SZVRQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZVRQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCA 375

Appeal from: SZVRQ v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 626
File number: NSD 592 of 2017
Judge: SNADEN J
Date of judgment: 25 March 2020
Catchwords: MIGRATION – protection visa – appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia – application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) – decision of the first respondent refusing an application for a protection visa – whether the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error – whether extortion because of the appellant’s ethnicity/particular social group could, by itself, amount to persecution – whether the Tribunal erred by considering what the appellant could do in circumstances of extortion, as distinct from what the appellant would do – appeal allowed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36 and 91R
Cases cited:

Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473

Applicant NABD of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 216 ALR 1

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA (2014) 254 CLR 317

SZTAP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 238 FCR 404

SZVRQ v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 626

Date of hearing: 2 October 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 47
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr L Karp
Solicitor for the Appellant: Dobbie and Devine Immigration Lawyers Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the First Respondent: DLA Piper Australia
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a submitting notice, save as to costs

ORDERS

NSD 592 of 2017
BETWEEN:

SZVRQ

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

SNADEN J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 MARCH 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.Orders 2 and 3 of the orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 31 March 2017 in proceeding (P)SYG3236/2014 (hereafter, the “Proceeding Below”) be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:

(a)a writ of certiorari be issued, removing into this court and quashing the decision of the second respondent (the then Refugee Review Tribunal) made on 6 November 2014 in case number 1311009 (hereafter, the “Quashed Decision”);

(b)a writ of mandamus be issued, requiring that the second respondent determine the application to which the Quashed Decision pertained (namely, for review of the decision made by a delegate of the first respondent on 11 July 2013) according to law; and

(c)the first respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application in the Proceeding Below.

3.The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed in default of agreement in accordance with the court’s Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).

Note:   Entry of orders is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZVRQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 375
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, SZVRQ, a Rohingya individual, appealed against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's decision to refuse his application for a protection visa. SZVRQ argued that the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) erred in its assessment of the risks he would face if returned to Pakistan. The Tribunal had considered the risk of extortion by authorities due to his ethnicity but concluded that such extortion, unless it threatened his capacity to subsist, would not constitute serious harm sufficient to grant a protection visa. The central legal issues in this appeal revolved around whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted and applied the law in determining whether extortion due to ethnicity alone could constitute persecution and if it erred in its assessment of what SZVRQ would do in the face of such extortion.

The court found that the Tribunal had committed a jurisdictional error in its reasoning. Specifically, the Tribunal failed to consider whether extortion due to SZVRQ's ethnicity could, by itself, constitute persecution. The Tribunal instead focused on whether the extortion would threaten his capacity to subsist. The court emphasised that persecution does not necessarily need to threaten an individual's capacity to subsist to qualify as such; extortion due to ethnicity could, in itself, amount to persecution. Furthermore, the Tribunal's consideration of what SZVRQ could do in the face of extortion, rather than what he would do, was flawed. This approach did not align with the legal standards for assessing protection claims. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was therefore irrational and failed to exercise its jurisdiction correctly.

Consequently, the appeal was allowed. The Federal Circuit Court's orders from March 2017 were set aside, and the Tribunal's decision was quashed. A writ of mandamus was issued to the Tribunal to reconsider SZVRQ's application according to law. Additionally, the Minister was ordered to pay SZVRQ's costs for both the original application and the appeal. This ruling underscores the importance of correctly interpreting and applying the law in refugee status determinations, particularly concerning the definition and scope of persecution.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Orders 2 and 3 of the orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 31 March 2017 in proceeding (P)SYG3236/2014 (hereafter, the “Proceeding Below”) be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:

(a) a writ of certiorari be issued, removing into this court and quashing the decision of the second respondent (the then Refugee Review Tribunal) made on 6 November 2014 in case number 1311009 (hereafter, the “Quashed Decision”);

(b) a writ of mandamus be issued, requiring that the second respondent determine the application to which the Quashed Decision pertained (namely, for review of the decision made by a delegate of the first respondent on 11 July 2013) according to law; and

(c) the first respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application in the Proceeding Below.

3. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed in default of agreement in accordance with the court’s Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

By his Judicial Review Application, the appellant submitted that the Tribunal Decision was the product of jurisdictional error and, as such, should be set aside so that his Visa Application might be reviewed afresh (and according to law). Of the grounds that he pursued to that end, only the following are relevant in the context of the present appeal:1. The Tribunal misinterpreted the applicable law or misapplied the law to the factsParticulars:(i) The Tribunal stated at [63] of its decision, in relation to the vulnerability of Rohingya in Pakistan to extortion from the authorities:..[.]the Tribunal has considered whether there is a real chance of the [appellant] being subjected to extortion on a regular basis, or being detained before the matter goes to court, because of his ethnicity and whether this would constitute serious harm. The Tribunal does not accept that low level extortion that does not affect the [appellant]’s capacity to subsist would be sufficient to constitute serious harm. The Tribunal is not satisfied on the basis of the evidence before it that there is a real chance that the [appellant] would be subject to extortion at a [sic] such a level as to threaten his capacity to subsist or that he would be unable to pay the extortion required so that there is a real chance that he would be detained.(a) The Tribunal failed to consider whether extortion of the [appellant] by the authorities because of his ethnicity/particular social group, by itself, could constitute persecution. Rather, the Tribunal erroneously required that the extortion of the [appellant] by the authorities had to have the additional element of threatening his capacity to subsist before that extortion could constitute persecution.…2. The Tribunal decision is arbitrary, irrational, unreasonable or illogical.Particulars:(i) The Tribunal stated at [63] of its decision, in relation to the vulnerability of Rohingya in Pakistan to extortion from the authorities:..[.] the Tribunal has considered whether there is a real chance of the [appellant] being subjected to extortion on a regular basis, or being detained before the matter goes to court, because of his ethnicity and whether this would constitute serious harm. The Tribunal does not accept that low level extortion that does not affect the [appellant]’s capacity to subsist would be sufficient to constitute serious harm. The Tribunal is not satisfied on the basis of the evidence before it that there is a real chance that the [appellant] would be subject to extortion at a [sic] such a level as to threaten his capacity to subsist or that he would be unable to pay the extortion required so that there is a real chance that he would be detained.(a) In the event that it is found that the Tribunal did not fail to consider whether extortion of the [appellant] by the authorities because of his ethnicity/particular social group, by itself, could constitute persecution, any finding (if it is determined that such a finding was made) that extortion from the authorities does not constitute persecution is arbitrary, irrational, or unreasonable or illogical, such that it failed to exercise its jurisdiction.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no question raised by this appeal about the jurisdiction of the Minister’s delegate to determine the appellant’s Visa Application, the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to review the Delegate’s Decision or the jurisdiction of the FCCA to hear the Judicial Review Application. It is unnecessary to set out the legislative provisions that confer jurisdiction in those regards.THE TRIBUNAL DECISION In response to the submissions that the appellant advanced before it, the Tribunal obtained and considered country information about the treatment of Rohingya in Pakistan. It made the following observations (references omitted):55. The Tribunal could only locate limited information about the treatment of Rohingya in Pakistan. Given the limited information about the treatment of Rohingya in Pakistan the Tribunal has also considered information about the treatment of Bengalis in Pakistan. The [appellant] stated, and the Tribunal accepts, that he would be likely to be treated as a Bengali Muslim in Pakistan because of his looks. The Tribunal accepts that in Myanmar Rohingya are considered to be Bengali Muslims and the country information referred to below appears to consider Bengalis and Burmese immigrants in Pakistan to be similar in their treatment.56. There is a large community of Rohingya and Bengalis in Karachi, with reports suggesting that Karachi has one of the largest Rohingya populations outside of Myanmar and totals around 200,000. The Tribunal has considered a wide range of reports in relation to the treatment of Rohingya and Bengalis in Karachi as well as those referred to, or provided by, the [appellant]. Reports suggest that Rohingya in Karachi continue to face many difficulties and are one of the city’s poorest and most vulnerable communities. There is a lack of legal recognition of them. For example, The News International reported in 2012 that according to the law, the three to four hundred thousand ‘illegal immigrant’ [Rohingya] in Karachi ‘simply do not exist’. In addition to the lack of legal recognition they lack political power which is crucial in the ethnicity based politics of Karachi. This means that their needs are ignored by the powerful political groups and they lack political affiliations which provide access to services, jobs and protection. The difficulties they face include access to citizenship, passports and obtaining a National Identity Card (NIC) with Rohingya either being denied such access or forced to pay bribes in order to obtain them. They are harassed, arrested, or threatened with arrest, for being illegal residents as a way for police to extract bribes. If the bribes are not paid then they can be arrested. A 2000 article in The Daily Star also refers to [Rohingya] in Karachi as ‘illegal immigrants’, some of whom ‘have spent many years in jail, detained under the Pakistan Foreigners Act’. They are discriminated against in terms of employment and tend to earn a living in low-paid jobs. There are reports of Bengali being denied medical treatment because of their meagre income and ethnicity. There are also reports of Bengali women being forced into prostitution or sold into slavery. These reports suggest that the general situation of ethnic Bengalis and Burmese in Karachi is primarily determined by their ethnicity, not by whether or not they personally have regularised their legal status and that possession of citizenship and documentation will not necessarily provide protection.57. However, the country information suggests that not all [Rohingya] in Pakistan live in destitute poverty or suffer extreme discrimination. In a personal account Derek Henry Flood, an independent journalist states: Arriving in Korangi, I immediately was greeted by a roadside lined with busy fresh fish stalls on one side and a herd of hulking, tar colored water buffalo blocking the rickshaw traffic on the other. I felt like I had been transported into a sliver of Southeast Asia on the Indian subcontinent. The most noticeable cultural contrast to the rest of Karachi was the appearance of the lungi, the ubiquitous floor length national dress of Bangladesh and much of Burma. We went to visit a small Rohingya settlement near Aziz’s one room concrete block home. In comparison to the immense suffering I would encounter in Bangladesh, the people I met were relatively prosperous and urbanized with some of them having been in Pakistan for decades. I wanted most to know how they came to arrive in outer Karachi from western Burma, which I gathered to be an immense logistical feat. 58. In light of the [appellant]’s denial that he is a Pakistani citizen, or that he has ever been to Pakistan, the [appellant] did not provide any evidence based on personal experience about the treatment of [Rohingya] in Pakistan or claim to have ever suffered harm as a Rohingya in Pakistan. The role of the Tribunal is therefore to make an assessment of whether there is a real chance of serious harm to the [appellant] based on the limited country information before it. The information provided by the [appellant], and found independently by the Tribunal, all refers to the situation in Karachi, which is where there is a large Rohingya community. Given the [appellant]’s claim to have no connection to Pakistan, there is nothing before the Tribunal to suggest that he would have to live in Karachi and he could choose to live in Islamabad or Lahore which are generally more secure than Karachi. However, the Tribunal considers that there is a large Rohingya community with whom he could communicate and find support in Karachi and therefore finds that Karachi is where the [appellant] would most likely live.59. The country information referred to above suggests that the communities which the reports refer to largely consist of members without Pakistani citizenship and with limited education, poorly paid jobs, low socio-economic standing and little political influence. However, the [appellant]’s background does not fit within such a profile. He appears to have been well educated (despite his claims to the contrary), he has a Pakistani passport and National Identification Card, he has held a well paid position in an international IT company and he has travelled extensively internationally. The Tribunal considers this to be an important distinction in considering the country information referred to above.60. The Tribunal has considered whether the type of harm that the [appellant] may face upon return to Pakistan would constitute serious harm. The Act does not contain an exhaustive definition of serious harm. However, examples of what would constitute serious harm are set out in s.91R(2) of the Act which states:(2) Without limiting what is serious harm for the purposes of paragraph (1)(b), the following are instances of serious harm for the purposes of that paragraph: (a) a threat to the person’s life or liberty; (b) significant physical harassment of the person; (c) significant physical ill-treatment of the person;(d) significant economic hardship that threatens the person’s capacity to subsist;(e) denial of access to basic services, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist;(t) denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist.61. While the country information refers to discrimination in employment, the Tribunal is not satisfied that there is a real chance of the [appellant] being unable to obtain employment and therefore being unable to subsist. The [appellant] has been able to find well paid work in the UAE and employment here in Australia. The reports referred to above suggest that while there is discrimination in employment, Rohingya in Pakistan are still able to obtain employment. The [appellant] has a Pakistani passport and National Identification Card which will assist him in obtaining employment. He has experience with an international IT company which would assist him in obtaining employment. He speaks, reads and writes Arabic and English and the Tribunal notes that English is one of Pakistan’s two official languages. The Tribunal is not satisfied that he will suffer discrimination in employment which would prevent him finding employment or being unable to subsist. The Tribunal is not satisfied that any harm he suffered as a result of discrimination in employment would be to such a level as to constitute serious harm.62. The independent country information provided by the [appellant] refers to some members of the Bengali community being refused passports in Pakistan and the [appellant] has provided a letter from the Office of the Sr. Superintendent of Police Security, Special Branch which refers to a National Identification Card as not being sufficient evidence of nationality. However, the Tribunal considers that the [appellant]’s circumstances are different in that the Pakistani authorities have already verified that he is a Pakistani citizen and he has been issued with a Pakistani passport and National Identification Card in the past. Therefore, the Tribunal is not satisfied that there is a real chance that the [appellant] would be refused a Pakistani passport in the future.63. The Tribunal has carefully considered the country information above which refers to the vulnerability of Rohingya in Pakistan to extortion from the authorities. While many of the reports suggest that such vulnerability is often borne from uncertainty about the legal status of Rohingya because of large numbers of illegal immigrants in Pakistan, nevertheless even Rohingya who are able to produce authentic documentation may have that documentation rejected and be falsely accused of being illegal and subjected to extortion on this basis. The country information suggests that the Pakistani courts acquit those who have documentary proof of citizenship which suggests to the Tribunal that the Rohingya in Karachi who have spent many years in jail, as referred to above, are those without citizenship papers. The Tribunal considers that this does not apply to the [appellant]. Nevertheless, the Tribunal has considered whether there is a real chance of the [appellant] being subjected to extortion on a regular basis, or being detained before the matter goes to court, because of his ethnicity and whether this would constitute serious harm. The Tribunal does not accept that low level extortion that does not affect the [appellant]’s capacity to subsist would be sufficient to constitute serious harm. The Tribunal is not satisfied on the basis of the evidence before it that there is a real chance that the [appellant] would be subject to extortion at…such a level as to threaten his capacity to subsist or that he would be unable to pay the extortion required so that there is a real chance that he would be detained. The [appellant] has family living and working in the UAE. He is educated and experienced. He has been able to access funds to travel extensively internationally. The Tribunal finds that the chance of him being detained as a Rohingya is remote.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established