LEOPARDI & ORS V COMPLETE NATURAL STONE P/L & CALABRESE
[1999] SADC 89 of 1999
Judge Allan
Civil
The principal issue in this case is whether the defendant Complete Natural Stone Pty Ltd (“CNS”) is entitled to operate a quarry owned by the plaintiffs.
The plaintiffs seek the following declarations and orders:
‘(a)... A declaration that the defendants are not entitled to enter on to or use the land and quarry.
(b)A declaration that the defendants are trespassing on the land and the quarry.
(c).... An order that the defendants forthwith remove or cause to be removed all of their plant and equipment located on the land and the quarry.
(d)That thereafter and until further order each of the defendants be restrained and an injunction be granted restraining them, whether by themselves or by their agents servants employees or otherwise from entering on to or otherwise dealing with the land on which the quarry is situated.
(e).... An order that an account and enquiry be made and taken with regard to all stone and other extracted minerals taken by the defendants from the quarry from 24 October 1988 to the date of this order.
(f)Costs.
(g).... Any further or other orders the court may deem fit.’
For its part, CNS seeks the following orders:
‘1..... An Order or Declaration that there is an agreement, right or licence (“the Agreement”) to enter onto the land and quarry and remove stone from the land in accordance with the terms set out in the document entitled “Heads of Agreement”.
2.Orders for specific performance of the Agreement.
3...... In the alternative, damages to be assessed compensating CNS for the Plaintiffs’ misleading and deceptive conduct..
4.Costs on an indemnity basis.’
The plaintiffs are the registered proprietors of the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5429 Folio 602; the plaintiff Leopardi (“Leopardi”) as to one undivided second part and the other plaintiffs (“the Rollonds”) as joint tenants of one undivided second part. Situated on the plaintiffs land, which is at Wistow, is a bluestone and slate quarry. The plaintiffs are the holders of a mining tenement in relation to the quarry. It is tenement No. PM170. In the tenement, Leopardi is described as the holder and operator and the Rollonds are described as the joint holders.
The plaintiffs bought the land from a man called Seaton Dredge in October 1997. They operated the quarry for the benefit of their respective businesses. The Rollonds had a landscaping business, amongst other things, and they used stone from the quarry for the purposes of that business. Leopardi sold stone from the quarry. The costs associated with the quarry, such as the royalties paid to the government, were shared; but there was no sharing of income; for example, Leopardi retained any money that he got for the sale of stone. The Rollonds owned a front end loader which they used in the quarry for their purposes and they allowed Leopardi to use it for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Leopardi & Or v Complete Natural Stone & Calabrese No. DCCIV... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SADC 56
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that no agreement was reached between the parties. Although Calabrese and Leopardi had discussions and prepared documents, the Rollonds, who were joint owners of the land, did not approve the proposed terms. The court held that Leopardi had actual authority to negotiate on behalf of the Rollonds but did not have apparent or ostensible authority to bind them to an agreement. The court also found that the Rollonds' conduct was not misleading, but Leopardi's conduct was misleading because he represented to Calabrese that CNS could mine the quarry, despite knowing the Rollonds' opposition.
The court ordered CNS to vacate the quarry and granted the plaintiffs an account of stone extracted since 24 October 1998. The court also found Leopardi liable for misleading conduct and directed him to compensate CNS for any losses or damages resulting from his actions. The court further directed the parties to provide further submissions on the form of orders, quantum of damages, and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi