TEXTS CITED:
REPRESENTATION: Counsel:Mr Carter for the PlaintiffMr Simpson for the Defendants
Solicitors:Fraser Clancy Lawyers for the PlaintiffRobbins Watson Solicitors for the Defendant
ORDERS: Judgment for the first and second defendants on the Statement of Claim
Judgment for the first defendant/cross claimant on the amended First Statement of Cross Claim in the amount of $3,465.00 together with interest pursuant to the Civil Procedure Act and Uniform Civil Procedure Rules of:$495.00 from 4 July 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 4 August 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 September 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 October 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 November 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 December 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 5 January 2009 to the date of judgment.
Interest on the above amount to be calculated by the parties and failing agreement to be calculated by the Registrar.
The plaintiff is to pay the costs of the first and second defendants of the proceedings.


Reasons for Decision

Introduction

1. These proceedings arise out of a commercial transaction between the plaintiff and the first defendant involving the rental of a laptop computer and an NEC brand digital telephone system (hereinafter referred to as the equipment). The second defendant personally guaranteed the obligations of the first defendant under the terms of that agreement which was entered into by the parties at some time or times between 18 June 2008 and 3 July 2008.

Background

2. The plaintiff is a corporation providing lease finance to customers to enable the customer to acquire equipment for use in the customer’s business. It has its principal place of business in Sydney.

3. The first defendant is a corporation trading as Intone Projects. The principal business activity of the first defendant is cabinet making and shop fitting which it conducts at Burleigh Heads in Queensland.

4. The second defendant is a director of the first defendant.

5. Fresh Telecoms (hereinafter referred to as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Technology Leasing Ltd v Tony Phillips Industries P/L and An... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWLC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Technology Leasing Ltd brought an action against Tony Phillips Industries P/L and Anthony Phillips. The plaintiff alleged that the defendants failed to provide equipment as promised under a rental agreement. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary legal issues were whether the requirement under the rental agreement for possession to be given was an express or implied term, whether an estoppel by convention applied, and if the equipment provider and finance broker were agents of the equipment owner. Additionally, the court had to determine if the money paid as rent was recoverable given that possession of the equipment was never obtained.

The court examined the nature of the contract terms and found that the requirement for possession to be given was an express term. It also found that the parties did not proceed on a shared assumption that possession had passed, hence no estoppel by convention was established. The court concluded that the equipment provider and finance broker were not agents of the equipment owner. As the contract was unenforceable due to the non-delivery of the equipment, the court ruled that the money paid as rent was recoverable. The court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover the rent payments made under the contract, as the defendants did not provide the equipment as promised.

The court awarded judgment in favour of the defendants on the plaintiff's claim and in favour of the first defendant on the amended First Statement of Cross Claim, ordering the plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs. The first defendant was awarded damages in the amount of $3,465.00 plus interest from various dates in 2008 to the date of judgment, with interest to be calculated by the parties or, if necessary, by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the first and second defendants on the Statement of Claim

Judgment for the first defendant/cross claimant on the amended First Statement of Cross Claim in the amount of $3,465.00 together with interest pursuant to the Civil Procedure Act and Uniform Civil Procedure Rules of:$495.00 from 4 July 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 4 August 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 September 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 October 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 November 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 3 December 2008 to the date of judgment;$495.00 from 5 January 2009 to the date of judgment.

Interest on the above amount to be calculated by the parties and failing agreement to be calculated by the Registrar.

The plaintiff is to pay the costs of the first and second defendants of the proceedings.