Sunshine Coast Regional Council v D Agostini Property Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND


CITATION:

Sunshine Coast Regional Council v D Agostini Property Pty Ltd & Ors [2019] QPEC 19

PARTIES:

SUNSHINE COAST REGIONAL COUNCIL
(applicant)

v

D AGOSTINI PROPERTY PTY LTD
(first respondent)

and

13 INVESTMENT COMPANY PTY LTD
(second respondent)

and

ROSS WILLIAM MAUDSLEY & MARYA VERONICA MAUDSLEY
(third respondent)

and

ROSSPROP PTY LTD
(fourth respondent)

and

ONCE UPON A TIME ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
(fifth respondent)

and

CEMONE LEITH TIRA
(sixth respondent)

and

XYCON PTY LTD, KYLA MARIE VAGG, STEVEN DOUGLAS MOODY, STEPHEN PETER VAGG AS TRUSTEES
(seventh respondent)

and

LMFC HOLDINGS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE
(eighth respondent)

and

MARION JOSEPHINE CRUTTENDEN
(ninth respondent)

and

VERA BRAZEL & BERNADETTE ANNE MOORE
(tenth respondent)

and

PRICELESS & UNIQUE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
(eleventh respondent)

and

GARRY ANDREW CAMPLIN & KAREN PAMELA CAMPLIN
(twelfth respondent)

and

JOHN ARTHUR HOZIER & DENISE BETTY HOZIER
(thirteenth respondent)

and

RL & CG THOMPSON PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE
(fourteenth respondent)

and

SHUKRY SAHHAR & HELEN SAHHAR
(fifteenth respondent)

and

KAY ELIZABETH SOMERVILLE
(sixteenth respondent)

and

ROBERT JOHN BALMER
(seventeenth respondent)

and

JAMES WILLIAM BROWN
(eighteenth respondent)

and

DIDIER MARIE LAROSE & MAEVA JOSEE ROSE-MAY LAROSE
(nineteenth respondent)

and

MICHAEL JAMES HARRIS & ASMEEN LIZA HARRIS
(twentieth respondent)

and

VIVIAN ELIZABETH GREEN, PHILILP JOHN GREEN, MICHAEL ESKANDER & OLIVIA ESKANDER AS TRUSTEES
(twenty-first respondent)

GREGORY JOHN BOTT & LINDA JULIE BOTT
(twenty-second respondent)

and

HOMESHIELD THE HOME IMPROVERS (SOUTHSIDE) PTY LTD
(twenty-third respondent)

and

KEVIN BRUCE FULFORD
(twenty-fourth respondent)

and

ADRIAN RICHARD ARTHUR WATERS AS TRUSTEE
(twenty-fifth respondent)

and

RICHARD ANTHONY GARDNER & FIONA HEATHER HORNERY
(twenty-sixth respondent)

and

RAOUF NASEIF ISHAG GEORGE
(twenty-seventh respondent)

PETER JOHN JACKSON & LEAH JANE JACKSON AS TRUSTEES
(twenty-eighth respondent)

and

KELLEY SUE LACY
(twenty-ninth respondent)

and

ALISON LOUISE BERNER
(thirtieth respondent)

and

LINDEMAN PTY LTD
(thirty-first respondent)

and

WILLIAM ANTHONY WELFORD PEGLER & ELIZABETH JEAN TOWNS
(thirty-second respondent)

and

STUART REGINALD SIMMONDS & VERITY LOUISE SIMMONDS AS TRUSTEES
(thirty-third respondent)

and

DENISE KAY RUHLE
(thirty-fourth respondent)

and

DAVID NEVILLE RICHARD HANLIN, DULCIE LOUISE HANLAN & RICHARD HENRY HANLIN AS TRUSTEES
(thirty-fifth respondent)

and

ANTHONY JOHN WEST & SANDRA DIANNE WEST
(thirty-sixth respondent)

and

RCR DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
(thirty-seventh respondent)

and

REX WILLIAMS BARNES & JUDI MARGARET BARNES
(thirty-eighth respondent)

and

ROBERT RAYMOND SPRIGGS & BENDA JOY STICKLER|
(thirty-ninth respondent)

and

BRONWYN LOUISE HOWE & PAUL ALEXANDER HOWE
(fortieth respondent)

GRAHAM IAN POWLEY
(forty-first respondent)

and

MICHAEL LOUIS WOODBURY BUGLER
(forty-second respondent)

and

GARY WAYNE JONES & LEE MARGARET JONES
(forty-third respondent)

GARY EDWARD PENROSE
(forty-fourth respondent)

and

BRIAN JOHN PEGLER & NAOMI LORRAINE PEGLER
(forty-fifth respondent)

and

BODY CORPORATE FOR PELICAN WATERS RESORT COMMUNITY TITLES SCHEME 34816
(forty-sixth respondent)

FILE NO/S:

9/2019

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

10 May 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 April 2019

JUDGE:

Reid DCJ

ORDER:

(1) By 3 June 2019 the applicant file and serve on the respondents any material, including certificates, upon which it intends to rely to determine the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunshine Coast Regional Council v D Agostini Property Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QPEC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Sunshine Coast Regional Council versus D Agostini Property Pty Ltd, the case was heard before the Queensland Planning and Environment Court. The dispute involved the interpretation of a clause in a Development Approval that determined the permissible use of residential allotments. The applicant, Sunshine Coast Regional Council, and the respondents, D Agostini Property Pty Ltd and others, sought orders to resolve their disagreement over the use of certain lots. However, they could not agree on the form of these orders.

The central legal issue was the interpretation of a clause in the Development Approval that specified the use of premises for a hotel, motel, function rooms, restaurant, and multiple dwellings. The specific clause in question was condition 5, which related to certain lots on a specified property. The court needed to determine whether the clause limited the use of these lots to temporary accommodation for travelers and holidaymakers or if it allowed for permanent or long-term accommodation as well. Additionally, the court had to define what constituted "temporary accommodation."

The court issued an order setting a timeline for the submission of materials by the applicant and respondents to facilitate the interpretation of the clause. It mandated that the applicant file and serve any relevant material, including certificates, by a specific date. The respondents were then required to respond with their own materials by another date. The court also scheduled a two-day hearing to address the interpretation issue. The hearing was deferred until the interpretation point was resolved. Any respondent who indicated they would not take an active part in the proceedings was excused from participating in the hearing and any further reviews. The application was set for review on a specific date.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) By 3 June 2019 the applicant file and serve on the respondents any material, including certificates, upon which it intends to rely to determine the interpretation point.

(2) By 8 July 2019 the respondent file and serve any materials upon which they intend to rely to determine the interpretation point.

(3) By 22 July 2019, the applicant file and serve on the active respondents any material in reply.

(4) The interpretation point be set down for hearing for two days commencing on 8 August 2019.

(5) The interpretation point is:

The interpretation of the decision notice dated 17 October 2003 for the use of premises for the purposes of a Hotel, Motel, Function Rooms, Restaurant and Multiple Dwelling, including condition 5 for that part of the premises identified as lots 201-218, 301-318 and 401-418 on SP 168156 and whether it:

(a) limits the use of that part of the premises to use for temporary accommodation of travelling and/or holidaymakers only; or

(b) allows that part of the premises to be used for permanent and/or long term accommodation as well as temporary accommodation for travellers and/or holidaymakers; and

(c) what temporary accommodation means.

(6) The hearing of the proceeding, including issues relating to the court’s discretion, be deferred pending the determination of the interpretation point.

(7) Any respondent that has given, or at any time gives, notice to the applicant to the effect that they will not take an active part in the Originating Application, is excused from participating in and appearing at the hearing (and any further reviews) of the Originating Application.

(8) The application can be listed for review on 19 July 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established