Lau (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

Lau (Migration) [2019] AATA 3543 (12 July 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Mr Yin Chun Lau

CASE NUMBER:  1830420

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):           BCC2017/2922428

MEMBER:Alison Mercer

DATE:12 July 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the applicant’s subclass 187 - Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa.

Statement made on 12 July 2019 at 2:45pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation – Regional Employer Nomination (Permanent) (Class RN) visa – Subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) – ground for cancellation – non-commencement of employment within the prescribed period – Departmental site visit – applicant unknown to employees of nominating employer – employment contract signed by former director without board knowledge or approval – sham employment arrangement – genuine effort to commence employment – non-genuine position – consideration of discretion – purpose of visa not fulfilled – failure to give an accurate account of true nature of employment arrangement – lack of strong ties to Australian community – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 137Q

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 9 October 2018 to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 187 - Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa under s.137Q of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa under s.137Q on the basis that the delegate did not accept that the applicant had commenced employment with his sponsoring employer within the 6 month period after being granted his visa, nor that the applicant had made genuine attempts to do so. The delegate found that this established a ground for cancellation. The delegate then considered a range of factors set out in the Department’s guidelines before determining that the correct and preferable decision was to cancel the applicant’s visa.

  3. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 11 June 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal also received oral submissions from the applicant’s migration agent, Mr William Markwell. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Cantonese and English languages, although the Tribunal notes that the last 40 minutes of the hearing was conducted without an interpreter, as the interpreter had to leave to attend another booking. The applicant was asked if, under the circumstances, he was happy to proceed with the remainder of the hearing without an interpreter. He was given the alternative choices that the Tribunal could attempt to find a telephone interpreter for the remainder of the hearing, or that another hearing could be scheduled with an interpreter in person on a future date. After consultation with his migration agent, the applicant elected to complete the hearing without an interpreter, having indicated to the Tribunal at the commencement of the hearing that he spoke…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lau (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 3543
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the cancellation of a subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) visa granted to the applicant, Mr Lau. The Department of Home Affairs had initiated cancellation proceedings on the ground that the applicant had failed to commence employment with his sponsoring employer, Cinix 1 Pty Ltd, within the prescribed period following the grant of his visa. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the ground for cancellation was established and, if so, whether to exercise its discretion to affirm the cancellation decision.

The Tribunal was tasked with determining if the applicant had failed to commence the nominated employment within six months of his visa grant, as required by the Migration Regulations 1994. It also had to assess whether the applicant had made a genuine effort to commence that employment within the stipulated period. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to consider the discretionary power to cancel the visa, weighing various factors including the purpose of the visa, the applicant's compliance with visa conditions, the circumstances leading to the cancellation ground, the applicant's behaviour towards the Department, and any potential hardship.

The Tribunal found that the ground for cancellation was established. Evidence indicated that the applicant was not known to employees at Cinix 1 Pty Ltd and that the employment contract was signed by a former director without board approval, suggesting a sham employment arrangement. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant had not made a genuine effort to commence employment and that the purpose of the visa, which is to fill genuine labour shortages in regional areas, was not fulfilled. In exercising its discretion, the Tribunal gave significant weight to the sham nature of the employment arrangement and the applicant's failure to provide accurate information to the Department, finding these factors detrimental to the integrity of the Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme. While acknowledging some compliance with previous visa conditions and potential hardship, these were outweighed by the serious nature of the immigration fraud.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Department's decision to cancel the applicant's subclass 187 visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be affirmed.CONSIDERATION OF LAW, CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Under s.137Q, the Minister has the power to cancel a ‘regional sponsored employment visa’ on specified grounds. ‘Regional sponsored employment visa’ means a visa of a kind included in a class of visas that has the words ‘Employer Nomination’ in its title and is prescribed by the regulations for the purposes of the definition in s.137Q(3). The visas currently prescribed by r.2.50AA of the Migration Regulations 1994 are: subclass 119 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme); subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) and subclass 857 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme). The applicant falls within the ambit of s.137Q by virtue of having been granted a subclass 187 (RSMS) visa on 31 January 2017. Given the serious nature of the Tribunal’s consideration, it is appropriate to set out the history of this matter in some detail.Departmental application The Department’s records indicate that the applicant first arrived in Australia in 2009 as the holder of a student visa. He was granted subsequent student visas until 2016, when, upon completion of a Bachelor of Design (Graphic Design) at Raffles College of Design and Commerce in Sydney, he applied for a subclass 187 (RSMS) permanent residence visa. The applicant was nominated for this visa by an Australian company, Cinix 1 Pty Ltd, which was based in Brisbane, Queensland (at that time, a designated regional area of Australia). The nominated position for the applicant was that of Graphic Designer. The Department’s records indicate that the applicant was granted a subclass 187 visa on 31 January 2017.Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation (NOICC) The Department’s records indicate that it sent 3 NOICCs to the applicant, one on 20 August 2018 and 2 on 21 August 2018. The covering email for the third NOICC advises the applicant to ignore the previous 2 NOICCs as they contained incorrect information and/or gave an incorrect date for response. The applicant was advised to respond to the contents and due date of the third NOICC, dated 21 August 2018. Relevantly, that NOICC advised the applicant that the Department was considering cancelling his subclass 187 visa under s.137Q of the Act as it had information that he did not commence the employment referred to in the relevant employer nomination with Cinix 1 Pty Ltd within the period prescribed in the Regulations (that is, 6 months from the grant of his visa, as per r.2.50AA). The NOICC further advised that a site visit was undertaken by Australian Border Force (ABF) officers on 2 August 2017 to Cinix 1 Pty Ltd at 10 Bow Street, Waterford West, Queensland, as this was the employer address the applicant provided in his visa application. However, the ABF found no business was operating at this address. The ABF officers therefore undertook a second site visit on 9 August 2017 to Cinix 1 Pty Ltd’s head office at 15 Ellen St, Logan, Queensland, where the business was found to be operating. The ABF officers spoke to a new director of the company and it was ascertained that the applicant was not working there, and had never done so. The new director advised that he had held that post for 6 months, having replaced the old director, Jacqui. The NOICC then stated that when an ABF officer contacted the applicant by telephone on 15 August 2017 about these matters, the applicant responded (in part) that:‘You work for Jacqui at Cinix1.When asked for the address you provided a post office box. When asked for a physical address when you said you did not know as ‘I just drive there.’ You stated it was a house, and when prompted, confirmed it was 10 Bow St, Waterford West.When advised that no one knows you at Cinix1 and that Jacqui resigned last year, and there is no business at 10 Bow Street, you then stated that you resigned 2 months ago. When questioned why no one knows you at all, you then stated that you worked from home.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant did not respond within the time frame set out above.Cancellation decision On 9 October 2018, a delegate of the Minister made a decision to cancel the applicant’s visa pursuant to s.137Q(1) of the Act, which provided that the Minister may cancel a subclass 187 visa if:(a) the Minister was satisfied that the person has not commenced the employment referred to in the relevant employer nomination within the period prescribed by the Regulations; and(b) the person does not satisfy the Minister that he or she has made a genuine effort to commence that employment within that period. The delegate noted that the period referred to in (a) was 6 months from the date of the grant of the visa, as per r.2.50AA. The delegate reiterated the information obtained by the Department, as set out in the NOICC, and concluded that the information before the Department indicated that the visa holder was not now, nor was he ever, an employee of Cinx1 Pty Ltd, as he had never commenced employment with them. The delegate was therefore satisfied that the applicant did not commence employment referred to in his employer nomination within the prescribed period. The delegate further noted that the applicant did not respond to the NOICC, and as such, had not provided further information about his efforts to commence employment with Cinix1 within the prescribed period. The delegate found that when interviewed on 15 August 2017, the applicant was unable to provide the current business address or identify the current director of Cinix1 Pty Ltd. The delegate was not satisfied that the applicant had made a genuine effort to commence that employment within the prescribed period. The delegate concluded that therefore, there was a ground for cancellation of the applicant’s subclass 187 visa under s.137Q(1) of the Act. The delegate then went on to consider whether there were any relevant considerations that might support not cancelling the visa, despite a ground for cancellation existing. The delegate had regard to the following factors, as set out in the relevant Department Procedural Instructions:·the purpose of the applicant’s travel to and stay in Australia, such as whether he had any compelling purpose for travelling to or staying in Australia – the delegate found the applicant came to Australia in 2011 as a student and applied for the RSMS visa after the conclusion of his studies. The delegate noted that the purpose of an RSMS visa was specifically to assist regional employers to nominate skilled migrants to fill full time vacancies where there was a genuine need. As the visa holder did not commence work with his nominated employer, nor made a genuine effort to do so, the delegate considered that the applicant’s purpose of remaining in Australia was not aligned with the purpose for which the visa was granted. As the applicant did not respond to the NOICC, the delegate was unable to assess any specific claims he might have had about his travel to and/or stay in Australia, or any compelling reasons for staying in Australia. However, as the applicant had been in Australia for a considerable period since first arriving, it appeared his intention was to remain here permanently. The delegate was not aware of any compelling reasons for the applicant to remain in Australia and therefore gave this consideration little weight in the applicant’s favour;·the extent of the applicant’s compliance with any conditions to which his visa was granted – the delegate found that the applicant did not commence employment with Cinix1 within the prescribed period and had not ever been employed there. He had not provided any further evidence to suggest he made a genuine effort to commence employment there, nor had he clarified the circumstances of his failure to work there. The applicant had therefore failed to comply the employment obligations of his subclass 187 visa and the delegate gave this consideration no weight in his favour;·the degree of hardship that might be caused to the applicant (and/or any family members) if the visa was cancelled (including financial, emotional and/or psychological) – the Department’s records indicated that the applicant had resided in Australia since late 2011, and the delegate considered he therefore would have established some social and economic ties to Australia and probably had the intention of remaining permanently. The delegate accepted that cancellation would cause the applicant a degree of emotional and financial hardship as a result. There was no indication that the applicant had any family members in Australia who would experience hardship as a result of the cancellation. The delegate gave this consideration a little weight in the applicant’s favour;·the circumstances in which the ground(s) for cancellation arose, such as whether there were any circumstances that were beyond the applicant’s control – the delegate relied on the information obtained by the Department indicating that the applicant had never commenced work for Cinix1, and that the position for which he was nominated may have been created by a former employee of Cinix1 to facilitate the grant of a permanent visa to the applicant to which he was not entitled. The delegate considered that the circumstances in which the cancellation arose were intended to mislead the Department and represented significant immigration fraud with a particular impact on the RSMS program and the regional areas it was designed to assist. The delegate found that the non-compliance in which the applicant participated risked causing financial harm to the regional industries that had a genuine need for skilled workers. Immigration fraud in the RSMS program risked creating skilled labour shortages in regional areas and inhibiting the growth of businesses in those areas. The delegate therefore considered the applicant’s actions were detrimental to the ongoing viability of the RSMS program and its genuine users. The delegate further found no information to suggest that there were extenuating circumstances beyond the applicant’s control that led to, or mitigated, the ground for cancellation;·the applicant’s behaviour in relation to the Department – the delegate found that in addition to not commencing work with Cinix1 in the required period, the applicant provided a shifting explanation to the Department before stating he had resigned from the company. He failed to respond to the NOICC. The delegate considered that the applicant had been uncooperative with the Department in relation to this issue, although there was no evidence of any other lack of cooperation. The delegate gave this consideration no weight in the applicant’s favour;·whether anyone in Australia would have their visa(s) cancelled pursuant to s.137T of the Act – the delegate was satisfied that there was not;·whether there were any mandatory legal considerations to a cancellation decision – the delegate noted that the applicant was eligible to apply for a bridging visa E while seeking review of any decision to cancel and would not be taken into immigration detention if this were granted. The delegate accepted that the cancellation would result in the applicant being subject to s.48 of the Act, which prevented most onshore visa applications, and to Public Interest Criterion 4013 (PIC 4013), which would prevent the grant of certain visas offshore for a period of 3 years after the cancellation. The delegate gave this consideration a little weight in favour of the applicant;·Australia’s international obligations, including whether the cancellation would lead to removal of the applicant in breach of Australia’s non-refoulement obligations – the delegate found there was no information to indicate that cancellation would breach Australia’s international obligations, including its non-refoulement obligations. The delegate gave this consideration no weight in favour of the applicant; and ·any other relevant matter(s) – the delegate found there was no information indicating that there were any other relevant matters affecting the applicant and gave this consideration no weight in the applicant’s favour.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that the ground for cancellation in s.137Q(2) is established. As the power to cancel under s.137Q is discretionary, the Tribunal must now proceed to consider whether the power to cancel the visa should be exercised.Consideration of discretion There are no matters specified in the Act or Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa. However, in considering whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the applicant’s visa, the Tribunal has had regard to the relevant circumstances including but not limited to matters identified in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual PAM3 ‘Visa Cancellation Instructions – Regional Sponsored Employment Visas – Assessing Any Reasons not to Cancel.’Purpose of the visa holder’s travel to and stay in Australia – whether the applicant has a compelling need to travel to or remain in Australia On the applicant’s evidence, he returned to Hong Kong in late 2017 and remained there until approximately August 2018, when he returned to Australia to try to resolve his situation with Cinix 1 Pty Ltd. The applicant’s evidence was that, since returning to Australia, he had been sharing accommodation with friends in Melbourne. He told the Tribunal that he is not employed in Australia and does not have any family here. He does have a circle of friends in Australia, and said that he preferred the environment in Australia to Hong Kong, as Australia was less crowded and polluted. The Tribunal considers that the applicant currently has relatively few strong ties with Australia of an employment or personal nature, and it gives little weight to this factor as a reason not to cancel his visa. Extent of Compliance with Visa Conditions Aside from the failure to commence employment which is the subject of this review, there is no evidence before the Tribunal to indicate that the applicant did not comply with the terms of his previous student visas, or that he has not complied with the terms of his current bridging visa. The Tribunal gives this factor some weight in favour of not cancelling his visa.Circumstances leading to the grounds for cancellation The Tribunal has set out its view of the circumstances leading to the grounds for cancellation above. It finds that the purported employment and nomination arrangement between the applicant and Cinix 1 Pty Ltd was a sham to enable the applicant to obtain permanent residence because of Cinix 1 Pty Ltd’s nomination of him, but that there was no genuine intention by either party that he would work for Cinix 1 Pty Ltd for 2 years as a Graphic Designer. It does not accept that these factors were outside the applicant’s control. The Tribunal gives this factor significant weight in favour of cancelling the applicant’s visa as it goes to the whole basis for existence of the subclass 187 visa category; that is, for Australian employers to fill genuine labour shortages in regional areas.Visa holder’s current and past behaviour in relation to the Department (including truthfulness of statements made to officers, or in applications under consideration by the Department)