Su v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SU & ANOR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2016] FCCA 83
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Subclass 857 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) (Class BW) visa – whether applicant commenced nominated employment within 6 months of grant of visa – where tribunal held applicant had not commenced nominated employment on a full-time basis – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.137Q(1), 137(T), 474(2)

Migration Regulations 1994, reg.2.50AA

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 84 ALJR 369
First Applicant: HA SU
Second Applicant: LU LI
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: BRG 494 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Jarrett
Hearing date: 21 October 2015
Date of Last Submission: 21 October 2015
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 19 January 2016

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Thackeray
Solicitors for the Applicants: VSTAR Lawyers and Consultants Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Richardson
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz

The second respondent entered a submitting appearance.

ORDERS

  1. The amended application filed on 30 September, 2015 be dismissed.

  2. The first applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application, including reserved costs, if any, fixed in the sum of $6,825.00.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT BRISBANE

BRG 494 of 2015

HA SU

First Applicant

LU LI
Second Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the second respondent made on 8 May, 2015 to affirm a decision of a delegate of the first respondent to cancel the first applicant’s subclass 857 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) visa.

  2. The first respondent opposes the application and the second respondent enters a submitting appearance.

  3. Both parties have filed written submissions to which I have paid regard.

  4. Before proceeding further, something should be said about the position of the second applicant. As the first respondent’s written submission point out, because the decision record of the tribunal named the second applicant as a party to the tribunal’s review, he may be a party to the application before this Court. But the tribunal only had jurisdiction to review a decision that related to the first applicant. There was no decision in relation to the second applicant. His visa was dependent upon the existence of the first applicant’s visa. Upon that visa being cancelled, the second applicant’s visa was cancelled by force of s.137T of the Migration Act 1958. The outcome of this judicial review application (and any later decision by the tribunal, if so ordered), will affect the second applicant, as the first respondent puts it, “in a self-executing way”.

Background

  1. The applicants are citizens of the People’s Republic of China.

  2. On 2 March, 2011 the applicant applied to the first respondent’s department for a subclass 857 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) (Class BW) visa.  At the time of the visa application, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Su v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Su, sought judicial review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) that affirmed the Minister for Immigration's decision to refuse her visa application. The core of the dispute concerned the applicant's alleged employment with a nominating employer, which the MRT found to be not genuine. The matter came before Judge Jarrett of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the court were whether the MRT had considered irrelevant material in reaching its decision, thereby giving rise to jurisdictional error. Specifically, the applicant contended that the MRT relied on one-sided information from a site visit and placed excessive weight on the employer's poor financial position, which led it to disregard her evidence of earnings. The applicant also argued that the MRT's finding that she never commenced employment was inconsistent with other evidence it considered, suggesting a failure to carefully consider relevant information.

Judge Jarrett reasoned that the applicant's ground of review invited an impermissible review of the merits of the MRT's decision. The court noted that the MRT had provided coherent reasons for discounting various documents relied upon by the applicant, including ATO notices and PAYE payment summaries, finding them inconsistent and not indicative of actual payment given the employer's lack of records and income. The tribunal also analysed the applicant's bank statements to understand her income. The court found that the tribunal did not question the bank statements but rather sought to understand the applicant's income flow. The tribunal's consideration of information from community members and departmental officers regarding the employer's operations and the applicant's alleged non-commencement of work was found to be within its purview.

The court dismissed the application, finding that the applicant had not demonstrated jurisdictional error. The MRT's findings regarding the applicant's employment were based on a comprehensive analysis of the evidence before it, and its approach to weighing that evidence was open to it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

However, the tribunal gave coherent reasons for discounting the reliability of various documents relied upon by the applicant to support her claim. Dealing with each of the categories of documents in turn:a)the tribunal did not call into question the contract and job description upon which the applicant elide. The tribunal pointed out that it had information that contracts of employment and job descriptions had been used by the nominating employer in other cases but the employment in those cases was fictitious. However, it made no findings about that in respect of the applicant.b)As to the ATO documents, what the tribunal said was:33. The applicant provided to the Department ATO notice of assessments for the year ending 2012 and 2013 indicating that she earned $35,536 and $43,433 respectively as evidence of her working at the Company. She also provided the PAYE payment summary for the year ending 2012 and 2013 indicating that she received gross payments of $35,130 and $48,548. The Tribunal accepts that the Company provided the applicant with PAYE payment summaries that were submitted to the ATO and, once submitted, the ATO issued notice of assessments. However the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant’s ATO notice of assessments or PAYE payment summaries are evidence that the Company paid the applicant that amount of money. On the applicant’s own evidence, her payslips from the Company were inaccurate because of computer problems and the information in the PAYE payment summaries provided to the Tribunal are not consistent with the corresponding ATO notice of assessments. In the delegate’s decision it states that the liquidators informed the Department that the Director of the Company did not keep books or records and never generated sufficient income to pay its rent, power bills or other liabilities. Given the Company did not keep books or records and did not generate sufficient income to meet its liabilities the Tribunal puts no weight on ATO notice of assessments generated on the basis of documents prepared by the Company as evidence of the applicant being paid.(my emphasis)c)The reasons why the tribunal gave not weight to the ATO documents and the applicant’s payslips were well explained by the tribunal. It was an approach that was clearly open to it for the reasons it explained; andd)contrary to the applicant’s assertions, the tribunal did not question the bank statements relied upon by the applicant, but analysed those statements so as to understand, or attempt to understand, the way in which the applicant received her income from her nominating employer. The applicant contends that the tribunal failed to consider relevant facts. In making that submission, the applicant argues:25. Of significance in the respondent’s findings was oral evidence supplied by: the “credible” Rosewood informant and the real estate agent. The informant:26. Concern was originally brought to the attention of the respondent in around 2011-12 through information supplied by a credible informant. This person related to the department the following observations: A. That the sponsors office was rarely, if ever open, and that it was his belief that the sponsor was involved in fraudulent activities and that this activity extended to illegal regional visa sponsorship arrangements. B. That these illegal activities involved migration agents and council members of Ipswich City Council. C. That the applicant was never paid by the sponsor.D. That the informant conceded that it was the informant’s observation that after February 2012 the applicant had left the office and not come back. 27. The last point is key with respect to the applicant’s contentions that the MRT did not carefully consider relevant information. 28. The applicant maintains that on the one hand, in its analysis the respondent finds unequivocally that the applicant never commenced employment and never made a genuine effort to do so. Then on the other hand, on the strength of its credible informant, the applicant had at least been present at work, seemingly making a genuine effort to do so, up until 13 February 2012; some 12 months after the commencement of her employment under the employment contract. 29. It was clear that the MRT must have had some regard to this evidence given that, in the conclusion of its decision, it accepted that the applicant had been working for the company for about 18 months until the end of 2012. 30. Therefore on the strength of the evidence upon which the respondent substantively relied, the applicant must have been employed, by the sponsor, in Rosewood for at least 12 months.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This ground is in the following terms:1. The Second Respondent considered irrelevant material in coming to its decision giving rise to jurisdictional error.PARTICULARSA. As stated at paragraph 24 of its decision record, the Second Respondent relied on the First Respondent’s claims in relation to a site visit to the Applicant’s place of work on 8 November 2011 during which it consulted an employee of a nearby business who verified specific details including the exact date the business opened. The Applicant was on leave during this site visit and as such the First Respondent’s claims are one sided and irrelevant. It is unlikely for someone who does not work in the Applicant’s place of employment to know or remember the exact date when the business actually opened.B. As at paragraph 23 of the decision record, the Second Respondent placed excessive weight on the fact that the business did not generate sufficient income to meet its liabilities and as such disregarded the Applicant’s ATO notice of assessments as evidence of her pay. The employer’s poor financial position does not mean that the Applicant could not have been paid. The Applicant had stated that she was paid in cash most of the time. The gravamen of this ground appears to be the submission that the tribunal took into account an irrelevant consideration because it was wrong to prefer certain evidence before it over other evidence more favourable to the applicant’s case that was before it. On its face, this ground invites impermissible merits review of the tribunal’s decision. The applicant argues that it does not. The applicant claimed that she had commenced employment with her employer in January, 2011 from the shop that she had identified at Rosewood. However, as a result of information received from members of the community (described in the reasons as a “dob-in”), the first respondent’s department commenced an investigation into the employer sponsor that had nominated the applicant for employment. The first respondent’s delegate had relied upon that, and other information, to conclude that the applicant had not met s.137Q(1) of the Act. The applicant gave to the tribunal a copy of the first respondent’s delegate’s decision for the purposes of the tribunal’s review. The tribunal referred extensively to the information that had been provided by community members and by departmental officers who had conducted two site visits to the premises in Rosewood and others purportedly operated by the applicant’s employer sponsor. After the tribunal’s hearing, the tribunal wrote to the applicant. The tribunal refers to that letter at paragraph 24 of its reasons. The applicant refers to that paragraph in particular A of this ground. Relevantly, the tribunal recorded:24. On 19 December 2014 the Tribunal wrote to the applicants inviting them to comment or respond to the following information:In August 2011 the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) was contacted by the police. The police advised that little activity had been observed on the premises at shop 4 18-20 John Street Rosewood since it opened six months ago.The Department received information stating that Brisbane Import Export Wholesale Pty Ltd. (the Business) in Rosewood is rarely open and, when it is open, it is only for a couple of hours. The information stated that the police are watching the Business.During a site visit from officers of the Department on 8 November 2011 an employee of a John Street business told the officers that:· The Business was opened on 8 March 2011 with some furniture for sale.· There has only been one person in the shop since.· The shop closed in July 2011 and no one has been seen in the Business since that date.· There are computer desks and furniture inside the shop.· The shop was always closed and padlocked from the enclosed wire fence. In March 2012 the Department received information that:· Mr Guang Fu Yin and Ms Lisa Wang asked for a $100,000 payment for visa sponsorship; and· signed employment contracts for a nominated position did not reflect a person’s actual working arrangements of being a causal employee earning $10 per hour plus commission.In May 2012 the Department received anonymous information that the Rosewood office of the Business does not actively operate.In May 2013 the Department received information that the Business set up a fake office in regional Queensland to use the 857 regional employer sponsored visa program.If the Tribunal finds that you were never employed in the position referred to in the nomination, that you did not commence employment within the prescribed period and that you did not make a genuine effort to commence that employment then your visa may be cancelled. The decision to cancel your visa is a discretionary one.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.