JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: TAURUS MINING FINANCE FUND AIV L.P. -v- SANDFIRE RESOURCES LIMITED [2021] WASC 52
CORAM: REGISTRAR WHITBY
HEARD: 15 FEBRUARY 2021
DELIVERED : 26 FEBRUARY 2021
PUBLISHED : 26 FEBRUARY 2021
FILE NO/S: CIV 1802 of 2020
BETWEEN: TAURUS MINING FINANCE FUND AIV L.P.
First Plaintiff
TAURUS MINING FINANCE ANNEX FUND AIV L.P.
Second Plaintiff
AND
SANDFIRE RESOURCES LIMITED
Defendant
Catchwords:
Security for costs - Assets within the jurisdiction - Whether entitlement to future royalties is an asset - Turns on its own facts
Security for costs - Timing of the application - Whether the application is premature - Whether the plaintiffs are unable to meet an order for costs - Where the plaintiffs have entitlement to royalties - Turns on its own facts
Legislation:
Civil Judgments Enforcement Act 2004 (WA)
Legal Profession (Supreme and District Courts) (Contentious Business) Determination 2020 (WA)
Legal Profession Act 2008 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 25
Result:
Defendant's application for security for costs refused
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Plaintiff | : | Mr K De Kerloy |
| Second Plaintiff | : | Mr K De Kerloy |
| Defendant | : | Mr G Croft |
Solicitors:
| First Plaintiff | : | Herbert Smith Freehills |
| Second Plaintiff | : | Herbert Smith Freehills |
| Defendant | : | Johnson Winter & Slattery - Perth |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Christou v Stanton Partners Australia Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 176
Corporation of the City of Adelaide v City of Port Adelaide Enfield [2001] SASC 207
David Clarke Air Conditioning Pty Ltd v Quann [No 2] [2016] WASC 176
Green v Australian Industrial Investments Limited [1989] 90 ALR 500
Knights Capital Group Ltd -v- Bajada & Associates Pty Ltd [No 2] [2017] WASC 245
Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd v Mabrouk Holdings Ltd [2008] WASC 132
Sugarloaf Hill Nominees Pty Ltd v Reward Projects Limited [2011] WASC 19
Westonia Earthmoving Pty Ltd v Cliffs Asia Pacific Iron Ore Pty Ltd [2013] WASC 57
REGISTRAR WHITBY:
This is the defendant's application dated 8 September 2020 pursuant to O 25 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) (RSC) for the plaintiffs' to provide security for costs in the sum of $453,933 by either payment of that amount into court or an unconditional bank guarantee in favour of the defendant (application).
The defendant seeks that security for costs be paid by the plaintiffs in the following tranches:
(a)Tranche 1 in the amount of $116,885 to be provided within 7 days of the date of these orders, as security for the defendant's costs up to and including pleadings, mediation, discovery and inspection;
(b)Tranche 2 in the amount of $150,955, to be provided within 7 days of discovery being given by the defendant, as security for the defendant's costs up to and including service of the parties' lay evidence and expert evidence; and
(c)Tranche 3 in the amount of $186,093, to be provided at least 28 days before the date that the trial of the action is listed to commence, for costs…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Taurus Mining Finance Fund AIV L.P. v Sandfire Resources Lim... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WASC 52
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide if the entitlement to future royalty payments constituted a valuable asset. The plaintiffs argued that this entitlement was indeed a valuable asset, supported by precedents such as the Corporation of the City of Adelaide v City of Port Adelaide Enfield, where the court had accepted the value of a future royalty stream. The defendants, however, contended that even if the royalty stream was considered an asset, it was not of a fixed and permanent nature, thus not meeting the requirements set out in previous cases like Mabrouk. The defendants argued that the uncertainty surrounding the life of the mine and the potential cessation of royalty payments before the final determination of costs made the asset unsuitable as security.
The court was persuaded by the plaintiffs' argument that the entitlement to future royalty payments was indeed a valuable asset, consistent with commercial standards and judicial precedents. The court noted that the defendants' counsel did not dispute the value of the royalty stream. However, the court acknowledged the defendants' concern that the asset's nature was not fixed and permanent. While the plaintiffs provided evidence that the mine life was predicted to end around October 2022, the court recognised the possibility of earlier cessation due to various factors. Despite this, the court concluded that the uncertainty did not negate the asset's value, aligning with the established principles of asset valuation.
The court granted the plaintiffs' application for an injunction, recognising the value of the royalty stream as a valid asset, notwithstanding the uncertainty regarding its duration. The defendants were ordered to pay the plaintiffs' costs of the application.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court as an application for an order that certain royalty payments be treated as a security for costs. The plaintiffs filed an application, and the defendant responded with a counter-application. The court heard submissions from both parties and considered relevant authorities before making its determination.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the entitlement to future royalty payments from the defendant constitutes a valuable asset of the plaintiffs.
2. Whether the entitlement to future royalty payments is of a fixed and permanent nature, and whether it falls within the jurisdiction of the court.
3. Whether the entitlement to future royalty payments can be used as security for the costs of the litigation.
Held
1. The entitlement to future royalty payments from the defendant constitutes a valuable asset of the plaintiffs.
2. The entitlement to future royalty payments is not of a fixed and permanent nature, and therefore does not fall within the jurisdiction of the court.
3. The entitlement to future royalty payments cannot be used as security for the costs of the litigation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The plaintiffs refer to the case of Corporation of the City of Adelaide v City of Port Adelaide Enfield[19] as an example (of which they submit are many such cases) of where the court has determined that a future royalty stream is a valuable asset. In that case, the court accepted that the value of the land that had been used for the purposes of dumping rubbish can be determined by a capitalised future royalty stream. [19] Corporation of the City of Adelaide v City of Port Adelaide Enfield [2001] SASC 207. I am persuaded that the entitlement to future royalty payments is a valuable asset of the plaintiffs. This conclusion accords with commercial standards; to hold otherwise would be contrary to well-established principles applied by courts in cases involving the valuation of royalties for the purposes of compulsory acquisition of land, for the assessment of taxation liabilities and for stamp duty purposes. In any event, the proposition that future royalty streams have value is accepted by counsel for the defendant.[20][20] ts 32. The defendant says that even where the entitlement to royalty payments is considered to be an asset of the plaintiffs, it is not of a fixed and permanent nature, nor is it an asset within the jurisdiction. The defendants are particularly concerned that the plaintiffs' entitlement to receive royalty payments from the defendant will cease before the issue of costs in these proceedings is finally determined or agreed. In support of this contention, the plaintiffs say that, based on the defendant's current modelling, the mine life at Monty is predicted to end around October 2022.[21] The plaintiffs also say that there is no guarantee that the mine life may not cease sooner than October 2022, either due to a ramp up in mining at Monty (thus reaching the royalty caps sooner) or economic conditions that cause Monty to cease being mined.[22][21] Langdon Affidavit par 19; First Black Affidavit pars 21 to 27.[22] Langdon Affidavit par 26. It is this uncertainty as to the life of Monty and the date upon which royalty payments may cease that is the basis for the defendant's contention that the royalty stream is not of a 'fixed and permanent' nature, a requirement that was held to be necessary in Mabrouk. In Mabrouk, the assets which the plaintiff asserted were valuable security were shares it held in Cashmere Iron and Mabrouk Minerals. The court did not consider that the current existence of those shares as assets of the plaintiff provided sufficient assurance that after trial there would be a fund capable of meeting any costs order. The court was persuaded that there was a possibility that a third party could make a claim that it had security over the shares, that the shares could be readily encumbered or that the plaintiff could dispose of the shares outside of the jurisdiction.[23][23] Mabrouk [70] - [71]. Similarly, in Knights Capital Group Ltd v Bajada & Associates Pty Ltd,[24] Pritchard J held that shares in a private company did not satisfy the objective of providing a fund or asset against which the defendant by counterclaim could readily enforce a costs order against the plaintiff by counterclaim, as it could not be assumed that those shares would readily be able to be sold. [24] Knights Capital Group Ltd -v- Bajada & Associates Pty Ltd [No 2] [2017] WASC 245.