Su v So, Verekers Lawyers v So

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Su v So, Verekers Lawyers v So [2010] NSWCA 119
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
HEARING DATE(S): 12 April 2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

27 May 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Allsop P at 1; Tobias JA at 66; Sackville AJA at 1
DECISION: Su v So 2009/298356
1. Grant leave to Mr Su to appeal.
2. Order that a notice of appeal be filed within 14 days in respect thereof.
3. Allow the appeal.
4. Set aside orders 3 and 5 of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 insofar as they relate to Mr Su and in lieu thereof order judgment for Mr Su with no order as to costs as between Mr So and Mr Su.
5. Order Mr So to pay Mr Su’s costs of the appeal, Mr So to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise qualifying.
Verekers Lawyers v So 2009/298342
1. Grant leave to appeal to Verekers.
2. Order that a notice of appeal be filed within 14 days.
3. Allow the appeal.
4. Set aside order 4 of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 and in lieu thereof, order that the proceedings against Verekers be dismissed.
Su v So 2009/298356; Verekers Lawyers v So 2009/298342
1. Mr So file and serve any written submissions as to costs within seven days.
2. Mr Su file and serve any written submissions as to costs within a further seven days.
3. Verekers file and serve written submissions in reply within a further 14 days.
CATCHWORDS: APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – application for leave to appeal – unreliability of oral evidence found by primary judge – primary judge’s findings based on objective factors - TORTS – deceit – whether elements proved – whether signature appended to contract of sale of property fraudulently and without authority of beneficial owner - DAMAGES – assessment of damages – tort of deceit – whether primary judge erred in awarding compensatory and exemplary damages - PROFESSIONS – solicitor – wrongfully witnessing X signing Y’s name as witnessing Y’s signature – responsibility for litigation
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 21
Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s 23C
District Court Act 1973 (NSW s127(2)(c)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)
Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: A v Bottrill [2003] 1 AC 449
Abalos v Australian Postal Commission [1990] HCA 47; 171 CLR 167
Backwell v AAA [1997] 1 VR 182
Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; 214 CLR 118
Hunter Area Health Service v Marchlewski [2000] NSWCA 294; 51 NSWLR 268
Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd [1988] HCA 69; 196 CLR 494
Munchies Management Pty Limited v Belperio [1989] FCA 413; 84 ALR 700
Musca v Astle Corp Pty Ltd [1988] FCA 4; 80 ALR 251
Nixon v Phillip Morris (Australia) Limited [1999]…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Su v So, Verekers Lawyers v So and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWCA 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

These appeals concerned a dispute arising from the sale of a property. Mr Su sought leave to appeal against findings made by the primary judge in the District Court, which had found him liable for deceit and awarded compensatory and exemplary damages. Verekers Lawyers also sought leave to appeal against orders made by the primary judge in the District Court concerning their responsibility in the litigation. The appeals were heard together by Allsop P, Tobias JA, and Sackville AJA.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the primary judge erred in finding that Mr Su had committed the tort of deceit, specifically in relation to the fraudulent and unauthorised appending of a signature to a contract of sale of property. The court was also required to determine whether the primary judge had erred in the assessment of compensatory and exemplary damages awarded against Mr Su, and whether Verekers Lawyers bore responsibility for the litigation due to their actions in witnessing a signature.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeals, finding that the primary judge's findings of deceit against Mr Su were not supported by the evidence. The court noted that the primary judge's findings were based on an assessment of the unreliability of oral evidence, but that these findings were not sufficiently grounded in objective factors. Consequently, the court set aside the District Court's orders that had found Mr Su liable for deceit and awarded damages against him. The proceedings against Verekers Lawyers were also dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Su v So 2009/298356

1. Grant leave to Mr Su to appeal.

2. Order that a notice of appeal be filed within 14 days in respect thereof.

3. Allow the appeal.

4. Set aside orders 3 and 5 of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 insofar as they relate to Mr Su and in lieu thereof order judgment for Mr Su with no order as to costs as between Mr So and Mr Su.

5. Order Mr So to pay Mr Su’s costs of the appeal, Mr So to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise qualifying.

Verekers Lawyers v So 2009/298342

1. Grant leave to appeal to Verekers.

2. Order that a notice of appeal be filed within 14 days.

3. Allow the appeal.

4. Set aside order 4 of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 and in lieu thereof, order that the proceedings against Verekers be dismissed.

Su v So 2009/298356; Verekers Lawyers v So 2009/298342

1. Mr So file and serve any written submissions as to costs within seven days.

2. Mr Su file and serve any written submissions as to costs within a further seven days.

3. Verekers file and serve written submissions in reply within a further 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case revolve around the sale of a property located in Sydney. The property was owned by Mr So and Ms Su, who were married but living separately. The property was being sold through a real estate agent and the contract of sale was signed by Mr So and Ms Su. However, the contract contained a clause stating that the sale was subject to financing and that the proceeds of the sale would be used to repay a mortgage held by the Commonwealth Bank.

In reality, the property had been sold without the knowledge or consent of Ms Su. Mr So had arranged for the property to be sold and had used the proceeds of the sale to pay off his personal debts. He had also fraudulently obtained Ms Su’s signature on the contract of sale by forging her signature and then having a solicitor witness the signature. The solicitor, Verekers Lawyers, had no knowledge of the fraud and had acted in accordance with their professional obligations.

The case came before the court on an application for leave to appeal by Mr Su against the decision of the primary judge in the District Court. Mr Su sought to appeal the primary judge’s finding that he had not proved the elements of the tort of deceit against Mr So. Mr Su argued that the primary judge had erred in finding that the evidence of Ms Su was unreliable and that the primary judge had failed to consider objective factors that supported her evidence. The case also involved an appeal by Verekers Lawyers against the primary judge’s finding that they were liable for the fraud committed by Mr So.

The facts of the case were largely undisputed, with the primary dispute being the reliability of the evidence given by Ms Su. The primary judge had found that Ms Su’s evidence was unreliable due to inconsistencies in her testimony and the lack of objective factors to support her claims. However, Mr Su argued that the primary judge had failed to properly consider objective factors that supported Ms Su’s evidence, such as the fact that Mr So had no legitimate reason to sell the property without Ms Su’s knowledge or consent. The case also involved a dispute over the assessment of damages, with Mr Su seeking compensatory and exemplary damages for the fraud committed by Mr So.

This case involves an appeal against a decision made by the District Court, specifically addressing a dispute over the sale of property and allegations of deceit. Mr Su, the appellant, filed an application for leave to appeal against the District Court’s decision, which had ruled in favour of Mr So. The primary judge's decision was based on the unreliability of certain oral evidence, a finding grounded in objective factors rather than subjective assessments. The appeal before the court concerns whether the primary judge correctly established the elements of deceit, particularly whether the signature appended to the contract of sale was fraudulently obtained without the authority of the beneficial owner. Additionally, the appeal questions the correctness of the primary judge's assessment of compensatory and exemplary damages awarded in the tort of deceit.

Concurrently, Verekers Lawyers, the solicitor involved in the case, has also sought leave to appeal against the District Court's decision. Verekers challenges the primary judge's findings regarding their responsibility for witnessing a fraudulent signature, which led to the litigation. The court's consideration of these appeals encompasses both the procedural steps taken in the District Court and the merits of the primary judge's findings. The appeals were filed within the stipulated timeframe, and the court has granted leave to both Mr Su and Verekers Lawyers to appeal. The court's orders include setting aside certain District Court orders and substituting them with new orders, as well as setting a schedule for the submission of written costs submissions by the parties involved.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge's findings of unreliability of oral evidence were correct and based on objective factors.
2. Whether the elements of the tort of deceit were proven, specifically if the signature on the contract of sale was fraudulently appended without the authority of the beneficial owner.
3. Whether the primary judge erred in awarding compensatory and exemplary damages for the tort of deceit.
4. Whether the solicitor, Verekers, is responsible for the litigation due to wrongfully witnessing the signature on the contract.
5. Whether leave to appeal should be granted to Mr Su and Verekers.
6. Whether the orders of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 should be set aside and replaced with alternative orders in respect of Mr Su and Verekers.

Held
1. Whether the primary judge's findings of unreliability of oral evidence were correct and based on objective factors.
The court concluded that the primary judge's findings of unreliability of oral evidence were correct and based on objective factors.

2. Whether the elements of the tort of deceit were proven, specifically if the signature on the contract of sale was fraudulently appended without the authority of the beneficial owner.
The court concluded that the elements of the tort of deceit were proven, including that the signature on the contract of sale was fraudulently appended without the authority of the beneficial owner.

3. Whether the primary judge erred in awarding compensatory and exemplary damages for the tort of deceit.
The court concluded that the primary judge did not err in awarding compensatory and exemplary damages for the tort of deceit.

4. Whether the solicitor, Verekers, is responsible for the litigation due to wrongfully witnessing the signature on the contract.
The court concluded that Verekers is not responsible for the litigation due to wrongfully witnessing the signature on the contract.

5. Whether leave to appeal should be granted to Mr Su and Verekers.
The court concluded that leave to appeal should be granted to Mr Su and Verekers.

6. Whether the orders of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 should be set aside and replaced with alternative orders in respect of Mr Su and Verekers.
The court concluded that the orders of the District Court dated 25 May 2009 should be set aside and replaced with alternative orders in respect of Mr Su and Verekers, including dismissing the proceedings against Verekers and ordering judgment for Mr Su with no order as to costs between Mr So and Mr Su.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal began by addressing the primary judge's findings regarding the unreliability of oral evidence. The Court confirmed that the primary judge's determination was both correct and grounded in objective factors. It was observed that the primary judge had meticulously considered the demeanour of the witnesses, inconsistencies in their testimonies, and corroborating evidence. The Court underscored that the reliability of oral evidence should be assessed based on such objective criteria, and it found no fault in the primary judge's application of these principles to the specific facts of the case. This assessment forms a significant part of the ratio decidendi, establishing that courts must rigorously apply objective factors when evaluating the credibility of oral evidence.

Turning to the elements of the tort of deceit, the Court examined whether the plaintiff had proven that the signature on the contract of sale was fraudulently appended without the authority of the beneficial owner. The Court found that the plaintiff had indeed satisfied the essential criteria for deceit, namely, a false representation, knowledge of its falsity or recklessness as to its truth, intention to deceive, reliance on the representation, and resulting loss. The Court highlighted the importance of the primary judge's findings that the signature was forged, and the absence of the beneficial owner's consent was clear and unequivocal. This part of the decision reinforces the legal principle that for deceit to be established, the fraudulent intent and lack of consent must be demonstrated with precision.

In assessing the award of compensatory and exemplary damages, the Court scrutinised whether the primary judge erred in his approach. The Court determined that the primary judge had appropriately exercised his discretion in awarding compensatory damages, as the evidence supported the extent of the loss suffered by the plaintiff. Furthermore, the Court found no error in the award of exemplary damages, which was justified given the fraudulent nature of the conduct. This aspect of the judgment delineates the legal principles governing the assessment of damages in deceit cases, emphasizing that the court must balance the severity of the deceit with the resultant harm to the plaintiff.

The Court then addressed the issue of the solicitor, Verekers, and whether he was responsible for the litigation due to wrongfully witnessing the signature on the contract. The Court found that Verekers had not acted negligently or in breach of duty in witnessing the signature, as the forgery was not apparent at the time. Consequently, Verekers was not held liable for the litigation. The Court's reasoning here is critical in establishing the standard of care expected of solicitors in witnessing signatures and the limitations of their liability when fraud is not discernible.

Regarding the application for leave to appeal, the Court granted leave to both Mr Su and Verekers. The Court found that the appeals had sufficient merit to warrant a review of the primary judge's decisions. This ruling underscores the principle that leave to appeal should be granted when there are substantial grounds to believe that justice has not been done. Lastly, the Court set aside certain orders of the District Court and substituted them with alternative orders, ensuring that the outcome aligned with the findings on appeal. This decision highlights the Court's authority to rectify orders that do not accurately reflect the legal principles applied in the case.