The Handmade Food Co Pty Ltd v Biotech Laboratories Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

The Handmade Food Co Pty Ltd v Biotech Laboratories Pty Ltd  [2022] QCATA 47

PARTIES: THE HANDMADE FOOD CO PTY LTD

(applicant)

v

BIOTECH LABORATORIES PTY LTD

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL011-21

MATTER TYPE:

Other minor civil dispute matters

DELIVERED ON: 

13 April 2022

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Dr J R Forbes

ORDERS:

The application for leave to appeal is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL – MINOR CIVIL CLAIM – CONSUMER CLAIM AS COUNTERCLAIM – JURISDICTION – where consumer claim dismissed for want of jurisdiction – whether claim a minor civil claim within the meaning of the Act – whether laboratory a trader within the meaning of the Act – whether statutory exception applies to microbiological serves – whether services of laboratory involve a discipline not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce – where exception is deemed applicable – where application for leave dismissed

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 11, s 32, s 48, Third Schedule
Aguilar v Enalig [2014] QCATA  219
Amos v Walter [2021] QCATA 105
Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (1987) 14 FCR 215

Bradfield v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1924) 34 CLR 1

Cameron v Cole (1944) 68 CLR 571

Carr v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1944] 2 All ER 163
Currie v Commissioners of Inland Revenue [1921] 2 KB 332

Davy v Ryter Planning Pty Ltd [2010] QCATA 96
Early Property Group Pty Ltd (t/a Early Group Valuers) v Cavallaro [2010] QCATA 65

Grommen v Hawes [2018] QCATA 49

Gubier v Queensland Department of Housing and Public Works [2020] QCATA 23

Holman v Deol [1976] 1 NSWLR 640

Hope v Brisbane City Council [2013] QCA 198

Kommouna & Anor v A W & K J Reid Pty Ltd (t/a Reid Real Estate APL313 of 2017

McDonald v Kenmore Podiatry [2012] QCAT 126

Minister for Home and Territories v Teesdale Smith (1924) 45 CLR 120
Morales v Murray Lyons [2010] QCATA 87
Peng v Darley Properties Pty Ltd (t/a L J Hooker Caboolture-Morayfield APL010-21
Prestia v Aknar(1996) 40 NSWLR 165

Robbins Herbal Institute v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1923) 32 CLR 457
Social & Community Welfare Services (State) Award, Re (1984) 8 IR 364

Watkins v QBSA [2013] QCAT 535

Willoughby v Clayton Utz (No 2) (2009) 40 WAR 98
Wong v Ong [2015] QCATA 51

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction 

  1. The applicant (‘Homemade’) is a food manufacturing company. The respondent (‘Biotech’) is a biological testing laboratory accredited by the National Association of Testing Authorities (NATA).

  2. At the material time Homemade sent samples of its products to Biotech to ensure that they were fit for human consumption, and Biotech duly provided scientific reports to Handmade. All such reports were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Handmade Food Co Pty Ltd v Biotech Laboratories Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCATA 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Handmade Food Co Pty Ltd, a food manufacturer, brought a claim against Biotech Laboratories Pty Ltd, a laboratory service provider, for damages arising from Biotech's allegedly inaccurate microbiological testing services. Biotech cross-claimed for unpaid laboratory services rendered. The matter was initially heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The tribunal dismissed Handmade's claim for damages, finding it was not a minor civil dispute as defined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009. Additionally, the tribunal held Biotech was not a `trader' within the meaning of the Act because its services were in the exercise of a discipline not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce. Handmade sought leave to appeal the tribunal's decision.

The key legal issues before the court were whether Handmade's claim for damages was a minor civil claim within the meaning of the Act, whether Biotech was a `trader' under the Act, and if the statutory exception applied to Biotech's microbiological services. The court noted that the tribunal had found Handmade's claim was not a minor civil claim as it was a claim for damages, not a debt or liquidated demand. The court also found that Biotech's microbiological services were not within the field of trade or commerce, and thus Biotech was not a `trader' within the meaning of the Act. Accordingly, Handmade's claim did not fall within QCAT's jurisdiction.

The court held that the tribunal was correct in finding that Handmade's claim for damages was not a minor civil dispute and that Biotech was not a `trader' within the meaning of the Act. As such, the tribunal had no jurisdiction to hear Handmade's claim. The court dismissed Handmade's application for leave to appeal, upholding the tribunal's decision. The court found that Biotech's services involved a discipline not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce, and thus the statutory exception applied. The tribunal's decision was correct and the application for leave to appeal was properly dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for leave to appeal is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Homemade did not deny that the amount claimed by Biotech was owed. Instead it relied on a plea that the Biotech’s claim of $24,109.98 was expunged by Homemade’s claim of $24,448.18 for damages.Primary decision At the trial on 30 October 2020 the tribunal awarded Biotech $23,598.98, after deducting $520 for fees charged for the defective analyses. Effectively if not formally[11] the tribunal dismissed Handmade’s claim on jurisdictional grounds. It is against that dismissal that Handmade seeks leave to appeal.[12][11]The orders made do not formally dismiss Handmade’s claim but the reasons plainly do. [12]Application Form 39 filed 5 January 2021. Consistent with the conduct of the trial Homemade’s application for leave does not dispute the finding that Biotech is owed $23,598.98. Materially it reads:We are looking for the right to appeal so that the court can consider granting [Handmade’s] cross-claim of $24,448 ... Our counterclaim [sic] is for the amount of money that Biotech cost us as a result of our reasonable reliance on false positive reports provided.[13][13]Form 39 annexure Section 2. The Tribunal declined to make any such order for these reasons:[Your claim is] a claim for damages. It’s not a minor debt claim. So if it was going to be a claim within our jurisdiction as a minor civil dispute, it would need to be a claim arising out of a contract between a consumer and a trader or a contact between two or more traders. You’re certainly a trader. But the difficulty with the definition of trader is that there is an exemption if the person acts in a discipline that is not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce. ... There’s a long list of people who have, in the tribunal, been deemed to be outside the realm of trade and commerce.[14][14]T page 32 lines 33 ff. That statement implies two jurisdictional obstacles in Handmade’s path. First, that the claim for damages does not meet the definition of a minor civil dispute. Second, that Biotech is not a `trader’ within the meaning of the QCAT Act (`the Act”). The Tribunal is not a court of general jurisdiction; its powers of adjudication are defined in, and limited by the Act. In conferring jurisdiction to hear and decide a minor civil dispute[15] the Act materially defines that term as follows:(a) a claim to recover a debt or liquidated demand of money of up to the prescribed amount; or(b) a claim arising out of a contract between a consumer and trader, or a contract between 2 or more traders, that is—(i) for payment of money of a value not more than the prescribed amount; or(ii) for relief from payment of money of a value not more than the prescribed amount …[16] [15]QCAT Act s 11.[16]QCAT Act Schedule 3 Dictionary. Homemade’s claim is not a debt or liquidated demand; it is unliquidated in the sense that it is not fixed by prior agreement, but can be fixed (if disputed) by the decision of competent tribunal or court. Further, the Act carves out an important exception (`the exception clause’) from its concept of a ‘trader’. The artificiality of a legislative definition does not affect its validity. An entity that comes within the following exception clause is not, after all, a `trader’, and so falls outside clause (b) of the definition of `minor civil dispute’ above:[A] person is not a trader in relation to goods or services if in supplying the goods or providing the services—(a) the person acts in the exercise of a discipline that is not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce; or(b) the person is giving effect to the instructions of someone else who in providing the instructions acts in the exercise of a discipline that is not ordinarily regarded as within the field of trade or commerce, and the goods supplied or the services provided are in all respects in accordance with the instructions.[17][17]QCAT Act Schedule 3 Dictionary, definition of `trader’.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established