Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd v Mabrouk Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   MABROUK MINERALS PTY LTD -v- MABROUK HOLDINGS LTD [2008] WASC 132

CORAM:   NEWNES J

HEARD:   22 MAY 2008

DELIVERED          :   8 JULY 2008

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1628 of 2006

BETWEEN:   MABROUK MINERALS PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

MABROUK HOLDINGS LTD
First Defendant

DIRECTOR GENERAL OF MINES
Second Defendant

(BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

MABROUK HOLDINGS LTD
Plaintiff by counterclaim

MABROUK MINERALS PTY LTD
First Defendant by counterclaim

DAVID KENNETH HENDRIE
Second Defendant by counterclaim

ANDREW RONALD MASTER
Third Defendant counterclaim

LESLIE JOHN STARKEY
Fourth Defendant by counterclaim

JOHN WILDER
Fifth Defendant by counterclaim

MACPHERSON NOMINEES PTY LTD
Sixth Defendant by counterclaim

CASHMERE IRON PTY LTD
Seventh Defendant by counterclaim

(BY COUNTERCLAIM)
 

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Security for costs - Party outside the jurisdiction - Relevant principles - Whether party has assets within jurisdiction capable of meeting order for costs - Relevance of nature of assets in the jurisdiction - Security for costs sought against counterclaimant - Whether counterclaim defensive in nature - Whether security will be ordered where claimant responding to attack - Whether counterclaimant forced to sue by self-help remedy employed by defendant to counterclaim

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 25 r 2

Result:

Security for costs ordered

Category:    B

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr R A S Rowick

First Defendant             :     Mr N D C Dillon

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Dean & Rowick

First Defendant             :     Minter Ellison

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Counterclaim

Counsel:

Plaintiff by counterclaim                 :      Mr N D C Dillon

First Defendant by counterclaim     :      Mr R A S Rowick

Second Defendant by counterclaim  :      Mr A Metaxas

Third Defendant counterclaim     :      Mr A Metaxas

Sixth Defendant by counterclaim     :      Mr A Metaxas

Fourth Defendant by counterclaim   :      Mr A Metaxas

Fifth Defendant by counterclaim     :      Mr A Metaxas

Seventh Defendant by counterclaim :      Mr S Penglis

Solicitors:

Plaintiff by counterclaim                 :      Minter Ellison

First Defendant by counterclaim     :      Dean & Rowick

Second Defendant by counterclaim  :      Metaxas & Hager

Third Defendant counterclaim     :      Metaxas & Hager

Sixth Defendant by counterclaim     :      Metaxas & Hager

Fourth Defendant by counterclaim   :      Metaxas & Hager

Fifth Defendant by counterclaim     :      Metaxas & Hager

Seventh Defendant by counterclaim :      Freehills

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Berkeley Administration Inc v McClelland [1990] 1 All ER 958

Buckley v Bennell Design & Constructions Pty Ltd (1974) 1 ACLR 301

Classic Ceramic Importers Pty Ltd v Ceramica Antiga SA (1994) 13 ACSR 263

D S Parklane Developments Pty Ltd v Korea First Finance Ltd (Unreported, NSWSC, 20 August 1997)

De Bry v Fitzgerald [1990] 1 All ER 560

Ebrard v Gassier (1884) 28 Ch D 232

Energy Drilling Inc v Petroz NL [1989] ATPR 50,418

Heller Factors Pty Ltd v John Arnold's Surf Shop Pty Ltd (1979) 22 SASR 20

Interwest Ltd v Tricontinental Corporation Ltd (1991) 9 ACLC 1218

Maatschappij Voor Fondsenbezit v Shell Transport and Trading Co [1923] 2 KB 166

Neck v Taylor…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd v Mabrouk Holdings Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASC 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd was the plaintiff and Mabrouk Holdings Ltd was the defendant in this case before the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute concerned an application for security for costs made by the defendant, Mabrouk Holdings Ltd, against the plaintiff, Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd. The plaintiff, Mabrouk Minerals Pty Ltd, had filed a claim against the defendant, Mabrouk Holdings Ltd, and the defendant had filed a counterclaim against the plaintiff. The defendant sought security for costs against the plaintiff on the basis that the plaintiff was ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction, and had no assets within the jurisdiction. The court had to determine whether the defendant was entitled to security for costs against the plaintiff.

The court considered the legal principles that apply to an application for security for costs against a party ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction. The court noted that while residence out of the jurisdiction is a ground upon which an application for security for costs may be granted, it is not a sufficient ground for making an order. The court had to consider whether the plaintiff had assets within the jurisdiction that could be used to meet an order for costs if the plaintiff was unsuccessful at trial. The court also considered whether the counterclaim filed by the defendant was defensive in nature, and whether the plaintiff was forced to sue by the self-help remedy employed by the defendant in filing the counterclaim.

The court held that the plaintiff was ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction, and had no assets within the jurisdiction. However, the court found that the counterclaim filed by the defendant was not defensive in nature, but was a separate and distinct claim. The court noted that the plaintiff was not forced to sue by the self-help remedy employed by the defendant in filing the counterclaim, as the plaintiff had brought the action in response to an attack by the defendant. The court held that the defendant was not entitled to security for costs against the plaintiff.

Security for costs was not ordered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Security for costs ordered

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The fact that a plaintiff is ordinarily resident out of the jurisdiction is a ground upon which an application for security for costs may be granted: O 25 r 2(a). The basis of the rule in O 25 r 2(a) is the risk that either an order for costs is likely to be unenforceable or that it will be enforceable only by a significant expenditure of time and money: Berkeley Administration Inc v McClelland [1990] 1 All ER 958, 963. But while residence out of the jurisdiction enlivens the court's jurisdiction, it is not of itself a sufficient ground for making an order. Whether or not an order will be made will depend upon the circumstances of the case. In Energy Drilling Inc v Petroz NL [1989] ATPR 50,418, Gummow J put the position as follows:The purpose of ordering security for costs against an applicant ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction is to ensure that a successful respondent will have a fund available within the jurisdiction of this Court against which it can enforce the judgment for costs, so that the respondent does not bear the risk as to the certainty of enforcement in the foreign country and as to the time and complexity of the action there which might be necessary to effect enforcement: Kent Heating Ltd v Cook‑on‑Gas Products Pty Ltd (1984) 59 ALR 277 at 279. On the other hand, the mere circumstance that an applicant is resident outside the jurisdiction does not necessarily invite an exercise of discretion in favour of ordering security, the question being how justice will best be served in the particular case. [50,422] Where a party resident out of the jurisdiction has no assets within the jurisdiction, that will usually be a factor weighing heavily in favour of an order for security. In PS Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co, McHugh J said:… the fact that a party, bringing proceedings, is resident out of the jurisdiction and has no assets within the jurisdiction has been seen as a circumstance of great weight in determining whether an order for security for costs should be made. Indeed, for many years the practice has been to order such a party to provide security for costs unless that party can point to other circumstances which overcome the weight of the circumstance that that person is resident out of and has no assets within the jurisdiction. (323) But it will generally not be appropriate to order security if the court is satisfied that the plaintiff has assets within the jurisdiction which will remain available to meet the defendant's costs if the plaintiff is unsuccessful at trial. In determining whether the plaintiff has such assets, it may be relevant to consider the value and the nature of the assets, including whether they are of a fixed and permanent nature: Ebrard v Gassier (1884) 28 Ch D 232, 235; or whether the court can ensure that the assets will not be dissipated: De Bry v Fitzgerald [1990] 1 All ER 560, 563. Order 25 r 4 expressly provides that an order for security may be made against a defendant who counterclaims in respect of a claim not arising out of the claim against him. I respectfully agree, however, with the learned authors of Civil Procedure Western Australia [25.4.1] that the rule does not limit the court's discretion to deal with a wide range of circumstances in which defendants are in substance plaintiffs. On an application for security for costs, what is relevant is not how the parties appear on the court record, but whether the counterclaim is in substance in the nature of a defence to the plaintiff's claim or whether it is a separate and distinct claim: Neck v Taylor [1893] 1 QB 560, 562, 563; New Fenix Compagnie Anonyme d'Assurances de Madrid v General Accident Fire & Life Assurance Corporation Ltd [1911] 2 KB 619, 625 ‑ 626; see Buckley v Bennell Design & Constructions Pty Ltd (1974) 1 ACLR 301, 307. The question of whether a counterclaim is defensive or offensive in nature should be considered in a realistic commercial sense: see Classic Ceramic Importers Pty Ltd v Ceramica Antiga SA (1994) 13 ACSR 263, 266; D S Parklane Developments Pty Ltd v Korea First Finance Ltd (Unreported, NSWSC, 20 August 1997).