Stock v Exalso Pty Ltd & Anor No. DCCIV-98-314 Judgment No. D89

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

STOCK v EXALSO PTY LTD & ANOR
[1999] SADC 89

Acting Judge Taylor
Civil

  1. The plaintiff brings these proceedings claiming that he has suffered injury to his hands and as a result of that injury he has sustained a loss of working capacity and it has also adversely affected his enjoyment of life. In his statement of claim he states as follows:

    “1..... At all material times the plaintiff was undergoing a training course in detailing motor vehicles.

    2.At all material times the defendant was a company carrying on the business of car detailing at 109 Angas Street, Adelaide in the State of South Australia (“the premises”).

    3...... On or about the 28th day of August 1995, the plaintiff commenced to be trained in car detailing (“the training”) by the defendant at the premises.

    4.As a part of the training of the plaintiff by the defendant, an employee of the defendant, whose name is unknown to the plaintiff, taught him what chemicals to use to clean different parts of motor vehicles.

    5...... In or about the beginning of October 1995, after washing a motor vehicle at the premises, the plaintiff put his hand into what he thought was a bucket of water (“the bucket”) which in fact was acid solution (“the accident”).

    6.The accident was caused by the negligence of the defendant.

PARTICULARS OF NEGLIGENCE

7.The defendant was negligent in that it:-

7.1... failed clearly or at all to label the bucket indicating that it was
dangerous;

7.2... failed to label the bucket clearly or at all that it contained acid;

7.3    failed adequately or at all to supervise the plaintiff in his training as a car detailer;

7.4... failed to warn the plaintiff that the bucket contained dangerous acid solution.

8...... As a result of the accident the plaintiff sustained injuries.

PARTICULARS OF INJURIES

9...... The plaintiff was born on the 26th day of August 1964.

9.1    The plaintiff sustained injuries including burning of his hands.

9.2... Subsequently, he developed blisters, swelling and redness of
the hands.

9.3... As a result of the accident the plaintiff suffered hand dermatitis. Subsequently, he developed a drying and peeling of the skin of the hands. The plaintiff was treated at the Casualty Department of the Queen Elizabeth Hospital with oral promethazine and topically applied hydrocortisone cream.

9.4    The plaintiff continues to suffer itchiness and peeling of the hands and continues to require indefinitely into the future topically applied hydrocortisone cream.

9.5... The plaintiff’s enjoyment of the amenities of life have been adversely effected in that he cannot involve himself in any past time or sport which involves his hands becoming wet or involving the use of chemicals.

9.6    The plaintiff has suffered a loss of working capacity. In particular, he is unfit for any occupation involving the use of chemicals.

9.7... As a result of the injuries he sustained, the plaintiff has incurred special damages, details of which will be supplied prior to trial.

AND the plaintiff claims damages.”

  1. The plaintiff is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stock v Exalso Pty Ltd & Anor No. DCCIV-98-314 Judgment No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SADC 89
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff in this case brought proceedings against Exalso Pty Ltd and another party, alleging that he suffered injuries to his hands as a result of the defendant's negligence. The plaintiff claimed that while he was undergoing training at the defendant's premises, he mistakenly put his hands into a bucket containing acid solution, which caused him to suffer burns and subsequent dermatitis. The plaintiff sought damages for the injuries, loss of working capacity, and diminished enjoyment of life. The court had to determine whether the defendant was negligent in the circumstances leading to the plaintiff's injuries and, if so, the extent of the damages to be awarded.

The court found that the defendant had taken reasonable steps to ensure the plaintiff's safety, including providing a safety briefing, ensuring the availability of safety equipment, and warning the plaintiff about the acid solution. The court accepted the evidence that the plaintiff was aware of the nature of the acid wash and had been warned about it. The court also found that the plaintiff's actions in putting his hands into the bucket were a result of his own negligence, as he chose to ignore the warnings and safety procedures. Therefore, the court concluded that the defendant was not negligent and dismissed the plaintiff's claim.

However, the court did acknowledge that the plaintiff had suffered some contact dermatitis as a result of the incident, which limited his capacity to work in occupations involving chemicals or wet hands. The court awarded the plaintiff damages for his non-economic loss and loss of future earning capacity, totaling $48,338.71. The court found that the plaintiff's history of employment and his own behavior played a significant role in his limited working capacity, and therefore, the award was considered just and appropriate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established