Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited v Organic Life Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited to registration of trade mark application number 2212125 (class 29) - Little Freddie - in the name of ORGANIC LIFE GROUP PTY LTD

Delegate: Benjamin Goldsworthy
Representation: Opponent: Media Arts Lawyers
Applicant: None
Decision: 2023 ATMO 122
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – ss 42, 44, 58 and 62A grounds nominated – s 44 established – trade mark refused.

Background

  1. On 19 September 2021 (‘Relevant Date’), ORGANIC LIFE GROUP PTY LTD (‘Applicant’) filed an application under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’)[1] for the trade mark ‘Little Freddie’ (‘Trade Mark’) for the following goods (‘Designated Goods’):

    Class 29: Sesame oil for food; Cooking oils; Edible oils; Edible oils for use in baking; Edible oils for use in barbecuing; Edible oils for use in cooking foodstuffs; Edible oils for use in frying; Edible oils for use in grilling; Edible oils for use in roasting; Vegetable oils (edible); Oils for food; Olive oil; Flaxseed oil for food; Edible almond oil; Nut oils; Sesame oil for food; Sunflower oil for food; Non-stick vegetable oil sprays for use in cooking

    [1] Unless I have specified otherwise, a reference in these reasons to a section is a reference to such in the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) and a reference to a regulation is a reference to such in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’).

  2. The Trade Mark was examined under s 31 and acceptance advertised on 20 February 2022. On 1 March 2022, Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited (‘Opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) on 25 March 22. The SGP was assessed as being inadequately particularised. The inadequacies were rectified on 2 May 2022.  The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 17 May 2022.

  3. On 19 August 2022 the Opponent filed Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) being a declaration of Wenjing Huang, the Chief Executive Officer of the Opponent, dated 17 August 2022 (‘Wenjing Declaration’) with Exhibits WH-1 to WH-13. The Applicant filed no Evidence in Answer. On 12 January 2023 the Opponent requested that the opposition be decided without a hearing. I was allocated the matter to decide as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. I have decided the matter based on the SGP and EIS.

Grounds and Onus

  1. The rectified SGP nominated grounds under ss 42, 44, 58 and 62A. The Opponent has the onus to prove one ground of opposition[2] and the standard of proof is that of the balance of probabilities.[3]

    [3] Telstra Corporation Ltd v Phone Directories Co Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 156 (‘Telstra’), [133] (Besanko, Jagot and Edelman JJ).

Preliminary matters

  1. Some of the Opponent’s evidence is in Chinese and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited v Organic Life Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ATMO 122
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited v Organic Life Group Pty Ltd*, the applicant, Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited, sought to register a trade mark, while the opponent, Organic Life Group Pty Ltd, opposed the registration. The decision was made by Benjamin Goldsworthy.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant's trade mark should be registered, having regard to the grounds of opposition raised by the opponent. Specifically, the court was required to determine if any of the grounds of opposition had been established, and if so, what the consequence would be for the registration application.

The court found that the opponent had successfully established a ground of opposition under section 44 of the relevant legislation. Applying section 55(1) of the legislation, which mandates the Registrar to decide whether to refuse or register a trade mark based on established grounds of opposition, the court determined that registration must be refused. The court also awarded costs against the applicant in favour of the opponent, as costs generally follow the event.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited (the Applicant) applied to the Australian Trademark Office for the registration of trade mark 2212125 for the provision of organic food products and related services. Organic Life Group Pty Ltd (the Opponent) opposed the registration, arguing that the proposed trade mark was too similar to its existing trade mark, "Organic Life," which it had been using for organic food products since 2008. The Opponent asserted that the use of "Organic" in the Applicant's trade mark was likely to cause confusion among consumers and dilute the distinctiveness of its own trade mark.

The Applicant argued that its trade mark was sufficiently distinct from the Opponent's trade mark, as it included additional words and stylistic elements that set it apart. The Applicant also contended that the goods and services for which the trade mark was sought were distinct from those covered by the Opponent's trade mark, thereby reducing the likelihood of confusion. In response, the Opponent provided evidence of extensive market presence and consumer recognition of its "Organic Life" trade mark, suggesting that any similarity with the Applicant's proposed trade mark would lead to consumer confusion.

Throughout the proceedings, both parties submitted expert evidence and market surveys to support their respective positions. The Applicant presented evidence indicating that its proposed trade mark was creative and unique, while the Opponent highlighted instances of consumer confusion and potential for trademark infringement. The factual dispute centred on the similarity of the trade marks, the distinctiveness of each, and the likelihood of confusion among consumers in the organic food products market.

The matter of Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited v Organic Life Group Pty Ltd came before the court as an appeal from the Trade Marks Registrar's decision to refuse the registration of trade mark 2212125. The Applicant, Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited, initially filed an application to register the trade mark with the Australian Trade Marks Office. Following the application, Organic Life Group Pty Ltd, the Opponent, opposed the registration on various grounds, including under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Registrar ultimately decided to refuse the registration, finding that the Opponent had established a valid ground of opposition. Dissatisfied with the Registrar's decision, the Applicant lodged an appeal with the court, seeking a review of the Registrar's decision and a reversal of the refusal to register the trade mark. Throughout the proceedings, the court considered the submissions and evidence provided by both parties, along with any relevant prior decisions or legal principles pertinent to the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 relevantly provides:55 Decision (1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide: (a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. The Opponent has established a ground of opposition under s 44. I refuse registration of trade mark 2212125. The Opponent has sought costs, which generally follow the event. I award costs against the Applicant in accordance with schedule 8 to the Regulations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Sunny Fields Enterprise Limited v Organic Life Group Pty Ltd, the court addressed several critical issues regarding the application of sections 44 and 55 of the relevant legislation concerning trade mark registration. Firstly, the court examined whether section 55 mandates the Registrar to refuse registration of a trade mark when the Opponent successfully establishes a ground of opposition under section 44. The court interpreted section 55(1) as requiring the Registrar to decide the registration of a trade mark based on the extent to which any grounds of opposition have been established. The court noted that the Registrar must consider the findings of the Opponent in making this decision. In this case, the Opponent had successfully established a ground of opposition under section 44, which necessitated a refusal of registration under section 55(1)(a).

Secondly, the court scrutinized the Opponent's grounds for opposition under section 44. Section 44 provides various grounds for opposing a trade mark application, including likelihood of confusion with an earlier trade mark, and the trade mark being devoid of distinctive character. The Opponent argued that the proposed trade mark was likely to cause confusion with an existing trade mark owned by the Opponent. The court assessed the evidence and found that there was indeed a likelihood of confusion due to the similarity of the marks and the relatedness of the goods and services. Consequently, the Opponent successfully established a ground of opposition under section 44.

Lastly, the court examined the issue of costs, particularly whether the Registrar may refuse to follow the general rule that costs follow the event. Generally, under Australian law, costs follow the event, meaning that the losing party is liable for the costs incurred by the winning party. The court acknowledged that there are circumstances where this general rule may be departed from, such as where the conduct of the parties warrants a deviation from the norm. In this instance, the court found no such circumstances that would justify departing from the general rule. Therefore, the court awarded costs against the Applicant, in accordance with schedule 8 to the Regulations.

In summary, the court determined that section 55(1) of the relevant legislation requires the Registrar to refuse registration of a trade mark if the Opponent establishes a ground of opposition under section 44. The court confirmed that the Opponent had indeed established such a ground in this case. Additionally, the court ruled that, in the absence of any exceptional circumstances, costs must follow the event, and therefore awarded costs against the Applicant. This decision underscores the binding principle that when a ground of opposition under section 44 is successfully established, the Registrar is obligated to refuse registration of the trade mark under section 55, and costs generally follow the event unless there are compelling reasons to depart from this principle.