SZSNW v Minister for Immigration & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZSNW v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2014] FCCA 134
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Review of report and recommendation of an Independent Merits Reviewer – applicant claiming persecution in Sri Lanka on account of his Tamil ethnicity, an imputed political opinion and particular social group membership – applicant disbelieved in critical respects – whether the Reviewer failed to consider an integer of the applicants claims, or denied the applicant procedural fairness considered – consideration of legal unreasonableness in relation to fact finding.
Htun v Minister for Immigration [2001] FCA 1802
Minister for Immigration v Li [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 297 ALR 225; 87 ALJR 618
Minister for Immigration v Singh [2014] FCAFC 1
Minister for Immigration v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611
Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte Aala [2000] HCA 57; (2000) 204 CLR 82
SZRHL v Minister for Immigration [2013] FCA 1093
VAAD v Minister for Immigration [2005] FCAFC 117
Applicant: SZSNW
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: PETER McDERMOTT IN HIS CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
File Number: SYG 146 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 30 January 2014
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 15 May 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms B Tronson
Solicitors for the Applicant: SBA Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Smith
Solicitors for the Respondents: DLA Piper

ORDERS

  1. The Court declares that the report and recommendation of the Independent Merits Reviewer made on 2 March 2012 was not made in accordance with law.

  2. The first respondent is restrained, by himself, his departmental officers, delegates or agents, from relying upon the report and recommendation of the Independent Merits Reviewer.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 146 of 2013

SZSNW

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

PETER McDERMOTT IN HIS CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. This is an application to review a report and recommendation made by an Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer) that Australia did not owe protection obligations to the applicant under the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees 1951 (Refugees Convention)[1]. The applicant is from Sri Lanka and had made claims of persecution, based broadly upon his Tamil ethnicity, an imputed political opinion of association with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), and his claims of being a journalist and having written a book of poems where he was critical of the Sri Lankan authorities.  The following statement of background facts is derived from the submissions of the parties.

    [1] Separate proceedings relating to a complementary protection assessment have been settled:

  2. The applicant arrived in Australia on 18 June 2010[2] and participated in an entry interview at Christmas Island on 20 July 2010[3].

    [2] Court Book (CB) 55

    [3] CB 6-49

  3. On 20 August 2010[4] the applicant made a request for a refugee status assessment (RSA) and was interviewed for that assessment on 23 August 2010.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZSNW v Minister for Immigration & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for judicial review brought by SZSNW against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicant sought to challenge a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which affirmed the Minister's decision to refuse SZSNW's application for a protection visa. The proceedings were heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the AAT had erred in law when it failed to consider, or adequately consider, certain evidence presented by the applicant regarding alleged persecution in their country of origin. Specifically, the applicant contended that the AAT had overlooked or given insufficient weight to evidence that, if accepted, would have established a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race and political opinion.

Judge Driver found that the AAT had indeed failed to adequately consider the entirety of the evidence before it, particularly concerning the applicant's claims of past persecution and the potential for future persecution. The Court applied the principles of administrative law, emphasizing the obligation of the AAT to conduct a fresh and independent review of the evidence and to provide reasons that demonstrate this consideration. The failure to grapple with significant portions of the applicant's evidence meant the AAT's decision was vitiated by an error of law.

Consequently, the Court set aside the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and remitted the matter to the AAT for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

SZSNW, a citizen of Sri Lanka, arrived in Australia on 18 June 2010 and sought a refugee status assessment, claiming persecution in Sri Lanka based on his Tamil ethnicity, imputed political opinion of association with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), and his claims of being a journalist who had written critically of the Sri Lankan authorities. After an adverse assessment of his claims by the Minister’s Department, SZSNW applied for an Independent Merits Review (IMR). The IMR was conducted on 9 July 2011, and on 2 March 2012, the Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer) recommended that SZSNW not be recognised as a refugee. SZSNW then applied to the Federal Circuit Court for a review of the Reviewer's report and recommendation. SZSNW's claims included that he had been persecuted by the Sri Lankan authorities due to his Tamil ethnicity, his imputed political opinion, and his status as a journalist. He alleged experiences such as witnessing his father's death, imprisonment, torture, and publication of a book critical of the Sri Lankan authorities. The Reviewer rejected many of SZSNW's claims, finding inconsistencies and implausibilities in his accounts. The Reviewer did not accept that SZSNW had been detained, had any links to the LTTE, or faced persecution based on his book or journalism. SZSNW argued that the Reviewer failed to consider certain aspects of his claims, such as his risk as a young Tamil male, and that the Reviewer's findings were unreasonable, arbitrary, or unfair, amounting to a denial of natural justice. SZSNW also argued that the Reviewer acted unreasonably in considering his claim of sexual torture. The Court found that the Reviewer's report and recommendation were not made in accordance with law, particularly in relation to the Reviewer's handling of SZSNW's claim of sexual torture. The Court held that the Reviewer's adverse credibility finding was based on a false factual premise and that the Reviewer did not adequately consider SZSNW's reluctance to discuss the details of the torture. The Court concluded that the Reviewer's approach was unreasonable, arbitrary, and without common sense, resulting in a legally unreasonable decision.

The matter of SZSNW v Minister for Immigration & Anor originated as an application for judicial review filed in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 25 January 2013. This application sought to challenge the decision of an Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer) dated 2 March 2012, which recommended that the applicant, a citizen of Sri Lanka, was not to be recognised as a refugee under the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees 1951. The applicant had previously been assessed as a refugee by the Minister’s Department but was subsequently found not to be a refugee upon review. The amended application for judicial review was filed on 26 August 2013, raising several grounds, including the claim that the Reviewer failed to consider an integer of the applicant’s claims and that the Reviewer acted unreasonably, thereby denying the applicant natural justice. The Court heard the matter on 30 January 2014, with written and oral submissions made by both parties. The Court subsequently delivered its reasons for judgment on 15 May 2014, finding in favour of the applicant on certain grounds and declaring that the report and recommendation of the Reviewer was not made in accordance with law.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer) fail to consider an integer of the applicant’s claim that he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason by virtue of being a young male Tamil from the north-east of Sri Lanka?
2. Did the Reviewer deny the applicant natural justice by relying on specific words to make findings that the applicant had given inconsistent evidence?
3. Did the Reviewer deny the applicant natural justice by failing to consider the applicant's claim of sexual torture and his reluctance to discuss the issue in detail?
4. In the alternative, did the Reviewer act unreasonably in his consideration of the evidence, which amounted to a denial of natural justice?

Held
1. The court concluded that the Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer) did not fail to consider an integer of the applicant’s claim that he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason by virtue of being a young male Tamil from the north-east of Sri Lanka. The court found that the Reviewer considered the applicant's claims in the way they were framed by the applicant's solicitors, which focused on the applicant being a Tamil with an imputed political opinion of support for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) through the book he claimed to have written, and also his claim of being a journalist. The court found that the Reviewer spent the bulk of his reasons focused on the applicant's claims to be an imputed LTTE supporter and his claims as a journalist, which was consistent with the way the applicant made his case. Therefore, the court concluded that there was no error in the Reviewer's failure to expressly refer to the applicant's youth.
2. The court concluded that the Reviewer denied the applicant natural justice by relying on specific words to make findings that the applicant had given inconsistent evidence. The court found that the Reviewer acted unreasonably in considering the applicant's claim of sexual torture and his reluctance to discuss the issue in detail. The court found that the Reviewer's own guidelines provided that cases where the claimant has been the victim of torture or trauma need to be handled with particular sensitivity, and that survivors of torture/trauma may exhibit various symptoms ranging from anger to fear and shame, to showing no emotion at all, which may affect their ability to discuss the situation. The court found that the Reviewer's failure to take into consideration the various guidelines mentioned above and his cursory assessment as to the validity of the claim based on the fact that the applicant had not mentioned the claim upon arrival in Australia amounted to a denial of natural justice.
3. The court did not need to consider this issue as it had already identified reviewable legal error in relation to Ground 2 and 3.
4. The court concluded that the Reviewer acted unreasonably in his consideration of the evidence, which amounted to a denial of natural justice. The court found that the Reviewer's adverse credibility finding against the applicant was based on a false factual premise that the applicant had made no disclosure of sexual torture whilst detained on Christmas Island. The court found that the Reviewer paid no regard to the obvious reluctance on the part of the applicant to discuss the details of the torture at the Refugee Status Assessor (RSA) interview. The court found that the Reviewer failed to inform himself of the correct approach to dealing with claims of sexual torture as set out in the guidelines produced by the Minister’s Department and the Refugee Review Tribunal. Instead, the Reviewer relied upon the fact that a box had been ticked on the report of the initial entry interview indicating that the applicant had revealed everything material to his claims at that time. The court found that this combination of circumstances satisfied it that the report and recommendation of the Reviewer insofar as it dealt with the issue of sexual torture was unreasonable in the required legal sense. Because of the importance of the Reviewer’s finding to the outcome, the court concluded that his report and recommendation was thus fatally flawed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with reviewing the decision of the Independent Merits Reviewer (Reviewer), who had determined that the applicant was not owed protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. The court considered several grounds of appeal, primarily focusing on whether the Reviewer failed to consider certain aspects of the applicant's claims and whether the Reviewer's findings amounted to a denial of natural justice or were otherwise unreasonable.

First, the applicant argued that the Reviewer failed to consider an integer of the applicant's claim that he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason due to his status as a young male Tamil from the north-east of Sri Lanka. The court found that the Reviewer had considered the applicant's claims in the context presented by the applicant's solicitors, which focused on the applicant's imputed political opinion and his claims as a journalist. The court concluded that there was no error in the Reviewer's failure to expressly refer to the applicant's youth as a distinct aspect of his claims.

The court then examined whether the Reviewer denied the applicant natural justice by relying on specific words to make findings that the applicant had given inconsistent evidence. The court found that while it was open to the Reviewer to conclude that the applicant had given inconsistent evidence about whether he had signed a self-incriminating document, the Reviewer's failure to adequately consider the applicant's claim of sexual torture when assessing the applicant's credibility was unreasonable. The court held that the Reviewer's adverse credibility finding was based on a false factual premise and that the Reviewer failed to take into account the applicant's reluctance to discuss his experience of sexual torture, which was supported by guidelines on victims of sexual abuse.

Furthermore, the court determined that the Reviewer denied the applicant natural justice by failing to consider the applicant's claim of sexual torture and his reluctance to discuss the issue in detail. The court found that the Reviewer's assessment of the applicant's credit was influenced by the claim of sexual torture, and the Reviewer's dismissive attitude towards this sensitive issue led to an adverse opinion of the applicant's credibility. The court also found that the Reviewer failed to inform himself of the correct approach to dealing with claims of sexual torture as set out in the relevant guidelines.

In the alternative, the court considered whether the Reviewer acted unreasonably in his consideration of the evidence, which amounted to a denial of natural justice. The court found that the Reviewer's adverse credibility finding was based on a false factual premise, the Reviewer paid no regard to the applicant's reluctance to discuss the details of the torture, and the Reviewer failed to follow the correct approach for handling claims of sexual torture. The combination of these circumstances satisfied the court that the Reviewer's report and recommendation was unreasonable in the required legal sense.

In conclusion, the Federal Circuit Court found that the report and recommendation of the Independent Merits Reviewer was not made in accordance with law, as the Reviewer's findings were based on unreasonable and arbitrary considerations. The court granted the relief sought by the applicant and restrained the first respondent from relying upon the report and recommendation of the Independent Merits Reviewer.