Tablelands Regional Council v Minister for Local Government

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Tablelands Regional Council v Minister for Local Government [2016] QSC 88

PARTIES:

TABLELANDS REGIONAL COUNCIL

(Applicant)

v
THE HONOURABLE JACKIE TRAD MP, MINISTER FOR INFRASTRUCTURE, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PLANNING

(First Respondent)
and
MAREEBA SHIRE COUNCIL
(Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 226 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

22 April 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

14-15 December 2015

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDER:

1.   Application dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 11 May 2016, unless the parties notify the court in the meantime that costs are agreed.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – GENERALLY - where the Tablelands Regional Council de-amalgamated and was replaced by two new local governments – where a dispute arose over the division between the two new councils of the former council’s cash balance – where  a comprehensive process to determine the final cash split was undertaken – where the dispute was referred to and decided by the  Minister under Local Government (De-amalgamation Implementation) Regulation 2013 (Qld) – where the applicant makes application for statutory review of the Minister’s decision pursuant to s 20 Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld) – where the applicant alleges there was no evidence or other material to justify the making of the decision – where the applicant alleges the decision was an improper exercise of power because of Wednesbury unreasonableness or because the Minister failed to take into account a relevant consideration – whether  even if the Minister did err it would be inappropriate to grant the application

LOCAL GOVERNMENT - REGULATION AND ADMINISTRATION - CONSTITUTION, AREA AND BOUNDARIES - REARRANGEMENT OF EXISTING AREAS - CONSEQUENCES OF REARRANGEMENT - ON ASSETS AND LIABILITIES – where the Tablelands Regional Council de-amalgamated and was replaced by two new local governments – where a dispute arose over the division between the two new councils of the former council’s cash balance – where in the first instance the dispute was determined by the Minister under Local Government (De-amalgamation Implementation) Regulation 2013 (Qld) – where the applicant makes application for statutory review of the Minister’s decision pursuant to s 20 Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld) – whether the Minister erred in her decision

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) s 35C(1)

Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld) s 20, s 24, s 32, s 48

Local Government (De-amalgamation Implementation) Regulation 2013 (Qld) s 3, s 5, s 12, s 18, s 20, s 21, s 24, s 26, s 27, s 30

Associated Provincial Picture House Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223, cited
Curragh Qld Mining Ltd v Daniel (1992) 34 FCR 212, cited
Intero Hospitality Projects P/L v Empire Interior (Australia) P/L & Anor [2008] QCA 83, cited
Kostas v HIA Insurance Services P/L(2010) 241 CLR 390, distinguished
McLean v Gilliver [1995] 1 Qd R 637, cited
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tablelands Regional Council v Minister for Local Government and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Tablelands Regional Council (TRC) sought a review of the Minister for Local Government’s decision concerning the division of cash balance between TRC and the Mareeba Shire Council (MSC) after the de-amalgamation of TRC. The dispute was referred to and decided by the Minister under the Local Government (De-amalgamation Implementation) Regulation 2013 (Qld). TRC applied for statutory review of the Minister’s decision pursuant to s 20 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), alleging that the Minister’s decision was not supported by evidence and was Wednesbury unreasonable. The court had to determine whether the Minister erred in her decision, and if so, whether it was appropriate to grant the application for review.

The court found that the Minister’s decision was based on the independent consultant’s report which determined the allocation of the cash balance between TRC and MSC. The Minister considered the consultant’s report and found it to be comprehensive and reliable. The court agreed with the Minister that the evidence provided by TRC did not conclusively demonstrate that the consultant had misstated TRC’s fair allocation of cash at de-amalgamation. The court also found that the Minister had not failed to take into account any relevant consideration. Therefore, the court held that the Minister did not err in her decision.

The court further held that even if the Minister had erred, it would be inappropriate to grant the application for review. The court noted that the Minister’s decision was based on a comprehensive process undertaken by the independent consultant, and that TRC’s concerns were misconceived. The court also noted that the Minister had taken into account a genuine error identified by the consultant and had adjusted the cash allocation accordingly. The court held that the Minister’s decision was not Wednesbury unreasonable and was therefore not liable to be quashed.

The court dismissed TRC’s application and ordered that the parties be heard as to costs at a later date, unless the parties notified the court in the meantime that costs were agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 11 May 2016, unless the parties notify the court in the meantime that costs are agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case the “matter mentioned in s 27” which the committee was unable to make a decision about and which the Minister therefore had to decide was a matter mentioned in s 27(a), that is, deciding the assets and liabilities to be transferred to the new local government.BackgroundThe Transfer Committee The transfer committee for TRC and MSC met from time to time from around 24 May 2013 until its final meeting on 26 September 2014. Mr Ian Church, the chief executive officer of TRC, represented TRC on the transfer committee throughout that period. Mr Peter Franks, the CEO of MSC, represented MSC to 3 February 2014 and Mr Rod Ferguson, the transfer manager and later acting CEO of MSC, represented it after that time.[13][13] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden [17]-[18].Methodology The transfer committee was obliged by s 23 of the regulation to “take all reasonable steps to comply with the transfer methodology” published by the department’s chief executive. The published de-amalgamation transfer methodology provided, inter alia, that:“The transfer committee must decide the split of assets and liabilities between the continuing and new council to determine the opening balance sheet position of the new council.”[14][14] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden Ex LP1, pt 6.1 p 16 (page numbers cited in this judgment are the deponents’ paginations). The methodology went on to explain that the Queensland Boundaries Commissioner’s de-amalgamation report had included a financial analysis prepared by the Queensland Treasury Corporation (“QTC”) which included opening balance sheet positions as at 1 July 2012 based on the actual financial position of each council at amalgamation in 2008 along with a break-up by new and continuing council area from 16 March 2008 to 30 June 2012. Because of the significant effort and cost involved in reaching that position the methodology recommended that the transfer committee give consideration to using the QTC analysis to determine a starting position for the break-up of cash and debt. At its meeting on 21 June 2013 the transfer committee decided against using QTC’s analysis and resolved to engage an independent consultant on the premise that the outcome of the process resolved by the transfer committee would “result in a more technically correct and independently assessed apportionment of debt, cash and reserve balance components of the balance sheet to be transferred”.[15] The minutes relevantly record:“DecisionThat the transfer committee:- …D. Engage an independent consultation reporting to the transfer committee to determine the debt, cash and reserve balance components of the balance sheet to be transferred from the continuing Tablelands Regional Council to the new Mareeba Shire Council and that such engagement be in accordance with the Scope of Works and process set out in Appendix 1.E. Note that following the completion of this independent expert report to the transfer committee:-a.the continuing Tablelands Regional Council will have that report independently reviewed by its internal auditors on behalf of the Tablelands Regional Council;b.the Transfer Manager will have that report independently reviewed by an independent financial consultant on behalf of the future Mareeba Shire Council …”[15] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden Ex LP2 p 30.Crowe Horwath Engaged

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Minister provided her reasons by correspondence of 13 May 2015. After dealing with introductory matters the Minister stated her reasons:“My detailed reasons regarding the matter in dispute are as follows:· Section 27(a) of the Regulation specifically provided that a key function of the Transfer Committee was to decide the assets and liabilities (including this disputed cash amount) that were to be transferred to the new MSC.· It was a legitimate decision of the Transfer Committee that independent consultants CH be engaged to determine the apportionment of the TRC balance sheet items between the continuing TRC and new MSC. TRC and MSC (as minuted by the Transfer Committee) agreed to the engagement of CH to determine the final allocation of cash between the two councils as at 30 June 2013 (interim report) and 31 December 2013 (final report).· I am advised that information provided indicates that this assignment was carried out in accordance with agreed methodologies and there is evidence of continued consultations between the Transfer Committee, council staff and CH throughout the project.· CH’s final report determined that the allocation should be $27.5M (53 per cent) to TRC and $24.6M to MSC (47 per cent). The final report included a reconciliation of changes in the cash allocation from the interim report. The reconciliation noted an adjustment of $5.5M for a re-allocation increase in Plant, Property and Equipment (PP&E) from TRC to MSC, which forms the basis of the Transfer Committee dispute.· I am advised that TRC’s submission did not accept the adjustment, arguing that it had been calculated using incorrect methodologies and on the basis of incomplete 2008/09 asset data. CH advised that this value actually represented the net adjustment made as asset location and ownership details were firmed up between the interim and final reports. I understand that CH also advised that the 2008/09 asset register was not taken into account as the register’s asset numbering and classification system changed significantly between 2008/09 and 2009/10, which made accurate reconciliation between the two years impossible.· MSC’s submission and further correspondence supported the CH view that the 2008/09 asset data was unreliable and unable to be used during the engagement.· I am advised that CH has undertaken a comprehensive process to determine the split of the balance sheet items and calculation of the final cash split, including the split of PP&E assets. I do not consider that the TRC’s submission provides sufficient information to conclusively demonstrate that CH has misstated TRC’s fair allocation of cash at de-amalgamation.· On 26 November 2014, CH advised the Transfer Committee members that it believed that an error was found to have been included in the final report and determination. Correction of the error ($1,469,082) would decrease TRC’s allocation to $26,024,048 (50 per cent) and increase MSC’s to $26,053,002 (50 per cent). CH advised the Department that the error had been previously identified, agreed and adjusted during their engagement but had [not] been included in the final report due to genuine human error.Given that this is a genuine error, relating to information previously identified and corrected during the engagement, and that CH itself agrees that the adjustment was overlooked in error, this adjustment has been taken into consideration in making my final decision. No other material errors or omissions have been identified subsequent to the delivery of the CH report.”Evidence on the review reveals TRC’s concerns were misconceivedEvidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

At its meeting on 21 June 2013 the transfer committee decided against using QTC’s analysis and resolved to engage an independent consultant on the premise that the outcome of the process resolved by the transfer committee would “result in a more technically correct and independently assessed apportionment of debt, cash and reserve balance components of the balance sheet to be transferred”.[15] The minutes relevantly record:“DecisionThat the transfer committee:- …D. Engage an independent consultation reporting to the transfer committee to determine the debt, cash and reserve balance components of the balance sheet to be transferred from the continuing Tablelands Regional Council to the new Mareeba Shire Council and that such engagement be in accordance with the Scope of Works and process set out in Appendix 1.E. Note that following the completion of this independent expert report to the transfer committee:-a.the continuing Tablelands Regional Council will have that report independently reviewed by its internal auditors on behalf of the Tablelands Regional Council;b.the Transfer Manager will have that report independently reviewed by an independent financial consultant on behalf of the future Mareeba Shire Council …”[15] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden Ex LP2 p 30.Crowe Horwath Engaged On 16 July 2013 the transfer committee decided to engage accountancy firm WHK, which thereafter became known as Crowe Horwath (“CH”), as the independent consultant. The Interim Report On about 24 January 2014 CH published its interim report. It contained an interim reconstruction up to 30 June 2013. It was only of provisional effect because the ultimate exercise had to embrace events up to the end of 2013. The transfer committee considered the interim report on 29 January 2014. The committee resolved to receive the report subject to a number of actions including:“c. That MSC and TRC look into the assets split and capital acquisitions and funding as at 31 December and provide further advice back to the transfer committee on any issues.” TRC had the interim report reviewed by its internal auditors, Pacifica. The review was to assess the reasonableness of the methodologies applied to the unallocated amounts within the separated profit and loss, balance sheet and cash-flow prepared by CH. Pacifica’s resulting report of January 2014 was not before the Minister. Even if it had been it is unlikely to have been material to the Minister’s decision. Pacifica’s report noted that the process and approach adopted by CH appeared logical and reasonable. It noted that it was understood from discussions with the transfer committee delegates that further internal review of some matters, including fixed assets and capital expenditure, was required.[16] [16] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden Ex LP7 p 95. After the issue of the interim report a further revised scope of work was issued to CH for a determination of the final cash and reserve balances to be allocated as at 31 December 2013. The scope, which was not later put before the Minister, noted a number of issues arising from reviews of the first report by MSC and TRC. One such issue noted in the scope as having been raised by both TRC and MSC was:“Capital funding needs to be reconciled to the asset register in terms of the capital expenditure incurred by each council area during amalgamation and the source/(s) of funding for those expenditures.”[17][17] Affidavit of Lachlan Peden Ex LP9 p 136.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established