Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2) [2007] FCA 493

COMPETITION LAW – exercise of the Commission’s power to issue a Part A competition notice pursuant to s 151AKA(2) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and written notice pursuant to s 151AKA(10) of the Act – whether competition notice circular, uncertain and fails to specify matters required by s 151AKA(2) – sophisticated carrier would understand terminology used in notices – competition notice states with sufficient clarity that carrier has engaged in at least one instance of anti-competitive conduct of a kind described in the notice – s 151AKA(2) complied with – allegation that s 151AKA(10) notice uncertain, circular and does not describe a kind of anti-competitive conduct – s 151AKA(10) notice describes with sufficient clarity a kind of anti-competitive conduct – whether kind of anti-competitive conduct specified in s 151AKA(10) notice differs in substance from kind of anti-competitive conduct described in competition notice – s 151AKA(10) notice describes the kind of anti-competitive conduct by reference to Retail Customers, a “weighted average” and the bundled Retail Fixed Services Market – competition notice describes the kind of anti-competitive conduct by reference to Lower Spend Customers and supply of services by means other than a bundle – difference of substance in kind of anti-competitive conduct described – failure by the Commission to comply with s 151AKA(10) – Commission not entitled to issue Part A competition notice

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – jurisdiction – whether “decision” to issue a s 151AKA(10) notice is reviewable pursuant to the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – satisfaction of s 151AKA(10) by the Commission involves no reviewable “decision” under s 5 but is reviewable “conduct” under s 6 of the ADJR Act – also reviewable pursuant to s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act – whether Commission obliged to provide Telstra with statement of reasons pursuant to s 13 of the ADJR Act – decision to issue competition notice may result in the bringing of proceedings for the recovery of pecuniary penalties (para (f) of Sch 2 to the ADJR Act) – no obligation to provide reasons for either decision

PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS – whether s 151AKA(10) of the Act exhaustively defines the requirement of procedural fairness – obligation to accord procedural fairness at common law not displaced by s 151AKA(10) – Telstra was not given an opportunity to be heard in respect of differences of substance between the s 151AKA(10) notice and Part A competition notice – Telstra was not given an opportunity to be heard in respect of issues or material adverse to Telstra and not apparent from the Consultation Notice – seriousness of the consequences of a Part A competition notice – denial of procedural fairness

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) Pt XIB, ss 151AB, 151AJ, 151AK, 151AKA, 151AO, 151AOA, 151AOB, 151AP, 151AQ, 151AS, 151BC, 151BX, 151BY, 151CB, 151CC, 151CE
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consume... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 493
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2), the dispute centred on the validity of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's (ACCC) issuance of notices under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The notices pertained to alleged anti-competitive conduct by Telstra regarding its pricing for wholesale and retail telephone line rental services. The court was tasked with determining whether the ACCC's actions in issuing the notices were valid under the Act and whether Telstra was afforded procedural fairness and natural justice.

The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 and the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (ADJR Act). Specifically, the court had to determine whether the ACCC's decision to issue a Consultation Notice, as a precursor to a Competition Notice, was a reviewable decision under the ADJR Act. Telstra argued that the Consultation Notice was a necessary step that impacted its legal rights and obligations, thus making it a reviewable decision. Conversely, the ACCC contended that the Consultation Notice was merely a procedural step and not a substantive decision.

The court found that the issuance of the Consultation Notice was not a reviewable decision under s 5 of the ADJR Act. The court reasoned that the notice was a procedural step required under the Act to be given before issuing a Competition Notice, involving no substantive determination. The court also concluded that the conduct in issuing the Consultation Notice was not reviewable under s 6 of the ADJR Act because it was essentially procedural and not substantive. Therefore, the court held that there was no reviewable decision or conduct in issuing the Consultation Notice.

No further orders were made as the court determined that there was no valid ground for review regarding the issuance of the Consultation Notice. The parties were directed to submit proposed orders to give effect to the court's reasons within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties submit proposed orders to give effect to these reasons within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

The notices were issued in the context of certain action by Telstra in connection with charges for its wholesale and retail telephone line rental services and correspondence between Telstra and the Commission. While the notices relate to asserted anti-competitive conduct, these proceedings are not to determine whether Telstra has engaged in anti-competitive conduct. At issue is whether the Commission exercised its powers validly under the Act and accorded Telstra such procedural fairness and natural justice as the statutory context or (if applicable) the common law required. BACKGROUND The underlying subject matter of these proceedings relates to the pricing of wholesale and retail line rental packages provided by Telstra. Telstra sells access to its Public Switched Telecommunications Network (‘PSTN’) to its own retail customers and to wholesale customers who are themselves licensed carriers or carriage service providers. Access to the PSTN is a “line rental” service which enables the customer to establish a link between it and the telephone exchange. In practical terms, however, line rental by itself does not provide a functional telephone service. It is necessary to acquire some further calling service in order to make use of the telephone. The simplest form of residential package available from Telstra to retail customers is “HomeLine Part”, which is a bundle of line rental with local call services only. Customers who select the HomeLine Part plan may then pre-select the other telephony services (eg, national long distance, international and fixed-to-mobile calls) from any carrier, including carriers other than Telstra. Telstra’s wholesale customers, such as Optus, may provide such pre-selectable services as part of a package that they provide to their customers. At the wholesale level, Telstra offers a stand-alone line rental service which is not bundled with other call services. Telstra charges other carriers and carriage service providers per month for line rental services for on-sale to residential end users. This wholesale service was and is known as “Home Access”. On 28 October 2005, Telstra informed the Commission of its intention to implement and from 5 December 2005 implemented a change to its wholesale Home Access plan, increasing the monthly price by $3.10 from $24.50 (excluding GST) to $27.60 (excluding GST) (‘the Home Access increase’). The Home Access increase was announced to at least some wholesale customers on 2 November 2005. Up to 30 November 2005 the Commission did not communicate to Telstra any relevant concerns held by it about the proposed increase. On 1 December 2005, Telstra also increased the price of its HomeLine Part service, that is, the pre-selectable service it provides its retail customers, from $26.95 (including GST) to $31.95 (including GST) (‘the HomeLine Part increase). The Commission was informed of Telstra’s intention to implement that price increase by letter dated 23 September 2005. On 24 October 2005, the Commission “consented” to the HomeLine Part increase. The Commission points out that that consent, given for the purposes of the Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth) and a specific statutory instrument, involved no view as to whether the proposed conduct would contravene the “competition rule” as defined in s 151AK of the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BENNETT J
The Commission puts in issue, as a preliminary matter, whether its “decision” or conduct in issuing the Consultation Notice is reviewable by the Court. Reviewable decision or conduct? The Commission accepts that its decision to issue the Competition Notice is reviewable pursuant to s 5 of the ADJR Act and s 39B of the Judiciary Act. The Commission asserts, however, that its “decision” to issue the Consultation Notice is not so reviewable. Section 5 of the ADJR Act relevantly provides for review in this Court of a ‘decision to which [the ADJR Act] applies’ on any one or more of the grounds set out in that section. Review may also be sought in respect of conduct engaged in for ‘the purpose of making a decision to which [the ADJR Act] applies’ on the grounds prescribed in s 6. A “decision” to which the ADJR Act applies is, subject to exceptions that are not presently relevant, a decision of an administrative character made, proposed to be made, or required to be made, under an enactment or by a Commonwealth authority or an officer of the Commonwealth under an enactment (s 3(1) of the ADJR Act). A “decision” will generally, but not always, ‘entail a decision which is final or operative and determinative, at least in a practical sense, of the issue of fact falling for consideration’ (Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321 at 337 per Mason CJ, with whom Brennan and Deane JJ agreed). It will also involve a substantive determination. ‘If “decision” were to embrace procedural determinations, then there would be little scope for review of “conduct”’ as expressly contemplated by s 6 of the ADJR Act (Bond at 337). The Commission accepts that the “decision” to issue the Consultation Notice is a step taken under the Act. It submits, however, that that step is determinative of nothing (Neate v Australian Securities Commission (1995) 60 FCR 518 at 520–1); it does not confer, alter or otherwise affect legal rights or obligations, whether arising under the Act or otherwise. At most, the decision is said by the Commission to precede ‘an act (the issue of a notice under s 151AKA(10)(a)) which gives rise to a limited procedural right (to have a submission considered) and a concomitant obligation to consider it’. The Commission further submits that, in any event, Telstra did not apply for a review of the alleged “decision” to issue the Consultation Notice within time (s 11(3)(b)(iii) of the ADJR Act). Telstra submits that the decision to issue the Consultation Notice depended upon the exercise of a specific statutory power under s 151AKA(10) of the Act, which decision gave rise to a legal right to put submissions to the Commission and legal obligation on the Commission to consider those submissions. It was a prerequisite to the issue of a Competition Notice and therefore had, according to Telstra, operative effect and impacted directly on Telstra’s legal rights and obligations. Further, Telstra submits that an extension of time to review that decision should be granted as the Commission has pointed to no prejudice arising from such an extension being granted. Optus consents to an extension of time being granted. Consideration

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BENNETT J

Telstra submits that the decision to issue the Consultation Notice depended upon the exercise of a specific statutory power under s 151AKA(10) of the Act, which decision gave rise to a legal right to put submissions to the Commission and legal obligation on the Commission to consider those submissions. It was a prerequisite to the issue of a Competition Notice and therefore had, according to Telstra, operative effect and impacted directly on Telstra’s legal rights and obligations. Further, Telstra submits that an extension of time to review that decision should be granted as the Commission has pointed to no prejudice arising from such an extension being granted. Optus consents to an extension of time being granted. Consideration As Mason CJ observed in Bond, a reviewable decision for the purposes of s 5 of the ADJR Act is ‘a decision which the statute requires or authorizes rather than merely a step taken in the course of reasoning on the way to the making of the ultimate decision’ (at 336). It is the case that s 151AKA(10) of the Act requires a notice under that section to be given prior to the issue of a Part A competition notice pursuant to s 151AKA(2). However, the satisfaction of that statutory prerequisite involves no “decision” of an administrative character. In order to comply with s 151AKA(10) the Commission must, as I have noted, give a notice stating that the Commission proposes to issue a Part A competition notice (s 151AKA(10)(a)(i)), describing in summary form the kind of anti-competitive conduct proposed there to be specified (s 151AKA(10)(a)(ii)) and inviting the carrier to make a submission within the specified time limit (s 151AKA(10)(a)(iii)). The Commission must then consider any submission received within time (s 151AKA(10)(b)). The discharge of those statutory obligations involves no determination of a substantive nature. The issue of a s 151AKA(10) notice is an action taken prior to the ultimate decision to issue a Part A competition notice upon satisfaction of the “reason to believe” threshold. That action is procedural in character and involves no “decision” within the meaning of s 5 of the ADJR Act. It follows that, there being no relevant “decision”, it is unnecessary to consider whether an extension of time should be granted under the ADJR Act to review the “decision” to issue the Consultation Notice. That leaves for consideration whether the Commission’s conduct in issuing the Consultation Notice is reviewable “conduct” within s 6 of the ADJR Act. No specific time limit applies to the review of conduct. “Conduct” engaged in for the purpose of making a decision includes ‘the doing of any act or thing preparatory to the making of the decision’, including the taking of evidence or the holding of an inquiry or investigation (s 3(5) of the ADJR Act). It ‘points to action taken, rather than a decision made, for the purpose of making a reviewable decision’. Conduct is ‘essentially procedural and not substantive in character’ (Bond at 341–2).