SZNAV & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZNAV & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2009] FMCA 693

MIGRATION – Review of RRT decision – where transcript of hearing showed omissions of interpretation and translations of words that were not actually spoken – whether standard of interpretation so inadequate as to amount to a breach of s.425 – whether Tribunal failed to take into account relevant evidence.

“Acknowledgement of Application” letter – where letter contained an invitation to provide information “immediately” without specifying the prescribed period for response – whether that letter contained an invitation to provide additional information written pursuant to s.424(2) – whether failure to indicate the prescribed period in breach of s.424B constitutes a jurisdictional error.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.359A, 359B, 359C, 414, 424, 424A, 424B, 424C, 425
Migration Regulations 1994
Perera v Minister for Immigration [1999] FCA 507
Minister for Immigration v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
SZCOQ v Minister for Immigration [2007] FCAFC 9
Minister for Immigration v Al Shamry [2001] FCA 919
SAAP v Minister for Immigration [2005] HCA 24
NAAF of 2002 v Minister for Immigration (2004) 211 ALR 660
SZLPO v Minister for Immigration [2009] FCAFC 51
Minister for Immigration v Sun [2009] FCAFC 201
SZLTR v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCA 1889
MZXRE v Minister for Immigration [2009] FCAFC 82
SZKCQ v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCAFC 119
SZKTI v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCAFC 83
SZEXZ v Minister for Immigration [2006] FCA 449
M v Minister for Immigration [2006] FCA 1247
SZLWQ v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCA 1406
SZIZO & Ors v Minister for Immigration [2008] 172 FCR 152
First Applicant: SZNAV
Second Applicant: SZNAW
Third Applicant: SZNAX
Fourth Applicant: SZNAY
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 3232 of 2008
Judgment of: Raphael FM
Hearing date: 6 July 2009
Date of Last Submission: 6 July 2009
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 23 July 2009

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms A Arunothayam
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms V McWilliam
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. A writ of certiorari issue directed to the Refugee Review Tribunal removing into this Court to be quashed the decision of the Tribunal made on 22 October 2008.

  2. A writ of mandamus be directed to the Second Respondent directing it to reconsider and determine the matter according to law.

  3. The First Respondent to pay the Applicant’s cost assessed in the sum of $5,500.00.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 3232 of 2008

SZNAV

First Applicant

SZNAW

Second Applicant

SZNAX

Third Applicant

SZNAY

Fourth Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicants are citizens of Bangladesh who arrived together in Australia on 24 March 2008.  On 6 May 2008 they applied to the Department of Immigration & Citizenship for protection (Class XA) visas.  On 20 June 2008 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant protection visas and on 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNAV & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FMCA 693
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of SZNAV & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor, the applicants, SZNAV and others, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT). The applicants challenged the RRT's decision on multiple grounds, including the quality of the interpretation and translation services provided during the hearing, the failure to consider relevant evidence, and the adequacy of the "Acknowledgement of Application" letter sent to the applicants. The court was tasked with determining whether the RRT's handling of the interpretation services constituted a breach of statutory obligations, whether the Tribunal failed to consider relevant evidence, and whether the "Acknowledgement of Application" letter was compliant with statutory requirements.

The court examined the quality of interpretation and translation services provided during the RRT hearing, assessing whether the omissions and inaccuracies amounted to a breach of the statutory obligations under section 425. The court also scrutinised the RRT's consideration of the applicant's evidence, particularly in relation to an alleged Muslim plot to attack and kill the applicant in 2007. Furthermore, the court evaluated whether the "Acknowledgement of Application" letter, which invited the applicants to provide additional information without specifying the prescribed response period, complied with the statutory requirements under section 424B.

In its reasoning, the court found that the RRT's interpretation services were inadequate, leading to a breach of the statutory obligations under section 425. The court also determined that the RRT failed to adequately consider the applicant's explanation of perceived inconsistencies in their evidence regarding the alleged attack plot. The court concluded that the "Acknowledgement of Application" letter did not specify the prescribed response period, thus failing to comply with the statutory requirements under section 424B. Consequently, the court found that these issues warranted the quashing of the RRT's decision.

The court issued a writ of certiorari to quash the RRT's decision and a writ of mandamus directing the Minister to reconsider the matter according to law. Additionally, the court ordered the Minister to pay the applicants' costs in the sum of $5,500.00.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

A writ of certiorari issue directed to the Refugee Review Tribunal removing into this Court to be quashed the decision of the Tribunal made on 22 October 2008.

2.

A writ of mandamus be directed to the Second Respondent directing it to reconsider and determine the matter according to law.

3.

The First Respondent to pay the Applicant’s cost assessed in the sum of $5,500.00.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Failure to Consider Relevant EvidenceParticulars (a) The Tribunal found that the Applicant gave inconsistent evidence of his capacity to hear or learn about a Muslim plan to attack and kill the Applicant in 2007. The Tribunal found that the Applicant never provided any details that helped make the story more convincing. In finding so, the Tribunal must have failed to take into account the Applicant’s explanation of the perceived inconsistency.” The Tribunal’s questioning of the applicant in relation to the plan to attack and kill him in 2007 is found at T12 of the Arafeen affidavit [L11 - 50]:“I:My father is still like, you know, very rigid now but still so far he hasn’t seen us and we just – there is this Hindu society is there and if we have like social program in our house and these Hindu people, the do not want to attend that.T:You were staying in your father’s house?I:No, I did not stay at my father’s house.T:Well you say that the conspirators in the mosque were talking about your father’s house and because – and because the people came to your father and talked about his house, you all inferred from that that it was about you. So in your own account of this you’ve created a link between your visit home and your father’s house.I:Your father’s house and what?T:Your visit back home and your father’s house.I:The link?T:Yeah, you’ve created a link. ‘Cause you were talking about the conspirators targeting you and your father’s house and the family’s assumption being that they were talking about the father’s house then they must be talking about you.I:My father did not accept us. Okay, well when there was a discussion of this conspiracy that was going on, my father came to -C SEN: (Foreign language)I:Let me finish. Please repeat that, you were interrupting. When my father landed, the discussion was about our house. Then my father realised, understood that the issue is with us, that these people of Muslim Para, they did not know where, which house we had been living. And then my father realised that, I mean this matter is of grave importance and then – Okay, my father, he sent the intimation to us, through our cousin, that if you are to live, you know, for the safety of your life you leave the place. Then we fled the place and then in the evening, like after dusk, they came in group and they circled our house and they were asking, like the people who have come here.” (emphasis added)The Tribunal’s comment upon this evidence is contained at [CB 385] at [170]:“The reference to people hearing what the Muslims in the mosque were discussing is similar to the disparate claims about what the Applicant’s parents supposedly said to the alleged vigilantes. More significantly, the Applicant gave divergent versions of what then happened: he said that when these people reported what they heard to his father, he and (presumably) his wife (the “us” to whom he referred at the hearing) realised the Muslims must have been discussing him and her. However, he gave evidence at the same hearing to the effect that he had no contact with his father and that he and his wife were hiding from him in another house. In that version of events, he could not have been a witness to the report that he interpreted as having implicated him and his wife. As with the disparate accounts of what his parents supposedly said to the alleged vigilantes, the Applicant gave inconsistent evidence of his capacity to be able to hear or learn what these supposed Hindus said to his father, and he never provided the Tribunal with any details that helped make the story sound more convincing.”. [emphasis added]In his submissions, the applicant focussed on the section of the sentence which is highlighted above. Taken in isolation, this comment of the Tribunal would appear to be inconsistent with the evidence at line 45 of the extract where the applicant says that his father sent intimation to him and his wife through their cousin. The impression may be that the Tribunal overlooked this piece of evidence. However, when the sentence is read as a whole, I am unable to exclude the possibility that what the Tribunal was really saying was that it was unconvinced by the explanation provided. This reading of the Tribunal’s decision is consistent with the cautionary observations of the High Court in Minister for Immigration v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at [271-272] that the administrative decision maker’s reasons are not to be construed minutely and with an eye keenly attuned to error; SZCOQ v Minister for Immigration [2007] FCAFC 9 per Moore J at [14].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Minister’s submissions do not deal with the problems posed by the existence of s.414(1) of the Act:Refugee Review Tribunal must review decisions (1) Subject to subsection (2), if a valid application is made under section 412 for review of an RRT‑reviewable decision, the Tribunal must review the decision. and the views expressed by McHugh J in NAAF of 2002 v Minister for Immigration (2004) 211 ALR 660 at [22] and [23].“The nature of the proceedings before the Tribunal[22]The provisions governing the Tribunal's review of the decision by the Minister's delegate were in Pt 7 Divs 2-7A of the Act. The legislation provided for an inquisitorial, merits-based review by an independent tribunal. As might be expected in view of the importance of the proceedings, particularly for persons in the position of the appellant, the legislation was detailed, and it provided for procedures of some solemnity. [23]Once an applicant had made a valid application for review of a delegate's decision, the Act imposed on the Tribunal a duty to review that decision: s 414(1). It provided that the Tribunal might exercise all the powers and discretions conferred by the Act on the delegate: s 415(1). It obliged the Tribunal to "pursue the objective of providing a mechanism of review that is fair, just, economical, informal and quick": s 420(1). The Secretary of the Department was obliged to give the Tribunal a statement about the decision under review setting out the findings of fact made by the delegate, referring to the evidence on which the findings were based, and giving the reasons for the decision: s 418(2). The Secretary was also obliged to give the Tribunal all other documentary material in the Secretary's possession or control, which the Secretary considered to be relevant to the review: s 418(3). There were provisions by which the applicant for review might supply, and the Tribunal might seek, information: ss 423 and 424. The Act also imposed duties on the Tribunal to supply the applicant with certain information for comment: ss 424A-424C. Section 425(1) compelled the Tribunal to invite the applicant to appear before it and detailed provision was made about the terms of that invitation: ss 425A and 426.” It seems to me to be clear that once an application is filed with the Tribunal the Tribunal is seized of it and any thing that it does in relation to the application is done in “conducting the review”. The letter is significant. It invites the applicant to provide additional information (the original information which the applicant has provided being the information contained in the application to the Tribunal) and the information is required for a particular purpose. That purpose is for the Tribunal to consider whether or not it is prepared to make a decision in the applicant’s favour without the necessity of inviting him to a hearing. This must be “conducting the review”. The additional information provided pursuant to the request thus has a particular importance. It could be more convincing than the applicant himself. The Tribunal might be prepared, on the basis of that information, to grant a visa which it might have declined having heard the applicant. I am unable to accept the Minister’s submissions on this point.