TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority [2002] FCA 896

TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LTD & ORS v AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING AUTHORITY

N 95 OF 2002

EMMETT J
SYDNEY
18 JULY 2002


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N95 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED
ACN 001 549 560
FIRST APPLICANT

QUEENSLAND TELEVISION LIMITED
ACN 009 674 373
SECOND APPLICANT

CHANNEL 9 SOUTH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING AUTHORITY
ABN 16 097 897 479
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EMMETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JULY 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. the application be dismissed; and
  1. the applicants pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N95 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED
ACN 001 549 560
FIRST APPLICANT

QUEENSLAND TELEVISION LIMITED
ACN 009 674 373
SECOND APPLICANT

CHANNEL 9 SOUTH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING AUTHORITY
ABN 16 097 897 479
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EMMETT J

DATE:

18 JULY 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicants are the licensees in respect of commercial television licences issued under the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) (“the Broadcasting Act”). On 29 November 2001, the respondent, Australian Broadcasting Authority (“the Authority”) determined that each of the applicants had breached a licence condition of its commercial television licence. By application for an order of review filed on 8 February 2002, as amended on 17 July 2002, the applicants seek orders setting aside the Authority’s decision comprising that determination and remitting the matter to the Authority for further consideration according to law.

    STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

  2. Under s 42(1) of the Broadcasting Act, each commercial television broadcasting licence issued under that Act is subject to the conditions set out in Part 3 of Schedule 2 to the Act. Clause 7(1)(a) of Schedule 2 to the Act provides as follows:

    “Each commercial television broadcasting licence is subject to the following conditions:

    (a)the licensee will not, in contravention of the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992, broadcast a tobacco advertisement within the meaning of that Act.”

    Under s 139(1) of the Broadcasting Act, it is an offence for a commercial television broadcasting licensee to breach a condition of a licence set out in clause 7(1).

  3. The Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992 (Cth) (“the TAP Act”) prohibits certain forms of tobacco advertising. In particular, ss 13(1) and 14 provide as follows:

    “13     A person must not, knowingly or recklessly, broadcast a tobacco advertisement in Australia… otherwise than as permitted by section 14…

    14       A person may broadcast a tobacco advertisement if:

    (a)the person broadcasts the advertisement as an accidental or incidental accompaniment to the broadcasting of other matter; and

    (b)the person does not receive any direct or indirect benefit (whether financial or not) for broadcasting the advertisement (in addition to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 896
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority involved TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd and the Australian Broadcasting Authority, with the dispute centering around whether certain footage broadcast by TCN constituted a tobacco advertisement under the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992 (Cth) (TAP Act). The Australian Broadcasting Authority had received complaints about an interview on the "60 Minutes" program that showed actor Russell Crowe smoking a cigarette. The Authority investigated the complaints, determined that the broadcast constituted a tobacco advertisement, and published its findings. TCN challenged this decision in court, arguing that the Authority had improperly considered irrelevant factors and made unreasonable decisions.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Authority's determination that the broadcast constituted a tobacco advertisement was lawful. TCN argued that the Authority had improperly considered factors such as potential public scrutiny and had made unreasonable decisions by reaching different conclusions about two similar broadcasts. The court needed to determine if the Authority's decision-making process was flawed and if the conclusions drawn were unreasonable.

The court found that the Authority had not improperly considered irrelevant factors such as potential adverse public scrutiny. While such considerations were mentioned in agenda papers, the Authority's reasons for its decision did not reference these factors, and the court did not find that they influenced the Authority's decision. Additionally, the court held that the Authority's conclusion that the two broadcasts differed in context was not unreasonable. Given the different contexts in which the tobacco advertisement appeared, the court found that it was not irrational for the Authority to reach different conclusions about the two broadcasts. The Authority's determination was based on a careful analysis of the law and the specific circumstances of each broadcast.

The court dismissed TCN's application, affirming the Authority's determination that the broadcast constituted a tobacco advertisement. The court ruled that the Authority had not improperly exercised its power and that its decisions were not unreasonable. As a result, the Authority's determination and publication of its findings were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. the application be dismissed; and

2.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EMMETT J
The terms “broadcast” and “tobacco advertisement” are defined in ss 8 and 9(1) respectively of the TAP Act. If program material falls within the definition of “tobacco advertisement” in s 9(1), it is a tobacco advertisement unless the material is covered by one of the exceptions set out in ss 9(1A) to 9(7) of the TAP Act. Relevantly for present purposes, s 9(7) of the TAP Act provides as follows:“9(7) If:(a)apart from this subsection, something (the advertisement) would, technically, be a tobacco advertisement; and(b)it is clear from the advertisement that its sole or principal purpose is to discourage smoking or the use of tobacco products;then, despite subsection (1), the advertisement is not a tobacco advertisement for the purposes of this Act.”THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW In October 2000, the Authority received complaints in relation to an interview contained in the “60 Minutes” program that was broadcast on 22 October 2000 by each of the applicants. The complaints were to the effect that the interview contained a tobacco advertisement in so far as it showed the actor Russell Crowe displaying a Marlboro cigarette packet while lighting and smoking a cigarette. Subsequently, the Authority received a complaint concerning the broadcast of the same footage during the following week’s “60 Minutes” program broadcast on 29 October 2000. Under s 149(1) of the Broadcasting Act, the Authority must investigate a complaint made to it about an alleged breach of a condition of a licence, unless the Authority is satisfied that the complaint is frivolous, or vexatious or was not made in good faith, or, relevantly, that complaint does not relate to a breach of a condition. Under s 178(1) of the Broadcasting Act, the Authority may prepare a report on an investigation. Under s 179(1) the Authority may cause a copy of a report on an investigation to be published. The Authority investigated the complaints in accordance with s 149 of the Broadcasting Act and, on 29 November 2001, the Authority made a determination and published its reasons for its determination. The determination was made by the Chairman of the Authority, as the delegate of the Authority.THE PROGRESS OF THE INVESTIGATION Following receipt of the complaints, the Authority sought comment from the applicants, which was provided in December 2000. Shortly afterwards, the Authority sought comment in relation to the 29 October 2000 broadcast and comment in relation to that broadcast was also provided by the applicants in December 2000. In July 2001, staff of the Authority prepared a preliminary investigation summary, which was discussed at a meeting of the Authority’s Policy and Content Regulation Committee on 2 August 2001. The Committee adopted the conclusions of the preliminary investigation summary, including a conclusion that neither of the broadcasts was permitted by s 14 of the TAP Act. Further comment was sought from the applicants in relation to the preliminary investigation report and, during September 2001, detailed submissions by solicitors advising the applicants were furnished to the Authority.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EMMETT J

I consider that, on a fair reading of the Authority’s reasons as a whole, the observations made by the Authority refer to the “Mailbag” segment in the narrower sense just described. I consider that the Authority did no more than make a finding of fact on the question of whether or not the sole or principal purpose of the segment was to discourage smoking. I do not consider that the Authority misdirected itself as to the correct construction of s 9(7) of the TAP Act.IMPROPER EXERCISE OF POWER – IRRELEVANT CONSIDERATION The applicants contend that, in making its determination, the Authority took into account an irrelevant consideration, namely the consideration that “a non-breach decision may attract adverse public scrutiny” or that “a non-breach decision may attract adverse public comment” as set out in the agenda papers for the meetings held on 25 October 2001 and 8 October 2001 respectively. The chairman of the Authority, who made the decision as its delegate, was present at both of those meetings. I was invited to draw an inference that a concern about adverse publicity was taken into account by the Authority simply because Authority staff drew the attention of the members of the Authority to that consideration on two occasions in the course of deliberations. However, there is no reference in the Authority’s reasons to the possibility of adverse public scrutiny or adverse public comment. The reasons run to some twenty-six pages of analysis of the law and consideration of the tobacco advertisement and other material. I do not consider that such an inference is warranted. The only inference that I would draw from the inclusion of the references in the agenda papers is that the matter should be dealt with carefully and with due deliberation. I would not draw the inference that the decision maker had regard to the possibility of adverse public scrutiny or comment as a reason for making the determination of 29 November 2001.IMPROPER EXERCISE OF POWER – UNREASONABLENESS The applicants contend that it was irrational for the Authority to find that the relevant footage was an incidental accompaniment to other matter broadcast on 22 October 2000 yet reach the opposite conclusion in respect of the broadcast of 29 October 2000. However, the context in which the tobacco advertisement appeared on 22 October 2000 was quite different from the context in which it appeared on 29 October 2000. I do not consider that this basis is one that would justify a conclusion that no reasonable person could have reached different conclusions in respect of the two broadcasts. Additionally, the applicants contend that no reasonable decision maker could have concluded that the tobacco advertisement was not broadcast as an incidental accompaniment to the broadcasting of the sentiments expressed in the viewers’ letters. This contention is really a reiteration of the arguments advanced in relation to s 14. Reaching an erroneous conclusion is not reaching a conclusion that is so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have made the decision. It may be, as I have said, that if I were in the shoes of the Authority I would have reached a different conclusion. That, however, is irrelevant. I do not consider that this ground is made out.CONCLUSION