Epic Feast Pty Ltd v Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

EPIC FEAST PTY LTD v MAWSON KLM HOLDINGS
PTY LTD (IN LIQ) AND STARMAKER (NO.51) PTY LTD

Full Court

Debelle J

This is an appeal from the decision of a judge of this court ordering a caveator to remove its caveat on the ground that it did not have a caveatable interest.

The caveator was the appellant Epic Feast Pty Ltd (“Epic Feast”).  The caveat was lodged on 25 October 1996 and endorsed on the relevant Certificate of Title on 30 October 1996.  On 25 October the registered proprietor of the land was the respondent Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd (“Mawson”). On 8 November 1996 Mawson transferred the land to Starmaker (No.51) Pty Ltd (“Starmaker”).  The transfer was expressly stated to be subject to the caveat.  The transfer has been registered.  The registration of the transfer does not defeat the rights of Epic Feast as caveator.  Instead, the interest of Starmaker is subject to whatever interest Epic Feast can establish pursuant to the caveat: Coles KMA Ltd v Sword Nominees Pty Ltd (1986) 44 SASR 120; Leros Pty Ltd v Terera Pty Ltd (1992) 174 CLR 407 at 420.

The interest claimed by Epic Feast is described in the caveat in the following terms:

“An Estate and Interest as Equitable Mortgagee under and by virtue of a Loan Agreement dated 13 September 1996 between the said Caveator and the said Caveatee in the sum of $400,000 (Four Hundred Thousand Dollars) plus interests, costs and other charges.”

The trial judge found that Epic Feast had lent amounts to Mawson totalling $310,000, not $400,000 as claimed in the caveat; that on 13 September 1996 the parties had orally agreed that Mawson would grant a mortgage over the land to secure repayment of the loan but that there was no memorandum in writing of the agreement to grant the mortgage; and that, because the agreement was not specifically enforceable, Epic Feast did not have an interest as equitable mortgagee. As Epic Feast did not have an equitable interest, the trial judge ordered that the caveat be removed.  The judge further ordered that, even if Epic Feast could establish that it had an equitable mortgage, its equitable interest had to rank after an earlier equitable interest Starmaker had in the land by reason of an option to purchase granted to it on 9 July 1996. 

Epic Feast raises three broad issues on this appeal.  The first is that the amount of the loan was $400,000 and not $310,000 as found.  The second is that it did have an equitable mortgage.  The third is that its equitable interest does not rank after the equitable interest of Starmaker.   Starmaker not only seeks to uphold the judgment but contends that there was never any clear agreement between Epic Feast and Mawson that Mawson would grant a mortgage.  Some time after these dealings in the land, an order was made in this court winding up Mawson. Mawson took no part in the trial.  It did not present…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Epic Feast Pty Ltd v Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6616
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

EPIC FEAST PTY LTD v MAWSON KLM HOLDINGS PTY LTD (IN LIQ) AND STARMAKER (NO.51) PTY LTD is an appeal from the decision of a judge of this court ordering a caveator to remove its caveat on the ground that it did not have a caveatable interest. The caveator was Epic Feast Pty Ltd. The trial judge found that Epic Feast had lent amounts to Mawson totalling $310,000, not $400,000 as claimed in the caveat. The trial judge further found that on 13 September 1996 the parties had orally agreed that Mawson would grant a mortgage over the land to secure repayment of the loan but that there was no memorandum in writing of the agreement to grant the mortgage. Because the agreement was not specifically enforceable, Epic Feast did not have an interest as equitable mortgagee. As Epic Feast did not have an equitable interest, the trial judge ordered that the caveat be removed. Epic Feast raises three broad issues on this appeal. The first is that the amount of the loan was $400,000 and not $310,000 as found. The second is that it did have an equitable mortgage. The third is that its equitable interest does not rank after the equitable interest of Starmaker. The Full Court held that the appeal should be dismissed. The Full Court found that Epic Feast had failed to establish that it held an equitable mortgage. The Full Court further found that the equitable interest of Starmaker would prevail over any equitable interest held by Epic Feast.

Background

Background to the litigation

Epic Feast Pty Ltd lodged a caveat on land owned by Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd on 25 October 1996, claiming an equitable mortgage over the land. The land was subsequently transferred to Starmaker (No.51) Pty Ltd on 8 November 1996, with the transfer expressly subject to the caveat. Epic Feast claimed that it had loaned Mawson $400,000 on 13 September 1996, with an agreement to grant a mortgage over the land as security. Mawson, however, did not repay the loan as agreed and failed to provide a written memorandum of the agreement to grant a mortgage. Epic Feast later sought to enforce the alleged agreement, leading to the current legal dispute over the validity of the caveat.

This case is an appeal from a decision made by a judge of the Full Court. The original decision ordered the removal of the caveat on the ground that Epic Feast did not have a caveatable interest. The appeal was brought by Epic Feast, who contested the trial judge's findings regarding the amount of the loan, the existence of an equitable mortgage, and the priority of their interest compared to Starmaker's interest.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there is an enforceable agreement by which Mawson agreed to grant Epic Feast an equitable mortgage.
2. What is the correct amount of the loan secured by the mortgage.
3. What is the priority between the equitable interests of Epic Feast and Starmaker?

Held
1. The appeal is dismissed. The trial judge's decision that Epic Feast Pty Ltd did not have an equitable mortgage over the Estcourt House land is upheld. The order requiring Epic Feast to remove its caveat on the land is affirmed.
2. The amount of the loan secured by the mortgage is confirmed to be $310,000, not $400,000 as claimed by Epic Feast.
3. The equitable interest of Starmaker, arising from an option to purchase the land granted on 9 July 1996, takes priority over any equitable interest that Epic Feast may have held.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court considered three main issues in the appeal: the existence of an enforceable agreement for an equitable mortgage, the correct amount of the loan, and the priority of interests between Epic Feast and Starmaker. The court found that Epic Feast failed to establish an enforceable agreement for an equitable mortgage over the Estcourt House land, primarily due to the lack of a sufficient written memorandum under the Statute of Frauds. Although there was an oral agreement on 13 September 1996 for Mawson to grant a mortgage, this agreement did not mention a mortgage, and the loan agreement document did not reference any security. The court also found that the amount of the loan was $310,000, not $400,000 as claimed by Epic Feast, based on the evidence presented at trial. Regarding the priority of interests, the court upheld the trial judge's decision that Starmaker's equitable interest, arising from an option to purchase the land granted on 9 July 1996, took priority over any equitable interest Epic Feast may have had. The court noted that Starmaker's option to purchase was earlier in time and, under general equitable principles, this earlier equitable interest prevails over later ones. The court refrained from expressing a concluded view on whether Starmaker's option to purchase was a clog on the equity of redemption, as this issue was not fully explored at trial.