SZNCX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZNCX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 1315

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 424, 424A, 424A(1), 424AA,

SZNCX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FMCA 679
Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
NADR v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 167
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507

SCAA v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCA 668

SZNCX and SZNCY v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

NSD 773 of 2009

REEVES J
13 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 773 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNCX
First Appellant

SZNCY
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 NOVEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 773 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNCX
First Appellant

SZNCY
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE:

13 NOVEMBER 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an appeal against a judgment of a Federal Magistrate delivered on 9 July 2009, dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).

    BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

  2. The appellants are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 31 May 2008.  On 11 June 2008, the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship.  A delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (“the Minister”) refused these applications.  The appellants then applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.  The Tribunal subsequently affirmed the delegate’s decision.  The appellants then made an application for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia.

  3. The second appellant is the husband of the first appellant (“the appellant”) and he applied for a protection visa on the basis of his membership of the appellant’s family.  Therefore, whether he is found to be a refugee under the Convention depends on the outcome of the appellant’s appeal.

    CLAIMS OF RELIGIOUS PERSECUTION

  4. The appellant (“the appellant”) claimed that she belonged to a “Christian Other Backward Community” in Kerala, a caste considered as “other backward community”.  She stated that she faced discrimination due to her caste in her education and social life.

  5. In 1994 there was escalating violence between Christians and Muslims in Kerala and the appellant claimed that she and her family were assaulted by armed Muslim thugs, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNCX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1315
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal was brought by the appellants, citizens of India, against the decision of the Federal Magistrates Court, which had dismissed their application for judicial review of the Refugee Review Tribunal’s decision to affirm the Minister’s refusal of their applications for protection visas. The Tribunal found the appellant’s account of harm she suffered in India to be not credible and concluded that she did not have a well-founded fear of persecution for Convention-related reasons. The appellants raised several grounds of appeal, including that the Tribunal’s conclusions regarding her credibility were not obviously open to it and that the Tribunal failed to provide her with country information prior to the hearing.

The court considered the grounds of appeal and found that they sought to challenge the factual conclusions reached by the Tribunal, which could not, without more, amount to jurisdictional error. The court emphasised that it was not the role of the Federal Magistrates Court to second-guess the Tribunal’s fact-finding role or to engage in a merits review of the Tribunal’s decision. The court found that the appellant’s sole ground of appeal must be rejected as it did not identify any jurisdictional error. The court also rejected the appellant’s additional written submissions, finding them to be devoid of merit.

The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the Federal Magistrates Court that the appellants’ application for judicial review be dismissed. The court concluded that the appeal had no reasonable prospect of success and there were no grounds upon which the appeal could be remitted to the Federal Magistrates Court for rehearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against a judgment of a Federal Magistrate delivered on 9 July 2009, dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY The appellants are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 31 May 2008. On 11 June 2008, the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (“the Minister”) refused these applications. The appellants then applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. The Tribunal subsequently affirmed the delegate’s decision. The appellants then made an application for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia. The second appellant is the husband of the first appellant (“the appellant”) and he applied for a protection visa on the basis of his membership of the appellant’s family. Therefore, whether he is found to be a refugee under the Convention depends on the outcome of the appellant’s appeal.CLAIMS OF RELIGIOUS PERSECUTION The appellant (“the appellant”) claimed that she belonged to a “Christian Other Backward Community” in Kerala, a caste considered as “other backward community”. She stated that she faced discrimination due to her caste in her education and social life. In 1994 there was escalating violence between Christians and Muslims in Kerala and the appellant claimed that she and her family were assaulted by armed Muslim thugs, and that many of her friends and distant relatives were killed by Muslims. After graduation the appellant joined ten other members of her Church in working for disadvantaged and socially discriminated women and children. Her work involved teaching, conducting Bible classes, assisting with clothing and providing financial assistance. The appellant claimed that in 2006 and early 2007 she received threatening telephone calls from Hindu fundamentalists who threatened her and other Church workers and accused them of converting the Schedule Castes and Schedule Tribes to Christianity. She claimed that she was stopped by thugs of the Hindu political party Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (“RSS”) and harassed. Furthermore, the appellant claimed that in January 2008 a group of Schedule Castes and Schedule Tribes approached and requested that she help them with their children’s education. She stated that she contacted the Church and was told to do the work. She claimed that she and others received threatening telephone calls warning them to cease their activities or face punishment. She stated that one member of the group was severely assaulted by the RSS. The appellant claimed that she was unable to receive protection from the police, or the government in Kerala.THE TRIBUNAL AFFIRMS THE DELEGATE’S DECISION – APPELLANT NOT A CREDIBLE WITNESS The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was a Christian and had been a member of the congregation of the Catholic Church in her village, that she had been involved in teaching literacy skills to “untouchable” Hindus, and that this activity may have resulted in a number of Hindus converting to Christianity.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

REEVES J
The appellant claimed that she was unable to receive protection from the police, or the government in Kerala.THE TRIBUNAL AFFIRMS THE DELEGATE’S DECISION – APPELLANT NOT A CREDIBLE WITNESS The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was a Christian and had been a member of the congregation of the Catholic Church in her village, that she had been involved in teaching literacy skills to “untouchable” Hindus, and that this activity may have resulted in a number of Hindus converting to Christianity. However, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant’s account of having suffered harm in India in the past was credible. It noted that her evidence at the hearing was vague about the specific incidents of harm she claimed to have suffered and that she had provided little or no circumstantial detail about the attacks and threats. The Tribunal stated that at no point did her responses to questions about these matters give the impression that it was based on authentic first hand experience. The Tribunal also noted that the appellant made new claims at the hearing, and her failure to raise those claims earlier led it to conclude that she was prepared to adapt her evidence, casting doubt over the credibility of her claims in general. The Tribunal also found that there were inconsistencies in her evidence about the identity of the persons who were said to have threatened and harmed her. The Tribunal placed no weight on a letter from a priest on the basis of the vagueness of the claims contained in it. Further, on the country information available to the Tribunal, it was not satisfied as to the credibility of the appellant’s claim that the current coalition government in Kerala was opposed to her work and nor was it satisfied that the government opposed Christianity. The Tribunal was also not satisfied that the government would have withheld protection from her, if she had sought it, as a result of being threatened by Hindu fundamentalists. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant was ever harmed, or threatened, as a result of her work with the Church, or that she was forced to leave India and come to Australia for her own safety. In summary, the Tribunal was satisfied that the appellant could return to India and involve herself in social welfare activities with Hindu untouchables and concluded that she did not have a well-founded fear of persecution for any Convention-related reason. THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATE FINDS NO JURISDICTIONAL ERROR In her amended judicial review application to the Federal Magistrates Court, the appellant raised the following grounds (in summary):1.The Tribunal’s conclusions regarding the appellant’s credibility were not obviously open to it on the known material, and were made without giving the appellant the opportunity to be heard in respect of those matters. 2.The Tribunal failed to give the appellant the benefit of the doubt in circumstances where it entertained the possibility that the appellant’s claims were plausible. 3.The Tribunal failed to provide the appellant with country information that it had about India and Kerala before the hearing, in breach of s 424A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”)4.The Tribunal failed to properly consider the appellant’s claim that she feared persecution on the basis of her social welfare activities with Hindu untouchables, which lead to their conversion to Christianity.5.The Tribunal applied the wrong test in considering the appellant’s claims and placed too high an onus on the appellant by requiring her to adduce independent evidence of her claims.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: REEVES J

The Minister also filed an outline of written submissions.CONSIDERATION The errors identified the sole ground of appeal (above) seek to challenge the factual conclusions the Tribunal reached, as to whether there was evidence to establish that the appellant was a refugee. Even if there was some error in the Tribunal’s conclusions about this matter – it is not possible from the unparticularised and general nature of the ground of appeal to begin to assess whether there is – there is clear authority that errors in the Tribunal’s factual conclusions cannot, without more, amount to jurisdictional error: see Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at 560 (at [137]). Furthermore, it is not the role of this Court, nor is it the role of the Federal Magistrates Court, to second guess the Tribunal’s fact finding role, or to engage in a merits review of the Tribunal’s decision. These are matters that fall squarely within the fact finding jurisdiction of the Tribunal: see, eg NADR v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 167 at [9]. It follows that the appellant’s sole ground of appeal must be rejected. Turning then to the matters raised in the appellant’s outline of written submissions. As noted above, the first submission raises a new matter in the sense that it was not raised before the Federal Magistrates Court. Ms Francois submitted that the appellant should not be permitted to rely upon this matter, either because it is new, or because it has no merit and is, therefore, futile. Because the appellant is not legally represented, I will deal with this matter on the latter basis. This effectively requires me to consider the submission on its merits. In this submission, the appellant has not identified what “additional information” she is referring to. In the Minister’s written submissions, Ms Francois points out that the Tribunal did not, in fact, seek any “additional information” from any source. From my reading of the Tribunal’s decision, apart from independent country information, which obviously falls into a different category, what Ms Francois says appears to be correct. It follows that, in the absence of any evidence that the Tribunal sought any “additional information”, this submission is devoid of merit and must therefore be rejected. The second of the appellant’s written submissions raises a matter which is similar, if not identical, to the first ground of review before the Federal Magistrate: see [16.1] above. From his consideration of the Tribunal’s reasons for decision, the Federal Magistrate found no substance in this allegation: see [17] above. I agree. It follows that this submission must be rejected. The third of the appellant’s written submissions is also similar to one of the grounds of review before the Federal Magistrate: see [16.3] above. I do not consider the additional references, eg to the OBC, affect this similarity. The Federal Magistrate concluded that the similar ground before him was misconceived as a matter of law because the Tribunal was under no obligation to put any independent country information to the appellant: see [19] above. Again, I agree. It follows that this submission must also be rejected.