Stowers v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stowers v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 485

File number(s): NSD 1524 of 2017
Judge(s): FARRELL J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2018
Catchwords: MIGRATION – review of the decision of the Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection – visa cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) on grounds of substantial criminal record – decision not to revoke visa cancellation – whether the applicant was denied procedural fairness – whether the applicant was given the opportunity to respond to adverse material which informed the decision – application dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499, 501, 501CA
Cases cited:

Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576

Falzon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 92 ALJR 201; HCA 2

M238 of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 260

Picard v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1430

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs; Ex parte Lam (2003) 214 CLR 1; HCA 6

Williams v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 226 FCR 112; FCA 674

Date of hearing: 12 March 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 29
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr G Johnson
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms R Francois
Solicitor for the Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 1524 of 2017
BETWEEN:

JUNIOR STOWERS

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

Respondent

JUDGE:

FARRELL J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 APRIL 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

FARRELL J:

  1. Mr Stowers is a citizen of New Zealand who was born in 1986.  He came to Australia in 2005 and was granted a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa. His visa was cancelled on 23 December 2016 by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (cancellation decision).  On 9 August 2017, the Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the Honourable Alex Hawke MP (Minister), decided not to revoke the cancellation decision under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act.

  2. This is an application for judicial review of the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation decision.  These are my reasons for dismissing the application with costs.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The delegate was obliged to revoke the visa under s 501(3A) because, at the time the decision was made, Mr Stowers was in prison on a full-time basis and he did not pass the “character test” in s 501(6)(a) because he had a “substantial criminal record” under s 501(7)(c) having been sentenced to a term of imprisonment…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stowers v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 485
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Mr Stowers applied for judicial review of the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation of his visa. The visa was cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) because Mr Stowers had a substantial criminal record. The sole ground of the application was that the Minister denied Mr Stowers procedural fairness by not putting him on notice of the potential adverse effect of the material in the Minister’s possession which informed the decision, namely the National Police Certificate. The application was dismissed with costs.

The legal issue before the court was whether the Minister denied Mr Stowers procedural fairness by failing to put him on notice of the potential adverse effect of the National Police Certificate. The court held that the Minister was not required to give Mr Stowers notice of the potential adverse effect of the material in the Minister’s possession. The court noted that there was no statutory obligation on the Minister to include language in the 30 May 2017 letter noting expressly that some of the material attached to the letter may be adverse. The court found that Mr Stowers could be taken to presume that the documents attached to the 30 May 2017 letter might hold matters which might be taken to be adverse to him but he was not put on notice of how it might be adverse to him. The court held that the Minister was entitled to rely on the contents of the National Police Certificate and that the adverse inference drawn by the Minister from the information in his possession was an obvious inference or a conclusion obviously open on the known material. The denial of procedural fairness did not affect the outcome of the Minister’s consideration of the exercise of power under s 501CA(4).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for judicial review of the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation decision. These are my reasons for dismissing the application with costs.BACKGROUND The delegate was obliged to revoke the visa under s 501(3A) because, at the time the decision was made, Mr Stowers was in prison on a full-time basis and he did not pass the “character test” in s 501(6)(a) because he had a “substantial criminal record” under s 501(7)(c) having been sentenced to a term of imprisonment greater than 12 months. On 22 July 2016, the Local Court of New South Wales convicted Mr Stowers on five offences, including two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm for which he was sentenced to a 14 month term of imprisonment. A non-parole period of nine months was imposed on one of these convictions. The offences involved domestic violence. Following an appeal in relation to the severity of his sentence, Mr Stowers’ non-parole period was reduced to 6 months. He was released from prison on 22 January 2017 and is currently held in immigration detention. On 25 January 2017, Mr Stowers made representations to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection seeking revocation of the cancellation decision. The Minister was not satisfied that Mr Stowers passed the “character test” set out in s 501(6)(a) nor was he satisfied that there was “another reason” why the cancellation decision should be revoked. Accordingly, neither limb of s 501CA(4) was satisfied. Mr Stowers was advised of the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation decision by letter dated 9 August 2017 which enclosed a copy of the Minister’s decision record. In submissions filed on 26 February 2018, counsel for Mr Stowers conceded that the Minister took into account each of the following matters which were raised in the representations made to the Minister: that Mr Stowers has ties to Australia, in particular a partner who supports him and with whom he has two young children; that Mr Stowers also has a child with a former partner and he has maintained contact with both the former partner and Mr Stowers’ eldest son; and that Mr Stowers suffers from mental illnesses, including bipolar disorder and depression for which he is presently prescribed medication. GROUNDS The amended application filed on 27 November 2017 relied on two grounds. The first is not now pressed having regard to the decision of the High Court in Falzon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 92 ALJR 201; HCA 2. Accordingly, the sole ground of this application is that the Minister denied Mr Stowers procedural fairness. The particulars of this ground are as follows:(1)On 30 May 2017, the Minister sent a letter to Mr Stowers informing him that the Minister had information which may be taken into account when making his decision whether to revoke the cancellation decision. That information included a National Police Certificate dated 19 December 2016.(2)The Minister failed to put Mr Stowers on notice of the potential adverse effect of the National Police Certificate.(3)At [44] of the decision record, the Minister relied expressly on “convictions for breaches of judicial orders and non-custodial dispositions” in causing him to “pause in accepting unquestioningly that Mr Stowers will not reoffend if returned to the community”.(4)The adverse inference drawn by the Minister from the information in his possession, including the National Police Certificate, was not an obvious inference or a conclusion obviously open on the known material. Mr Stowers was denied an opportunity to comment on the information in the Minister’s possession. The denial of procedural fairness may have affected the outcome of the Minister’s consideration of the exercise of power under s 501CA(4).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Minister’s decision record dealt with “Risk to the Australian community” at [38]-[45]. In paragraphs [38]-[43], the Minister took into account mitigating circumstances and rehabilitation. This included remarks made by a Judge hearing the appeal on 9 August 2016 regarding Mr Stowers’ dysfunctional childhood and exposure to violence and domestic violence as a child, that he suffered from bipolar disorder and depression at the time he committed the assault offences for which he was sentenced, that Mr Stowers appeared committed to pursuing treatment for his mental health and that he loves his partner and his children and wants to be a good committed father and not carry the issues of his own dysfunctional childhood through his life. The Minister also took into account Mr Stowers’ statement that, while in prison, he has done a lot of learning about his illness and role as a father and that was supported by a statement from his partner. The Minister noted that while Mr Stowers has made efforts to remain medicated during his time in custody, a return to the community would test his ability to manage his ongoing mental health issues and deal with his psychological issues in an unsupported environment where he would be exposed to external stressors. The Minister concluded this part of the decision record at [44] and [45] as follows:44.I have considered Mr STOWERS’ convictions for breaches of judicial orders and non-custodial dispositions, as well as his false declaration on an incoming passenger card on which he indicated that he had no criminal convictions at the time when he held a criminal conviction in New Zealand. I find that Mr STOWERS’ prior conduct displays a disregard for judicial orders and gives me pause in accepting unquestioningly that he will not reoffend if returned to the community.45.I cannot rule out the likelihood of Mr STOWERS reoffending in future, particularly if exposed to external stressors and/or if he neglects to manage his mental health issues. I find that there is an ongoing likelihood that Mr STOWERS will reoffend, albeit a low one and should he offend in a similar manner, it would result [in] physical and psychological harm to a member or members of the Australian community.SUBMISSIONS CONCERNING THE EVIDENCE In their submissions, Mr Stowers and the Minister refer to aspects of material in the letters dated 23 December 2016 and 30 May 2017 to Mr Stowers from the Department of Immigration and Border Protection and to documents which accompanied those letters. It is useful to set out some of that material.23 December 2016 letter and attachments The Department’s letter dated 23 December 2016 advised Mr Stowers of the cancellation decision and of his opportunity to apply to the Minister for its revocation. At pages 2-3 of its 6 pages it included the following information (bold emphasis added): Opportunity to seek revocation of the cancellation decisionWhile your visa has been cancelled and you no longer hold a visa, you have an opportunity to make representations about revoking the decision to cancel your visa.You are hereby invited to make representations to the Minister about revoking the decision to cancel your visa. The representations must be made in accordance with the instructions outlined below, under the headings entitled “How to make representations about revocation of the decision to cancel your visa” and “Timeframe to make representations about revocation”.The decision to cancel your visa may be revoked by the Minister under s501CA(4) of the Act if you make representations in accordance with the specified instructions and the Minister is satisfied that:Ÿyou pass the character test (as defined by s501 of the Act); orŸthere is another reason why the decision to cancel your visa should be revoked.The full text of s501CA of the Act is also included in Attachment 1.How to make representations about revocation of the decision to cancel your visaIf you decide to make representations about the revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, you can write to us using the attached Revocation Request Form.Under s499 of the Act which permits the Minister to issue written directions about the exercise of powers under the Act, the Minister has issued Direction 65 - Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA which identifies issues that are relevant to the revocation consideration. A copy of Direction 65 is enclosed for your information. You should address each paragraph in PART C of the Direction that is relevant to your circumstances.Please note that if the decision-maker who makes the decision regarding whether or not to revoke the decision to cancel your visa is a delegate of the Minister, they must follow Direction 65. If, however, the Minister makes a revocation decision personally, he or she is not bound by Direction 65, although Direction 65 provides a broad indication of the types of issues that the Minister is likely to take into account in deciding whether or not to revoke the decision to cancel your visa.A copy of the following document, which contains information in the possession of the department at the time the mandatory decision to cancel your visa was made, is also enclosed for your information.ŸConviction, Sentence and Appeals report from the New South Wales Department of Corrective Services dated 16 December 2016ŸFile note dated 23 December 2016No further action will be taken in relation to the enclosed information as it will not alter the mandatory decision to cancel. However, if you make representations about revocation of the cancellation decision according to the instructions in this letter as outlined below, then the enclosed information will also be taken into consideration when deciding whether or not to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision.As some of the enclosed information is adverse information that may undermine the possible revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, if you decide to make representations in support of revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, you may also wish to provide specific comments regarding the enclosed information, in particular the adverse information.You can provide any other information that you feel the decision-maker should take into account. This can include, but is not limited to, letters of support from your family, friends, employers or others.…

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Department’s letter dated 23 December 2016 advised Mr Stowers of the cancellation decision and of his opportunity to apply to the Minister for its revocation. At pages 2-3 of its 6 pages it included the following information (bold emphasis added): Opportunity to seek revocation of the cancellation decisionWhile your visa has been cancelled and you no longer hold a visa, you have an opportunity to make representations about revoking the decision to cancel your visa.You are hereby invited to make representations to the Minister about revoking the decision to cancel your visa. The representations must be made in accordance with the instructions outlined below, under the headings entitled “How to make representations about revocation of the decision to cancel your visa” and “Timeframe to make representations about revocation”.The decision to cancel your visa may be revoked by the Minister under s501CA(4) of the Act if you make representations in accordance with the specified instructions and the Minister is satisfied that:Ÿyou pass the character test (as defined by s501 of the Act); orŸthere is another reason why the decision to cancel your visa should be revoked.The full text of s501CA of the Act is also included in Attachment 1.How to make representations about revocation of the decision to cancel your visaIf you decide to make representations about the revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, you can write to us using the attached Revocation Request Form.Under s499 of the Act which permits the Minister to issue written directions about the exercise of powers under the Act, the Minister has issued Direction 65 - Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA which identifies issues that are relevant to the revocation consideration. A copy of Direction 65 is enclosed for your information. You should address each paragraph in PART C of the Direction that is relevant to your circumstances.Please note that if the decision-maker who makes the decision regarding whether or not to revoke the decision to cancel your visa is a delegate of the Minister, they must follow Direction 65. If, however, the Minister makes a revocation decision personally, he or she is not bound by Direction 65, although Direction 65 provides a broad indication of the types of issues that the Minister is likely to take into account in deciding whether or not to revoke the decision to cancel your visa.A copy of the following document, which contains information in the possession of the department at the time the mandatory decision to cancel your visa was made, is also enclosed for your information.ŸConviction, Sentence and Appeals report from the New South Wales Department of Corrective Services dated 16 December 2016ŸFile note dated 23 December 2016No further action will be taken in relation to the enclosed information as it will not alter the mandatory decision to cancel. However, if you make representations about revocation of the cancellation decision according to the instructions in this letter as outlined below, then the enclosed information will also be taken into consideration when deciding whether or not to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision.As some of the enclosed information is adverse information that may undermine the possible revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, if you decide to make representations in support of revocation of the decision to cancel your visa, you may also wish to provide specific comments regarding the enclosed information, in particular the adverse information.You can provide any other information that you feel the decision-maker should take into account. This can include, but is not limited to, letters of support from your family, friends, employers or others.…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Department again wrote to Mr Stowers by letter dated 30 May 2017. The letter relevantly stated as follows (bold emphasis added): Further information regarding possible revocation of visa cancellation, under s501CA of the Migration Act 1958In a notice dated 23 December 2016 you are notified that your Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa was cancelled under s501(3A) of the Migration Act.Included in the notice were particulars of the information that the decision-maker considered was the reason, or part of the reason, for making the cancellation decision. You are invited to make representations about revocation of the cancellation decision. Your response to the invitation has been received.The Department has information which has been received and which may be taken into account when making the decision whether to revoke the decision to cancel your visa under s501CA of the Migration Act. The information consists ofŸNational Police Certificate dated 19 December 2016ŸTranscript of Judgement by the Gosford District Court on 9 August 2016ŸSentencing remarks of the Gosford Local Court on 22 July 2016ŸNew Zealand Police in Confidence dated 29 March 2017ŸIncoming Passenger Cards dated 16 September 2005 and 5 August 2006 where you have indicated you have no criminal convictions. (Note: According to our records the actual arrival date in 2006 was 6 August 2006)A copy of this information is enclosed. You are invited to comment on this information. Your response must be in writing and may be sent by mail, email or fax. It can be sent to any immigration office, but it is preferred that you send it to the address shown below. Counsel for Mr Stowers submitted that the 30 May 2017 letter identified the documents attached only by broad description, as opposed to any information that might be contained in them. He acknowledged that there was no statutory obligation on the Minister to include language in the 30 May 2017 letter noting expressly that some of the material attached to the letter may be adverse, being language of the kind which was included in the 23 December 2016 letter. Counsel acknowledged that Mr Stowers could be taken to presume that the documents attached to the 30 May 2017 letter might hold matters which might be taken to be adverse to him but he was not put on notice of how it might be adverse to him. He submitted that any issue that the Minister had with the contents of the National Police Certificate should have been highlighted in the same way as the emphasised words above put Mr Stowers on notice of the issue with the way he had completed the incoming passenger cards. The National Police Certificate is a document of three pages in date order from most recent to earliest offences. It showed:(1)At 9 August 2016, convictions for:(a)common assault (five months prison); (b)stalk/intimidate intend fear physical etc harm (six months prison);(c)two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm (14 months prison, one with a non-parole period of six months); and(d)armed with intent to commit indictable offence (six months prison).(2)At 22 July 2016, the same convictions, noting that a severity appeal had been lodged;(3)At 25 July 2014, in Gosford Local Court, a conviction for driving while disqualified from holding a licence (four months prison);(4)At 26 June 2013, in Gosford Local Court, convictions for common assault (an 18 month bond with supervision) and driving while disqualified from holding a licence (a mandatory 100 hour community service order). The third conviction (for which no penalty was recorded) was:Fail to appear in accordance with Bail Granted undertaking(5)At 1 April 2010, in Liverpool Local Court convictions for:(a)using an uninsured motor vehicle ($200 fine);(b)using an unregistered registrable class a motor vehicle ($200 fine); (c)two counts of driving with a high range prescribed concentration of alcohol (the first count with a fine of $1,200 and three years disqualification commencing 9 December 2010, and the second with a fine of $2,000 with a 16 month suspended sentence on entering into a 16 month bond and a five years disqualification commencing 1 April 2010 (habitual offender): quashed traffic offenders program); (d)using an uninsured motor vehicle and using an unregistered registrable class a motor vehicle ($300 fine for each count); (e)not stopping at a red arrow ($100 fine and traffic offenders program); and(f)drive on road etc while license suspended ($600 fine with a two year bond and two years disqualification commencing on 9 December 2013 (habitual offender) quashed traffic offenders program); in each case with court costs of $76.(6)At 6 February 2008, in Penrith Local Court, breaking and entering a building (steal) to a value of less than or equal to $15,000 (a two year bond).