PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
SENIOR JUDGE SKOIEN
P & E Application No 358 of 2004
| JENNY-ANNE DILLON AND OTHERS AS SET OUT IN SCHEDULE 1 | Applicants |
| and | |
| DOUGLAS SHIRE COUNCIL | Respondent |
CAIRNS
..DATE 06/09/2004
JUDGMENT
HIS HONOUR: I adjourned this matter on the 1st of September 2004. I have had the opportunity of thinking about this matter over the intervening five days. The application which founds this hearing seeks declarations on the meaning and construction of a temporary local planning instrument of the respondent council and a section of the draft Integrated Planning Act Scheme for the Douglas Shire.
Mr Tudehope, who owns land in the area which is the subject of the TLPI and the draft section, seeks to become a respondent on the basis that these provisions purport to restrict his right to build on his land. Indeed, his argument, logically extended, is that all landholders in the area should be joined as respondents. The evidence establishes there are 836 other landholders and the cost of identifying all of them by reference to the council records would be $8,360. Obviously apart from that sum there would be a great deal of extra cost in amending the application to name them all and in serving each of them.
Rule 8 of the Planning and Environment Court Rules of 1999 require that an originating application name as respondents persons "directly affected by the relief sought in it". The question therefore is whether Mr Tudehope is directly affected by the application.
The word "directly" is a common word in the English language and, to my mind, it is well understood. Relevantly it means "immediately" or "straightaway". If an originating application seeks an order that a person do something or refrain from doing something, that person is directly affected. Here, the council is directly affected because immediately the Court declares the meaning of the provisions, the council will be bound to administer them in a way consistent with the interpretation and declarations.
However the declarations which the Court may make, if it makes any, will not require Mr Tudehope immediately to do or not to do anything. If it affects him, that effect will be indirect. By way of analogy let us consider the situation in which a Court is asked to make a declaration or interpret a provision, for example, of the Income Tax Act. The Commissioner of Taxation would, of course, be directly affected and would be a respondent to the proceeding. Every taxpayer in Australia could be indirectly affected according to the result of the Court hearing. But it has never been the case that every taxpayer in Australia has to be made a respondent to applications of that sort, or actions of that sort.
Similarly, let us take the case of a motorist affected by, say, a prosecution under the Traffic Act or Regulations who, in Court proceedings, seeks some sort of an order as to the meaning of and effect of a section of the Act or…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dillon v Douglas Shire Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] QPEC 50
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether Mr. Tudehope was directly affected by the application, and therefore, should be joined as a respondent. The court found that the term "directly affected" meant "immediately" or "straightaway." If an originating application sought an order that a person do something or refrain from doing something, that person was directly affected. However, the court held that the declarations which the court may make, if it made any, would not require Mr. Tudehope immediately to do or not to do anything. If it affected him, that effect would be indirect. The court concluded that it was not necessary to join Mr. Tudehope as a respondent to the proceeding.
The court also considered the matter of the scandalous material contained within Mr. Tudehope's affidavit, which it decided to remove from the court file. Finally, the court addressed the application for directions, ordering as per the draft initialled by the court and placed with the papers. The court further noted that it would prepare reasons in relation to the other matter and make an order accordingly.
This case provides guidance on the meaning of "directly affected" in the context of planning and environment proceedings and highlights the importance of joining the appropriate parties to a proceeding. It also underscores the court's discretion to remove scandalous material from the court file and the importance of following court rules and procedures.