Sun North Investments Pty Ltd as trustee v Dale

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sun North Investments Pty Ltd as trustee v Dale & Anor [2013] QSC 44

PARTIES:

SUN NORTH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 010 436 469 as trustee of the SUN DEVELOPMENT TRUST (plaintiff/first defendant by counterclaim)
v
DAVID JEFFREY DALE
(defendant/plaintiff by counterclaim)
and
LUIGI ALFIO GAROZZO
(second defendant by counterclaim)

FILE NO/S:

S 5543 of 2010 (Brisbane registry)

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

28 February 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATES:


15, 16, 17 and 18 October 2012

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

The call option deed made between the plaintiff and defendant and executed on or about 5 June 2009 is declared void. 1.          

The defendant will deliver to the plaintiff:2.          

(a)a release duly executed by the defendant of the fixed charge made between the plaintiff and the defendant and executed by the plaintiff on or about 28 April 2009;         

(b)an Australian Securities and Investments Commission form 312 in respect of such release, duly executed by the defendant;        

(c)the undated standard share transfer form executed by the plaintiff in respect of its $1,200,000 fully paid ordinary shares in Sugarworld Pty Ltd.         

The counterclaim is dismissed.3.          

I will hear the parties as to costs and any other orders they contend are necessary to give proper effect to my findings.4.          

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY – EQUITABLE REMEDIES – UNCONSCIONABLE BARGAINS - REMEDIES OF MORTGAGOR – REDEMPTION – PENALTY – RELEIF AGAINST FORFEITURE - where defendant loaned funds to plaintiff secured by a fixed charge – where call option to buy shares in plaintiff company – where call option exercised by defendant – whether option was a separate transaction to loan – whether is a clog on the equity of redemption – whether the traditional rule against clogs on the equity of redemption has been narrowed by Australian courts - whether exercise of option constitutes a penalty – whether relief against forfeiture should be granted.

MORTGAGES – REMEDIES OF MORTGAGEE – REDEMPTION – whether option is part of the same lending transaction or a separate transaction – whether option extinguishes the plaintiff’s right to redeem the shares – whether the rule against clogs on the equity of redemption applies only if there has been unconscionable conduct – whether option is void.

CONTRACT – COUNTERCLAIM - BREACH – DAMAGES - REPUDIATION – where defendant counterclaims alleging breach of contract – whether seeking a determination of legal rights evinces an intention not to be bound by the contract.

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (2012) 86 ALJR 1002

Baker v Biddle (1923) St R Qd 46

Chase Corporation v North Sydney Brick & Tile (1994) 35 NSWLR 1

DC Wagemaker & Sons v Commonwealth Development Bank (1970) 91 WN(NSW) 617

Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v New Garage and Motor Co Ltd [1915] AC 79

Epic Feast Pty Ltd v Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd (1998) SASR 161

Fairclough v Swan Brewery Co (1912) AC 565

Kreglinger v New…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sun North Investments Pty Ltd as trustee v Dale and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QSC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sun North Investments Pty Ltd as trustee for the Sun North Superannuation Fund v Dale involved a dispute between the plaintiff, a trustee of a superannuation fund, and the defendant, who had loaned funds secured by a fixed charge and a call option to purchase shares in the plaintiff’s company. The plaintiff argued that the call option constituted an unconscionable bargain and a clog on the equity of redemption, while the defendant claimed the option was a separate transaction from the loan and was not a clog on redemption. The court was required to decide whether the option was part of the same lending transaction or a separate transaction, whether the option extinguished the plaintiff’s right to redeem the shares, and whether the rule against clogs on the equity of redemption applies only if there has been unconscionable conduct.

The court determined that the call option deed was void as it constituted a clog on the equity of redemption. The court held that the option was part of the same lending transaction as the loan and therefore extinguished the plaintiff’s right to redeem the shares. The court found that the traditional rule against clogs on the equity of redemption has not been narrowed by Australian courts and that the exercise of the option constituted a penalty. The court also held that relief against forfeiture should be granted in this case. The court dismissed the defendant’s counterclaim, finding that seeking a determination of legal rights did not evince an intention not to be bound by the contract.

The court ordered that the call option deed made between the plaintiff and defendant and executed on or about 5 June 2009 be declared void. The defendant was ordered to deliver to the plaintiff a release of the fixed charge, an Australian Securities and Investments Commission form 312 in respect of such release, and the undated standard share transfer form executed by the plaintiff in respect of its $1,200,000 fully paid ordinary shares in Sugarworld Pty Ltd. The court reserved costs and any other orders that the parties might contend were necessary to give proper effect to the court’s findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The call option deed made between the plaintiff and defendant and executed on or about 5 June 2009 is declared void. 1.

The defendant will deliver to the plaintiff:2.

(a)a release duly executed by the defendant of the fixed charge made between the plaintiff and the defendant and executed by the plaintiff on or about 28 April 2009;

(b)an Australian Securities and Investments Commission form 312 in respect of such release, duly executed by the defendant;

(c)the undated standard share transfer form executed by the plaintiff in respect of its $1,200,000 fully paid ordinary shares in Sugarworld Pty Ltd.

The counterclaim is dismissed.3.

I will hear the parties as to costs and any other orders they contend are necessary to give proper effect to my findings.4.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established