State of Queensland v B

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

State of Queensland v B [2008] QSC 231

PARTIES:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(applicant)
v
B, by her Litigation Guardian
(respondent)

FILE NO:

BS 9246/08

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

26 September 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Supreme Court, Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 September 2008

JUDGE:

Wilson J

ORDERS:

1. Declaration that the termination of B’s pregnancy by the therapeutic administration of the drug misoprostol would be reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to B’s mental health;

2. Order that B be permitted to undergo and the applicant’s servants or agents be permitted to perform termination of B’s pregnancy by the therapeutic administration of the said drug.

CATCHWORDS:

CHILDREN – Court’s inherent jurisdiction – parens patriae – where 12 year old girl is almost 18 weeks pregnant – where the girl is a patient of a public hospital conducted by the applicant – where the applicant sought Court’s authorisation of termination of pregnancy – where continuation of pregnancy is a danger to the girl’s mental health and well-being – where the girl is of less than average intelligence and maturity – where the girl and her parents wish the pregnancy to be terminated – whether the girl’s parents are able to consent to the termination of the pregnancy – where it is an offence unlawfully to administer a drug or use force or any other means with intent to procure an abortion – where proposal is to administer a drug to induce labour – where there are sound medical reasons for not performing a surgical procedure – where it is the duty of every person with care of a child to take precautions reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to child’s health and to take action reasonable in all the circumstances to remove the child from such danger – whether danger to child’s health includes danger to her mental health – whether the applicant is a person with care of the child – whether administration of the drug in order to terminate the pregnancy would be reasonable to avoid danger to child’s mental health – whether it would be in child’s best interests for termination of her pregnancy by that means to proceed

Criminal Code Act 1899, s 224, s 226, s 286

Fountain v Alexander (1982) 150 CLR 615, referred to
Gillick v West Norfolk AHA [1986] AC 112, referred to
K v T [1983] 1 Qd R 396, considered
Marion’s Case (1992) 175 CLR 218, considered and applied
R v Gyngall [1893] 2 QB 232, cited
Re Bayliss [1985] Supreme Court of Queensland OS 326 of 1985 (Unreported, McPherson J, 24 May 1985), referred to
State of Queensland v Nolan [2002] 1 Qd R 454, considered and applied

COUNSEL:

S Gallagher for the applicant
The respondent was represented by her litigation guardian, her father
JR Hunter as amicus curiae

SOLICITORS:

Minter Ellison for the applicant

  1. WILSON J: On 17 September 2008 I made the following orders:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v B and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 231
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a 12-year-old girl, referred to as B, who was almost 18 weeks pregnant. B was a patient at a public hospital managed by the State of Queensland. The State sought the court's authorisation to terminate the pregnancy, arguing that continuing the pregnancy posed a significant risk to B’s mental health and well-being. B and her parents also wished for the pregnancy to be terminated. The court had to determine whether the parents could consent to the termination and whether the proposed method of administering a drug to induce labour was lawful and in B’s best interests.

The central legal issues were whether the girl's parents had the authority to consent to the termination of her pregnancy, and if the administration of the drug misoprostol to induce labour constituted a lawful and reasonable means to avoid danger to the girl's mental health. The court needed to consider whether the risk to B’s mental health warranted intervention under the court’s inherent jurisdiction in matters concerning children, and if the hospital, as a person with care of the child, had a duty to take reasonable action to protect B from this danger.

The court found that the girl's parents could not consent to the termination due to her age, but the court had the authority to make the decision in her best interests. It concluded that the risk to B’s mental health constituted a danger to her health, and the administration of misoprostol to terminate the pregnancy was a reasonable and therapeutic measure to avoid this danger. The court emphasised that the duty to protect a child from danger extended to mental health risks and that the hospital, as a person with care of B, had the duty to take reasonable action to remove her from such danger. The court granted the declaration and order sought by the State.

The final orders of the court declared that the termination of B’s pregnancy by the therapeutic administration of the drug misoprostol would be reasonable to avoid danger to her mental health. It also ordered that B be permitted to undergo, and the hospital’s servants or agents be permitted to perform, the termination of B’s pregnancy by administering the drug.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Declaration that the termination of B’s pregnancy by the therapeutic administration of the drug misoprostol would be reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to B’s mental health;

2. Order that B be permitted to undergo and the applicant’s servants or agents be permitted to perform termination of B’s pregnancy by the therapeutic administration of the said drug.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a 12-year-old girl, referred to as B, who is nearly 18 weeks pregnant and a patient at a public hospital managed by the State of Queensland. The hospital, acting through its authorised representative, the Director of the Queensland Health Department, sought the court's authorisation to terminate B's pregnancy. The hospital argued that continuing the pregnancy posed a significant risk to B's mental health and well-being due to her young age, less than average intelligence, and maturity. Both B and her parents expressed a desire for the pregnancy to be terminated. However, the court needed to determine whether B's parents could consent to the termination, as it is an offence under Queensland law to unlawfully administer a drug or use force to procure an abortion. The proposed method for terminating the pregnancy was the administration of the drug misoprostol to induce labour, as there were sound medical reasons against performing a surgical procedure. The court also had to consider whether the duty to avoid danger to a child's health includes mental health and if the hospital, as the person with care of the child, could reasonably administer the drug to terminate the pregnancy. Finally, the court needed to decide if terminating the pregnancy in this manner would be in B's best interests.

The matter came before the court as an application by the Director of the Queensland Health Department, who was seeking the court's authorisation to terminate the pregnancy of B, a minor patient in its care. This application was filed under the court's inherent jurisdiction and parens patriae powers, recognising the court's responsibility to act in the best interests of children when necessary. The court reviewed the application and the evidence provided by the hospital, including medical assessments and expert opinions. The case did not involve any prior decisions from lower courts or tribunals, as it was a first-instance application directly to the court for authorisation. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application, the submission of medical evidence, and the court's consideration of the legal and ethical implications of authorising the termination of the minor's pregnancy.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the girl’s parents are able to consent to the termination of the pregnancy?
2. Whether the administration of the drug misoprostol to terminate B’s pregnancy would be reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to B’s mental health?
3. Whether it would be in B’s best interests for the termination of her pregnancy by the administration of misoprostol to proceed?

Held
1. The court concluded that the girl's parents do not have the capacity to consent to the termination of the pregnancy as the girl is a minor and the court must make the decision in the best interests of the child.
2. The court held that the administration of the drug misoprostol to terminate B’s pregnancy would be reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to B’s mental health.
3. The court found that it would be in B’s best interests for the termination of her pregnancy by the administration of misoprostol to proceed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court exercised its inherent jurisdiction under the parens patriae doctrine to make a decision in the best interests of the child. The court held that the girl's parents do not have the capacity to consent to the termination of the pregnancy as the girl is a minor and the court must make the decision in the best interests of the child. The court considered the sound medical reasons for not performing a surgical procedure and the reasonable precautions that must be taken to avoid danger to the child’s health and well-being. The court held that the danger to the child’s health includes danger to her mental health and that the applicant, as the person with care of the child, has a duty to take reasonable action to remove the child from such danger. The court held that the administration of the drug misoprostol to terminate B’s pregnancy would be reasonable in all the circumstances to avoid danger to B’s mental health. The court found that it would be in B’s best interests for the termination of her pregnancy by the administration of misoprostol to proceed, considering the girl's less than average intelligence and maturity and the wishes of the girl and her parents. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction to make a decision in the best interests of a minor child in relation to the termination of her pregnancy, taking into account the risk to the child’s mental health and the reasonable precautions that must be taken to avoid such risk.