Salim v Loh

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Salim v Loh [2005] FCA 372

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – strike out motions – complex factual case pleaded – nature of case clear – small amounts of money involved – undue expense in requiring repleading – order dispensing with pleadings – statements of facts and contentions to be filed – security for costs – related proceedings – security for costs in one proceeding where applicant out of jurisdiction – stay order in related proceeding conditioned on non-compliance with security requirement in first proceedings – directions relating to conduct of trial

Trade Practices Act 1976 (Cth) s 52, s 82
Corporations Law ss 995 and 1005

Kurniadi v Loh [2005] FCA 49 cited

IWAN SALIM v SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH, ROBERT ASHMAN, STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL, NEIL HENRY POLLARD  and OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA) LTD (In liq)
WAD9 of 2004
CHARLES LIAW and HERLINA SALIM v SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH, ROBERT ASHMAN, STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL, NEIL HENRY POLLARD  and OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA) LTD (In liq)
WAD10 OF 2004

FRENCH J
6 APRIL 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W9 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

IWAN SALIM
APPLICANT

AND:

SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH
FIRST RESPONDENT

ROBERT ASHMAN
SECOND RESPONDENT

STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL
THIRD RESPONDENT

NEIL HENRY POLLARD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA) LTD
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 APRIL 2005

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is listed for further directions on 8 April 2005 at 9.30am.

2.The parties have liberty to submit any necessary corrections to the proposed orders attached to the reasons for judgment published herewith.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W10 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

CHARLES LIAW AND HERLINA SALIM
APPLICANTS

AND:

SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH
FIRST RESPONDENT

ROBERT ASHMAN
SECOND RESPONDENT

STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL
THIRD RESPONDENT

NEIL HENRY POLLARD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA) LTD
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 APRIL 2005

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is listed for further directions on 8 April 2005 at 9.30am.

2.The parties have liberty to submit any necessary corrections to the proposed orders attached to the reasons for judgment published herewith.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W9 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

IWAN SALIM
APPLICANT

AND:

SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH
FIRST RESPONDENT

ROBERT ASHMAN
SECOND RESPONDENT

STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL
THIRD RESPONDENT

NEIL HENRY POLLARD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA) LTD
FIFTH RESPONDENT

W10 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

CHARLES LIAW and HERLINA SALIM
APPLICANTS

AND:

SIMON THUANG CHYE LOH
FIRST RESPONDENT

ROBERT ASHMAN
SECOND RESPONDENT

STEPHEN WILLIAM MARSHALL
THIRD RESPONDENT

NEIL HENRY POLLARD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

OSTRICH MEAT & MARKETING COMPANY (AUSTRALIA)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Salim v Loh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 372
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Salim v Loh, the parties involved were the Salim family, who brought claims against various respondents, including Loh, related to alleged breaches of contract and misrepresentations in a business agreement. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The legal issues before the court included whether the Salim family, as the parents, could validly pursue a claim for breach of contract when the agreement was made by their son, and whether the claims could proceed despite the son's involvement in the transaction.

The court addressed these issues by examining the nature of the claims and the roles of the parties involved. The court found that even if the parents held their interest in the agreement in trust for their son, they could still be appropriate applicants in an action for breach of contract. The court also considered the characterization of the payment made by the son and whether there was a legal liability giving rise to arguable loss on the part of the parents. The court concluded that the motion to strike out the statement of claim was not justified, and that the claims could proceed despite the complexity of the family dynamics and the son's involvement.

The court ultimately dismissed the motions to strike out the statement of claim and denied the motion for summary judgment. The costs of the motions were reserved, and further directions were given regarding the proceedings, including the joining of additional respondents and the procedures for filing contentions of fact and law. The court also made specific orders regarding security for costs, which required the applicants to provide certain financial guarantees to proceed with the litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is listed for further directions on 8 April 2005 at 9.30am.

2. The parties have liberty to submit any necessary corrections to the proposed orders attached to the reasons for judgment published herewith.

A. On each of the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents’ motions to strike out the substituted statement of claim or parts thereof:

1. The motion is dismissed.

2. The costs of the motion is in the cause.

B. On each of the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents’ motions for security for costs:

1. The applicant is to provide security for the costs of the action up to and including trial in the amount of $30,000 for each of the second, third and fourth respondents, such security to be provided by way of bank guarantee in a form approved by the Registrar or as otherwise agreed on or before 6 May 2005.

2. In the event that security is not provided as directed the proceedings are stayed from 7 May 2005 until further order.

3. The costs of the motions are reserved.

4. Out of the sum of $6,000 paid into Court pursuant to the order of McInnis FM, the sum of $700 will be paid out to the second respondent by way of its costs of the motion for security before McInnis FM.

5. The sum of $5,300 paid into Court by all applicants in the previously consolidated proceedings shall remain in Court pending the resolution of all proceedings or further order.

C. The orders made on 4 February 2005 as to the costs of the deconsolidation motion be varied so that each party bears its own costs of the motion. The order that costs thrown away are the respondents’ costs in the proceedings is not varied.

D. On the Applicant’s motion for directions:

1. The Ostrich Meat & Marketing Company (Australia) Ltd (In liquidation) be joined as fifth respondent.

2. The applications WAD9 and WAD10 of 2004 be heard concurrently with evidence in one being evidence in the other.

3. Pleadings be dispensed with.

4. The applicants’ amended substituted statement of claim is to stand as a statement of its contentions of fact and law.

5. The respondents are each to file and serve contentions of fact and law by times to be directed.

6. Evidence at the trial of the application is to be by way of affidavit and alternatively witness statements to be adopted by the witness as part of his or her evidence-in-chief.

7. Liberty to apply for further directions as to timetabling.

A. On the Second Respondents’ motion for summary judgment:

1. The motion is dismissed.

2. The costs of the motion are reserved.

B. On the Fourth Respondent’s motion to strike out parts of the substituted statement of claim:

1. The motion is dismissed.

2. The costs of the motion are in the cause.

C. On the Second and Fourth Respondents’ motions for security for costs:

1. The proceedings will be stayed on and from 7 May 2005 until further order in the event that, by that date, the applicant in WAD9 of 2004 has failed to provide the security ordered in those proceedings.

D. The order made on 4 February 2005 as to the costs of the deconsolidation motion be varied so that each party bears its own costs of the motion. The order that costs thrown away are the respondents’ costs in the proceedings is not varied.

E. On the Applicants’ motion for directions:

1. The Ostrich Meat & Marketing Company (Australia) Ltd (In liquidation) be joined as fifth respondent.

2. The applications WAD9 and WAD10 of 2004 be heard concurrently with evidence in one being evidence in the other.

3. Pleadings be dispensed with.

4. The applicants’ amended substituted statement of claim is to stand as a statement of its contentions of fact and law.

5. The respondents are each to file and serve contentions of fact and law by times to be directed.

6. Evidence at the trial of the application is to be by way of affidavit and alternatively witness statements to be adopted by the witness as part of his or her evidence-in-chief.

7. Liberty to apply for further directions as to timetabling.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
The result is that each of the motions to strike out the SSC or paragraphs thereof will be dismissed. I will make a separate direction that par 41.2 is struck out with leave to replead in terms set out in the amended SSC. The costs of each of the motions will be in the cause. I propose to make consequential directions as foreshadowed in relation to the filing of contentions of fact and law by the respondents and the use of affidavits and witness statements at trial.Summary judgment motion by second respondent in WAD10 of 2004 The second respondent moves to dismiss the applicants’ claim in WAD10 on the basis of affidavit evidence of the applicant in WAD9, filed in both WAD9 and WAD10. The applicants in WAD10 are the parents of the applicant in WAD9. There is evidence from Mr Salim, the applicant in WAD9, that he made the payment to OMM underpinning the agreement made by OMM with his parents. The proceeds, it is said, were intended to benefit Mr Salim’s nephews and nieces. This is reflected in the proposed amended SSC. Although the agreement was signed by Mr Salim’s parents it appears all profits and returns were to come to him. In the SSC for WAD10 it is pleaded that it was Mr Salim, the applicants’ son, who read the newspaper advertisement, met with Ostricom and listened to the presentation and associated representations. Then it is said that on or about 2 November 1998, he showed the applicants, his parents, the proposed agreement and conveyed to them the substance of OMM’s representations. (SSC42) According to the pleading, they then executed the agreement and paid $38,000 relying upon the representations conveyed by their son and contained in the agreement. In the proposed amended SSC for WAD10 it is alleged, in par 43, that the applicants executed the agreement in November 1998 and that their son paid OMM the sum of $38,000. Somewhat confusingly the balance of the pleading alleges that it was the applicants who paid the money. (SSC 57.5 and 73.2) It may be that, having regard to the affidavit evidence referred to by the second respondent, the claim for damages under s 82 of the Act would be difficult if not impossible to sustain. However that of itself is no answer to the breach of contract claim. Even if the parents hold their interest in the agreement in trust for their son, they can be appropriate applicants in an action for breach of contract. There also remains the question of the characterisation of the payment made by the son and whether there is a legal liability giving rise to arguable loss on the part of the parents, albeit the recovery be held in trust for their son. The amended SSC does leave the position as between the applicants and their son with respect to the payment made by him in a state of confusion. This should be clarified by further amendment. I am not satisfied, however, that this is a case in which I should dismiss the application as a whole by way of summary judgment. The second respondent’s motion will be dismissed. The costs of the motion will be reserved. Motion to strike out substituted statement of claim in WAD10 of 2004

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J