Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd v Morton; Morton v Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd v Morton; Morton v Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd [2023] QCA 250

PARTIES:

In Appeal No 14740 of 2022:

THALLON MOLE GROUP PTY LTD
ACN 104 671 801
(applicant)
v
LOUISE MORTON
(respondent)

In Appeal No 14793 of 2022:

LOUISE MORTON
(applicant)
v
THALLON MOLE GROUP PTY LTD
ACN 104 671 801
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 14740 of 2022
Appeal No 14793 of 2022
DC No 2695 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Civil)

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2022] QDC 224 (Muir DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

8 December 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 June 2023

JUDGES:

Bond and Boddice JJA and Kelly J

ORDERS:

In Appeal No 14740 of 2022:

1.   Leave to appeal be refused.

2.   The parties file written submissions in respect of costs limited to three pages within 14 days.

In Appeal No 14793 of 2022:

1.   Leave to appeal be refused.

2.   Leave to file the notice of contention be refused.

3.   The parties file written submissions in respect of costs limited to three pages within 14 days.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – PERFORMANCE OF WORK – where the parties entered into a residential construction contract – where, during the course of the construction, the homeowner terminated the contract for various breaches – where the construction company commenced proceedings for the recovery of outstanding progress claims under the contract, the return of retention monies and restitution on the basis of a quantum meruit – where the homeowner counter-claimed, seeking liquidated damages for delay and costs incurred for completing rectification of allegedly defective and omitted works – where, at trial, both parties succeeded on some of their claims and counter-claims respectively – where judgment was given in favour of the homeowner in the sum of $12,502.25 – where both parties seek leave to appeal the decision of the primary judge – where, before this Court, the parties advanced ten grounds of appeal across the two appeals – where those grounds of appeal relate to the primary judge’s findings with respect to the award of damages, residual labour costs and interest for certain rectification works, the construction company’s quantum meruit claim for variations to an agreed scope of works and deductions from the contract price for specified items – whether the primary judge erred in assessing the sum payable to the homeowner by reason of any of the challenged findings

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 40, s 108D

Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd v Marsden [2002] NSWCA 419, cited
Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613; [1954] HCA 36, applied
Cerutti v Crestside Pty Ltd & Anor [2016] 1 Qd R 89; [2014] QCA 33, cited
Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 85, cited
Grincelis v House (2000) 201 CLR 321;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd v Morton; Morton v Thallon Mole G... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCA 250
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd v Morton; Morton v Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd involves a dispute between a residential construction company, Thallon Mole Group Pty Ltd, and the homeowner, Mrs Morton, over a residential construction contract. The homeowner terminated the contract for various breaches, and the construction company initiated proceedings to recover outstanding progress claims, the return of retention monies, and restitution based on quantum meruit. In turn, the homeowner counter-claimed for liquidated damages for delays and costs incurred in rectifying allegedly defective and omitted works. The primary judge found in favour of the homeowner, awarding $12,502.25. Both parties sought leave to appeal the primary judge's decision, advancing ten grounds of appeal.

The legal issues in this case primarily revolve around the primary judge's assessment of damages for the homeowner's rectification work, residual labour costs, and interest for certain rectification works. Additionally, the court considered the construction company's quantum meruit claim for variations to an agreed scope of works and deductions from the contract price for specified items. The primary judge's findings concerning the necessary and reasonable cost of the homeowner's rectification work, particularly regarding the installation of the upstairs timber flooring, were central to the appeal. The construction company contested the primary judge's conclusion that the method of installation was defective and argued that the homeowner was not entitled to the costs of rectifying the alleged defects.

The court found that the primary judge was correct in her assessment of the homeowner's entitlement to the cost of rectifying the timber flooring. The contract specified that the flooring should be installed in accordance with industry standards or the manufacturer's recommendations. The evidence indicated that the flooring was not installed according to these standards, as the construction company used beaded adhesive with secret nailing instead of a full bed of flooring adhesive. The expert evidence supported the primary judge's finding that the floor was not fixed in accordance with industry standards, and there was a material risk that it would become unsuitable for its intended purpose over time. Consequently, the homeowner was entitled to have the flooring replaced and installed in accordance with the contractual requirements. The court also rejected the construction company's argument that the homeowner's focus on the gapping between floorboards was misplaced, as the consequence of the method of installation was relevant.

In Appeal No 14740 of 2022, the court refused leave to appeal and ordered the parties to file written submissions in respect of costs, limited to three pages, within 14 days. In Appeal No 14793 of 2022, the court also refused leave to appeal and leave to file the notice of contention, and similarly ordered the parties to file written submissions in respect of costs, limited to three pages, within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

In Appeal No 14740 of 2022:

1. Leave to appeal be refused.

2. The parties file written submissions in respect of costs limited to three pages within 14 days.

In Appeal No 14793 of 2022:

1. Leave to appeal be refused.

2. Leave to file the notice of contention be refused.

3. The parties file written submissions in respect of costs limited to three pages within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary judge was satisfied the rectification work carried out by Mrs Morton to the upstairs timber flooring was both necessary and reasonable, and allowed $60,281.99 (including GST) as the reasonable cost of that rectification.Consideration of submissions before this Court TMG does not challenge the primary judge’s findings concerning the way in which the floor was laid, nor the recommendations about how the floor should be laid. TMG submits that the primary judge erred by allowing the amount for the reinstallation of the timber flooring in the upstairs area of the house as the floor, as laid, was not defective. Although there was some gapping between floorboards, the expert evidence at trial was that it was inevitable that even a properly laid timber flooring would have some degree of gapping. TMG submits the primary judge was in error in focusing on whether the method of installation was defective, rather than on whether the result was defective. TMG further submits that a consideration of the evidence as a whole supports a conclusion that the primary judge was erroneous when she accepted that the gapping and cupping alleged to exist was significant. The expert evidence was that, save in one room, the gapping exhibited was within the Queensland Building and Construction Commission’s standard. Further, there was no evidence given by the expert, Mr Hilston, of having observed any significant cupping or any other defects in the floor. TMG submits the primary judge ought to have found, on a consideration of the evidence as a whole, that the method of construction adopted had resulted in an acceptable floor, free from defect in the contractual sense in all but one location. TMG submits that once that is accepted, the primary judge’s consequential finding of liability for the cost of repairing walls that were damaged as a result of removing the floor, could not be supported on the evidence. There is no substance in TMG’s submissions in respect of this ground. The contract provided for the installation of timber flooring, having regard to the best industry standards or practices or recommendations of the manufacturer as to the method of installation. The finding of the primary judge was that floorboards of the specified dimension were recommended to be installed by use of a full bed of flooring adhesive, whereas, TMG had used beaded adhesive with secret nailing. That finding was consistent with the expert evidence of Hilston, who did not resile from his opinion that the floor was not fixed in accordance with industry standards. Once it is accepted that the flooring was not laid in accordance with the contractual requirements, Mrs Morton was entitled to have the upstairs flooring replaced and installed in accordance with the contractual requirements. Further, TMG’s focus on the gapping is misplaced. TMG warranted that the timber flooring would be suitable for its intended purpose. The expert evidence was that there was a material risk that over time the floor would be subject to gapping and cupping, rendering it unsuitable for its intended purpose. To that extent, the consequence of the method of installation was relevant.