Guilfoyle v Wicks

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Guilfoyle v Wicks [2020] QMC 11

PARTIES:

Aaron John GUILFOYLE (Work Health Safety Prosecutor)

(Complainant)

v

Angus Ruthven WICKS

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

MAG-00216053/19(2)

DIVISION:

Magistrates Courts

PROCEEDING:

Sentencing Hearing

ORIGINATING COURT:

Dalby Magistrates Court

DELIVERED ON:

4 September 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Dalby Magistrates Court

HEARING DATE:

4 September 2020

MAGISTRATE:

T. E. Mossop

ORDER:

CATCHWORDS:

SOLICITORS:

R. Watson, In-House Legal for Work Health Safety Prosecutor, Qld Government

Counsel Andrew Hoare i/b Carvosso and Winship for Defendant

A jolt from Farming Focus

  1. On a Tara farm one spring day in 2017, no doubt in many ways like many other days in the course of preceding decades, a farming machine was being moved.  That mobile machine was an auger, used to load grain from trucks into silos. This particular day soon turned tragic because as the auger was being repositioned, it came into with contact with an overhead, high-voltage electrical power line.  This caused serious and permanent injuries from electrocution to both the Defendant farmer and his employee, a 17 year old farm-hand.

  1. In the realms of work, health and safety, what was being done that day was not electrically safe. The injured farmer had failed to comply with his duties under the Electrical Safety Act 2002 and by his failure exposed individuals, including himself, to risk of death or serious injury. That exposure was actualised when serious injuries to two persons resulted.

  1. A complaint and summons followed, within time limitations, some 2 years later.

  1. At the very first mention of this matter in court on 17 December 2019, the Defendant pleaded guilty, thus making it a very early plea.

  1. The matter was listed for a sentence hearing in early 2020 at the lawyers’ behest.

The Facts Surrounding the Incident, Contained within the Complaint and Summons Particulars and Agree Schedule of Facts

  1. The 12k Volt uninsulated single wire earth return high voltage overhead electrical line traversed the farm property in the vicinity of two grain silos at a height of about 7.2 metres. It is a powerline as part of the provision of electricity supplied by Ergon Energy.

  1. The auger was only used for about one month a year.  It was being repositioned from one silo to the other.

  1. The Defendant was operating the hydraulic controls of the auger as his employee was steering it at the rear jockey wheel. The auger had to be spun 180 degrees to move it from one silo to the other.

  1. The auger was in a raised position when it contacted with the overhead power line.

  1. Both the Defendant and his employee assisting in moving the auger received serious injuries, including electrical burns, which required transportation and treatment at the Royal Brisbane Hospital.

  1. The injured employee suffered burns to his hands, feet, right arm, chest, back, buttocks, genitals and both legs.  He had four toes amputated and has suffered psychologically it seems, according to his own victim impact statement as opposed to any formal, professional diagnosis or report.  He was hospitalised…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guilfoyle v Wicks and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QMC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Magistrates Court of Queensland, the case of Guilfoyle v Wicks was heard, where Aaron John Guilfoyle, the Work Health Safety Prosecutor, brought forth a complaint against Angus Ruthven Wicks, the defendant. The case revolved around a tragic incident on a Tara farm in 2017, where Angus Wicks, the defendant, and his employee were severely injured due to the auger they were operating coming into contact with an overhead, high-voltage electrical power line. Wicks had failed to comply with his duties under the Electrical Safety Act 2002, leading to the injuries of both himself and his employee. Wicks pleaded guilty early on in the proceedings.

The court was required to determine the appropriate penalty for Wicks' breach of the Electrical Safety Act 2002. The court considered several factors, such as the existence of the hazard, the legislative requirement to implement safety measures, the real risk of death and injury, punishment, deterrence, injury and harm caused by the breach, community denouncement, maximum penalty, and all appropriate mitigating factors. The court also referred to relevant cases and sentencing principles to guide its decision.

The court found that Wicks had failed to take the necessary safety measures, such as establishing an exclusion zone to prevent any person or machinery from coming within an unsafe distance of the high voltage power line. Although Wicks had since installed orange bollards to mark the exclusion zone, the court considered the gravity of the consequences and the need for general deterrence. The court also took into account the mitigating factors, such as Wicks' early guilty plea, his lack of prior history, his remorse, and the adverse effects of the drought and COVID-19 on his farming business. The court ordered Wicks to pay a fine of $16,000 and did not impose any additional costs on him.

In summary, the court found Angus Ruthven Wicks guilty of breaching the Electrical Safety Act 2002 and imposed a fine of $16,000 on him. The court took into account the various legal principles and factors to arrive at an appropriate penalty, considering both the severity of the incident and the mitigating circumstances.