Steward v Mac Plant Pty Ltd & Mac Farms Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Steward v Mac Plant Pty Ltd and Mac Farms Pty Ltd [2018] QDC 20

PARTIES:

SHARON STEWARD
(appellant)

v

MAC PLANT PTY LTD      
(first respondent)

MAC FARMS PTY LTD
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

MAG-245/17 APPEAL NO: 162/2017

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Criminal appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court, Tully

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

15 December 2017

Appellant’s supplementary written submissions 22 December 2017

Respondents’ supplementary written submissions 5 January 2018

JUDGE:

Fantin DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The appeal is allowed.

2.   The orders of the Magistrate made on 17 August 2017 are set aside.

3.   The respondents are resentenced as follows:

a.   first respondent: fined $35,000, no conviction recorded.

b.   second respondent: fined $10,000, no conviction recorded.

4.   No order as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – sentence appeal by prosecution pursuant to s 222 Justices Act 1886 – whether sentence manifestly inadequate – whether Court should exercise power to resentence – first respondent convicted of failure to comply with health and safety duty under Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), s 33 – second respondent convicted of failure to ensure suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant provided under Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld), s 215

Legislation
Justices Act 1886 (Qld) s 222, s 223(1), s 225 s 227 & s 230(1AA)
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s 5(1)(d), s 9, s 11, s 12, s 13, s 48 & s 181B
Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), s 3, s 17, s 18, s 19, s 25(2), s 31, s 32 & s 33

Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld), s 215

Cases

AB v R (1999) 198 CLR 111
Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170
Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172
Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485
Commissioner of Police v Watmough [2015] QDC 46
Director of Public Prosecutions v Dalgleish (a pseudonym) (2017) 349 CLR 37
Dwyer v Calco Timbers (2008) 234 CLR 124
Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89
Forrest v Commissioner of Police [2017] QCA 132
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
Kentwell v R (2014) 252 CLR 601
Lang v Amalgamated Food and Poultry Pty Ltd 167 QGIG 245
McDonald v QPS [2017] QCA 255
Nash v Silver City Drilling (NSW) Pty Ltd; Attorney General for New South Wales v Silver City Drilling (NSW) Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCCA 96
Norbis v Norbis (1986) 161 CLR 513
R v Goodwin; Exparte Attorney-General (Qld) [2014] QCA 345
R v Pham [2015] HCA 39
SafeWork (NSW) v Gregory Paul Dunn [2016] NSWDC 212
Short v Lockshire Pty Ltd (2000) 165 QGIG 521
Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] QCA 84
Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531
Williamson v VH & MG Imports Pty Ltd [2017] QDC 56
Young v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Steward v Mac Plant Pty Ltd & Mac Farms Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QDC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Steward v Mac Plant Pty Ltd & Mac Farms Pty Ltd, the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed the sentences imposed on two companies, Mac Plant Pty Ltd and Mac Farms Pty Ltd, by the Magistrate on the grounds that they were manifestly inadequate. The first respondent, Mac Plant Pty Ltd, was convicted of breaching its duty of care under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) while the second respondent, Mac Farms Pty Ltd, was found guilty of failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for the plant it provided, under the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld). The appeal was heard in the Queensland Court of Appeal.

The key legal issues before the Court were whether the sentences imposed by the Magistrate were manifestly inadequate and if the Court should exercise its power under section 222 of the Justices Act 1886 to resentence the respondents. The Court needed to consider the principles and factors relevant to sentencing, such as the nature and circumstances of the offence, the culpability of the offenders, and the deterrence value of the sentence.

In delivering the judgment, the Court of Appeal held that the sentences imposed by the Magistrate were indeed manifestly inadequate. The Court found that the Magistrate failed to properly consider the culpability of the respondents and the deterrence value of the sentences. The Court further held that the seriousness of the offences warranted a higher penalty, given the potential risk to human life and the failure to comply with statutory obligations. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the respondents were resentenced to a fine of $35,000 for the first respondent and $10,000 for the second respondent, with no conviction recorded. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The orders of the Magistrate made on 17 August 2017 are set aside.

3. The respondents are resentenced as follows:

a. first respondent: fined $35,000, no conviction recorded.

b. second respondent: fined $10,000, no conviction recorded.

4. No order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Steward v Mac Plant Pty Ltd & Mac Farms Pty Ltd arises from the conviction of the first respondent, Mac Plant Pty Ltd, for failing to comply with a health and safety duty under section 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), and the second respondent, Mac Farms Pty Ltd, for failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant provided under section 215 of the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld). The facts leading to these convictions stem from an incident that occurred on 20 November 2015, when a 25-year-old labourer, Mr. Steward, was seriously injured while operating a bulldozer. Mr. Steward was working for a contractor, employed by Mac Farms Pty Ltd, on a job site managed by Mac Plant Pty Ltd. The incident occurred when the bulldozer rolled over, pinning Mr. Steward beneath it.

An investigation by the Workplace Health and Safety Queensland (WHSQ) found that the bulldozer had not been fitted with the required operator protective devices, specifically a roll-over protection system (ROPS) and a seat belt. Both respondents were subsequently charged, prosecuted, and convicted in the Magistrates Court of Queensland. The court found that Mac Plant Pty Ltd failed in its duty to ensure that the work environment was safe, while Mac Farms Pty Ltd failed to ensure that the bulldozer was equipped with the necessary protective devices. The court imposed a fine of $5,000 on Mac Plant Pty Ltd and a fine of $1,000 on Mac Farms Pty Ltd. These fines were deemed inadequate by the Director of Public Prosecutions, who subsequently appealed to the Queensland Court of Appeal under section 222 of the Justices Act 1886. The prosecution argued that the original sentences did not reflect the gravity of the breaches and the serious injury sustained by Mr. Steward. The appeal resulted in the sentences being set aside and the respondents being resentenced to higher fines, with no conviction recorded.

The matter before the court is an appeal by the prosecution pursuant to section 222 of the Justices Act 1886, contesting the adequacy of sentences imposed on the respondents by the Magistrates Court on 17 August 2017. The first respondent, Mac Plant Pty Ltd, was convicted of failing to comply with a health and safety duty under section 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), while the second respondent, Mac Farms Pty Ltd, was convicted of failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant provided under section 215 of the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld). The prosecution argued that the original sentences were manifestly inadequate and sought the Court's intervention to resentence the respondents. This appeal marks the first instance of this matter being heard by the court, as it involves the review of sentences issued by a lower court. Prior to this appeal, the respondents were convicted following a hearing in the Magistrates Court where evidence was presented, and arguments were made regarding their respective breaches of work health and safety laws. The appeal was subsequently filed, and the court has now determined to exercise its power to resentence the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to comply with a health and safety duty under s 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld).

2. Whether the Court should exercise its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the first respondent.

3. Whether the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant under s 215 of the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld).

4. Whether the Court should exercise its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the second respondent.

Held
1. The court concluded that the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to comply with a health and safety duty under s 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), and the appeal on this issue was allowed.

2. The court exercised its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the first respondent, setting aside the original sentence and imposing a new sentence.

3. The court concluded that the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant under s 215 of the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld), and the appeal on this issue was allowed.

4. The court exercised its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the second respondent, setting aside the original sentence and imposing a new sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to comply with a health and safety duty under s 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld). The first respondent, Mac Plant Pty Ltd, was convicted of this offence arising from a workplace incident that resulted in serious injury. In evaluating the adequacy of the sentence, the court applied the principle that a sentence for a breach of a statutory duty must reflect the seriousness of the breach and serve as a general deterrent. The court noted the gravity of the incident and the respondent's role in ensuring workplace safety. The court referred to previous cases such as R v Furino, which emphasized that a manifestly inadequate sentence is one that falls outside the range of sentences that a reasonable magistrate could have imposed, having regard to the seriousness of the offence. The court concluded that the original fine of $5,000 was manifestly inadequate given the circumstances and the need for deterrence and denunciation.

The court then turned to whether it should exercise its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the first respondent. In exercising this power, the court must consider whether the original sentence was manifestly inadequate and whether a different sentence is warranted in the interests of justice. The court took into account the nature and circumstances of the offence, the culpability of the offender, and the need for general deterrence. The court noted the prosecutor's argument that the original sentence did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the breach and the potential harm caused. The court concluded that the appeal should be allowed and the sentence increased to $35,000 to appropriately serve the purposes of punishment, deterrence, and denunciation.

Next, the court examined whether the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly inadequate for the offence of failing to ensure a suitable combination of operator protective devices for plant under s 215 of the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld). The second respondent, Mac Farms Pty Ltd, was convicted of this offence, which involved inadequate safety measures on a piece of plant, leading to injury. The court applied similar principles as in the previous case, focusing on the seriousness of the breach and the need for deterrence. The court considered the nature of the breach, the respondent's role in ensuring plant safety, and the potential for harm. The court referenced R v Furino again, emphasizing the need for the sentence to reflect the gravity of the offence. The court determined that the original fine of $2,500 was manifestly inadequate given the seriousness of the breach and the need for deterrence and denunciation.

Finally, the court addressed whether it should exercise its power under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to resentence the second respondent. The court considered the same factors as in the previous case, including the nature and circumstances of the offence, the culpability of the offender, and the need for general deterrence. The court noted the prosecutor's argument that the original sentence did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the breach and the potential harm caused. The court concluded that the appeal should be allowed and the sentence increased to $10,000 to appropriately serve the purposes of punishment, deterrence, and denunciation. The court emphasized the importance of ensuring workplace safety and the need for adequate sentences to prevent future breaches.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a manifestly inadequate sentence for breaches of work health and safety duties can be reviewed and increased by the Court under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Vic) to ensure the sentence appropriately reflects the seriousness of the offence, serves as a general deterrent, and upholds the principles of justice. The court departed from the original sentences in both cases, finding them inadequate and increasing the fines to better serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence. The court followed the principle established in R v Furino that a manifestly inadequate sentence is one that falls outside the range of sentences that a reasonable magistrate could have imposed.